ONE FOR THE VINE (Chris L & Brad G cover Genesis)

[earlofmar11]

"One for the Vine" is maybe my all time favourite Tony Banks composition (even though some others come close). Your version is absolutely superb. I loaded the video on my iPod and am watching it regularly. You really have the talent and the dedication!

Makes me wonder how many hours you spend each day on making all this marvellous music...

[chris21125150]

@earlofmar11 Thanks, earlofmar11, for the comment and the support!

[axsisofevil]

WOW!!!

[chris21125150]

@axsisofevil Thanks, axsisofevil!

[yea78861]

well done chris,

brad sounds great on this

sorry i missed this one..

tim

[chris21125150]

@yea78861 Thanks Tim!

[logophile]

Too good for words. I am going to stop making videos now.......

[chris21125150]

@logophile Thanks, logophile, but please don't stop making videos. :)

[zylyp]

That's brilliant! Bravo!

[chris21125150]

@zylyp Thanks, zylyp!

[LOL4618]

No doubt that this is your best video.

[chris21125150]

@LOL4618 Thanks so much, LOL4618! My favorite is the full length Supper's Ready on my channel. Please check it out. Thanks for all the comments!

[LOL4618]

3:55 :D

[LOL4618]

OMG. I love this music.

[chris21125150]

@LOL4618 Thanks again for the comment, LOL4618!

[MICHAELSTEPHENROGERS]

i have been a genesis fan since the early seventies What you you have achieved with your videos is nothing short of miraculous I have always wanted to see these tracks performed in the manner you have presented Tribute bands come and go but what you have done is nothing short of perfection I liked the vocals also

[chris21125150]

@MICHAELSTEPHENROGERS Thanks so much for your kind words!

[sarcee1960]

Love the mellotron bits.

[chris21125150]

@sarcee1960 Thanks, sarcee1960!

[WinstonKiva]

Absolutely great. Perfect. 

[chris21125150]

@WinstonKiva Thanks! Winstonkiva!

[NofreG]

Better than the original. Nearly. Just amazing. It has a soul, it's not only a cover. You can breath the love and sensibility put into it. Thanks.

[chris21125150]

@NofreG Thanks again for the comment, NofreG!

[galactus170X]

Good job man! Good job.

[chris21125150]

@galactus170X Thanks, galactus170X!

[JorgeGM1]

Excelentemente bien tocada esta hermosa y difícil canción de Genesis, una de mis preferidas. Enhorabuena, Congratulations!

[chris21125150]

@JorgeGM1 Muchas gracias por su comentario. ¡Mucho apreciado!

[ordenaguer]

Wow, its si good, i really love that song and it has been played like i had never heard before. Congratulations!

[chris21125150]

@ordenaguer Thank you, ordenaguer!

[youpooroldsod]

I stumbled upon this and was absolutely blown away. Nothing amateur or unprofessional -- it's hard enough to play this piece on any one instrument, let alone all you incorporated, and the vocals were quite alright. To put in all that attention to details and come up with this is a formidable achievement -- congratulations and thank you for sharing the fruits of your labor.

[NintendoSoup]

This is the most impressive Genesis cover i've ever seen!!!

Thank you very much for providing me this amazing experience!!!

I already added it to my favorites ;~~

Congrats!!

[chris21125150]

@NintendoSoup Thanks for the comment, NintendoSoup! I'm glad you enjoyed it!

[ClarkyUK1]

Absolutely wonderful! Held my complete attention for the whole piece and left me in awe as to how much work had gone into this! Respect brother!

[chris21125150]

@ClarkyUK1 Thanks for your kind words, ClarkyUK1! I'm glad you enjoyed my little video. :) :)

[musichopper]

Nice.But, I think the bass guitar note @ 1:20 should be C# and sticks the C# unchanging while the synth plays off the major 7th degree thing to the F.

[musichopper]

Nice. I think the bass guitar note @ 1:20 should be C# and sticks the C# unchanging while the synth plays off the major 7th degree thing to the F.

[ontherush77]

Amazing! but the drums a pretty quiet

[mbvicaria]

Chris

magnifico trabajo, great job. thanks

Manolo

[BaertM]

Very well done, one of my favourites by Genesis. Just spent the whole morning listening to your stuff and created an account so I can react. Just found your channel too.

