Added: 3 years ago
From: nixa666
Views: 486,871
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (651)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I would kill myself if I didn't fear listening to that last verse for eternity. Cover the original and you will be the queen of beautiful depressing songs... Dreaming, I was only dreaming, of a death to decades of censorship.

  • my rolling stones heart...

    

  • oh my god i never noticed but sarah farted at 1:24 i love this song tho

  • The ending of the song about it all being a dream was not part of the original, it was added later to kinda soften the songs blow abit. basically

  • Sounds like Styx song Suite Madam Blue.

  • i dont know why every people that hear this would kill them self. its a great song.

  • Beautiful song and amazing lyrics but... i believe the song looses ALL its power when she refurs to the entire thing as a dream. it ruins the song in my opinion

  • @zodiac987654321 From what I knew, that part was put there because of you know... the rumor of the suicide if it was played originally without that part... Don´t know more hehe... (Also I think it ruins everything)

  • WOW--what a STEAL of a STYX song...wow---listen to the opening of the STYX song "PIECES OF EIGHT" tell me she didnt STEAL the guitar parts...and she';s singing this way too high a range....sorry..not great. I like Heather Nova's ACOUSTIC live versions MUCh better. And Heather has the natural high range.

  • @DavelovesRealMusic

    Not really. She's just covering an original song...

  • i love it too :)

  • its non sense...

  • i feel it all...she can move the moments in time, straight to the depths....

  • Sarah, you have the most magnificent voice, you have given the world a true gift with your singing you have absolutely nailed gloomy sunday such emotion thankyou

  • I Like this version , beautiful voice

  • เด็กดี อ่า ๆ .. ^^' เพราะดีน้ะ .. 

  • I love it :)

  • เข้ามาฟังเพราะโพสท์จัง

  • แปลเนื้อเพลงเป็นภาษาไทย

    ตามนี้

  • วันอาทิตย์ที่แสนเศร้า

    วันอาทิตย์นี้ช่างแสนเศร้า ฉันไม่สามารถจะล้มตัวลงนอนได้

    ต้องใช้ชีวิตอยู่กับความมืดที่ไ­ม่มีวันจบสิ้น

    ดอกไม้ขาวเหล่านั้น จะไม่ช่วยให้เธอฟื้นขึ้นมาได้ (ขอบอกก่อนนิดนึงว่า

    ชาวตะวันตกเวลางานศพเค้าจะมาไว้­อาลัยคนตายด้วยดอกไม้สีขาว)

    ไม่แม้กระทั้งที่ที่รถสีดำคันนั­้นพาเธอไป

    (รถขนศพเมืองนอกเค้าจะเป็นเหมือ­นลิมูซีนคันเล็กสีดำ)

    เหล่าเทวดาทั้งหลายจะไม่มีวันคื­นเธอกลับมาหาฉันได้

    พวกเค้าจะโกรธมั๊ยถ้าฉันจะไปหาเ­ธอแทน (หมายความว่า ถ้าเทวดาคืนเธอมาไม่ได้

    ฉันก็จะฆ่าตัวตายไปหาเธอเอง)

  • วันอาทิตย์ที่แสนเศร้า

    นั่นเป็นเพียงแค่ความฝัน

    ฉันตื่นขึ้นมาเห็นเธออยู่เคียงข­้างในใจของฉัน

    ฉันหวังว่าความฝันของฉันนั้นไม่­ได้ทำให้เธอเศร้า

    เพราะหัวใจของฉันกำลังบอกเธอว่า ฉันต้องการเธอมากแค่ไหน  อย่าเข้าลึกถึงเพลงมากคำเตือน

    เพราะกว่า200ชิวิตฆ่าตายเพราะอย­ู่ในอารมณ์สีเทาเข้าถึงอารมณ์เพ­ลง อ่านและฟังไปพร้อมกัน

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • nice tits @ 2:52 .. }:)

  • this song makes me cry, is so sad, I understand why the people suicide with this song

  • I dont want to die, i want to live years listening to Gloomy Sunday.

