I'm sorry but i didn't think this was a bad thing yes dean cheated on his wife but Rory and dean were meant to be. But I do think the should of never married Lindsay if he knew he was still in love Rory he should of called off the wedding and told Rory how he felt and she felt the same and then they should of slept together
@teamdamon91girl Having a connection doesn't give anyone the right to cheat on their spouse. The fact that they got married in the first place shows some sort of commitment from BOTH parties. My opinion, of course.
chris and sherry were on a break, they were not engaged and both loreli and chris had no idea sherry was pregnant... so rory what your mom did was not the same as what you did, you knew dean was married.. and just because he took the ring off doesnt make one bit of difference!
I love Rory with Jess. Dean is just terrrible for her. I didn't mind her with Logan but he did really hurt her but so did Jess but Jess did get him self together by the end but Logan didn't. He didn't get what he wanted right when he wanted it so he left her.
@Mehlwurm18 Could it be the cheating on his wife? :P But yeah, there was something uber-skeevy about Dean cheating with Rory. He went from being a sweet if sometimes jealous boyfriend to That Guy, who married somebody else and then PINED for his ex the whole time, all the while hurting his wife (um, who really should have gotten a job if she was so damn desperate for the finer things in life) and treating her like crap for NOT BEING RORY. What a jerk he turned into!
I HATE Rory's character after this. Actually, I hated the way she treated Jess in the previous episode even more, but ohmygod. The writers made a huge mistake with this. Not only her sleeping with Dean, but her choosing him over Jess?! But she was being a brat here. &the thing that annoys me is that she doesn't even realize it's wrong until like after the summer. &Lorelai was so right, even tried to talk to Rory about it calmly, but Rory shoved her away. Rory deserves the worst at this point.
this is the point where she went on a downward spiral... cheating with dean, stealing yachts. should have chosen Jess!!!!! at least he got her back to yale logan didnt care..
I have to admit Jared is waaay more gorgeous than Milo could ever be. Especially in season 4 when he has the facial hair and THOSE DARN DIMPLES! Just sayin.
This scene was powerful in the sense that we finally see Rory in a different light. Granted, sleeping with a married man whose not your husband isn't the best idea. Naturally they're going to have their differences, but I have to side with Lorelai on this one. But this is one of the best scenes in the Gilmore Girls series in my opinion...
Dean is now Sam on supernatural and his brother is named Dean and Sam now is way more bad ass. This aint shit, oh wow he got Rory pussy, fuck that shit Sam got grade A quality Vagin in supernatural.
Rory and Dean having sex just grosses me out, to be honest. Probably because I hate Rory's hair and dress and Dean drives me nuts because he's a tool. Just my opinion, though. :D
Did anyone else notice how ugly Dean looks? I don't know about you, but if were Rory, I would take the good-looking, well-read, unpredicatble, gelled-hair Jess over Dean...
High school Rory was the best. The college Rory made me want to cry.
@sockrokr2 Do you honestly think Jared is ugly or are you just saying that because you'd rather Rory be with Jess lol? Cos even though I like Jess over Dean, I still say that he is a very gorgeous guy lol
i dont see what the problem is, considering rory's age, she can do whatever she pleases. I get that dean is married and that is pretty bad but rory doesnt have to consult her mother in whatever she does it is her own choice.
@charlottecheesecake Considering Rory's age, she's a child. And sure, she doesn't have to consult her mother but considering how close they are, it would be a first instinct. Besides Lorelai is totally right in this argument, I usually don't side in their fights but this one... totally on Lorelai's side.
@charlottecheesecake considering rory's age she should know right from wrong and sleeping with a married guy is wrong! and loreli needed to give rory a reality check.. and the way rory acts in this scene she definitly doesnt seem her age at all! she's acting like such a brat!
Lorelai did the same with christopher except he wasn't married. She knew he was in a committed relationship with sherry living together, etc. Hypocrite..
@rmpr123456 wait, i thought they were broken up. oh wasn't it that he told her that they were taking a break and he was going to break up with her? either way i don't think she's a hypocrite
@candymandy224 they were stil together. He didnt break up with her he was planning to according to what he told to Lorelai. Basically she slept with a guy knowing that he was in a relationship so its basically the same.
i know. with a mom like that you would think you would be humble and cool. but no shes a brat, she always goes to her grandpa for everything. its understandable, i dont hate rory, but i am constantly disappointed by her
ok I've just recently started watching Gilmore Girls and I'm only up to season 2 but does Rory really change that much after the third season? I mean yeah it was wrong to sleep with Dean but everyone is entitled to make mistakes. I'm not saying you all are wrong I'm just curious.
