Added: 3 years ago
From: yurksemesh
Views: 3,207,074
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,855)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I've never listened to Birdy's version of this song, but I can't imagine why you'd need/want to cover this.

  • the two versions are really 2 completely different genres. this is folk, birdy's is pop

  • Birdy's cover sounds good, but it isn't soulful with emotion like Bon Iver's. Also it makes no use of dynamics. It sounds appealing like pop music, but its bad music. pretty much sums up all the music today. which is bad

  • who the heck is birdy?!!!

  • I don't like Birdys verision of this song.

  • G-d is no longer a dj,he's Bon Iver aka Justin

  • she changed the harmony by changing the chords underneath the melody...can't we just admit that Birdy took a good song and transformed it into something even better?

  • they need to label birdy's version a cover so people dont think it's hers....

  • @Gunzenzo bon ivers song. Learn to take a hint

  • @GloriousBrilliance Captain Picard Facepalm

  • bon iver > birdy

  • I like this. But I will admit that I kind of like Birdy's version better. Even if she didn't give him credit. Everyone knows Bon Iver made it first anyways. But I just like Birdy's better because I am a piano fanatic.

  • oh my god, give the poor girl a break. Both are really talented singers so back off.... and I dont understand why you would even be making fun of a 15 year old girl on someone elses video, Bon Iver is seperate though they sing different songs, no need to collide comments. They need seperate times to shine.

  • Even though Birdy does an amazing cover of this song, i actually prefer Ed Sheeran's over both. js.

  • birdys version is sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooo much metter

  • @luvya1999 no it's not.

  • @luvya1999 different strokes for different folks i guess......i actuallydon't understand the hype over birdy's version

  • @luvya1999 what? seriously

  • @luvya1999 ok there bud....

  • justin vernon is a god

  • I like Birdy's version better, has much more feeling & a less 'produced' sound. This has no raw emotion to it. Don't get me wrong, I like Bon Iver, I just like Birdy's version better on this particular song.

  • @catcando75 No raw emotion? Are you fucking serious? This doesn't sound produced at all.. it sounds like a rough version of someone who's just pulled out their guitar and sang straight from their heart.

  • Whether you like Birdy's cover or not doesn't really matter, just don't complain about her having covered the song or how lame you think her version is. Birdy had to get permission from Bon Iver to cover the song anyway, if they're alright with it I'm sure you silly Birdy haters can get over it.

  • Everybody just stop comparing both birdys and bon ivers singing. Skinny Love by Bon Iver is the original. Get over it. If you wanna listen to Birdy's version then by all means go listen to it! You dont need permission? Because truthfully nobody cares who you like better. It's as simple as that.

  • I hate how Birdy's cover has more views than the original. It's not that bad or anything, but it's annoying that she's getting more recognition for it when it's not even her song.

  • god !!

  • I hate that you can only find Birdys version for your ipod.

  • I tried to give Birdy's cover a chance but I just had to come back to Bon Iver's original.

  • Ok so I like Birdy's cover. It's good. No, it's great. But it's a great COVER. This is an original. There can never be any comparison between the two, so stop hating on Birdy like she actually had a chance of somehow 'beating' Bon Iver. Stop hating on her and start loving Bon Iver instead, 'cause this is amazing!!

  • @mathilde224 Agreed. This is a great original,but people need to get over their defensive-ass selves and just respect that the two are completely different you can't compare the two. I love both versions, it took guts for Birdy to try and cover such a perfect song...that's part of being an artist is creating great work like she's done with her other music AND turning this song into something else...even bringing a different meaning to the song. They not comparable at all people.

  • not bad but no where near as good as the original

  • @GloriousBrilliance This song is the original, and the best...

  • @GloriousBrilliance This IS the original

  • @GloriousBrilliance wait...are you for real? This IS the original

  • @GloriousBrilliance can't tell if you're trolling or just woefully misinformed...

  • Way better than the version from Birdy!

  • this version is nicer then the version of birdy

  • Best versions of this song-

    1.Bon Iver

    2.Bon Iver

    3.Bon Iver

  • am i the only one who despises birdy's cover?

  • @WhaddupDoc72 NO. :)

  • @WhaddupDoc72 nope, I hate it too.... and the thing is, I wouldn't even hate it as much as I do if she even attempted to give the slightest acknowledgement to Justin Vernon/Bon Iver for this masterpiece of a song.

  • <3

  • hey fellow bon iver fans, come check out Bryan Yurgelis and the Winter Shakers. best regards

  • the only real!<3

  • I had to come here to cleanse myself of Birdy's cover.

  • @lunchboxdays agreed!

