great video! i was on holidays and caught both shows in Milan. close to 90 000 fans and they sang louder than you could ever imagine. gives me chills watching this. cant wait till they play my hometown edmonton canada but i know it will be nothing like this show. Those damn Italians sure love this band!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
News-Flash: This is U2s Last tour
there is a disconnect between the lead singer and the band, Bono doesn't believe in it anymore, his passion and his edginess has gone,he looks so uncomfortable, is he a stand in? It is understandable and totally natural for a 49 year old to feel a little silly up there , when there is so many more important things to do. The album was great..keep making great albums. The show a parody of a rock band , going through the motions. From mike a big U2 fan.
Interesting. I'm almost 49 myself. I urge you to remember your comment when you reach that age, and then, think about how young you will still feel then, despite your age.
I mean absolutely no disparagement.
Just, maybe, when you turn 49, you 'll realize how young you still are (and so am I), in so many ways... :)
didn't like the song originally but last nite at Soldier Field with the Chicago skyline behind almost in attendance ,it became the soundtrack for difficult times almost and reflection
E io ero li 3 giorni fa, quando erano a Nizza, ma sono rimasta delusa dai francesi... Tutti e 4 hanno dato il massimo, ma nessuno ha fatto festa o ha cantato o gridato facendo loro complimenti...:( é proprio vero che gli italiani sono i + bravi a fare festa. peccati che non ero a milano!
the bigest power of a band is to still after those years wrighting new songs..but good songs.i thing the new album it is awesome,and this song is the new
'with or whithout you"of our years.i was there and after the end of the show i still singing this song for long time....
Hey, I saw you are from Zielona Gora, Nice city, the city of women. Me and my friends wil go there first this summer on holiday and then we go to Chorzow. Can't wait until monday, my first concert (Amsterdam)
I've never thought that this song could the last one. in my opinion with or without maybe could be better...anyway that was an unforgettable show, and "the claw" is amazing...magic! we love you U2
I was there at both Milan shows, AMAZING! Moment of Surrender is the perfect closer, it's a spiritual moment, hauntingly beautiful. Bono's very much into it, he seems to love the song a lot. True beauty, especially the second verse. Only thing I miss is the "God do not deny her" part, don't know why he's never singing this one live. Great great show, U2, amazing tour!
From the first chorus to the end of the song, it is perfect. However, the intro and first verse need work. The bass needs to be more featured in the verse, and Edge should stick to the piano for that to happen. I think the drums should cut out for Bono's first couple of lines, and then kick back in. The first few lines sound a bit hurried. Also, cut out one verse of the 'oh-oh-oh'.
The first time I listened to the album I thought, "Wow! This is the perfect song to close with! I also thought tat Magnificent would be a good opener. Now though, I think that Magnificent shouldn't be. I love Breathe! It's my favorite on the album!
They need to figrue out a way to end that song so the crowd is left chanting the "Ohhhh Ohhh Ohhhh!" parts. It's a great song but it has such a lack luster end especially toe dn the concert.
some of the other ones are fantastic and they sound great and the tour is getting better every night. Bono doesn't seem like he is rushing through Breathe anymore :)
But MOS is obviously still finding it's live version.
There were 5-6 mistakes in one song and I'm sure they are not thrilled with this performance-
But I am sure if you were there, it was still awesome~
3 anello blu , gli u2 sono u2 io che li sento da 30 anni come dici tu a sarrabanda alla prima nota la indovinavo e tutti cantavano , niente avevate il biglietto di jacko ???
ero primo anello verde e si sentiva discretamente,immagino a quei poveretti che erano agli anelli superiori! san siro già fa cagare come acustica se poi togliamo anche il volume,spero che non suonino più a san siro.voglio risentire la potenza di questa musica sublime
av1708 ... mi dispiace davvero ... purtroppo non è uno stadio per fare concerti .... lo sostengo da un bel po .... ero al secondo arancio ... non posso lamentarmi ma il sentire bene è tutta un altra cosa ... e questi suonano in 4 ... quando sono in 10 non te lo spiego nemmeno.
better than previous versions, but still not very good. and you can't hear clayton 's thumping bass, as you can on the album... disappointing, and not good song to end the show..