How can Rory equate Lorelai sleeping with Chris to her sleeping with Dean?! She says Chris and Sherry were engaged and Sherry was pregnant: they were taking a break, neither Chris nor Lorelai knew she was pregnant and Chris and Sherry got engaged after Lorelai slept with him, as a result of her being pregnant. Sorry, haha, rant over. That part just kinda bugs me...
I really miss Season 1/2/3 Rory :(
And how could anyone ever choose Dean over Jess?! Come on!
@sneakiebug09 Yes, but they weren't engaged or in a committed relationship at that point, they had practically broken up, if they hadn't Lorelai would never have slept with him (or so I'd like to believe). It was only AFTER Lorelai had slept with him that Chris is told that Sherry is pregnant then, once he'd gone back to her, they became engaged (and we don't even know how long it was between him going back to her and them getting engaged). If you're arguing that they must have been in a serious
@sneakiebug09 (cont. my other post - sorry if there were multiple posts of that one, I was on a different browser than I was used to and don't know if it managed to post)
relationship in order to have become engaged at the beginning of Series 3, then I disagree, because Chris made it pretty clear that he was only going back to her because she was pregnant, and they weren't already engaged, they were on a break.
@jessrules05 (realizing it's an old post).Disagreeing with the Dean vs. Jess question (:-)), I think you put the the Rory Season 1~3 vs the later years correctly. I felt that this was the start of Rory being more of an adult making faulty choices, entering a 'realm' that can't be protected by Lorelai. Unfortunate that it had to be losing her virginity and entering a sexual relation with an ex, but then again, I guess there wouldn't be any greater way to 'mark' the start of that sequence.
@jessrules05 why would anyone choose jess over dean?! jess treated her horribly and never did one nice thing for her while they were together and never did something she wanted him to do or would sulk when he did and never told her what was going on with him, he wasnt dependable and then just abandoned her. dean however did nothing but love her even when she treated him horribly to chase after jess and he only married lindsay because he couldnt have rory. rory and dean shoulda ended up together!
@klarebear721 Well, putting aside the physical side that Jess is way more attractive than Dean. let's have a look. Firstly, Rory would never have ended up with someone who didn't share her interests in books, music, movies etc because that just makes up too much of a part of who she is so, while Dean was a good first boyfriend, he was never gonna be endgame; no matter whether Rory ended up with Jess, Logan, Marty, a new guy, or alone, it could never have been Dean.
@klarebear721 Secondly, Jess if just plain out more intelligent than Dean, so he and Rory were more like-minded, which is important in a relationship. There's also the fact that Jess/Rory had amazing chemistry while Dean/Rory had the chemistry of a dry plank, but that's physical again so I'll put that aside. Then, Jess always challenged Rory where Dean never really did, which was important, especially with his role in season 6.
@klarebear721 Last, while Jess was hardly a saint, he never did anything as plainly wrong or childish as marrying someone to get over someone else and then cheating on his WIFE. And after that, do we so redemption for Dean? No, we see him shout at Lindsay after having cheated on her, dump Rory in front of her friends and tell Luke that his relationship with Lorelai won't work (his last ever appearance). In contrast, Jess is almost completely redeemed for anything he did wrong by the end.
@jessrules05 Firstly, yes, i actually agree that fact of the matter was rory was too smart for dean and to be honest i actually like her best with logan. but jess is just such a jerk there with him the bad FAR outweighs the good. first, he lies, steals, smokes when he first gets to town and is rude to everyone except rory who also made a mistake of chasing after him while she had a boyfriend!
@jessrules05 then when she and jess are dating he treats her like absolute crap! throughout their relationship he never wants to do anything she wants to or sulks when he does, never tells her the truth about anything and is never honest with her. then he blows town again without saying goodbye again and then when he comes back a year later he continually ignores her until he tells her loves her at which point he leaves her again!