[ChrisSousa9]

How does this not have more views? This is an amazing showing of skill, musicianship, and reproduction.

[badrogue66]

Dude that was pretty fucking awesome

[stokkernk]

Amazing!! Excellent work guys, well done!!

[broadaccent]

The best song of Phil Collins era. Great cover.

[Pjomell]

Amazingly great job!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[cosmicjazzer]

Some bits of this are better than the original! many of the keyboard sounds are lovely! Wonderful! Listening to this has somehow... reconnected something in me... Thanks! :)

[70srules]

Simply Great !

[mollyscreationz]

WOW! Absolutely AMAZING!

[lookingfortalent2007]

Hello, if you're taking requests, I'd love to hear your version of "a venture" by YES, it has an intricate piano ending, thanks

[NCMountainDavis]

From a long time Genesis fan...This is great stuff! Now, lets hear Cinema Show...

[cosmicjazzer]

This actually very nice! Lovely :)

[martindbowman]

Chris again quite extraordinary work brings tears to my eyes I look forward to viewing more of your covers cheers

[groeni100]

Congratulations for the good singer!

[donniemartin]

suuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuperb all the best DonnieM

[CrustyCurmudgeon]

Makes me yearn to re-live the 70's and catch all the great music live that I missed the first time around. Bravo guys!

[eleventhearlofmar]

Awesome!!!

[avidvideoviewer]

You dudes rule! Harken back to days gone when true art hath been done!!

[7dmv]

Made of 100% pure awesome. You guys are great!

Now, let's hear 'The Cinema Show/Aisle of Plenty' from Selling England By The Pound.

[gazzo45]

Chirs - I missed this posting. Utterly fabulous stuff - and a great vocal from The Bradster too! Brilliant...

[chris21125150]

Thanks, gazzo45!

[panisperna]

I am speechless... Wonderful! Complments!

[copiedoffme]

Very nice Chris and Brad!!

[Sovietico88]

brilliant

[andrew2410]

great job! thanks.

Makes you wonder how Tony played all those keyboard layers. Brilliant.

[redazul1]

damn man very good

[benperezc]

Congratulations Chris!! I think your longest effort so far deserves an encore and I salute you from Chile, South America. I've been a big fan of Progressive Rock Bands and especially Genesis. Have you ever contacted Genesis staff or Tony Banks? I think you are really doing an awesome work covering their songs. My congratulations to your vocals he's done a great job in this difficult song. I wish you the best, warm hugs and I will post some information about your work in my blog.

[gazzo45]

No kidding, this is utterly BRILLIANT. Chris, you are a marvel - why aren't you making a fortune playing in a top band? Stunning stuff. Also an excellent vocal from Brad.

[Townender80]

Wonderful. You do Genesis proud.

[Trisprint]

Outstanding work. The attention to detail is astonishing. Thankyou.

[stexxie]

Unbelievable.

Thank you.

[manthega2]

Só para quem entende de música! Lindo , Perfeito, Fantástico. Uma verdadeira Obra Prima! Pena que poucas pessoas no mundo conhecem estas canções. "Eles" tocaram esta no show aqui onde moro no Rio de Janeiro nos Anos Dourados 70. Me escondi no banheiro nos Intervalos e assisti a todos os Shows durante os 3 dias. Toco alguma coisa no Violão e voce é uma grande inspiração para mim. Tu és um Gênio, o Paraíso te aguarda... Forte Abraço...Chris...

[urasak00]

素晴らしい！４ヶ月でgenesisになりきれるなんて!!。C­hrisの演奏もすごいけど、やはりgenesisの名曲は心に­響きます。Thank you Chris!

[objimmy]

OUTSTANDING!!!!! My fav Genesis tune... GREAT JOB!!

[BabyEvil1]

Bravo. 

Jan

[chrisoconnell32]

hi chris,would love to put a vocal over this with you,click on my name tag to hear my voice,im doin the lamb and stuff.

