Added: 5 years ago
From: gedelapena
Views: 519,949
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (662)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Petula Clark was NEVER a Spice Girl. Emma can do whatever she wants.

  • Such an arrogant and deluded girl, thinking she could do this song justice.

  • not quite there luv.........where's the fuckin power/passion of Petula's !

  • check out the video of my 1 yr old singing this song! :)

  • shit!

  • She took it down a whole step.

  • cute as a button come to the goring august 22nd

  • The Petula Clark version is still the best ... but this cover is not bad at all.

  • IMHO it is really just a matter of preference as to who sings this song better. I personally like Emma's version because I just love her voice.

    Maybe just me but I think Emma Bunton has the best voice in the world.

  • Oh stop picking. It is a fun and respectful cover of the great original. What's wrong with some fun?

  • this is disgusting and an insult to everyone who has ever heard of petula clark .

  • @anney0207 : I agree though I still love Emma. Sigh.

  • every single one of her band members is more talented than her =/

    at least she looks good, rite?

  • Over 500 people liked this?

    I must admit it made me laugh!

    Come on............, Emma cant sing!

    I cant even begin to compare her version to Petula Clark's.

    I feel sorry for the musicans, they must be thinking...... how did I sink this low!

  • Over 500 people liked this?

    I must admit it made me laugh!

    Come on............, Emma cant sing!

    I cant even begin to compare her version to Petula Clark's.

    I feel sorry for the musicans, they must be thinking...... how did I sink this low!

  • Forget comparing singers.....as a baby boomer I love these young singers enjoying covering classics....just enjoy a different style!

  • lol I put this innopropiate LOL

  • Takes guts to do something like this

  • who would actually buy this version when you could get the one and only petula clarks .

  • Born in '61, so I grew up and loved Pet's version as a kid...One of those countless originals that can't be topped, ever. But as far as pop goes, this ain't half bad. The most important question, though, is this: What does Tony Hatch think..?

    Cheers pop pickers..!

  • Marks out of 10.......3 and I am feeling generous!!

  • She is in one WORD....SHIT. I have heard better singers doing this on Karaoke. Total wrecked a classic song by a far SUPERIOR singer.

  • I think this is really charming and warm. I expected to hate it, and at first I figured she'd try to sex it up and add a lot of phony drum machines and stuff. In fact, she's so respectful of the material that for me it erases any issue of not being Petula- which no one else is, anyway.

  • @SurferJoe1 What???? She is RESPECTFUL of the material? She murdered this song she is CRAP. Her voice is FLAT.

  • @pammyoneto Yep. Respectful in the sense that it's almost identical to the original arrangement, and she never deviates from the melody as sung by Petula Clark. Don't know what else you want . Of course her voice has nowhere near the power of PC's, but I listened again carefully and could not identify a flat note. Maybe you could tell me where you heard one. I get the impression you're responding with your emotions, but we're all entitled to our own opinions and taste, and I respect yours.

  • ok, but lack the soul of the original!

  • i bought Pet's Version As a young boy. I wouldnt buy this CRAP

  • lower by an octave than the original but what the hell

  • cutie, but butchers the song, no range

  • Hottest spice girl fact!

  • beautiful voice!!

  • Dear oh dear... that's all that need be said......

  • This girl cannot sing Period!

  • Double volume on lead mic....

  • where she left her voice??

  • she looks like chukie's bride, hahahahahahahaha!

  • @Denisse99 she sings like it too!!

  • original is so much better jees she should write her own music and not ruin a classic

  • !!!!!!REMIXED THIS SONG CHECK IT OUT!!!!!!!

  • SLUT lol she makes this song sound dirty. the original is so much better.

  • PATHETIC! Petula Clark kicks her ass big-time.

  • SO WEAK ..BRING BACK PETULA CLARK

  • @FredONeil1 okey

  • Whoever's at the sound desk hasn't got a clue about the level of the lead vocals!

  • it just needs some more power...

  • Comment removed

  • chill god it was for CHARITY!!!!

  • deeeown teeeown

  • crazy eyes

  • beautiful!~

  • it's too soft. not enough power!

  • Not bad, but Petula simply made this song. A classic for kids born in the sixties, this is one song that is so memorable. Hard to do better than Ms. Clark, the originator.

  • Oi Bunton shut it, the original is much better.

  • Petula's gun - voice, Emma's gun - body...

  • great cover version,tho :)

  • emma rocks!!!!!!!!!!

  • Theres nothing downtown but a bunch of mexicans :(...

  • @fleshtheworld nowadays,yes,but back then, it was different. my, how times have changed, huh ??