  • the awkard moment when people actually think that Birdy's version is the original song

  • @Ilonaaproductions and that birdy's is better

  • Bon Iver forever! :)

  • I think the original is asking it to last but Birdys is it how it won't last

  • This is beautiful!

  • Your attachments piss off my opinions.

  • Yeah this songs good, but better than original? nah..

    i dont think so - personal opinion though..

    @SuperNerdWebb ................ -facepalm-

  • @GunzEnzo excuse me? sorry i dont quite understand that comment:L

  • @GunzEnzo i apologise if your previous comment was hugely sacarstic, its hard to portray tone in a written form of communication. if that isnt the case and you are genuinely serious then i feel very, very sorry for you.

  • things that annoy me;

    1. nicki minaj, skrillex and j. cole fans saying bon iver didnt deserve the grammy, learn to appreciate real music!

    2. birdy's cover of this song has 5times the amount of views, bon iver deserves as much if not more recognition than birdy!

    bon iver are a talent<3

  • @SuperNerdWebb Fucking oath.

  • Comment removed

  • Don't get irritated, be happy! :D Life is too short, for getting irritadet for this.

    And respect others taste in music, people should listen to what they want! :)

    I personally don't like pop, but I',not being cruel or anything.

  • @Thin1Thin2Thin3 i didnt say fans of those artists should listen to bon iver, i just said it's wrong for them to think he didnt deserve the grammy because their music isnt to their taste:)

    what an optimistic and beautiful comment:)<3

  • what there was even a dislike button on this page? r u kidding me how did these bastards even hear about it then

  • This song has so much feeling in it..

    I simply adore how so many people can connect to the horrid, irritating feeling of losing one's love.

    Iver seems to be one of the artists I can really connect to.

  • Still my favourite version.

  • whow this is nice

  • I hate the cover by birdy... :C

  • It's ea-Vair not iiverr.

  • Bon Iver and I have been through some tough shit together. We belt this song on a rainy day, we hum it by a lake in the sun, late nights camping under the stars, traveling with loved ones from town to town, driving home heart broken in the middle of the night, drinking myself silly and serenading random folk. This guy is always along for the ride with me.

  • @snowyangel97 go away

  • @ThatGuyNamedTim No thanks, I'm simply just expressing my opinion, and it is true, when you listen to it there is no true emotion and you are emotionally absent if you can't sense that.

  • @snowyangel97 In my opinion, he's the only one who puts emotion into this song at all, birdy just does a cover, Justin wrote the song expressing his emotions, while isolated in a cabin

  • @snowyangel97 Did you even listen to the song? There is a lot of emotion, especially in the chorus.

  • This is a masterpeice I'm ashamed its taking me so long to find

  • I'm sitting in my room in the dark right now blasting this song, crying and laughing and I can't even figure out why. I'm just absolutely amazed.

  • God, I love this song so much! Soo much.

  • Even though the volume is on max, IT'S JUST NOT FUCKING LOUD ENOUGH! MY WHOLE NEIGHBORHOOD HAS TO HEAR THIS!

  • Bring back Chuck...

  • @gaetan0702

    Hell yeah. Chuck ripped a hole in my heart.

  • commeee on skinny love...we love you Bon Iver. Beautiful beyond words

  • I heard this BEFORE the grammys. Gosh darn it guys

  • I could imagine that his guitar is a very old one, like the one he played when he was young. It has an unbelievable sound. Paul McCartney would click "Like" on this, because this is great music!

  • I love this song. Birdy's verison of it is good too.

  • only 3.000.826 views? Seems i listen that song alone.

  • @SmilingSnowGirl mind boggling that birdy's COVER has 5x the amount of views<3

  • Comment removed

  • BONNY BEAR!

  • Don't know him that long, but I love his music ever since I do. This man can make you feel heartbroken while the love of your life is sitting right next to you.

  • Please check out my video which is a lesson on how to play skinny love, this is for normal tuning on acoustic guitar. Please leave comments and requests if you liked my lesson. Thanks

  • Its really amazing how all the bad things that were happening to Justin during this time and turned it into for emma, forever ago. Is truly amazing and inspiring.

  • @sg248. He isn't mainstream and will not be. He will never play in huge venues and never get fans who appreciapt him as much of those from eau claire/minneapolis who in fact have been listening for years on the current radiostation, attending local shows, and understanding his journey so far. So if u can appreciate it, go for it. But he nor his real fans care whether he goes mainstream or not. He isn't yet and I don't think he will be a pop sensation. He's better than that.

  • I hate it when people get all possessive over a musician when they become mainstream, when the artist in question has no fucking idea who you are, and are also delighted to now be raking in the rewards from being recognised.

  • lol! good lord im confused who actualy wrote this song! aha, bon iver right?

  • He's really good. But has nobody ever heard Matt Pond before?

