Within Temptation - Our farewell (ft Gea Gijsbertsen or Tarja Turunen )

[LeonardoQezoth01]

Chorei com essa música :)

[KetjowTheCat]

o kurna.

[Blueyluvscheese]

People, please. This is Gea Gijsbertsen. It's taken off the Mother Earth Tour DVD, which I have, and it's definitely not Tarja, it doesn't even sound like Tarja. I seriously can't believe I'm seeing comments where people are saying it's Tarja, and then insulting those who KNOW it's Gea...how pathetic can you get? Tarja has never sung with Within Temptation. If you need proof, check the video of this performance, it has no sound, but it's solid picture proof that it's Gea.

[Geagijsbertsen]

@Blueyluvscheese, thank you for the info. We let it rest in peace :-)

[Blueyluvscheese]

@Geagijsbertsen No problem! :)

[SvensonC]

at end "applaus for Gea"... ;)

[TheIrishgay]

it not tarja it  Gea Gijsbertsen

[Simo2797]

It's Gea. Read this from Wikipedia: A live recording of the song is on the Mother Earth Tour DVD, in which the song is performed as a duet with Dutch opera singer Gea Gijsbertsen.

[PrinceOfFreedon]

amazing .. just amazing

*-*

[mikeshinoda555]

i miss my mum~

[DuncanMacLe0d]

Oh and by the way, the part from 3:15 and up cost me my 5x100W DTS surround system. Every time I hear it a piece of heaven drops down and lands on my eye's.

[DuncanMacLe0d]

Come on children, give Gea some credit. It's her. Point.

[Druidin12]

I love Tarja Turunen, but it´s Gea!

[sentoas]

its Gea

[Evusiq1]

Its Gea, not Tarja.....

[veve7664]

malgre que ce ne soit pas tarja la chanson n en reste pas moins belle

[Sovietk21]

Tarja joins at 1:40 when the crowd starts yelling idiotas!

[m0o0oeh]

I've heard this live and this it not Tarja, its good, but its no Tarja

[666999Daredevil]

This is not Tarja!

[Rinoa242]

This is GHEA!!! NOT Tarja Turunen!!!

[NymphaNivis]

Guys, this IS Tarja. Open your ears...

[chostoclos]

@NymphaNivis come on, i have that video, it is not tarja, that is Gea, look, her on you tube is a video, look for it as Within Temptation featuring Gea Gijsbertsen - Our Farewell ( Live @ Lowlands Festival ), it has no sound, but if you can play this and that one at the same time you will see that is Gea, just need to delay the other one like 8 seconds so you you can palm the audio here and the vide on that one, but trust me, i know it may sound like tarja

[ranbelthilsken]

LIMDO SOM GRACIAS !!!!!

[Geagijsbertsen]

@flammuth

I'm the promotor for Gea's work, she asked me for this.. nothing violating... ;-)

[Geagijsbertsen]

@flammuth

you are right to say that it might not be Sharon herself that does this. But its true that the original video 'our last farewel 'is removed from youtube and replaced with a video where you see some other singer but with the voice of Gea. And that is a strange way to do... I'm not trying to blame or slander anybody, just giving the facts.

And Gea was no teacher of Sharon!

[rey982]

@VirusitaREC Hola, la cantante del video, se llama Gea, es más arriba ha comentado algo, con su cuenta Geagijs... Es una mezzo soprano holandsea

[travel23231]

Deffinately not Tarja!

[AliceShowbiz]

But.... in the end Sharon says "Applause to Tarja", doesn't she?

[unevilGenius]

@AliceShowbiz She says "Applause to Gea"

[AliceShowbiz]

@unevilGenius How do you pronounce "Gea"? I thought the name Sharon says it's too long to be that one :)

[unevilGenius]

@AliceShowbiz Just like you write it. Sorry, I clearly understand "Gea" and can't imagine how this could sound like "tarja"

[GothaXDark]

Gea Gijsbertsen was a teacher of Sharon van den adel!!!

[Geagijsbertsen]

@GothaXDark

Gea has never been a teacher to Sharon!! Thats a lie that Sharon keeps alive. She also blocks the original video With Gea from internet.

[GothaXDark]

@Geagijsbertsen I dont know to be honest, I just wrote what a friend of mine wanted me to write ^_^

She doesn't have an account so she asked me to put that there.

[Blueyluvscheese]

@Geagijsbertsen No, it's not Sharon that keeps up this lie, I guess a fan one day said this as a lie, and people believed them. I have never heard Sharon talk about this. Also 'she' doesn't block the original video - that would be the record company due to copyright. Did you know Within Temptation's own uploaded videos get blocked in Germany against their wishes? I'm not trying to offend anyone here, I'm just correcting some things that have been said.

[ShaeAogiri]

Not Tarja

[kiniro83]

I remember this. Record is from related video by ERDALxFOREVER.

I don't know Gea but definetly it's not Tarja voice. And face. IMO she is terrible. She could be (i think) Sarah Brightman.

And sorry for bad english.

[1MusicManiac1]

@kiniro83

I don't know Gea either, though the name does sound familiar, but there's no way that's either Tarja Turunen or Sarah Brightman. Sounds half-decent though, I suppose.