  • Boy, did she ever slut down a nice, classy song...

  • as tony hatch who wrote downtown would say,the song was better then the singer,

  • So this is what this song is like when you just sing through the words...Who knew that actual feeling and passion were important in singing?

  • Sorry, but this uninspired plastic garbage is an affront to the classic original. At the very least, Petula Clark could sing. Emma Bunton just pretends to, and not very convincingly. Typical really.

  • I like THE WHOLE thing from head to toe Yummm; and the song is great too!!

  • Wow I haven't heard from baby spice in a long time now. Good to know she's still singing and doing a great job of it.

    Hope she continues to the top...once again!

    

  • Baby Spice can do anything in my book. Yummy Emma.

  • in the original version you hear nothing but petulas voice and some music fitting in the background

    here you really have to look for her small voice.

    sounds like a mouse (not) trying to sing against a big band

  • PleEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEse! check out Pet clark's version!

  • @RImusclebear I did...it was good.. you seemed so adamant, i listened a few times..LOL

  • ehhh not bad no where as good as the original...

  • ...this is absolutely perfect for Emma Bunton...love herrrrr.

  • Wow. She is absolutely horrible! No one sings this better than Petula. Sorry.

  • crap comapred to original ...

    originals 4ever ^^

  • ugly make up

  • My fave version is Jane McDonalds but listening to this i really like Emma Buntons aswell, i didnt realise how good a singer she is. Janes still my fave though! xx

  • Awesome performance. I wouldn't say it's better or worse than the original - it's just different. Both are amazing, so why bother about which is the best?

  • aw, its great.. go emma!

  • she sings better than brittany. haha imagine brittany spears singing this hahahah

  • I know what Petula means by 'downtown'...

    when EB says it it just seems to be saying 'give me oral'

  • the two version are very good

  • Petula Clark's voice is, in many ways, nicer to listen to than Emma Bunton's.

    BUT, the instrumental arrangement on this modern version is far superior to the original.

  • It's nothing special but when someone covers a song it is in honor of the original artist so it's still very nice

  • If you're going to cover someone elses song at least do something different and make it your own. This is no better than a karaoke version of the original. Emma Bunton is nice enough but as this is an attempted copy of what Petula Clark sang, it really is shit in comparison. I've heard pissed scrubbers in the pub with a better vocal range than Emma Bunton.

  • PRETTY GOOD COPY

    No patch on the original but why do a photocopy at all?

  • sO BEAUTIFUL

  • This is TERRIBLE! Have Sporty give you some singing lessons.

  • ... FAIL

  • fuckin shite, petula clarks version is so much more original and unpretentious yuk

  • This version is not as good because it wasn't in LOST. That is all.

  • I don't see the innuendo.......

  • this makes me happy <3

  • Lostttttttttttttttt

  • @CorrieClassics yeah, badly :P

  • fueraaaaaaaaa,,a la puta calleee

  • i'd go downtown on her, NOM NOM NOM

  • crappy, its sounds like Emma is trying her best, but wow, what a pathetic effort. It sounds sooo karaoke

  • nothing compares to petula clarks version

  • She doesn't EVEN have the power range for this song.

  • @BowlingAlleigh

    |Oh, really? How come she´s note out of key then?

    lmof

  • @Pirilim195

    I think you need to go back and listen to the original version again.

  • omg...can´t sing!

  • Just an observation... but why try and sing it with an American accent ? Wrecks it. Sorry Emma...

  • when you make comparisons..this is pretty weak

  • Delicious!

  • OhMy, this sucks.

  • I really like her voice.

  • i wanna go downtown with emma :)

  • NO SHIT

  • the best

  • Why did she add a bit of Innuendo to this?

    This song is NOT meant to have it. LISTEN and WATCH Pet sing this song like it is supposed to be sung.

  • Hot. Her look kinda reminds me of Michelle Marsh, another gorgeous woman!!!!

  • PERFECT!

  • you've  perfect voice buddy

  • Sorry. Lacks punch. Brave attempt at taking on a classic. Good back-up.

  • I never like Emma lot, but she is a good singer. I loved her solo album!

  • Great version Emma, Love it, can i take you Down Town please lol

  • I've been in love with Emma since I was 9 years old but I don't like the innuendo she adds to it.

  • There is only 1 Petula Clark this is an ok cover I guess but I'm sorry she doesn't have the power behind it...

