How do you solve a problem like Maria - Top 3 Siobhan Song 1

[MizzSoRandom]

oh maan, she was the best:') <3

I cant believe that it was back in 2006 when I would be all excited for the show to come on and I would make mummy go to the supermarket to get me sweets, and I'd vote, and pretend that it didn't go through so I could vote again:')

Thank you Andrew Lloyd Webber, you braught me into the music industry<3

[placeboeffect2004]

I have to say that although Siobhan was my least favourite of the three finalists, I think she was given a very unfair deal in the final. Helena and Connie had two big showstoppers, but this is a very average song. It has no big climax like Cabaret and As Long As He Needs Me.

I also recall that the first finalist to go out (Samantha) in I'd Do Anything sang this song as well. Coincidence?

[SingerTinaRose]

What artist originally sang this song? and do you know here ic an get the backing track from? xxxxx

[hugh2022]

@SingerTinaRose i think it was dionne warwick

[Lexigiggles]

The wardrobe department on this show failed hideously. 

[longtobeanactress]

i love this song

[khsseig]

She so should have won! I would buy her records anyday

[henrik1n]

Her most convincing performance, although she still lacks some passion and true emotions. I think she should be very happy with a record proposal and a deserved third place.

[alan2637]

I agree, i doubt shes musical theatre, but shed definately sell records!

[joespug]

Brilliant song, should have won in my opinion.

[jimbobyeah]

gorgeous song - gorgeous girl!

[underwood1232]

Janna Polzin form the canadian maria sung this better then this girl!

but this girl can really sing great but not for the role of maria!

[henrik1n]

I will have to disagree on that, Janna might be a better singer but with this song/performance I think Janna came across as a bit "ordinary" and careless.

[josiex56x]

what is the song calld?

[longtobeanactress]

anyone that had a heart

[leemeadisthebest]

She was very good but not right for Maria- too pretty!

[elianelegolas]

OMG that's is amazing she's great

[musicafanxox]

You push that bastard GIRL!! :P

[EM2118]

I love her voice! she sounds amazing!

[magssenible59]

Siobhon really should have won. I think she had a better voice and acting abilities then either Connie or Helena.

[ASDAPOI]

I think that this is beautiful, she put a lot of expression into her voice.

[jwlnler]

Ironically, Janna in the 2008 CBC "HDYSAPLM" has been given alot of the same songs as Connie and Siobhan... is that a sign?

[xxxwaayxxx]

i think siobhan is great and when sam sang Defying Gravity now that was amazing, i think they are both amazing but at the end of the day they are both different performers and i dont think anyone should compare them just cuz they sang the same song, they both did it amazing in different ways xx

[lauren243]

this preformance was definately better than sam's. The emotion in this is really beliveable. great preformance!

[MissFletcherFletch]

vocally; sam did this one better (and I don't even like her)

siobhan acts this one out better. just a tad.

not convinced.

[emilialingwood]

i think sam was better when she sang it.

[blueneonrainbow]

Sam is truly outclassed by this performance.

[Pixiepuu]

I think Siobhan has a much more beautiful voice than Sam, Sam sang 'too' and 'you' with this weird American accent, I think Sam is fab and voted for her in the final a few times but vocally noone surpasses the beauty of Siobhan's voice- I could listen to her sing forever and I think she did really connect to it and act it amazingly like with Chains and Songbird, i dnt gt why ppl are saying she was wooden and forced because I believe every word

[bradleyy2kaii8]

i fink shes good but sam was better because sam is onli 17 and sam has a better voice and she used her emotions in it soibhan should have 1 but ;(

[peprilen]

no - siobhan has much more of a mature voice, it has such a difference

[FrankyPanda]

I think this was worst than sam.

[natz351]

MUCH better than sam did on sat in id do anything

[scootyscoot4]

I love it when she shouts "YOU!" this song was probably her best acting performance as she connected with the song and sang it with passion.

[jannekejansen1992]

I think she's good!

[JustSusie94]

Eww :S

[appletiser89]

i think her dress is so cool!! i acrtually love it!! and .. er .. rather than pink knickers, r we sure she wasnt wearing red ones to match her colour scheme?

[ZeeJex]

Awesome

[LootzO]

Yeah, but she doesn't chose the clothes so that the dress is short was nothing that she could have stopped.

pink knickers?! Are you a perver or something teebee17?

[Amiie0x]

brilliant vocals, BUT could that dress be any shorter??

[teebee17]

she was wearing pink knickers ... true

[JudyJinglesLikesJell]

comments from panel?