Dal terzo anello rosso, l'audio è stato sempre un boato indefinito di suoni indistinguibili...
Per me e per tanti fan degli u2, è stata una vera delusione assistere ad un concerto senza poter partecipare, tutti in silenzio, sembrava di stare a sarabanda, vinceva chi riusciva ad indovinare la canzone!!!
I'm afraid that unison singing ruins both this song and Unknown caller for me. It's simply not their thing. As soon as Bono starts singing slightly differently than the backing vocals, both songs become great, to me at least.
É neste momento que vou chorar, tenho certeza! 13/04/11 lá no Morumbi - São Paulo - Brasil.
missdanubia 10 months ago
Edge needs to practice that solo
newpixeldude 11 months ago
I think this is one of the greatest songs of U2.
ohhh...
I've got moved ...
LM24H7122MRT917053 1 year ago
Beautiful song... We're waiting for U2 here in Brazil on april 2011.
MarcStell 1 year ago
shame everyone cannot stfu during this...
kazrak 1 year ago 2
This song is a prayer. it makes the perfect bonfire song to sum up my feelings for the day...
GQOfficial 1 year ago
one of my favorite songs from the new album.
yosoyisrael 1 year ago
great video! i was on holidays and caught both shows in Milan. close to 90 000 fans and they sang louder than you could ever imagine. gives me chills watching this. cant wait till they play my hometown edmonton canada but i know it will be nothing like this show. Those damn Italians sure love this band!
jlizelle 1 year ago 5
W U2!!!!!!
camozfa 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
IO C'ERO.... che emozioni....oggi mi sto rivivendo il concerto... che serata fantastica .. questa canzone con ultraviolet... da pelle d'oca!!
IAllwantyou 2 years ago
IO C'ERO.... che emozioni....oggi mi sto rivivendo il concerto... che serata fantastica .. questa canzone con ultraviolet... da pelle d'oca!!
IAllwantyou 2 years ago
Incredible as Bono sings with such strength and feeling ... He is unique!
ArthurRosa21 2 years ago
last CD was way better.
gregsobekofficial 2 years ago
Wow, 62BONO, couldn't be better said.... thank you for your words!
dewisweet 2 years ago
I agree with you 62BONO!!
anpi529 2 years ago 4
by this song, I can feel God in my heart and proud to be a u2's fan. The most beautiful song from the album for me: Thank you Bono.
62BONO 2 years ago 26
...Going through the emotions, get it right. Bono is keeping it real he doesn't have to act like a rockstar on stage all the time.
Franckdatankpart2 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
News-Flash: This is U2s Last tour
there is a disconnect between the lead singer and the band, Bono doesn't believe in it anymore, his passion and his edginess has gone,he looks so uncomfortable, is he a stand in? It is understandable and totally natural for a 49 year old to feel a little silly up there , when there is so many more important things to do. The album was great..keep making great albums. The show a parody of a rock band , going through the motions. From mike a big U2 fan.
wildcathill 2 years ago
Hmmm...interesting. I do have to agree that the Atlanta show was a bit under-energized.
We will see I guess....
sljouzo12 2 years ago
Interesting. I'm almost 49 myself. I urge you to remember your comment when you reach that age, and then, think about how young you will still feel then, despite your age.
I mean absolutely no disparagement.
Just, maybe, when you turn 49, you 'll realize how young you still are (and so am I), in so many ways... :)
mrspeel7 2 years ago 3
@wildcathill no its not. infact, when i saw them, i believed they played as one. believe me, theyll be back despite bono's broken back :(
GQOfficial 1 year ago
nice work all around...what device did you use to film??
RikkerPKeaton 2 years ago
oh my god i was there..... wonderful...
matteogege92 2 years ago 2
didn't like the song originally but last nite at Soldier Field with the Chicago skyline behind almost in attendance ,it became the soundtrack for difficult times almost and reflection
vikTrikster 2 years ago
great video and audio quality...thanks! love this song.
Satellitegirl41 2 years ago 4
That daego at the begining needs to shut up.