  • sounds almost exactly like petula

  • JULIET

  • I work in Downtown. i like, out of town

  • NICE JOB, BUT ITS PETULA'S SONG,

  • carlmonico what if its her song JK i know its petula's

  • petula clark.. i love ya.. this is also good.. but i growed up with the original verion and nothing version will be better than petulas :D

  • Good! I like this performance, but the original is better.

  • i want to go down town with emma....

  • i mean 0:08 duh

  • she danced weird at 0:18

  • Just a little bit karaoke. Listen to the voice of Petula Clark!

  • A superb classic, sadly not in the same league as Petula Clarkes version.

    However one can't knock it realy as it was sung for children in need and went to no;2 in the hit parade. Nice try though.

  • vikken jävla pingla <3

  • She does a good job.

  • Beautiful lady and great talent,

    From Caracas Venezuela.

  • The original is sooo much better.

  • @PetertheWolf hahaha - the BEST version is the one on the soundtrack of Piscilla Queen of the Desert - they took this song and made it!!! but you are right Petula sang it better - i think this orchestration is better though

  • @PetertheWolf Nah really

  • Listen to the version of Pam Berry from her Glo-Worm's album "Glimmer". Just beautiful.

  • Bunton gives it a good go, and it's not her fault that she can't replicate an absolute pop classic. Her producer and arranger should have given her something at least a tad different to do with the song - because comparisons to Pet Clark are inevitable when you use nearly her and Tony Hatch's exact arrangement. The black and white video of Clark under Related Videos illustrates the impossible task of matching the class and control of the original.

  • Landed flat on her voice :D Good effort though

  • Not in the same league as Pet Clark

  • Miss the horn section at the end.

  • Petula Clark was so much better!

  • Nice, but original version is better!!

  • Excellent

  • Nice version Baby :D

  • the original it´s better i think

  • The original is always better but this remake is great!

  • Dear Em, it's dOwntOwn, not dAwntAwn...

  • petula clark sing this song better than her

  • first comment on a video....anyways of course the original is still the best. But Bunton's version is refreshing, tasteful, and not a damn remix. She brings this song to a whole new generation and thus keeps Clark's song current.

  • It's ok, but not nearly as good as the orginal. Pet Clark still preforms this song.

  • Send for Pet Clark Now at once

  • Spice Girls another no talent formulated chick band....period.

    What's next Pussycat dolls? LOL.

  • @Thejbirdy Exactly send for Pet Clark to do the job properly now at once

  • Amen! Love that song too much to see it slaughtered like that.

  • Hmm... she looks familiar... I cant put my hand on it

  • Nice try, but this cover isn't half as good as the original. Petula clark always had something to her voice that sounded sweet.

    Bunton is hot, but this song is beyond her level. The musical cover sucks too.

  • que bien canta en directo!!! arriba emma, esperamos nuevo disco!!!

  • Better than the original! Me like Emma long time up the downtown

  • Better than Pet Clark DONT BE STUPID

  • Pet Clark must cringe when she listens to this version

  • I allways think like this:

    Emma--->Perfect ♥

    Posh----> The most sexy

    Gery----->Second perfect . hehehe

    Mel B-----> Gr8 vioce !

    Mel C-----> the ridiculous (no offens)

  • This is terrible version... You should delete this video! just an opinion.

  • why microphone looks like a dick :)

  • i liked emma til this...christ she can kill a classic

  • pls emma this is crap when you compare it with petula clarks version

  • id like to go downtown with emma.

  • Brill. Top tune, top bird.

  • the original was pretty cool.. emma button totally massacres it

  • Sweet. I wish there were more songs innocent enough to play with kids around...

  • a lot of tones under the original,low range,bad bad,the original song isn´t so difficult

  • Get in mah Belly!!!!

  • I'm so in love with her voice!!! love when she sings live!

  • As one who appreciates and loves (and REMEMBERS) the Petula Clark version I can't agree with TheUtubesuxass. Personally I would put their renditions about even, with maybe Petula just edging it. But the use of language by

    TheUtubesuxass gives some indication of his intellect and manners - and sanity. I think if

    TheUtubesuxass went anywhere near Petula he;d be regarded not as a fan but as mentally deranged stalker.

  • honestly? my opinion is i agree with you. Emma Bunton stayed true, just modified it very little. I heard the original, and then i listened to this one. the only major differences would be it sounds like Petutal Clark doesnt have an accent quite like Emma Buntons vocals. But again that was years ago, so the sound was differents for each vocalist compared to todays. But i like both of them, i own them both b/c i liked the two versions so very much. Thanks for giving ur input on this song.

  • where'd you buy the emma bunton version of downtown? i can't find it on itunes. : (

  • try amazon, or digstation.

  • shes a babe