Oasis - Live Forever [2009'07'19 Germany Melt! Festival]

[aguileraerica]

El final de oasis ....

[fernandezbelen]

this is so fucking sad

[RealMadridForever21]

MAN THIS IS DEPRESSING. noel's face and liams attitude is just too much. this was the end, and they both know it. no one can live forever, not even liam or noel.

[zerostellar24]

i actually dont mind his voice here. prob lost it a but from the tour they were on. he's in top form now though with beady eye

[xnic0491x]

the oasis's fans always support to liam..and we are millions

[jamamafegan4]

How sad. The look on Noel's face... I really hope Oasis get back together, but the question is will Liam's voice ever be the same as it was in the 90s?

[MuseOfMetal666]

Sad really.

[MuseOfMetal666]

Something happened backstage before this performance. You can hear it in Liam's voice, you can see it in his face... And then there's Noel, tearing up and all.

[fabererer]

as always in Germany the crowd is shit

[IssDELUJO2010]

When I see Noel's cry I start to cry too :/

[TheDeidaraMaria]

@IssDELUJO2010 cry ? when ?

[IssDELUJO2010]

@TheDeidaraMaria 1:51

[Ricardoespinoza96]

They are just perfect, you say what you say, say that liam doesn't sing like 90's, say that they are old, even you say what you say, they are GODS.

[pacotruchiasecsi]

3:46 Cannot be from Germany without beer

[victoralmeida97]

oh shit =/

[RubyReapz]

Bascially everyone, Liam was shouting the lyrics directing them at noel.. They hated eachother and knew this was the end of oasis..:/ R.I.P OASIS

[TheGuitarfender96]

Noel crying? @1:53

[RubyReapz]

@TheGuitarfender96 Noel knew that this was the end of Oasis.. So yup :(

[davidmaxpower]

A liam parece no importarle cantar bien... esta versión es absolutamente horrible por su voz y sobre todo por su interpretación

[SoraTheHappyEmo]

I think Noel was crying because he knew Oasis wouldn't live forever.

[Ewhuraazih]

Херово спел

[Ravstar999]

/watch?v=jrtJarBAVdQ :') remember back in the day

[delboy20091]

class performance

[taylorboy1997]

Look what smoking drugs and alcohol has done too Liams voice :(

[DannyMadFerIt]

@taylorboy1997 Noel is also a smoker and he took mroe drugs than Liam... It's not because of drugs and cigarettes but because of his pose. Try to sing for 20 years with Liam's pose

[DannyMadFerIt]

@DannyMadFerIt more*

[taylorboy1997]

@DannyMadFerIt Yeah I know what you mean, he seem's to be getting his voice back at beady eye anyway

[DannyMadFerIt]

@taylorboy1997 Yeah .. but I still miss good old Liam from the 90's :(

[dave790]

@DannyMadFerIt that, and the sheer amount of singing.

[bizkit1167]

Very interesting to watch the faces/expressions on the bandmembers here. You can just see in Noel's face he's just totally done with it. Liam still is a great frontman he just looks bored singing the material. Still best band ever

[bizkit1167]

The best band of the last 20 years i am obsessed with Oasis I almost saw them o their last American tour but i got sick Oasis will live forever!! My kids listen to this band now

[xxKYLExGxx]

noel's crying because liam can't hold a note in a paper bag.

[RockstarSupernova25]

1:48 - 1:58 WTF that aint right is wrong

[danne9501]

hes not crying for fuck sake

[taylor4canucks]

i think noel was crying cus he new hes was about to leave oasis. the brothers obviously had some sort of fight before the gig... just over a month later, noel announced he had left oasis. but new that they would live forever

[nofilthy]

Lol...anyone see the Russel Brand Look-a-like at "4:38"

[dr05guitar]

noel's guitar tone is to die for :) love it

[dreck93]

so emotional

[HonkyCat90]

I think he's crying because of sadness, like someone said, something happened backstage.

[Britex123]

when was he crying?

[genibernat]

Doesn't matter how Laim voice is, I WANT OASIS BACK!!!!! The will Definitely Maybe Live Forever in my heart...

[AdyinH0bo]

Pause the video at 3:03. Liam's face. He looks worried. Something happened with the two brothers backstage. I feel bad.

[FreezerBurn1704]

Damn that line "Now is not the time to cry, now's the time to find out why" finally made sense.

[niko0o0m]

If I had to chose just one song to hear before I die it would be Live Forever without a doubt, no matter what, I always feel better after I hear it. Thank you Noel Gallagher.