@jessrules05 then he comes back and expects her to be so weak minded that after everything he put her through she's just going to fall into his arms and run off with him! like seriously? if he knew her at all he knows that she would never do that, ESPECIALLY not for him. and you wanna talk about wrong and childish? jess did countless wrong and childless things his entire time in stars hollow and went through life not caring who he hurt, including rory. jess was easily the worst of her boyfriends
@jessrules05 the only thing jess had going for him was that he was cute and that he was as smart as she was, but when she was his, he treated her terribly. i;ll admit he got better by the end and maybe if there had been an eighth season they could've ended up together but the fact of the matter is for the bulk of the show jess was an inconsiderate rude thoughtless punk and i was relieved when she turned him down that second time and met logan.
@klarebear721 I just saw your entire conversation, and I almost disagree on all of it, but putting that aside, I have to say that Logan was MUCH worse than Jess. Do you realize that Jess never got a second chance? He tried so hard, but he never got another chance. Dean got like five, and Logan got a bazillion chances. Logan hurt Rory WAY more (cheating on her, breaking up with her after being a total dick to Jess, etc.). Jess may not have treated her very well, but it was always clear that he
@XshamosasX @klarebear721@jessrules05 basically, Jess and Logan were shitty boyfriends and Dean was the best one she got. I do think marrying lindsey, even knowing that he still loved Rory and always would, was a huge mistake, BUT he could've simply gotten a divorce, if it wasn't for Jared starring Supernatural... At least he was always great to Rory and that's all that matters.
@klarebear721 really loved her. He had some problems, yes, but he figured all of that out in the end. He had the most chemistry with Rory & understood her in a way that Logan never did. You see that ESPECIALLY in the s6 when Jess is the ONLY one who can convince her to go back to Yale - including her boyfriend and her mother! Logan never even tried to get her back, he even encouraged it! He was lazy, rich, & spoiled, and changed Rory completely. And I just can't see Rory w/ someone like that.
@klarebear721 oh. wow. I never read your username. Sorry xD Jeez, this just shows how much energy I spend on this xD BUT, did we argue about Logan? I don't remember.
It's funny how people said they didn't like Rory after this cuz she changed. I agree, but I never thought about it till I read those comments. I just thought I disliked her because of Logan and the fact that I never liked Dean to begin with. But it's true that she really changed after this point.
I have to disagree. I was disappointed that the character that I once idolized made such a poor choice but I like it because it's realistic. It shows that she isn't perfect, made a mistake, and she figures it out.
rory was trying to self justify wat she did. she knew it was wrong but she was trying to coninve herself it was rite. grr this is when rory went downhill! rory and dean sucked togther and rory and logan were just as bad, cuz logan turned rory into something shes not. jess was the perfect guy for her and she was too stupid to realise it. and he was too little to late. gosh rory just sucked after this epi. she sounded so immature and naive. go loralie!
Linsey found a note from Rory to him, so she kicked him out of the house. But the note was Rory telling Dean that she couldn't be with him because he was married. Somehow they ended up together a few episodes later.
Sorry, shadesofgrey1947, I don't have any clips from this. I'm still trying to make downloading programs work on my computer, and I don't have gilmore girls on dvd yet.
Well Dean was never going to really tell Lindsey what happened but Rory told Lorilei to give him a letter and Lindsey founf it and they got divorced and Dean and Rory went out for awhile but shortly broke up because they didn't belong.
lorelai normally pisses me off so much, but i was totally rooting for her in this scene. what the heck is wrong with rory? this is when she really changed for the worst.
i can uderstand why the tention could make this a funny scene. not as in joking funny but that odd feeling that makes you just want to laugh because there is nothing else to do, funny.
Dean's married and Lorelai just about walked in on him having "relations" with her daughter-who is not his wife. That's what the conversation is about. It's not meant to be a funny moment.
No, she wasn't, but Lorelai knew she was in the house. Did you not notice the volume of her voice? It wasn't like she was talking to someone next to her.
no she knew rory was there because rory told her that she was going to go home from the inn to get the cds and dean followed. then they had sex and dean is married and lorelai is pissd
*you're* (you are) the other woman.
siobanethier 6 hours ago
I never cried that much:((((((((((((((((((((
RomanYdOLLsMadeline 1 week ago
what ep & season is this ?
smoshwatcher100 1 month ago
@smoshwatcher100 Raincoats and Recipes is called
RomanYdOLLsMadeline 1 week ago
@RomanYdOLLsMadeline so from what season?
smoshwatcher100 1 week ago
@smoshwatcher100 Season 4 ,episode 22
RomanYdOLLsMadeline 1 week ago
@RomanYdOLLsMadeline thanx :P
smoshwatcher100 5 days ago
what a scene. :,( a real tear jerker. oh, rory.
meghani2006 1 month ago
This scene always makes me wince. Ouch. Greats gods cool mom or not to have your mom catch you in the 'right after' oui cringe worthy.
