Baptiste's was definitely better, it took incredible acrobatic skill and great hands, Prothro's was good, but he kinda just caught it and held it against the defender.
Prothro's was easily better. There is no comparison. I've seen a thousand one handed grabs. Prothro caught the freakin' ball over a defender and pinned it on his back and maintained possession while doing a flip. It's the best damn catch in football history!
lol no offense but middle schoolers catch what bapsiste caught. what prothro got was incredible because he had to see the ball over the guy right in front of him
Damn what do you mean baptiste can catch better than prothro i have seen my 14 year old bro seth catch like babtiste many times thats titty shit to him but i've seen anyone catch like prothro not even seth. now anybody got a problem to that can come watch this shit themselves
the catch by tyrone was pure luck. It was still a good catch. But, Edwin catch was a greatest catch ever. But I say tie.. But if i had to pick between them i would pick baptiste
@BlackPrez303 what? NO!! Prothro's catch was, yes, partly luck, but also just skill. Any football player could do what Baptiste did. It really wouldn't be that hard. What Prothro did, however, IS hard. Therefore, since Baptiste's mostly easy-ass (yet incredible) catch is just repeatable and Prothro's is not, PROTHRO IS THE BETTER PLAYER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
A one handed leaping grab on the tip of the fingers and to finish the play is amazing, but to catch the ball behind the defenders back and maintain control for the TD is equally amazing. It's gotta be a tie...
Prothro could have been better if he hadn't had the injury we could have seen so many more great catches. This video shows Babtiste better in my opinion. By the way I'm an Alabama fan.
Both were great but I can tell you as a WR that Prothro's was a harder catch to make. Babtiste's was very difficult but he could see the ball all the way through the catch and "simply" made a great on heanded grab and fell back wards. The bounce/flip added some great drama to the catch but Prothro not only couldn't see the ball once it was behind the helmet but he had to grab it hard enough to keep it from bouncing off, not to mention hang on to it through a flip where his head almost broke off!
"Prothro now works as a bank teller in Tuscaloosa". WTF is that for justice?
caesarves 5 months ago
Baptiste's was definitely better, it took incredible acrobatic skill and great hands, Prothro's was good, but he kinda just caught it and held it against the defender.
juiceboxhero12 7 months ago
to bad he broke his ankle a couple weeks later,would have great NFL player
pyIez 1 year ago
Tyrone Prothro was better.
lakerskid2013 1 year ago
songg?
88beastlyman 1 year ago
songg?
88beastlyman 1 year ago
song sucks & Protho's was better but people you still got to give credit to Bapsiste cause that was one of a kind one handed catch
krimsonfox2112 1 year ago
Prothro's was easily better. There is no comparison. I've seen a thousand one handed grabs. Prothro caught the freakin' ball over a defender and pinned it on his back and maintained possession while doing a flip. It's the best damn catch in football history!
bruise2237 1 year ago
lol no offense but middle schoolers catch what bapsiste caught. what prothro got was incredible because he had to see the ball over the guy right in front of him
silverblade43 1 year ago
Damn what do you mean baptiste can catch better than prothro i have seen my 14 year old bro seth catch like babtiste many times thats titty shit to him but i've seen anyone catch like prothro not even seth. now anybody got a problem to that can come watch this shit themselves
MyRolltide22 1 year ago
the catch by tyrone was pure luck. It was still a good catch. But, Edwin catch was a greatest catch ever. But I say tie.. But if i had to pick between them i would pick baptiste
jermaine432 1 year ago
What is the song playing while we can Watch the Edwin Baptiste Catch ??
iMathz 1 year ago
prothros- best catch in college football history
bapsiste- could actually be done again
jchaff4bama93 1 year ago
yeah dat was a nice edwin catch but wtf prothro caught it behind the guy back u kant compare dat......Prothro
D3MONTRA 1 year ago
What is the name of the first song ?? Thx
iMathz 1 year ago
wtf? is there even a comparison? Edwin Bapsiste could be one of the greatest catches in football PERIOD...
BlackPrez303 2 years ago
@BlackPrez303 what? NO!! Prothro's catch was, yes, partly luck, but also just skill. Any football player could do what Baptiste did. It really wouldn't be that hard. What Prothro did, however, IS hard. Therefore, since Baptiste's mostly easy-ass (yet incredible) catch is just repeatable and Prothro's is not, PROTHRO IS THE BETTER PLAYER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
7399me 1 year ago
i've seen a catch exactly like prothro's done by a high school player
thurstonodom 2 years ago
@thurstonodom I highly doubt that.
bamafan73191 1 year ago
Prothros, Pure Luck
Baptiste, Skill
vientinho 2 years ago
Comment removed
23reggiebush 2 years ago
song remix???
joeman8765 2 years ago
you'll never see another prothro catch
you'll see another baptiste catch
aubiesucks12 2 years ago 6
Tyrone Prothro is WAY BETTER
JesusFrk472 2 years ago 2
Baptiste's catch simply showed more athletic ability than Prothro's
JRec83 2 years ago
A one handed leaping grab on the tip of the fingers and to finish the play is amazing, but to catch the ball behind the defenders back and maintain control for the TD is equally amazing. It's gotta be a tie...
scootoro 2 years ago
Prothro could have been better if he hadn't had the injury we could have seen so many more great catches. This video shows Babtiste better in my opinion. By the way I'm an Alabama fan.
R3DINK 2 years ago
Both were great but I can tell you as a WR that Prothro's was a harder catch to make. Babtiste's was very difficult but he could see the ball all the way through the catch and "simply" made a great on heanded grab and fell back wards. The bounce/flip added some great drama to the catch but Prothro not only couldn't see the ball once it was behind the helmet but he had to grab it hard enough to keep it from bouncing off, not to mention hang on to it through a flip where his head almost broke off!
markquimby82 2 years ago
Baptiste
powerscons37 2 years ago
Baptiste's man, Prothro's was good but technically more possible then Edwin's.
Just look at the jump he did, extended his arm and caught it. AMAZING.
Prothro's was an amazing catch, it's just that he didn't let go. It was nice timing though.
baronron98 3 years ago
what is the song you played during the baptiste catch??
rjclarke72 3 years ago
prothro
pride4tide 3 years ago
i say edwin's. prothro's was crazy n nothing has been done like it b4, but edwins was so impressive because of the stretch.
Proskeet23 3 years ago
prothro
aubiesucks12 3 years ago
the refs are like wtf haha
APB323 3 years ago
they b like wtf wat 2 do
SantizClaus 2 years ago
i say edwin. that was a sick catch but both were beautiful
ftan3389 3 years ago
nice video...wat was the first song
Abercrombiex0o 3 years ago
the one where you can see the prothro catch...it's lil wayne - moment of clarity.
but thank you anyway :)
go4it2score 3 years ago
nice vid....what's the song called?
go4it2score 3 years ago
which song
patsfan1228 3 years ago
@go4it2score tic tic by lil wayne
CoD3x4life 1 year ago
@go4it2score 'Moment of Clarity' Freestyle by Li'l Wayne. It sux.
caesarves 5 months ago
protho
dancindillon10 3 years ago
I go for Prothro! Alabama is who I go for! I wish Prothro didn't get injured.
Pivot1king 3 years ago 2
Prothro's was probably a tougher catch but both are equally impressive.
bigbluetopper 3 years ago 5
bet that sucked the air right out of his lungs...best catch ive seen in years...
whitesteve22 3 years ago 14
Prothro make the best catch ever!!
will81387 3 years ago 12
OH MY GOD
bwit89 3 years ago 15