[COTTONHEAT]

anyone who had a heart

[jackthecat09]

What is the name of this song? I love it!! Please reply back!!

Laura M.

[xxgeorgibunnyxx]

Cilla Black sung it loool. Atomic Kitten r doing a cover....boooooo. xxxx

[Anuketra]

This song is called "Anyone Who Had A heart"

[StellaB1991]

I'm glad everyone agrees here, she wasn't Maria but still talented. I think this was probably her best performance, she actually connected with the song, at last! I like this song because of her, which is saying a lot as I really disliked her for most of the series.

xxStellaxx

[fluffymugnaini]

haha i love it how they always put her in short skirts. dirty perv producers...

[CrackerzTSCGirl]

shes amazing, not a connie though but still great. anyone know what shes doing now?

[Dervalsayshello]

Yeah, she was really good but Connie was just Maria! Siobhan is currently in the West End in Grease as Patty Simcox-don't ya think that really suits her? SO there ya go!!

[londongaylad]

ahh...thanks so much for this update. It hard to get info on what happens next> i was told, she had a myspace site, but couldn;t find it.

[NikkiSara13]

she's in grease now as patty simcox!!!!!!!

[babykendra123]

Me & ma mate sing this in the common room at lucnh times for every 1

[babykendra123]

she is one of the most beautiful talented people i have ever seen

[hippogriffs95]

Her bet performance in the whole show.Good singer,and would make a good Christine in Phantom of the Opera,but not Maria.

[waliice]

o yer i totally agree, she would be fantastic in that part!

[Veganator]

I loved her, she should have won! She has my name! lol =P

[SammyJane176]

PURELY EXCELLENT

[JAYNE20]

What's the album going to be called and what date's it out anyone?

[CheesynessOnAStick]

YEAH YEAH WOOT WOOT GO SIOBHAN!!! YEY POLYDOR!!! y didnt she win? ppl r saying it was rigged. i would buy her february album even if it is complete s**t! but it won't be because its gonna have songbird on it - her song from the top 7

[sw3nick]

y'know that doesnt make sense

[roblondonuk]

I absolutely love her...& Im gay!!! Her problem was shes far 2 beautiful 2play Maria & shes unfortunately not clued up enough 2 her amazing talent! If she sang the yellow pages I'd buy it!

[Lucilon]

when will we get news on a record deal....thats what i wanna know, last time i checked it was just saying she hadn't signed anything but was still in talks....hurry up and stop talking.

[Leppicon77]

ABI SHOULD BE HERE..NOT HER

[xGangOfOnex]

This was the best performance by her actin-wise but that kind of ment she wasn't as good vocally. The other 2 were a lot better but she's gonna do well too.

[00Anna]

She is the BEST!!! GO SIOBHAN!

[sapphiretree]

exactly ^ whats the point being so negative, if you don't like don't watch simple as, noones forcing you to watch it so if you dont like it watch something else - obviously

[AbiFinleyFan]

nar, i'm not. I love this video, i just want to watch the video's and i think twats like you shouldnt be alloud to comment. Just bugger off and stop causing trouble.

[EmzBabii]

Why can't people stick to the topic of the video. I thought that was really good and showed lots of emotion. Loved it.

[TheComplainer]

pmsl say that often enough and you will start to believe it....I notice you are too pussy to go back to the Aoife video comments.

Pussy whipped mini dyke eh? OK lets ruin this thread too? Or will you go back to where it started? oh no thats right, you are a pussy!

[AbiFinleyFan]

Sure...Fine...Whatever...Call me minidyke if you wish, but me and my boyfriend both know i'm straight, but you probly don't know about love between staight people do you because your so god damn bent.

[TheComplainer]

no minidyke....we both just have the same opinion of you! pmslllllllllllllllll freak!!

[AbiFinleyFan]

Sure, Fine Whatever, you just copied some one eles's comment you retard. Now F**k off

[TheComplainer]

No, But I bet you wank off to her daily, minidyke!

[AbiFinleyFan]

Bit like you then. ;-)

Great video and song.

[TheComplainer]

she has all the charisma of a pile of poo in that video

[CheesynessOnAStick]

wtf TC she is absolutely amazing. i suppose you just like complaining and insulting. i dont know anyone who GENUINELY thinks that wasn't a winning performance. (she didnt win, but still...she couldve won with that performance)

[alicanqwert]

I always thought that Siobhan should have won, but that song she just sung didn;t make her voice sound impressive at all. And HOW THE HELL did Helena get into the top 3!?

[CheesynessOnAStick]

I know ALW shouldve saved laura at the beginning. she wasnt the best, but better than helena.