Willow698 1 month ago
I love lorelai's facial reaction when she saw Dean get out of Rory's room, she knew what was going on when he got out of her room.
brookiebear7 2 months ago
My mom had me when she was 16 and now were close like Rory and Loerlie
Jerseyqueens4 2 months ago 2
Ohhhhh SHIT!!
Vamperlis 2 months ago
am i the only one that liked dean + rory better than rory+jess ?
taniafatbitch32 3 months ago 10
@taniafatbitch32 You are not the only one! :D
ajb92191 2 months ago
i miss this show!!
partygirl209 3 months ago 4
I'm sorry but i didn't think this was a bad thing yes dean cheated on his wife but Rory and dean were meant to be. But I do think the should of never married Lindsay if he knew he was still in love Rory he should of called off the wedding and told Rory how he felt and she felt the same and then they should of slept together
teamdamon91girl 4 months ago
@teamdamon91girl Having a connection doesn't give anyone the right to cheat on their spouse. The fact that they got married in the first place shows some sort of commitment from BOTH parties. My opinion, of course.
Raacchhaaeell 1 month ago
@teamdamon91girl "should have" becomes *should've*, not 'should of' would have=would've, could have=could've
siobanethier 6 hours ago
Lorelai: What did he borrow..?
Me: HER VIRGINITY!
Haha i'm sorry, it's just as soon as I heard that line I automatically thought of that xD
ThePinkPanther207 4 months ago 24
I will never understand why Dean didn't just stay in Rory's room until Lorelai left.
StarsHollowPrincess 5 months ago 6
I dont see how this is all Dean's fault I mean he didnt make her sleep with him. I mean give him a fucking break the guy made a mistake.
payneicecold3000 5 months ago
chris and sherry were on a break, they were not engaged and both loreli and chris had no idea sherry was pregnant... so rory what your mom did was not the same as what you did, you knew dean was married.. and just because he took the ring off doesnt make one bit of difference!
tyryryrrr 5 months ago
why did Dean have to come out of rory's room like that??? it was so obvious... he should have stayed in there, door closed..
bluemooncarter19 6 months ago 6
I love Rory with Jess. Dean is just terrrible for her. I didn't mind her with Logan but he did really hurt her but so did Jess but Jess did get him self together by the end but Logan didn't. He didn't get what he wanted right when he wanted it so he left her.
Jasey4Ever 6 months ago 3
The emotion in this scene is so expertly played by Lauren and Alexis. I'm mesmerized by their talents.
ggaddict1537 7 months ago 2
oh watching this when i was fifteen back then and said poor rory and now like 7 years later i realized Lorelai is kinda right.
LostStella17 7 months ago
Something about Dean disgusts me ...
Mehlwurm18 8 months ago
@Mehlwurm18 Could it be the cheating on his wife? :P But yeah, there was something uber-skeevy about Dean cheating with Rory. He went from being a sweet if sometimes jealous boyfriend to That Guy, who married somebody else and then PINED for his ex the whole time, all the while hurting his wife (um, who really should have gotten a job if she was so damn desperate for the finer things in life) and treating her like crap for NOT BEING RORY. What a jerk he turned into!
SenseOrSensibility 6 months ago 4
I HATE Rory's character after this. Actually, I hated the way she treated Jess in the previous episode even more, but ohmygod. The writers made a huge mistake with this. Not only her sleeping with Dean, but her choosing him over Jess?! But she was being a brat here. &the thing that annoys me is that she doesn't even realize it's wrong until like after the summer. &Lorelai was so right, even tried to talk to Rory about it calmly, but Rory shoved her away. Rory deserves the worst at this point.
XshamosasX 8 months ago 2
this is the point where she went on a downward spiral... cheating with dean, stealing yachts. should have chosen Jess!!!!! at least he got her back to yale logan didnt care..
natflix 9 months ago 6
Dean is hot, but i love Jess (cause he looks like Adam Levine) :P lol
JenniferPKeaton 10 months ago
I have to admit Jared is waaay more gorgeous than Milo could ever be. Especially in season 4 when he has the facial hair and THOSE DARN DIMPLES! Just sayin.
kissame104 1 year ago
This scene was powerful in the sense that we finally see Rory in a different light. Granted, sleeping with a married man whose not your husband isn't the best idea. Naturally they're going to have their differences, but I have to side with Lorelai on this one. But this is one of the best scenes in the Gilmore Girls series in my opinion...
kidj2006 1 year ago 3
Okay, under what possible situation would "he took the ring off" make things better?