[trevizons]

Congratulations, Beautiful job, quite accurate, but, with all due respect, and I know it's very hard to reproduce masterpieces like this one here, it takes years sometimes, if you just added some emotion to it, specially at the guitar solo, emphasizing more on those cords, the way Steve does it, perhaps simple, but with a lot of deep feeling, in order to achieve that unique sound that charecterized old Genesis, make that guitar vibrate and you will accomplish some perfection, thanks Chris Cheers

[BrentMB79]

Wayyyyyy to talented to be on just youtube!!

Great work on a very hard song!

[pizzafrenzyman]

Brilliant!

[vikingilvikingo]

Bravissimi - THANKS CHRIS .

[chris21125150]

no problem and thanks for the comment, vikingilvikingo.

[sirReginaldFartsalot]

Wow! I'm blown away.  What an amazing reproduction!

[chris21125150]

thank you sirReginaldFartsalot.

[celestina06]

Fantastic! Absolutely beautiful! I am lost for words... thank you so much....x

[chris21125150]

Thanks, celestina06. I'm glad you enjoyed it.

[colininla]

Don't be discouraged by the 'frankness' of some of the usenet news groupers. This is something you both can be quite proud of. Thanks.

[chris21125150]

Thanks colininla. I take it all with a grain of salt. :)

[westrokker]

wow, amazing

[Eldanoth]

This is one of the most beautiful and complicated song by Tony Banks.

Thank you Chris! Thank you, thank you, thank you. I love it!

Please more

[chris21125150]

Thanks, Eldanoth. I'm glad you enjoyed it.

[mkiver]

Absolutely outstanding Chris....One for the Vine and one for the road!!

[chris21125150]

Thank you for your comment, mkiver.

[julyvalls]

You are amazing Chris!

[chris21125150]

Thanks for the compliment, julyvalls.

[rodeoskunk]

Sounds like Yes doing Genesis.  I like it.

[chris21125150]

Thanks, rodeoskunk. I'm glad you liked it.

[arank1rs]

Ditto to that. He has both Jon Anderson's and Trevor Horn's voices.

[martindbowman]

This is awesome!!! Thanks so much

[chris21125150]

You're welcome, marindbowman. Thanks for the comment.

[lookingfortalent2007]

3 seconds to favorited, very elaborate, very good, you are doing everything but the singing?

[chris21125150]

Thank you, lookingfortalent2007. Yes, I'm doing everything but the singing.

[jasonbass1962]

excellent work, guys! it shows your admiration for this great tune.

[chris21125150]

Thanks, jasonbass1962!

[placidian]

That was wonderful, and the slight instrumentation change for the last verse section was so lovely. (I'm referring to the classical guitar) Amazing playing!

--------

A VERY long time ago, my old band learned One For The Vine only to find that the singer was uncomfortable in the orig. key; the decision to transpose a whole step nearly caused mutiny in the band. ha! such an enormous amount of work for a cover song that nobody knew anyway. Oh well... =)

[chris21125150]

Thanks for the comment, placidian.

[brianedmunds]

Now how are the rest of us supposed to compete with this? Excellent work - 5 stars

[chris21125150]

Thank you, brianedmunds.

[gardenwall07]

i can only imagine what a hard and long job it took you to make this! congratulations! i liked your personal arrangement in the second part of the song...:-) brad made a great job too !

[chris21125150]

Thanks for the compliment, gardenwall07

[sheer88]

Amazing, as always! :)

Still waiting for Supper's ready! :D

[chris21125150]

Thanks sheer88. Yah, Supper's Ready is definitely one I want to do, but when I don't know. So many songs so little time! Thanks for watching.

[centralscrutinizer9]

excellent Chris!! that sure is alot of parts to work out i'm exhausted just imagining it

the bloke on the vocals was also great

superb video

[chris21125150]

Thanks for your kind words, centralscrutinizer9.

[AJAUK1]

Brilliant work

[chris21125150]

Thanks, AJAUK1.

[watchersofthesky]

Fantastic work. Bookmarked, just in case you ever decide to Los Endos...??

[chris21125150]

Thank you, watchersofthesky. Los Endos....maybe one day.