[mattvocalPHHS]

Daaang. That must have been a dark gig

[EvelinevandeWinckel]

liam looks seriously pissed off

[asd87877]

this is the performance that says it all, listen to the mood of this man

[125possom]

so sad seeing noel cry.. :(

[LGKemp]

Why is noel crying? :'(

[RockIndieRock]

Now is not the time to cry! Then Noel cryes. Makes me wanna cry :(

[mct1207]

che brutte espressioni: l'aria tra loro si taglia a fette

[jtnjtnjtnjtn]

Seeing Noel cry really got to me it's one of the saddest moments ive seen from any oasis gig

[TheGuitarfender96]

pobre liam :S

[olias88]

Liam sounds angry here. They must have gotten in to a(nother) fight before the show

[xorasel]

@olias88 1:54 holy shit that must've been a bad argument; noel's about to cry here D:

[96Dano]

Where is this Liam from 90's? With perfect voice...full of life... and not as arogant as now... Not saying that I don't like him now but I definitely want old Liam back... Our Kid has 38 tomorrow... shit time really flies :(

[dr05guitar]

why's everyone ragging on liam's voice so much? Yeah it sounds different than in 1994, but it's not bad , geez

[LGKemp]

@dr05guitar What do you mean not bad? He can't sing anymore. You know why he doesn't hold the notes? Cus he can't keep them in tune!

[ONE1ONEONEONEONE1ONE]

Such an awesome song, but I think the split was for the best after hearing Liam's voice here, It's cruelly ironic that he's singing this song.

[ale81289]

he's a monster...he is GOD

[leb3186]

Why do you guys think that Noel is crying at 1:53? Is it because of Liam's voice?

[drumboyex]

liam sounds shiteeeeeeee

[oasis4ever92]

watching oasis in the concerts close to the end was like a boxer going out for one last fight. you still love them but to see them at their peak you got to look at the early years

[jore0806]

Oasis is all about Noels great writing skills and Liams unique and powerful singing. His voice took much damage over the years and has lost it's edge. He must feel horrible.

Just think of something you've made yourself known of and it would be taken from you.

Some of you people are ignorant and cold, where's your sympathy now when the singing won't do? I almost hope Liam retires. Then it would be all the hare-brained fools crying to hear him singing Live Forever like he used to instead of Noel.

[Chio95nwfan]

Now I've noticed that he cried right in the verse,,now it's not the time to cry,,...wow,Liam must have hurted him really bad

[Chio95nwfan]

I ussually love Liam but here his voice is terrible,my God,I can't belive it is real, he had lost so much talnet it's so sad,but it's also sad that Noel cried,he has soul and talent and seeing him in this concert I just feel like I develope some kind of love for him...

[MegaLiam01]

LONG LIVE OASIS!

[ruidoabsurdo]

Great band , Great song.

From Peru

[mrxelash]

Liam and Oasis gonna live forever!

[96Dano]

One of the best fuckin voices that he ever had...GREAT!!!

[fofoskywalker]

Was this the last concert before Noel quit in Paris?

[mejtd1]

@fofoskywalker No the last concert was at V Fest on 23rd August - They cancelled the August 24th V fest show because Liam "supposedly" had laryngitis. The next gig was then in Paris, which of course never went ahead because Noel quit :(

[OasisU214]

I think liams voice is actually better than the don't believe the truth tour. Not quite as muck screeching.

[OasisOblivion]

Very sad one his last song ever with the whole band ''Live Forever''.....I think this is the reason he is crying thinking about what he made and what he leave behind him awsome video!!!

[ivikaEilona001]

liam is handsome here but noel is crying ,that's sooo sad

i don't care liam's voice he is the best singer in the best band

noel i love you,you're my wonderwall!!!!!!!!!!!!

[fofoskywalker]

What he's saying at 5:48?

[KutaniCrane]

@fofoskywalker

"theres no way that you are from manchester" afaiu

[villalba77]

my imagination or liam distracts noel in the solo fuckin dAMN

[96Dano]

i think that Lima has fuckin great voice here! its better than 2008...in my opinion

[yahhhtrickyah]

he could he just wasnt trying

[leothelion75]

they were fresh air 2 us n shook us all up;yeah liam cant sing for shit now but hey they still got class at end of their road.

[96Dano]

Liam could sing this song much better, but he going out of mic so quick...

anyway...i think that 2009 is comeback of Liam's voice....(only little bit)

awesome....and very sad

[d4322263]

i have no doubt that noel cryy! but i cant imagine why. maybe cuz liams voice is not the same, or he remeber when he wrote the song, or he knows that it was getting close the end of Oasis but the only thing im sure is that THEY FUCKING CHANGE MY LIFE WITH HIS MUSIC (: I DONT CARE LIAMS VOICE! I ONLY KNOW THAT OASIS GONNA LIVE FOREVER! mad fer it :D

[LukaRaPtoR]

@d4322263 stop being so pretentious

[LgFaver]

no existe .... Oasis son los unicos que poseen este material y no lo van a subir asi nomas a youtube. A esperar el lanzamiento del DVD y luego alguien lo podra subir.