2wingo 1 year ago 12
Dean is way better than Jess! :)
PurpleStain6 1 year ago
Dean is now Sam on supernatural and his brother is named Dean and Sam now is way more bad ass. This aint shit, oh wow he got Rory pussy, fuck that shit Sam got grade A quality Vagin in supernatural.
scienceatheism 1 year ago
Lorelai was 200% right on this one
Paramorered 1 year ago 42
It is scenes like this that show what a spoiled brat rory is....
8sakuraleaf9 1 year ago 7
Comment removed
SSNoraSS 1 year ago
I loved Seaon 4 because Luke and Lorelia kissed but then Rory went and had sex with Dean.
skinsisthebest2 1 year ago
thank god caller id wasnt around yet
Ryu7490 1 year ago
Rory and Dean having sex just grosses me out, to be honest. Probably because I hate Rory's hair and dress and Dean drives me nuts because he's a tool. Just my opinion, though. :D
DizzyDior12 1 year ago 10
Did anyone else notice how ugly Dean looks? I don't know about you, but if were Rory, I would take the good-looking, well-read, unpredicatble, gelled-hair Jess over Dean...
High school Rory was the best. The college Rory made me want to cry.
Also, I hate season 4 with a passion.
sockrokr2 1 year ago 12
@sockrokr2 Do you honestly think Jared is ugly or are you just saying that because you'd rather Rory be with Jess lol? Cos even though I like Jess over Dean, I still say that he is a very gorgeous guy lol
kissame104 1 year ago 4
ok i agree with jessrules05 because both chris and sherrie were over and they ddint even know that she was pregnant
LoveRoryandJess 1 year ago 3
Rory is definately wrong thistime...
kvanci53 1 year ago 7
i dont see what the problem is, considering rory's age, she can do whatever she pleases. I get that dean is married and that is pretty bad but rory doesnt have to consult her mother in whatever she does it is her own choice.
charlottecheesecake 1 year ago
@charlottecheesecake Considering Rory's age, she's a child. And sure, she doesn't have to consult her mother but considering how close they are, it would be a first instinct. Besides Lorelai is totally right in this argument, I usually don't side in their fights but this one... totally on Lorelai's side.
romancese23 1 year ago 3
@charlottecheesecake considering rory's age she should know right from wrong and sleeping with a married guy is wrong! and loreli needed to give rory a reality check.. and the way rory acts in this scene she definitly doesnt seem her age at all! she's acting like such a brat!
tyryryrrr 7 months ago
Lorelai did the same with christopher except he wasn't married. She knew he was in a committed relationship with sherry living together, etc. Hypocrite..
rmpr123456 1 year ago
@rmpr123456 wait, i thought they were broken up. oh wasn't it that he told her that they were taking a break and he was going to break up with her? either way i don't think she's a hypocrite
candymandy224 1 year ago
@candymandy224 they were stil together. He didnt break up with her he was planning to according to what he told to Lorelai. Basically she slept with a guy knowing that he was in a relationship so its basically the same.
rmpr123456 1 year ago
Comment removed
rmpr123456 1 year ago
I love lorelai in this scene, she manages to keep so calm, whereas Rory is such a bitch! x
MistYouMadly 1 year ago 3
@MistYouMadly totally agree
aleluzmi 1 year ago
I don't know why this scene bothers people so much...
Yezaria13 1 year ago 4
What episode/season is this?
dreamers1994 2 years ago
season 4 episode 22
philippehungary 2 years ago
whats for a season?
AqueaTyrolensis 2 years ago
lorelei's a good mom
xxannabellaxx1 2 years ago 32
Im totally on Lorelai's side with this one... Rory is so annoying in this scene
smileyfan16 2 years ago 20
wow, rory isnt acting like rory at all in this scene.
but when she walks outside who did she call?
xxTIFFANYYxx 2 years ago
It sounds like she tried to call Dean's house, but his wife answered the phone.