14691 2 years ago
Do you kno what a daeog is mofo-ya you 14691.......please be quiet
Mokadelite61 2 years ago
Monica's favorite song ~ Just Realized it's becoming Mine as Well ~ Happy Birtday ~
MAG ~ MSH
Applemac44 2 years ago
a livello di partecipazione san siro è the best
stellina997 2 years ago
Mi rivolgo al tizio che ha insultato gratuitamente la figlia di Bono .. Cioè , ma non avevi altro da dire-fare in un momento del genere?
Bellissimo video comunque !!
JosephBB1 2 years ago
sn d accordo
stellina997 2 years ago
I was on concert here in Croatia, in Zagreb, and it was amazing, too.... I wanna cry when i remember :)
breskvica11 2 years ago 2
Terrific song, great upload
Manashr5690 2 years ago
Thanks Martin for your beautiful videos
niconew16 2 years ago
a quello che commenta in sottofondo...SEI TU UNA MERDA !
CHE CAZZO DI GENTE CHE CI STA...
GOD SAVE U2 !
pupazzicchio 2 years ago 2
to hear 80,000 people singing the end of with or without you must be an amazing feeling as a band...then into this song...just awesome
robthelegend6 2 years ago 6
i think there was more people :) i was there :)
joethefast 2 years ago
the voice of bono are coming down, however he´s great!!! no doubt!!!
Drivexz46Xin 2 years ago 5
i think his voice is amazing...best since popmart...my opinion though...and yep he is great! =)
nlothvictor 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The single most awful song U2 have ever written. Filth
rankingjohnmajor 2 years ago
fu fu fu fu fu fu fu
laboloche 2 years ago
Awesome!
dominiquedv 2 years ago 12
the best song of the new album... it will become a classical, no doubt!
matteogege92 2 years ago 7
i prefer no line on the horizon
dantemutante 2 years ago 3
What's Bono saying in Italian at the very beginning?
Smentol 2 years ago 3
"siete bellissimi"
"you are wonderful"
matteogege92 2 years ago 5
Thanks ;)
Smentol 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
dantemutante 2 years ago
Thank You for sharing this video, its GREAT to be able to whatch MY U2 LIVE, when U2 are NOT coming to MANCHESTER!!!!!!!!!!
shazandbono 2 years ago
E io ero li 3 giorni fa, quando erano a Nizza, ma sono rimasta delusa dai francesi... Tutti e 4 hanno dato il massimo, ma nessuno ha fatto festa o ha cantato o gridato facendo loro complimenti...:( é proprio vero che gli italiani sono i + bravi a fare festa. peccati che non ero a milano!
splorenzo 2 years ago 4
I was there... :)
p8little 2 years ago 3
Momenti storici e indimenticabili :)
WecklStyle93 2 years ago 2
They spend less than a month in Europe??
jpjames1 2 years ago
This is so beautiful!
Even Larry is singing! I can't hear it well, but I'm sure we will hear him singing when we see them live, Amsterdam 20 July!!!
iridikim 2 years ago 2
Io c'eroooooooooooooooooooo!
Meravigliosaaaaaaaaa 2 years ago
ja en ik was er niet bij:( heb je genoten?????
flevobirdy 2 years ago
the bigest power of a band is to still after those years wrighting new songs..but good songs.i thing the new album it is awesome,and this song is the new
'with or whithout you"of our years.i was there and after the end of the show i still singing this song for long time....
taitakostas 2 years ago 5
roll on at Hampden
chillfmdude 2 years ago
voi siete bellissimiiiiiiii
ASCOLIzzatorra 2 years ago 3
Such an awesome song. I just think that they haven't figured out how to REALLY capture the essence of the song live yet. I have confidence they will.
farluu1 2 years ago
YEAH ! Very good job !
And awesome show ! I was at the show in Paris yesterday. GREAT ! MAGNIFICENT show !
BenaiMagnificent 2 years ago
fantastica
gran bel video
grazie
gianchiinf66 2 years ago
This is a good video. Congratulations to the film maker!
dominiquedv 2 years ago
This is very good song for live performances!
I'm happy, that Bono is in very good vocal condition
Waiting for Chorzow, Poland...
fanpsone 2 years ago
Hey, I saw you are from Zielona Gora, Nice city, the city of women. Me and my friends wil go there first this summer on holiday and then we go to Chorzow. Can't wait until monday, my first concert (Amsterdam)
DiRomatti1 2 years ago
Serata splendida.. grazie ragazzi ancora una volta per quello che arriva in fondo al cuore di chi vi ascolta.