[keepitwildbass]

Poor Liam, his voice has been torn up over the years, but it still has a good presentation, the emotion is still there.

RIP Oasis, Cant wait to hear Noels solo stuff!

[somemightsay100]

¡que interpretación! es un despliegue de soberbia digna de los mejores musicos, estoy seguro que en el futuro se reuniran y haran cosas asi.

[knebworth1000]

fucking englsh you understand anything liam's voice is the best today, he's just older and has the rage again in his voice , he is just older and represents rock & roll

a pure lad. live forever.TODAY'S EMPIRE TOMOROW ASHES

[olias88]

what an emotional performance. <3 Noel

[96Dano]

I meant Noel cryed cause he knew he will go out from the band =D

[ansenpietje123]

/watch?v=e2l_esQuLdQ

That's what Liam had, and lost, and it the reason why Noel cries

[Tim1994shaw]

Fair enough, but he still represents rock n roll in its greatest form in my opinion and he did have a a lot of good shows, wembley stadium for example when i saw em there he was on top form.

[ansenpietje123]

Noel is fed up with a very arrogant rude and immature brother, who lost his voice almost 10 years ago, they were the best fucking band in the 90ies, and if stubborn Liam would listen to just a little piece of advise, who could have kept his song.

Liam is angry because he now also realizes what he has done, and it´s too late to fix his throat.

They could have been "The Beatles 2.0" but Liam blew it.

And this comes from someone who is beyond beying a fan.

[lelio86]

I'm really sorry to say that, but Liam's voice was much better 10 years ago... damn

[pbuk]

Oasis music will live forever.

[basszamegpeti]

So sad to see Noel cry. Liam is fucking angry for some reason. But Noel... he was crying during Live Forever. What the fuck happened between them?

[nath909]

@basszamegpeti

Noel wasnt crying

[qachito]

pesimo

[rocknrollCollins]

worst month ever august my dad passed away and oasis split up:(

[doctorvini]

sad, man

[rocknrollCollins]

thnx dude

[Azza593]

sorry to hear that :(

[rocknrollCollins]

thankyou mate

[MrBojangels15]

@rocknrollCollins

but i guess this is not the same category

[southpark990]

@rocknrollCollins stay strong man!

[VanMocen]

@rocknrollCollins

sad about your dad man. screw the split up, it's just a rock n roll band..

[96Dano]

1:52 Noel dont cry!!! you are the best songwriter ever!!!!!

[Damon83]

xDDDDDDDDDDD

[finefineitsok]

liam sings almost like he's mocking some one .

BUT IT'S STILL GOOD

[johny14141]

Aj ty ondro na SLOVENSKU po SLOVENSKY

[johny14141]

Dano na Slovensku po Slovensky

[96Dano]

no....Liam is singing OK.....but he knew he will go out of the band

[96Dano]

1:52 is Noel crying???

[thedoors4m79]

Seems so. Probably because Liam is singing so bad.

[19DANNYBOY89]

get a grip

[helenacrazycupcake]

@96Dano yeah, i think so

[96Dano]

great vocals!!!!

[belbatron]

russel brand at 4.38? hahaha

[stig1010]

What a great rock n roll voice

[fat0obob]

i just seen jesus lol

[RyanRotten80]

where?

[fat0obob]

the guy on the keyboard looks like jesus lol

[Trikz1990]

he is jesus, chanted jesus jesus give us a wave and he gave us a wave! True story.

[eddyd63]

he sings this much better than normally, i reckon he just needs some time out for his voice to recover, aparently hes got vocal nodules tho so thats why its sounds strained, he better recover for an oasis comeback LIVE FOREVER

[lsdarcy]

whats vocal nodules?

[SwitchAndrew540]

People seem to forget that he's not a fucking pop star, he's a rock star. His voice has definitely changed over the years but like everyone else he's getting older. Greatest frontman of our time, appreciate it.

[pspcrazy205]

his voice is gradually getting better..... you can hear the vibrato coming back and him holding the notes a tad longer by the time his solo stuff comes out his vocals will probly have recovered

[flummapa]

what liam should do is stop fucking around the mic and just sing his brians out like he does at the end of this song (gonna live foreveeeeeeeeer) because he sounded quit good there. but as long as he moves away from the mic before he ends a verse and all the mallarkey he wont sound very good. liam get a grip and give the people what the came for, a good concert, not an angry man city fan that only half sings :/

[nosemanz]

shut up

[grovestreet]

Aw Noel Crying :/

Love Oasis <3

[jamesfromcasino]

who cares bout his voice, its oasis.. its like the pogues used to be with shane mcgowen, i still watch and love them tho

[niicllas]

He maybe don't sing so good these days. Singin since the 90's untill now, and smoking and drinking, living like a fucking rockstar for 20 years.

