Wonderful performance. It was obviously never going to match Radiohead's - I would rank Fake Plastic Trees up with Let Down and No Surprises as Thom's best three vocal performances - but KT still does a great job, and it's beautiful to listen to...
I was at the concert on the 6th when she was singing this and it was fantastic - one of the many highlights of the show - I would imagine the DVD and CD versions will have much better sound for the naysayers!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This version is horrid. It is almost as if a zombie or a vampire or some other souless being is singing this song. She just doesn't have the emotion behind the words. I will admit that it was mostly unlistenable to me and I had to skip large parts of it for fear I would destroy my computer just to stop the horror and pain she was inflicting on me. The original is one of my very favorite songs and you can hear Thoms voice cracking and at the brink of tears.
The 3rd night was definitely being filmed for DVD. Whether it's a standalone or a bonus disc with the forthcoming album they recorded at Neil Finn's studio I don't know. And maybe the other 2 nights were also being filmed.
The previous "7 World's Collide" DVD from 2001 was a composite of performances from different nights.
Wonderful performance. It was obviously never going to match Radiohead's - I would rank Fake Plastic Trees up with Let Down and No Surprises as Thom's best three vocal performances - but KT still does a great job, and it's beautiful to listen to...
ThyBrad 2 years ago 4
Musically a very good performance. Emotionally, meh. It's not bad but it pales next to Tweedy's rendition let alone Thom's.
RadioMuse1 3 years ago 4
johnny marr on guitar there too, aso nthe Geoff Tweedie one.
hughwrang 3 years ago
I was at the concert on the 6th when she was singing this and it was fantastic - one of the many highlights of the show - I would imagine the DVD and CD versions will have much better sound for the naysayers!!
sashapah67 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This version is horrid. It is almost as if a zombie or a vampire or some other souless being is singing this song. She just doesn't have the emotion behind the words. I will admit that it was mostly unlistenable to me and I had to skip large parts of it for fear I would destroy my computer just to stop the horror and pain she was inflicting on me. The original is one of my very favorite songs and you can hear Thoms voice cracking and at the brink of tears.
elinver 3 years ago
She's brave :) I would never have had the guts to do that on stage with two Radiohead memeber, but she's doing it really good :) Love KT
HeleneRT 3 years ago 7
wow! what a great song to cover and what an amazing performance
sarah6667 3 years ago
Stunning version. Much better than Jeff Tweedys.
But how many guitars does this song actually need? There appears to be 6 of them up there at least!
kemikalrxn 3 years ago 2
LOL 90% of the original song is just one guitar.
elinver 3 years ago
Yeah! And doesn't it give ye chills??
MrDrewseph 3 years ago
Wow!!!! It's just perfect
Calixta007 3 years ago
How many times was this song performed on the night, as I notice that tweedy from Wilco also did a version...
paulsawers 3 years ago
There were 3 nights of shows. Tweedy sang it on night 1 & 3, Tunstall on night 2.
jp30 3 years ago
Whoa. I'm SO glad I went on the 2nd night. Not only is KT frickin amazing, but it's a fantastic song...
I reeeally hope they filmed this for a dvd. (It would make sense, right?)
MrDrewseph 3 years ago
The 3rd night was definitely being filmed for DVD. Whether it's a standalone or a bonus disc with the forthcoming album they recorded at Neil Finn's studio I don't know. And maybe the other 2 nights were also being filmed.
The previous "7 World's Collide" DVD from 2001 was a composite of performances from different nights.
jp30 3 years ago
This was filmed - I was standing beside the camera and soundboard. The whole show was awesome.
spenserspenser25 3 years ago
amazing
pedrowasabi 3 years ago
Thanks for posting! I was starting to think no one had any video of these shows. Any chance you have bodysnatchers from this night?
orangecrush333 3 years ago
Thanx and no I don't thinl I do.I'll check just in case.
DimNarz 1 year ago