JeanetteFusion 2 years ago
she called deans house and linday picks up the phone
heatherrogers1 2 years ago
@xxTIFFANYYxx Dean but Lindsay answers.
RandomAccount08 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Dean was too sweet for rory, Jess was perfect for her but he was also a rolling stone :( Logan and rory were the best and i wish she had said yes!
kissame104 2 years ago
lorelei is so cool
waln492 2 years ago 4
Rory doesn't deserve Dean or Jess, or anyone with the slightest amount of decency in them. Why did she change?
Rachy2049 2 years ago 22
i know. with a mom like that you would think you would be humble and cool. but no shes a brat, she always goes to her grandpa for everything. its understandable, i dont hate rory, but i am constantly disappointed by her
waln492 2 years ago 31
@waln492 I defintely agree!! I love loreali and wish that rory could sometimes see that she isn't always right.
shadesofgrey1947 1 year ago
ok I've just recently started watching Gilmore Girls and I'm only up to season 2 but does Rory really change that much after the third season? I mean yeah it was wrong to sleep with Dean but everyone is entitled to make mistakes. I'm not saying you all are wrong I'm just curious.
paperfl0wers 2 years ago
How can Rory equate Lorelai sleeping with Chris to her sleeping with Dean?! She says Chris and Sherry were engaged and Sherry was pregnant: they were taking a break, neither Chris nor Lorelai knew she was pregnant and Chris and Sherry got engaged after Lorelai slept with him, as a result of her being pregnant. Sorry, haha, rant over. That part just kinda bugs me...
I really miss Season 1/2/3 Rory :(
And how could anyone ever choose Dean over Jess?! Come on!
jessrules05 2 years ago 84
@jessrules05 Engaged = committed relationship.
sneakiebug09 1 year ago
@sneakiebug09 Yes, but they weren't engaged or in a committed relationship at that point, they had practically broken up, if they hadn't Lorelai would never have slept with him (or so I'd like to believe). It was only AFTER Lorelai had slept with him that Chris is told that Sherry is pregnant then, once he'd gone back to her, they became engaged (and we don't even know how long it was between him going back to her and them getting engaged). If you're arguing that they must have been in a serious
jessrules05 1 year ago
@jessrules05 he was married when that happened wasn't he?
VampireGirl726 1 year ago
@VampireGirl726 Christopher? Nope, him and Sherry weren't married or engaged, they weren't even together, they were taking a break.
Chique1616 1 year ago
@sneakiebug09 (cont. my other post - sorry if there were multiple posts of that one, I was on a different browser than I was used to and don't know if it managed to post)
relationship in order to have become engaged at the beginning of Series 3, then I disagree, because Chris made it pretty clear that he was only going back to her because she was pregnant, and they weren't already engaged, they were on a break.
jessrules05 1 year ago
@jessrules05 (realizing it's an old post).Disagreeing with the Dean vs. Jess question (:-)), I think you put the the Rory Season 1~3 vs the later years correctly. I felt that this was the start of Rory being more of an adult making faulty choices, entering a 'realm' that can't be protected by Lorelai. Unfortunate that it had to be losing her virginity and entering a sexual relation with an ex, but then again, I guess there wouldn't be any greater way to 'mark' the start of that sequence.
2006unsw 1 year ago
@jessrules05 Well I think your right.
But i would choose Dean over Jess,
TheOCmylife 11 months ago
@jessrules05 why would anyone choose jess over dean?! jess treated her horribly and never did one nice thing for her while they were together and never did something she wanted him to do or would sulk when he did and never told her what was going on with him, he wasnt dependable and then just abandoned her. dean however did nothing but love her even when she treated him horribly to chase after jess and he only married lindsay because he couldnt have rory. rory and dean shoulda ended up together!
klarebear721 7 months ago
@klarebear721 Well, putting aside the physical side that Jess is way more attractive than Dean. let's have a look. Firstly, Rory would never have ended up with someone who didn't share her interests in books, music, movies etc because that just makes up too much of a part of who she is so, while Dean was a good first boyfriend, he was never gonna be endgame; no matter whether Rory ended up with Jess, Logan, Marty, a new guy, or alone, it could never have been Dean.
jessrules05 7 months ago
@klarebear721 Secondly, Jess if just plain out more intelligent than Dean, so he and Rory were more like-minded, which is important in a relationship. There's also the fact that Jess/Rory had amazing chemistry while Dean/Rory had the chemistry of a dry plank, but that's physical again so I'll put that aside. Then, Jess always challenged Rory where Dean never really did, which was important, especially with his role in season 6.