[lampynoiseboy]

Just to let you know that it was worth the hard work. really enjoyed your playing as usual. you have an amzing talent for playing music. Please keep it up, even though it must be hard work! You must see if you can write some of your own material as well....

[chris21125150]

Thanks for the comment, lampynoiseboy.

[AJAUK1]

First class

[sulement]

Honestly, Chris if this is your production I'm awestruck.

The instruments, the vocal, the arrangement? Wow.

Your talent is so patently obvious it won't be long before some big names in the industry come looking to sign you.

[chris21125150]

Thanks for the kind words, sulement!

[pinamar13]

Thanks Chris, Brad, are excellents!!

your work is wanderfull

[chris21125150]

Thanks, pinamar13.

[gsal2112]

Chris, once again you have demonstrated your phenomenal musical gifts....and you have done it again with some of the best music ever made! Thanks for all the enjoyable videos you make.

[chris21125150]

Thank you, gsal2112.

[IAMoraes]

The vocal is perfect for this song!!! Excellent, guys!

[chris21125150]

Thanks, IAMoraes.

[yesfan951]

This is beast!

[agusagaz]

Incredibly good!!!!!!!! 5 stars isn't fair enough!

[chris21125150]

Thanks, agusagaz.

[0Skyzer0]

Perfect! as always :D

[chris21125150]

Thanks, OSkyzer0

[brotherofmine]

What can I say but wow! Aside from your undoubted talent watching you play everything side by side, I really get a feel of how much work goes into composing these songs. Thank you again.

[chris21125150]

Thanks for your kind words, brotherofmine!

[Starrdustwoman]

Lovely~

Loads of talent..and much appreciated!

[chris21125150]

Thanks a bunch, Starrdustwoman.

[Quiquemusic]

Bravo¡ Amazing¡ It is wonderfull.

Congratulatios. Greetings

[chris21125150]

Thank you, Quiquemusic

[butcherbird52]

Very good. No offense, but I did not appreciate some of the vocal work, but the instrumental parts were just splendid.

[MarxNutz]

Bravissimo! You did it again, Chris! I got goosebumps! Excellent cover of a post-peter gabriel Genesis classic!

[chris21125150]

Thanks, MarxNutz.

[miaris]

This is marvelous!

Fantastic job :)

[chris21125150]

Thank you, miaris!

[pjtpjt]

Totally lost for words. This was just fantastic...

[chris21125150]

Thanks, pjtpjt.

[isadog77]

Chris,just terrific! thanks a million

[chris21125150]

Thank you, isadog77

[yea78861]

real nice chris, i like this alot, right on

brads voice is very well suited for this

[chris21125150]

Thank you, yea78861.

[bengalbacker]

Absolutely fantastic, as usual.

[chris21125150]

Thanks, bengalbacker.

[DominickBlack]

Good job.

[chris21125150]

Thank you, DominickBlack.

[plugh1]

wow - this is in a league by itself.

[chris21125150]

Thanks, plugh1.

[troubleclef]

Chris, you've outdone yourself this time...

I'd be content to just play one of those parts well. Let alone figure it out and put it all together. How, I ask, how DO you do it?

[chris21125150]

Thanks troubleclef. Just a lot of hard and sometimes mundane work. :)

[EvH920410]

AHHHH!! an explosion at 8:29

[EvH920410]

wow 7:16 was cool synth

[EvH920410]

wow wat a crazy metal guitar for a genesis song lol

[EvH920410]

this is my favorite of brads vocals never heard them like that.........im surprised this didnt take longer lol awesome

[hyperboreal]

OMG, you're my hero Chris, I don't have words to describe your enormous talent! You must really be the chosen one! :) The rasgueados (strumming) on that classical guitar are a nice and warm personal touch, also did you use any bass pedals on the early part? And 4:47 ? lol

If it's not much to ask, do you have the karaoke version of this?

[chris21125150]

Thanks, hyperboreal. Haha, chosen one, yah right. :) I didn't use any bass pedals in this song. Glad you liked my 'blooper' at 4:47. :) I don't have a karaoke version of this at this point.

[hyperboreal]

Alright Chris, no problem. You must be exhausted after finishing this one. Thanks for performing my favorite song from Wind & Wuthering.