Oasis will Live Forever!

[LSO92]

I actually don't think his voice sounds bad at all. No it's not breathtaking like it was back in 1994, but he's still got a voice and is capable of singing in tune. He sounds like a 37 year old man, not a 19 year old kid.

[hotelthehookers]

brian molko is at pretty much the same age and he sounds like his first day with placebo...ville valo is 33 and sounds like when he was 17......dont take me wrong I like oasis and I respect liam but his age is not an excuce....however I agree that he is still singing at least in tune

[flummapa]

roger daltrey, robert plant, mick jagger, even noel gallagher have probably drinken as much as liam and they dont have any problems singen these days. and their even older than liam

[nosemanz]

have all these toured as much as liam, no i dont think they have, age probably isnt an excuse, but liam definitely puts his voice under more strain than these guys, if u look at the tours oasis go on constantly u will understand. also i think liam wants to annoy noel at times and just shouts and changes words

[flummapa]

haha are you kidding me, these guys have been touring since the 60's! of course theve toured more than liam! And they still sound good. But maybe and probably, liam dosnt give a shit anymore.

[nosemanz]

i not sayin they havent toured, but their tours are nowhere near as intense, because they obviously have managed themselves better, whereas oasis tour so much and hardly have a break. for example this present tour oasis played a gig either every day or every couple of days, and he the songs dont lend themselves to keeping your best voice. anyway liam is still the best frontman out there

[flummapa]

yes oasis have had a quit intense schedual, especially during the 90's. Maybe liams just had to much whiscy :P anyways you are right about liam being the best front man out there. It's a rare breed:D

[MarkyNova]

i actually think his voice is fucked.

you can see he isnt like straining the notes, you cantell in his facial expressions.

so..i actually think that is his voice these days (N)

[RyanRotten80]

they sing properly though.. all these years liam has forced that brash voice out with his throat. it's destroyed his vocal chords.

[Oasisman102]

Go listen to Stand on the Edge of Noise, then tell me he still can't sing. He just can't sing perfectly after being on tour for days and days and days.

[RyanRotten80]

i never said he can't sing you tard. his vocal chords are fucked, any one that isn't a special needs spazz can hear it. ONE gig, on the whole tour he sounded slightly better..

[moses4president]

is noel crying at 1:55?

love this song

[gemarcher83]

He crying for liam's voice... :(

[Liamforever83]

oasis live forever!

[RussellBoyce]

Voice is obviously gonna be dying a bit after 20 years of singing in such a style whilst also living the rockstar lifestyle. The difference between LG and NG is, whilst Liams amazing talent (his voice) might be slightly waring, he is still giving 110% - NG lost interest and began goin thru the motions. I spent 100's of pounds seeing them this tour and I would pay to see Liam again - and only Noel if he was up for it. Liams out there EARNING his money giving his all - Noels there FOR the money.

[flenost]

its the other way around man

[noelsfan1]

Regardless to what might ever happen to NOEL,....

HE´S GONNA LIVE FOREVER,..!!

[whatsthestory09]

his voice makes no difference, they were still the best band around

[mick1983lfc]

this is the end of a massive world tour so he's not gonna sound amazing . true his voice is not as good as it used to be but this tour he's sounded better 18 mths would take it out of anyone

[Forestgravy]

TBH he's sounded worse than this and he's still got it in recording so it might just take a bit of extra practise or summit. Or get off the fucking fags

[hotelthehookers]

MY GOD.I used to listen to oasis years ago and I really had a long time to see a live by them and I feel socked!I really respect liam but GOD!he really has to take care of his voice....I hope he will make it up somehow cause...well.....this is sad....liam had a really great voice...soft where needed...dont take me wrong I like oasis....

[caimanque]

I dont care if he cant sing, he is the rocknroll star there

[LeandroCRamos]

Oasis needs a new singer

[qwertyarchex]

Saying that Oasis need a new singer, U might as well listen to other bands instead of Oasis u dick.

Maybe u r someone that cant even sing like how liam sing in this video LOL.

[FranciscoSCarvalho]

Oasis Lives Forever !

[aphextwin2000]

Noel quite cryin here..

he deserves much, much better relationship

[JackieWild]

this is so fuckin hard to watch.. you can see how Liam is frustraded and pissed too.. his voice is his biggest treasure.. imagine how frustrating it must be to have it start dying on you... feel really bad for him :(

[jetch11gd]

you´re right but this song however sings Liam will be the best fuckin song ever