[mariaisabelmedia]

if you are showing emotion you are acting ^ :) any fool can stand there and just stare, siobhan showed emotion and acted,

i listened to the other versions and i like siobhans better, the others actually hurt my eardrums

[TheComplainer]

The emotion of not being able to act?

[sickwench]

Well done shibhan you showed plenty of emotion in this song.

[rach165]

She is  the best i love siobhan

[telboy1987]

whats this song called

[CheesynessOnAStick]

Anyone Who Had A Heart

[lOveEmmaBunton]

who's song is this??

[CheesynessOnAStick]

Cilla Black (in England it is, although she sung it on BBC America)

[Lucilon]

The problem is that this ong was sung by Dionne Warwick and then our Cilla....both excellent singers. I think Siobhan is gonna get better and better, but you know, right now she was good, not excellent.

[wmzegan]

Thought Siobhan sang this well, only the other two were better. Overall, I'd have voted for Siobhan over Helena though, but not over Connie. Oh, and everyone I know voted for Connie!!

[teebee17]

Siobahn was simply wonderful, on this song anyway!

[SexiMinx87]

I thought this performance was awful. She was well out of tune. Glad Connie won!

[issy999]

I Cannot Believe Siobhan came third. I'm not saying she was the best actor, singer, or dancer, because she wasn't, but she had so much public support...And I don't know ANYONE who voted for Connie in the end.

[everythinglesmis]

Actually, I only know people who voted for Helena and Siobhan too...

[TheComplainer]

If bad acting was an emotion, Shiv had it in spades.

[dannmurray13]

are me and the judges watching the same video? no emotion? They really shud get their eyes tested...

[sapphiretree]

helena certainly improved and connie was always my vote to win as maria, but siobhans performances were always way better to watch than the other two,

[scootyscoot4]

Amen to that lol! Although I wanted Siobhan to win from the start (or Briony) Siobhan's performances were much more interesting to watch than the others ;-).

[weloveannanetrebko]

i'm sorry but she absolutely nothing on the other two in terms of acting or vocal ability

[Bahoral]

Here here. She was the worst of the three be a mile.

[kerrykb]

Siobhan rocks & so sud have won!!!! But I am sooooo excited that she is gonna get a record deal!!! I wud so buy her stuff & go c her in concert!!

[sapphiretree]

yeah i can't get over her acting, it looked so real to me but the judges think she has no emotion, :S how much more emotion did they need

[crabtree2]

That was an amazing performance!! How did she not win? I don't understand these judges comments sometimes. Her singing was sensational just like every week, but her acting was such an improvement. She had always struggled with the acting part but it hardly showed in this performance. What a talented young lady! I sure hope she's a leading lady in a West End musical in the future. I would definitely buy tickets to see that!

[inthemoonlight00]

wow. brilliant performance. gutted she hasn't won, but i'll buy anything she releases!

[sapphiretree]

amazing! glad connie won but at the same time wanted siobhan to win, i'd prefer her with record companies than musicals though,

[Shaunie1234]

I am so Happy for Siobhan She has a Huge Major Record Deal!! I really can't wait to go and Buy all Her Records and see Her in Concerts Yay!!! Siobhan is the Best!

[tabletop246]

shes amasing cnt w8 for her to do musocals and records!

[COTTONHEAT]

brilliant no wonder record companys want to sign her

[teebee17]

I know its a cliche, but that really did 'make the hairs on the back of my neck stand on end' absolutely wonderful performance.

[sarie13]

i was so gutted that siobhan didnt win i would buy anything siobhan release :(

[everythinglesmis]

I was so sad that Siobhan didn't win, but at least she is almost definately going to do some kind of musical or CD soon.

[maskedmystery]

Though Siobhan was my favourite, I'm glad she didn't win. She can have a bigger career in the music industry than with musicals.

[ImputYourSoul]

totally agree

[weloveannanetrebko]

thing that annoys me about her is that she gets by on some level on her looks.girls feel humbled by her.she doesn't suit maria and in fact her voice is not really that well suited to many musicals.glad connie won.

[TheComplainer]

You all may call that acting, I call it crap.

[cybergen2K]

there we go!

[cybergen2K]

Well done Siobhan she is a star and she can easily get a top 10 single with all this publicity not that I'm cynical or anything. Awaits a much more cynical comment from TC!...

[rachelb1310]

she was absolutely fantastic, i cant believe shes not in the final 2. ill buy her album if she ever records one

[dcyp]

who care what the judges think, i think siobhan should have won and she is still brilliant, and i will definatly buy any record she puts out. if she does!