Is it just me or does Sharon sound a bit out of breath, at the beginning of the song at least?

[myrezpro]

This Gae person sings horribly

I mean, except the fact that her voice sounds horrible with Sharon's, she's just a horrible singer.

In this song at least, she makes mistakes all of the time.

[Namantos]

I can agree that the idea of Tarja and Sharon on the same stage is sweet and both have awesoem voices... but... not in a duett :/ Honestly, it sounds pretty bad when they sing together... well, that's only my opinion, which I am entitled to have without being stoned ^^

[OmorosePanya]

@Namantos You are allowed to have an opinion, yes, but we are also allowed to criticize it.

Just sayin'.

Anyway, I agree with you. Also, I hate when the audience claps. They never do it on beat. >.>

[dikaoner]

kegrandeeeeeeeeeeeee tyarja

[3MJM3]

It's Gea Gijsbertsen NOT Tarja :P

[LauX31]

awesome and fantasic a great duet with this beautiful voices

Sharon Den Adel and Tarja Turunen!!!

[Asahiart]

ppl> Gea is not a metal wannabe whatever , she is an opera singer , who came as a guest ... Anyway to me thats the best version of this song , give me goosebump everytime Gea is singing , shame that this song is underated !

[TearisShatteredMoon]

@Asahiart The problem is people don't think it works cause of the style originally, both original and this version are beautiful so why can't they just listen to the one they like? Me myself I think it add a whole new depth as a duet sounds like a family being torn apart!

[acoupleanutcases]

i kinda like her voice, though the technique seems far from perfect... but hey, live singing ain't easy :/ Personally I'm not especially into fusing styles like that, but this wasn't quite as bad as I expected :P

[Phobeus87]

@acoupleanutcases Keep in mind that this is a live performance.. I think it's awesome.

[LudiHERMANkoknit]

That Gea person is a horrible singer. God I hate those metal wannabe opera singers. This is not opera singing, it's so bad you can't call it that. A fifteen year old beginner in opera sounds better than her. Ugh... horrible. And this is such a nice song. At least Sharon sounds lovely as always.

[TearisShatteredMoon]

@LudiHERMANkoknit BULL! Gea is a beautiful singer and it added a whole new depth to do it as a duet!

[LudiHERMANkoknit]

@TearisShatteredMoon She sucks and it hurts my ears. I know what I'm talking about and you should be ashamed. Go listen to some real opera before saying that. Go type in Sumi Jo or Eglise Gutierrez and than compare them to this. Her singing is absolutely dreadful. I've heard teenagers in music school that sound a million times better than her.

[TearisShatteredMoon]

@LudiHERMANkoknit Again I say BULL, I classically trained in music my husband was in orchestra, She has a raw talent the difference is she is a rough deeper voice not a true high opera it's a DIFFERENT voice not worse.

Get a real music education opera is not the beat all end all of music and not all soprano or high notes are opera

[LudiHERMANkoknit]

@TearisShatteredMoon You are clearly an idiot. The color of her voice has absolutely nothing to do with the fact that her technique sucks, or better yet, she doesn't have any. She makes mistakes in her singing that I can hear, and if you can't you obviously have no idea what you're talking about. 

[TearisShatteredMoon]

@LudiHERMANkoknit you are clearly an abecedarian troll if you don't like it go away and get a real musical education. I never said "color of her voice" so obviously you are illiterate too get a life.

[LudiHERMANkoknit]

@TearisShatteredMoon You're a retard.

[TearisShatteredMoon]

@LudiHERMANkoknit get a life, mister pot v kettle

[TheDevilHerslef]

Dunno if it's Tarja or the other woman but personally it ruined the entire song...it sounds hideous...some fake wannabe opera voice on a light pretty song omg I can't even listen to this....

[NightwishZandoz]

Evert truthfull Within Temptation fan should know that's Gea Gijsbertsen.

[voullab]

It's Gea Gijsbertsen who sings along with Sharon

[GSPM4EVER]

if only this had the actual footage of this song from the mother earth tour...oh well

[kiotocitystories]

Loosers this is not Tarja.

Look at the first related video and watch it!!!! Don't be fooled by the title, because if you look at the woman she doesn't even look as Tarja.

[theGoob713]

that's Tarja

[will9457]

its gea gijsbersen at 1:42

[Legendil]

1:42 There's Tarja singing..

[Lizianeeee]

Its not Tarja, But I love yhis voice

[parm311]

Thats not Tarja... but the song is beautiful...

[wendybcl1979]

Uważam, że bez względu na to, który nie jest Tarja Turunen, ale isa piękna piosenka, uwielbiam Within Temptation .....

[Tarja456]

Hmm... A no rzeczywiście , Sorki...

Nie no bo ta facetka ma "podobny" głos do Tarji ...

Sorki ... :D

[Tarja456]

1 uwaga, Tą piosenkę z Sharon nie śpiewa " Gea Gijsbertsen " Tylko Tarja Turunen !! -_-

[kamiloos]

@Tarja456

Szczegolnie , ze pod koniec kawalka Sharon wola "Gea, applause for Gea" :P

[satsukimi]

I love this song ♥