jessrules05 7 months ago
@klarebear721 Last, while Jess was hardly a saint, he never did anything as plainly wrong or childish as marrying someone to get over someone else and then cheating on his WIFE. And after that, do we so redemption for Dean? No, we see him shout at Lindsay after having cheated on her, dump Rory in front of her friends and tell Luke that his relationship with Lorelai won't work (his last ever appearance). In contrast, Jess is almost completely redeemed for anything he did wrong by the end.
jessrules05 7 months ago
@jessrules05 Firstly, yes, i actually agree that fact of the matter was rory was too smart for dean and to be honest i actually like her best with logan. but jess is just such a jerk there with him the bad FAR outweighs the good. first, he lies, steals, smokes when he first gets to town and is rude to everyone except rory who also made a mistake of chasing after him while she had a boyfriend!
klarebear721 7 months ago
@jessrules05 then when she and jess are dating he treats her like absolute crap! throughout their relationship he never wants to do anything she wants to or sulks when he does, never tells her the truth about anything and is never honest with her. then he blows town again without saying goodbye again and then when he comes back a year later he continually ignores her until he tells her loves her at which point he leaves her again!
klarebear721 7 months ago
@jessrules05 then he comes back and expects her to be so weak minded that after everything he put her through she's just going to fall into his arms and run off with him! like seriously? if he knew her at all he knows that she would never do that, ESPECIALLY not for him. and you wanna talk about wrong and childish? jess did countless wrong and childless things his entire time in stars hollow and went through life not caring who he hurt, including rory. jess was easily the worst of her boyfriends
klarebear721 7 months ago
@jessrules05 the only thing jess had going for him was that he was cute and that he was as smart as she was, but when she was his, he treated her terribly. i;ll admit he got better by the end and maybe if there had been an eighth season they could've ended up together but the fact of the matter is for the bulk of the show jess was an inconsiderate rude thoughtless punk and i was relieved when she turned him down that second time and met logan.
klarebear721 7 months ago
@klarebear721 I just saw your entire conversation, and I almost disagree on all of it, but putting that aside, I have to say that Logan was MUCH worse than Jess. Do you realize that Jess never got a second chance? He tried so hard, but he never got another chance. Dean got like five, and Logan got a bazillion chances. Logan hurt Rory WAY more (cheating on her, breaking up with her after being a total dick to Jess, etc.). Jess may not have treated her very well, but it was always clear that he
XshamosasX 6 months ago
Comment removed
anauckermann 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@XshamosasX @klarebear721 @jessrules05 basically, Jess and Logan were shitty boyfriends and Dean was the best one she got. I do think marrying lindsey, even knowing that he still loved Rory and always would, was a huge mistake, BUT he could've simply gotten a divorce, if it wasn't for Jared starring Supernatural... At least he was always great to Rory and that's all that matters.
anauckermann 4 months ago
@klarebear721 really loved her. He had some problems, yes, but he figured all of that out in the end. He had the most chemistry with Rory & understood her in a way that Logan never did. You see that ESPECIALLY in the s6 when Jess is the ONLY one who can convince her to go back to Yale - including her boyfriend and her mother! Logan never even tried to get her back, he even encouraged it! He was lazy, rich, & spoiled, and changed Rory completely. And I just can't see Rory w/ someone like that.
XshamosasX 6 months ago 2
@XshamosasX you do realize we;ve argued this all out on another video, right? so....hello again!
klarebear721 6 months ago
@klarebear721 oh. wow. I never read your username. Sorry xD Jeez, this just shows how much energy I spend on this xD BUT, did we argue about Logan? I don't remember.
