Thank you so much for posting such a thorough history of the song, along with the Scottish lyrics. Fascinating. I had no inkling that it was as old as it is.
This is a great version of this song. Very nice indeed. I agree with you that it doesn’t really matter whether the song is Irish or Scottish, people shouldn’t waste time worrying about that. Like you say, it truly belongs to all of us.
Were is that picture at 0:28 ??
And great work.. All your songs on this channel are wonderful, I especially like your song Medals of Gold.
mhicLabhrainn 1 day ago
makes me homesick for Scotland<3
RCADY0137 4 months ago
Thank you so much for posting such a thorough history of the song, along with the Scottish lyrics. Fascinating. I had no inkling that it was as old as it is.
greenshp 6 months ago
beautiful voice ... beautiful song... I know how to play the whistle...
AndyKarm 7 months ago
Quite wonderful, thank you for this.
bagpiper2010 1 year ago
Robert:
Any chance you could post the guitar acompanyment as a tab? I am sure that I am not the only amateur who would love to emulate your arrangement.
Thank you for sharing this cultural jewel with a world-wide audience.
rosengj 1 year ago
This song has a special place in all our hearts. You sing it so beautifully.
MoiraMcDonald1 1 year ago
Outstanding, Robert. This is wonderful. Congratulations. Keep them coming.
jrkjenkins 1 year ago
This is absolutely lovely. In my opinion, this has to be one of the best versions of this song I have ever heard. Well done!
celticprincess1000 1 year ago
Beautiful version. :)
jenitreehugger 1 year ago
This is a great version of this song. Very nice indeed. I agree with you that it doesn’t really matter whether the song is Irish or Scottish, people shouldn’t waste time worrying about that. Like you say, it truly belongs to all of us.
MusicManIreland 1 year ago