  • my, my, my, my, my, my, my 

  • Justin Vernon is probably the most influential artist for me. His story is also influential to me as well. I'm a 16 year old, who plays guitar, bass, harmonica, drums, and some piano. I record my own music with two microphones in a small room in my house. I would love to make music my living. I just finished recording a small EP. It is located on my channel under the playlist, "Winter EP" My style is similar to Bon Iver's, so don't worry about it sounding like pop garbage. Please vote this up!

  • Hi. I made a mashup/remix with this song and with Lana del reys Born to die. Please listen and tell me what you think :)

    /watch?v=jyKeZ25olAc&context=C­34c60fbADOEgsToPDskLX4RX-AdUUm­kk_sIyXap1P

  • I love how at the grammy awards, backstage justin vernon said that he thought he: "Didn't deserve to be there." More like he was the only one who deserved to be there. People like chris brown and all those other talentless people can hide behind their dancing and their overly loud synthetic beats/instruments, but they can never come close to even comparing with justin vernon just stood there, playing his guitar and singing

  • I FUCKING LOVE BONNY BEAR

  • I closed porn because of this.

  • @goodoldmanny No you didnt, this is still porn, Earporn.

  • Who cares if people are hating on him now? It's their loss.

  • Um, I love both Bon Iver AND Lady Gaga. Take that conformity on both sides of the issue! xD

  • How did this win a NEWCOMER award? Still, I'm so happy it did :-)

  • @Pablosammy1 haha yeah i was also confused about that...

  • No matter how hard i try i cant get into this simply because the music is too happy for what he is saying.

  • @notjohn100 Happy? Seriously? You need a bit more experience in music to understand his voice and the sound. -.-

  • @diana27563 his voice and the lyrics are not happy in the slightest, which is why i have a problem because i do not think the beat or the guitars go with it at all.

  • @diana27563 and it's really only during the "and i told you to be patient" part

  • who the fuck is skrillex !!!!  Congrats Justin !

  • Just found out about Bon Iver through the Grammys. I think I'm in love.

  • I love Bon Iver!

  • Bittersweet feeling that Bon Iver(Justin Vernon) won the grammy tonight. Although talented music is finally being recognized, idiots everywhere with no taste in music are bashing on Bon Iver just because they are just now finding out who he is, or for not dressing as idiotic as Katy Perry, Rhianna, or Lady Gaga. Learn to pronounce the name before you diss on him.

  • @checkyourself06 Amen. He's not a new artist. His grammy acceptance speech pretty much summed it up.... Lots of overlooked talent.

  • @checkyourself06 true that, hopefully the trolls will forget about him soon, and he gains a good chunk of new fans aswell

  • Birch sings a song, Bon Iver tells a story. love both versions

  • best fucking artist, theres hope for music :')

  • @silkymilky99 Go away.

  • @silkymilky99 Because he is infinitely better. Infinitely.

  • dang where have i been does the radio play their songs

  • i have heard birdys version and i think that this version is good but i actually like birdys version better i think the piano works better than a guitar no affence but its a beautiful song truly (:

  • @TheJake455 Please don't vote.

  • @TheJake445 If you keep spelling like that nobody is going to take you seriously.

  • BEST NEW ARTIST I LOVE YOU

  • @TheJake445 you're a dildoface

  • @TheJake445 Considering that Nicki Minaj has a song called "Stupid Hoe", I think your point is invalid.

  • he just won!!! BEST NEW ARTIST

  • Comment removed

  • Bon Iver gave that song the SOUL, not Birdy or anybody else.

  • Comment removed

  • Perhaps some would like to hear this interpretation (use normal Youtube link url before)

    MPNhADttvac

  • Such an amazing song, such a great album. Truly one of my faves to listen to. the covers, blase compared to this.

  • I love how this song is very unique and how beautiful it truly is :)

  • Reminds me of eating disorders...so pretty

  • This is so beautiful.

  • so nice ....

  • beautiful song. :)

  • Finally a cover that deserves some recognition.

    /watch?v=cgRt2VbCtlQ

    Please check this out. Thumbs up if you like it!

  • I'm late, but some songs deserve to be heard done.

  • Bon Iver is amazing.....Scoop over to our channel and check us out.....One day we dream of Scooping this Bon Iver genius.....keep it Mellow9

  • love his work what a voice

  • Mooi liedje

  • Chuck I'll miss it

  • wow this is great"

    sounds very different...

    is the original from ed sheeran?

    i also like the one from birdy!

  • @iam10000000 This is the original

  • @xxCelineex Echt ga weg.

  • @xxCelineex ik sluit me aan bij @tenmashi. En nee, ik ben geen kakker.

  • Just b