Amy Lee vs Kelly Clarkson , My Tourniquet

[zelly51]

Who fucking cares about how much they weight that's so Irrelevant! all that matters is that they both sing like goddesses!

[waitingfortherain1]

Who cares?

[abbaabbaaaabb]

Kelly's a great singer as well and that is what matters. At least if you're not a totally ignorant and stupid person. Everyone has flaws, but that's why Kelly became a singer, not a model!

[PosinousVixen]

This video isn't ignorant. Its trying to prove a point.

[ty0kroitoru1]

actually, you put all the beautiful pics of Amy and the ugliest pics of Kelly but it doesn't really matter i think that Amy is much better

[DrPieszecki]

Amy Lee was slightly plump when Kelly Clarkson was thin.

Now it's the other way around. From what I can see Amy is much thinner and Kelly has gained weight. But they are both great singers so stop arguing about it please.

[JZ311995]

I Love Kelly Clarkson And Amy, But Kelly's My Favorite! And Kelly And Amy r good friends KC Went to amy's concert not so long ago! STOP BEING CHILDISH!

-Kelly Clarkson fan :)

[Ohmieffinggosh711]

This is one of the most idiotic things I have ever seen, hahaha! Can you say "No Life"?

[kellyclarksonismygd]

This is disgusting. You should ashamed of making this video.

[TheMarisela92]

ALWAYS AMY I LOVE HER

[rv1709]

Kelly clarkson is better .. no comparison

[iloveevanescence1795]

seriously, anyone who thinks AMY LEE is fat has some serious issues to work out with themselves and their own self esteem.

[MeoshaXfluffy]

why are we comparing amy to kelly! this makes no damn sense! they're not even in the same genre!

[SpiritofInsanity]

From a purely objective point of view, Kelly Clarkson is a bit heavier. Why do we even care though? Both girls have amazing personalities and voices, and that's what matters.

[ZaphoraCorrum]

No....I don't care what anybody says. Any lee is way better than Kelly Clarkson in every way. Better body, face, voice, hell even her hair is better

[awilkinsjr]

THIS IS THE MOST IGNORANT FUCKING VIDEO AND TOPIC I'VE EVER SEEN.

[jazzymcjazzster]

Shoot.....Kelly clarkson is built exactly like me....So...obviously kelly is built amazing. Duh. hahahaha seriously though...we are built exactly alike. So, people saying kelly's fat, thank you. Glad to know that's what fat is.

[DarkyAngel1982]

they are both fat... sorry....

[Eduardo131451]

ewwwwwwwwww look at kellys arms at 1:13 thats nasty

[maykayre]

they are both fat. i think that only models are slim. i am fat too... most of us are fat

[TylerDamien]

I'm sorry, this video is a bitch move. Seriously... Low blow...

[hochunkgirl62]

Who in he'll cares who's fat, it's there singing and there inner beauty you gotta look for

[TheLaAshlee]

The pictures prove it Amy's skinny and beautiful and Kelly fat, but she's still not ugly

[lacrymosa789]

Amy lee shouldnt be compared to Kelly Carkson

Amy's too damn good

[21ctm21]

Gayest video ever

[VeronikEVfan]

i looove amy lee ...... i loke kelly too ... but amy is the beeest .... woooohoooooooooo !!!!!!! \m/

[dotcake]

They both change weight, I believe that amy's work out is when she's performing, she constantly runs around and jumps everywhere so I'm guessing when she's doing concerts and tours she loses weight and when she takes a break to record songs (still waiting -.-) She might put on some weight from lack of excercise? Plus kelly just stands there and sings, so it's not like she get's much excercise done and she seems like the celebrity to lose weight going on diets and doing serious excercise

[danyman88]

they're both kinda fat...

[carolinagirl009]

This video is ridicoulseand uncalled for. Picking fun of Kelly and using non flattering photos of her is stupid. How low people can get.

[monkeygirl333sm]

Lmfao Kelly's got fat all over her! Amy is so not fat my Tourniquet u guys get ur eyes checked! And Amy is better. :)

[Freeyyaaa]

LMFAO! Amys fat?

your having a laugh?

Kelly is actaully fat

Amy dosent have an inch of fat on her!

THUMBS UP IF YOU AGREE!

[carolinagirl009]

@Freeyyaaa Kelly is not fat she's normal size, and Kelly has actually lost some weight but the whole who's fat, who's not shouldn't matter. Kelly & Amy are singers not models. :)

[Freeyyaaa]

@carolinagirl009

I'm only saying my opinion.

I know theyre not models

I absoloutly adore amy so what do you expect me to say, id obviously stick up for amy even if i dont know her shes still my insporation.