ROBY78U2 2 years ago
incredibile,se Dio avesse una voce sarebbe quella di Bono....non una di più...Bello esserci indimenticabile..Grandi,unici..GRAZIE
slydinibis 2 years ago
cazzo che voce... pensate che questa era l'ultima... niente a che vedere con il 2005... ma come hai fatto Bono... ti amo
youtooone 2 years ago
ma che cazzo a parlare durante la canzone....
giunovecento 2 years ago
INCREIBLE!
suitbluesky 2 years ago
My favorite song from No Line and Bono sounds magnificent! and i love how all the guys are into it and love the song. Look Larry is singing too!
u2MacPhisto09 2 years ago
perfect !!!!!!!
KIKI2403 2 years ago
I've never thought that this song could the last one. in my opinion with or without maybe could be better...anyway that was an unforgettable show, and "the claw" is amazing...magic! we love you U2
denisns98 2 years ago
I was there at both Milan shows, AMAZING! Moment of Surrender is the perfect closer, it's a spiritual moment, hauntingly beautiful. Bono's very much into it, he seems to love the song a lot. True beauty, especially the second verse. Only thing I miss is the "God do not deny her" part, don't know why he's never singing this one live. Great great show, U2, amazing tour!
cypress1975 2 years ago 2
From the first chorus to the end of the song, it is perfect. However, the intro and first verse need work. The bass needs to be more featured in the verse, and Edge should stick to the piano for that to happen. I think the drums should cut out for Bono's first couple of lines, and then kick back in. The first few lines sound a bit hurried. Also, cut out one verse of the 'oh-oh-oh'.
khyber900 2 years ago
bono couldnt sing whit the continue singing of the public!!
emicontessa 2 years ago
ma ki è sto cretino che commenta l abbilgliamento scomodo degli u2???? ma gente cosi non capisce na mazza della vita!!!
emicontessa 2 years ago
Cazzarola che finale emozionante!! Questa canzone era perfetta come chiusura, e la sua voce... che voceee!!!!
MsVaniglia 2 years ago
U2 is number 1 of all time...
SilverDragon1994 2 years ago 3
It seems they wrote this song to close their concerts: it's perfect!
ElaManu1978 2 years ago
The first time I listened to the album I thought, "Wow! This is the perfect song to close with! I also thought tat Magnificent would be a good opener. Now though, I think that Magnificent shouldn't be. I love Breathe! It's my favorite on the album!
bono778 2 years ago
i say.... two balls
OOOOH OOHH OH OH
zaffirina990 2 years ago
Nice emotional solo at 5:35, forget about those fast solo's, this is it !!
Gilmourish like :)
Looking forward to see them in Amsterdam ArenA
5744F 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I love U2 but this is a boring song.
Even they look bored playing it.
normanmadrid0076 2 years ago
They need to figrue out a way to end that song so the crowd is left chanting the "Ohhhh Ohhh Ohhhh!" parts. It's a great song but it has such a lack luster end especially toe dn the concert.
Hallucination 2 years ago
you really make me jealous!
you have the best videos U2006!!
I love the boys, but this was rough...
some of the other ones are fantastic and they sound great and the tour is getting better every night. Bono doesn't seem like he is rushing through Breathe anymore :)
But MOS is obviously still finding it's live version.
There were 5-6 mistakes in one song and I'm sure they are not thrilled with this performance-
But I am sure if you were there, it was still awesome~
Thanks again!
jmjmchip 2 years ago
Who's number 1 among these bands?
U2
Radiohead
Oasis
Goo Goo Dolls
Red Hot Chili Peppers
jamaicanhemp 2 years ago
U2 by a loooooong shot...not even close
rojb33 2 years ago
u2 with radiohead at a close second the others aren't even in the same league
mf088 2 years ago
U2 for sure is #1. I'd put Sterophonics as #2
Hallucination 2 years ago
I have to say Radiohead. With U2 a close second. Goo Goo Dolls are awesome live, but they're not above Chili Peppers.