XshamosasX 6 months ago
@XshamosasX hey no problem, im the same way lol and i believe we touched on it towards the end... we can agree to disagree on this one
klarebear721 6 months ago
@jessrules05 I 100000% agree with you!
readerchick1989 6 months ago
It's funny how people said they didn't like Rory after this cuz she changed. I agree, but I never thought about it till I read those comments. I just thought I disliked her because of Logan and the fact that I never liked Dean to begin with. But it's true that she really changed after this point.
impasse0124 2 years ago 9
I have to disagree. I was disappointed that the character that I once idolized made such a poor choice but I like it because it's realistic. It shows that she isn't perfect, made a mistake, and she figures it out.
xbabebeeex 2 years ago 81
retiring home. haha.
xbabebeeex 2 years ago 6
rory was trying to self justify wat she did. she knew it was wrong but she was trying to coninve herself it was rite. grr this is when rory went downhill! rory and dean sucked togther and rory and logan were just as bad, cuz logan turned rory into something shes not. jess was the perfect guy for her and she was too stupid to realise it. and he was too little to late. gosh rory just sucked after this epi. she sounded so immature and naive. go loralie!
livexthexlife192 2 years ago 18
I agree! After this....rory is different.
shadesofgrey1947 2 years ago 9
what happened after she slept with dean? did he leave his wife or anything?
thatgovchick12 2 years ago
Linsey found a note from Rory to him, so she kicked him out of the house. But the note was Rory telling Dean that she couldn't be with him because he was married. Somehow they ended up together a few episodes later.
13twilightrox 2 years ago
Do u hav the clip where lindsey found the note?
shadesofgrey1947 2 years ago
Sorry, shadesofgrey1947, I don't have any clips from this. I'm still trying to make downloading programs work on my computer, and I don't have gilmore girls on dvd yet.
13twilightrox 2 years ago
Well Dean was never going to really tell Lindsey what happened but Rory told Lorilei to give him a letter and Lindsey founf it and they got divorced and Dean and Rory went out for awhile but shortly broke up because they didn't belong.
allea365 2 years ago
lorelai normally pisses me off so much, but i was totally rooting for her in this scene. what the heck is wrong with rory? this is when she really changed for the worst.
khlax75 2 years ago 14
agreed after this rory went from the character i loved to the one i couldnt stand.
livexthexlife192 2 years ago 2
rorys mad annoying! ew
Minaaisadorkmuch 2 years ago 2
I'm for team Lorelai on this.
Rory annoyed me in this scene.
rachelsaplayerrr 2 years ago 8
It should be 'You're the other woman.'
Not 'Your the other woman.'
This always bothers me when people get it wrong.
peach6182 3 years ago 8
i can has skool?
turnoutlane 3 years ago
ditto!!
thank you for the correction, don't know why so many people make this mistake, it boggles my mind!
damasareyasui 3 years ago
you would love my sister!
rosydonut 3 years ago
when is this ??
iLvSawyer 3 years ago
The last episode of season four. This is the very last scene.
It bothered me so much that I actually had to wait until season 5 aired on TV. Well, I guess that's the way with all season finals.
ImPolygloty 3 years ago
rory acted like a brat
jessmindadumbass 3 years ago 7
no she didn't. she loved him. she just didn't wanna face the fact that her mum was right, she wasn't being a brat. she was confused.
h44512 3 years ago 9
I agree.
Impactblue312 2 years ago
i can uderstand why the tention could make this a funny scene. not as in joking funny but that odd feeling that makes you just want to laugh because there is nothing else to do, funny.
amieslater 3 years ago
not rory
MarthaJack 4 years ago
the funny moment is with loreli
MarthaJack 4 years ago
at the begging who is loreli talking to
it is so funny
MarthaJack 4 years ago
She's talking to Rory; her daughter.
Did you pay any attention at all?
Dean's married and Lorelai just about walked in on him having "relations" with her daughter-who is not his wife. That's what the conversation is about. It's not meant to be a funny moment.
RubyRed05 4 years ago
yes but rory wasnt in the room
MarthaJack 4 years ago
No, she wasn't, but Lorelai knew she was in the house. Did you not notice the volume of her voice? It wasn't like she was talking to someone next to her.
RubyRed05 4 years ago
i though loreli was just talking to herself out loud
MarthaJack 4 years ago
no she knew rory was there because rory told her that she was going to go home from the inn to get the cds and dean followed. then they had sex and dean is married and lorelai is pissd
micaamry 3 years ago
...someone needs to c-a-l-m d-o-w-n.
karamac82 3 years ago
Really? I love Rory, but I hated her in this scene. I completely agreed with Lorelai.
RubyRed05 4 years ago 7
I agree with your comment. I agreed with Lorelai, and it was kinda sad that rory didn't see it.
peters206 4 years ago 2
about what
MarthaJack 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i know that what rory did was wrong, but i still hated lorelai in this scene.
dance38 4 years ago
why she is funny
MarthaJack 4 years ago