[haleyrockerz]

Amy lee!!! so fucking sexy!!! :))

[KeeperofLimbo]

Seriously this is one of the most stupid videos i have ever seen on here , who the hell cares whos fat or not! Are you really that shallow that you think that has any relevance to the fans its about the music fool. I can only hope that you wont be allowed to breed!

[letxmexchew]

@KeeperofLimbo i agree

[froshizzle101]

i kinda feel bad for kelly. i mean she is pretty. there werent any good pics of kelly. i mean i like amy more but there are better pics for kelly. i hope she loses alittle weight tho.

[fghfhg1212121]

AMY

[xVicious96]

First of all, the person who made this video is only showing pictures of Amy Lee when she was thin. She had her times when she was a bit thick, so this video is very biased. To me, though, it really doesn't matter her weight. Amy Lee just somehow knows how to pull off that amazingly beautiful look no matter what. Go Amy!

[elmocracker36]

EVANESCENCE ALL THE WAY x]

[rocknroller1986]

I like Kelly, But i love Amy- therefore she wins hands down.

Kelly's American idol contestant who's minutes of fame has almost run out. i'm not sure why fans are comparing the 2?

[froshizzle101]

amy lee fat?? well maybe some of her outfits were faltering but shes not fat in some photos shes looks pretty skinny. its probally the dresses she wears sometimes. seen pics of her in 2010 recording and shes very thin. go amy lee!!!!! HAHAHA

[dorrisgurl]

amy lee was never fat but kelly was so what she got rid of her weight!

[dorrisgurl]

AMY LEE IS NOT FAT MAN PPL R SO FUCKING STUPID!

[piggyandamy]

what a stupid video! amy is very very fat sometimes, so...but who cares if they're fat or not, they're not models, they don't need to be thin, they need to be talented, and i think it's safe to say both of them are...

[pannenkoekensmurf]

@piggyandamy you don't know what fat means BITCH

[J0K3R1n4]

Its not who's fat..Why do you always think that the best singer is a skinny stupid barbie doll on stage??...Different singers and kinds of music!!HELLOOOO what's wrong with u people??Do not COMPARE TWO ***COMPLETELY*** DIFFERENT THINGS...

BTW...Amy I love you.....

[alochan100]

hell yeaa!! who cares if the're fat? or if tey arent!!

i mean!! the most important thing in here is that

they both sing EXCELENT!

decide of who is fatter and who is thinner.. is such a stupid action!! really!!

but.. honestly.,.

ame lee is thinner XD hahahaha

ok no

they both sing pretty good :DD

[musiclove133]

I have three fans say .. its not Kelly say to Amy thick .. because what Kelly is so thick as to Amy and is in first and second what is important is the thickness of the song? a final and was Amy coarse not because to say that fans of Kelly thick? Finished.

[Illuminati10101]

@musiclove133 could someone explain this comment to me? i never understood any of it. lol

[evieandtracy4]

omg amy is so not fat i agree with u EVANESCENCE RULES!!!!!!!!

[choirboy258]

ok i dont like much pop music but kelly clarkson is oneof the few i actually like but i LOVE AMY LEE and ya kelly is getting a little on the chunky side

[SoNotEmonescence]

Amy Lee is not fat.  WTF

[MusicGirl953]

i love picture of 1:29

[SynGaite011]

hell kelly started as a hottie but now shes a fatty even fatty then ruben studered(season 2 winner)

[Shell5145]

i actually love both of them. i love amy more because lets face it, shes brilliant. but kelly can sing wonderfully. who cares about their weight?

[xXemozrusXx]

i luv u amy!!!!

[immortalnightof77]

carly never kicked anyone to the curb, amy is still writing music and fixin to drop another evanescence album. shes never gonna go away haterz shut up and go sip sum hateraid bitchez hahahahha :]

[GhaithXGuyan]

LOOOOL

im a huge fan of Evanescence but i think talking bout Amy and Kelly

from this point [ wether they are fat or not ] is just stupid

they are singers for god sake

[georgiacaldwell32]

they can both sing really good, and neither of them are fat, and besides who cares about if they're fat or not

[liilyarmstrong]

Nada qe ver Kelly no se compara en nada con Amy

[GrandTheftAutoFinal]

Amy is the best!

Amy we LOVE YOU!

[spongequeen]

yeah yeah... amy may be fat but not as FAT as kelly clarkson... amy is chubby... kelly is fat...