But Radiohead #1. They're probably the only band that has made an amazing album after completely changin genres.
zachbredberg 2 years ago
i was there!!!!great feeling.......nice video my frend!
taitakostas 2 years ago
Wow!Wow!Wow! Great video - how many of their concerts are you going to? What a blast!
miarrem 2 years ago
io ero a 5 metri da lui...parter incredibile! veramente eccezionale!
ilmazzo4690 2 years ago
3 anello blu , gli u2 sono u2 io che li sento da 30 anni come dici tu a sarrabanda alla prima nota la indovinavo e tutti cantavano , niente avevate il biglietto di jacko ???
spitfiresp 2 years ago
secondo verde, non era male, mancava un po di potenza
fantanero 2 years ago
ero primo anello verde e si sentiva discretamente,immagino a quei poveretti che erano agli anelli superiori! san siro già fa cagare come acustica se poi togliamo anche il volume,spero che non suonino più a san siro.voglio risentire la potenza di questa musica sublime
sciupola 2 years ago 2
av1708 ... mi dispiace davvero ... purtroppo non è uno stadio per fare concerti .... lo sostengo da un bel po .... ero al secondo arancio ... non posso lamentarmi ma il sentire bene è tutta un altra cosa ... e questi suonano in 4 ... quando sono in 10 non te lo spiego nemmeno.
pliscopolipo 2 years ago
better than previous versions, but still not very good. and you can't hear clayton 's thumping bass, as you can on the album... disappointing, and not good song to end the show..
nitch003 2 years ago
And you don't think that you can hear Adams bass live? LOL! Fantastic finish of a great show.
liquidforceaxis 2 years ago
Dal terzo anello rosso, l'audio è stato sempre un boato indefinito di suoni indistinguibili...
Per me e per tanti fan degli u2, è stata una vera delusione assistere ad un concerto senza poter partecipare, tutti in silenzio, sembrava di stare a sarabanda, vinceva chi riusciva ad indovinare la canzone!!!
Mai più.
av1708 2 years ago
not a closer, alas, great song not for the end.
patternshirt 2 years ago
too much talking during the song
thewsonn 2 years ago
wonderful (L)
screamkaneofficial 2 years ago
but alot better then previous versions ;)
MartiniTyran 2 years ago
...and edge messed up the end of his solo
MartiniTyran 2 years ago
ah c'mon... messed up?
iridikim 2 years ago
...maybe a bit harsh...;)
MartiniTyran 2 years ago
try to harmonize, and play the piano and play the guitar at the same time and then tell me if it's easy
kuroroluc 2 years ago 2
that's impossible because you'd need 4 arms to do that.
MartiniTyran 2 years ago
too much "oh oh ooooh oh oh"
MartiniTyran 2 years ago
Io ero al primo anello blu... l'audio non è stato ottimale in certi momenti, non riesco a capire il perchè...
giovannibrunoro 2 years ago
Bono kinda sounds like Tom Jones at some of the verses. I like it when he pulls out the operatic voice.
Rubikscube27 2 years ago 2
grazie per aver pubblicato questo video. Ma dove eravate, sull'anello "dei privilegiati" (detto scherzosamente eh! ;)
Che piano suona The Edge?
grandissimi...
Bblackmoonlight 2 years ago
Sooo beautuful!
Shiffers donw my spine ;)
100* out of 5*
iridikim 2 years ago 3
GREAAAATTTTT!!!!! i was there yesterday!!! u2 are really the best band of the world!!
RikiCe85 2 years ago 4
Fantastic video. Thanks for sharing it. i love this song.
Ketch67 2 years ago 4
Larry and Edge making a three part harmony is great!
NilThree 2 years ago 4
I'm afraid that unison singing ruins both this song and Unknown caller for me. It's simply not their thing. As soon as Bono starts singing slightly differently than the backing vocals, both songs become great, to me at least.
dragmio 2 years ago
By the way, this song needs to be rehearsed more carefully in order to be perfect.
potenzor 2 years ago
This one was really good. The Barcelona's perfomances were crappy, specially the one of 02 july.
potenzor 2 years ago
Moment Of Surrender!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
wherethejose 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
excellent video. thanks for postin
sholbech22 2 years ago
Another great performance; thanks for posting so swiftly!
gretchenshae 2 years ago
one of their best of all time
Vertigo190 2 years ago 4