[nsivi]

las weasssss xDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD juzguenla por su talento no por su fisico!! tarados de mierda xD

[fralocesa]

i cant find words to say how much i love that woman (Amy)

[BlakeMaplesMusic]

this is really cruel, the funny thing about this is ummm who do you hear on the radio kelly or amy... umm yea kelly a shit load more famous now than amy is especially after carly smithson took her spot and kicked herr to the curb so yea lol

[Nevska130]

@BlakeMaplesMusic 'We Are The Fallen' is a huge fail. Carly is a bigger fail, just another Amy wannabe. And I don't know what crappy radio you're listening to but I hear a sh*t load more Evanescence than Kelly Clarkson on the radio. Oh, and since fans of Evanescence hate Carly now, Amy is even more popular. ^_^

[VampireWillow13]

I like amy lee a heck of alot more than kelly clarkson

[GothjAmy]

DAMN. Kelly is FAT

[Kuruni02]

Well I remember one Evanescence performance and Amy Lee was kind of fat and for Kelly, isn't fair, this video shows pics of her fat and Amy thin. Btw, what's the deal with being fat? Amy has a beautiful face and so does Kelly :S

[VampireGirl01247]

Kelly Clarkson is fat and Am Lee is skinny

[Xherzcool]

i like this tourniquet version..

more melodies..

lol

[sammiejoify]

There is definetely something wrong with the people commenting on either one's weight.plus who freakin cares!

[TristanandIsolt]

Neither of them is fat and who gives a shit if they are. They are singers. Since when has being skinny made a person a better singer?

[Madelinemandias]

I like Amy lee sooooooo much more :3

Evanescence <3

[03muzikah]

I like them both but amy is far away better.

[zsoraus]

body image doesn't count when judging talent,that's shallow.

[TheDarkness202]

amy lee is better kell yis not nor is she pretty amy is pretty

[Will88Jam]

it doesnt matter how big they are.....they are both amazing singers in their own right....I LOVE them both.

[silviatsoniovska]

amy is like an angel,i love her and i'll always be her fan

[thbritneyfan]

I don't listened songs of Kelly, but i think it don't matter if she's fat or skinny, she is beautiful, and they're to different.

Amy, of course, is more than Kelly!

I choose Amy 'cuz se FUCKING ROCKK!

[SunderX]

What a massive waste of web space. <3 for the song, but I retch at the tabloidness of celebrity comparison.

[1evanescencerocks]

kelly got fat

[Ribbonescence]

Amy Lee is average. Just 'cause all of the other Celebrities are puny and size 000 doesn't mean Amy can't be herself.

I just wish I could be as beautiful as her and sing as great as her one day.

She's a GODDESS!

When will you all see?

[bornlazy101]

Kelly really let herself go kinda upsetting to see it but at least she can still sing.

[znazn13]

photo shop kelly clarkson pictures more plz fucking noob nigger jew fail......

[larzylars]

FUCKING SHALLOW!!!!

[larzylars]

It's funny how over half the pictures of ms hartzler were from the neck up, not showing her body at all.

But on another note, are we really such a horrible and selfish society that we have to focus on appearances and bringing down girls because of how they look? Jesus christ!!!!

YOU BASTARD!!!!!

[aldys92]

amy is soo beautiful i love her¡¡¡¡

[iloveKClarkson]

I don't agree with this video 'coz my favourite singer is Kelly and my favourite band Evanescence, so I think their bodys don't matter when we speak about music. Don't be children, please. KELLY AND AMY are amazing girls!!!!!!!!!! outside and inside.

[bwg84387]

dont matter if they are fat or not they are both to hot for me to care

[Schnoookums]

i find it interesting how you used all of the photography photos of amy lee and then used the paparazzi pictures of kelly...hmm.

[klupe16]

Who cares if they are fat or not!!

They sing beautiful :D

[haleyrockerz]

@klupe16 -yah right!!! :D

[ecogoth]

woah, kelly has gotten really fat

[adarkangel88]

omg, you must have plenty of time to being looking around the internet for crappy photos of kelly and putting it together on a video..

what you made it's like those commercials.. before and after.. the worst photo ever first and then the beatiful one..

i could totally make the same with amy, it's just how you wanna make it look ;)

[TheRaven18DarkQueen]

@adarkangel88 oh sure come on,look buddy Amy WAS a little bit fatter a few year ago but nothing close to Kelly's

[gothicgirl8787]

ok? they are SO NOT FAT! and besides they sing good. i vote for amy lee! ♥ evanescence

[1MusicLover09]

I so wish i could go to an evanescence concert! (btw, this vid was posted on my birthday!!) I lové évanescence!

[Illuminati10101]

I'm not saying Amy Lee is fat. I'm saying Kelly Clarkson is fat.

[xxMisfit13XX]

Does it really matter if they are fat or not????

[iLOVEChihuahuas123]

They both got fat

its so obvious. These two have got to stop going to McDonalds

[eierkneifer]

ok.. they're singers. who cares how fat they are?^^ im not a fan .. i can't understand those things xD

[Illuminati10101]

So what did "EV"ery one think of Evanescence's latest 2 performances? One in New York Nov 4th and the other Nov. 8,2009?

lol,... i'd rather have went to the New York one,it was inside while the one in Brazil was outside and it POURED! But that didn't seem to affect the 40,000 that were there,they were having an awesome time!