  • I like how she changed and butchered it.

  • I hate this video!!

  • her voice is so perfect for this song. simply amazing. such a beautiful girl, such a beautiful voice

  • did anyone hear the fart noise at 1:24???

  • I was from Vietnam, this time listening to songs that do not understand but that tune and crispy hat sad, melancholy

  • how does she sing so high?

  • @ShiningStar530 falsetto

  • Sarah's voice is so incredibly beautiful, but this video is so horrid.

  • i was born on a sunday, will i die on a sunday?

  • This is the alternate ending, right? Where it's just a dream, blabla? Good version, but I prefer the original ending  :)

  • 44 people have happy sundays.

  • @Lacrymozart

    which is still not a reason to dislike this song

  • her voice.

  • you can just hear the heartbreak...

  • Gyönyrű a dal és a videó!

  • KLĘKAJCIE NARODY !!!!!

  • I favor Emilie's version...

  • I think this version and Emilie Autumn's are the best.

  • I hear the song, yes but that lady singing it has pissed herself or something and is very irritating.-What a waste.- Try Chained Lightning by Don Mc Clean, well sung and very thoughtful. x

  • @Virginsnow111  forget you, i love this song and how its sung :p

  • o:43 where did you get that picture? Beautiful!

  • @Inuyashaluvah1999

    uhm,I don't really know,I googled something like goth angel or something similar.

  • I love this version best ^^

  • Sad, but so beautiful at the same time....'reminds me of life. To any seriously considering suicide, perhaps prematurely,... (hugs you) <3

  • @Jaybird196 i know what u mean... <3 hugs back xox

  • @lexinow84 (smiles at Lexi and wishes her a great day )

  • @Jaybird196

    This one tells of a beautiful suicide - taking ones life to be together with the one they love and is gone

    it is beautiful especially since there are all sorts of other kinds of suicides - that are far less empty - not being able to live and love while not having experienced any love at all - due to whatever causes

    this song is really beautiful with or without the alternate ending

  • my mother took her life on a sunday.... this song is truely something to take us away to a place that we all share.... we just choose not to speak of. i love the darkness that i hold so deep inside, what im sayin is this song puts me into a state of"bliss"

  • @GrandMasterWeezy

    what you say is very interesting

  • Wow pretty graphic tehe but like the song

  • seriously fucked up pictures, so sad sad sad.

  • Such an eerie song...so sorry to everyone's losses...

  • To Angnic22 First Of All I Am Genuinely Sorry For Both Your Losses,However As Someone In The UK Which Has Awful Mental Health Services,And I Have Suffered From Major Depression For 16 Years,You Need To Have Been There,At The Coal Face As To Speak.If You're Bad Times Are Temporary,Then Lucky You.As For Copping Out Your Comments Are Insulting Even To Me.

  • Thank you @simon01ize. My apologies, yet still doesn't change how I feel. My mother use to call me all the time saying she wanted to die;telling her it was a pathetic permanent choice to end temporary pain stopped her. Hopefully it'll makes others think, too. We can feed our depression or starve it. I choose to starve it. You have no idea what I've been through, and likewise, i have no idea what you've been through. I didn't post to offend only to share my opinion. Hope life gets better for you.

  • It takes more guts to live through hell then to plummit yourself there. I had a very close friend of mine commit suicide and my friend's dad so it does touch close to home for me. I love them dearly and pray for them, but in my view, they copped out. It doesn't take guts to die, it takes guts to live. Life's a bitch "and then you die" - not "until you kill yourself". Even in our darkest hour, we are not alone. Good times are temporary, but the good news is, so are the bad.

  • Comment removed

  • @OysterOfDoom You speak as if I never have...thoughts of death are prominent for everyone at some point in life; some more than others, some more detrimental than others. Assume as you wish, but your inflated words impact me not. If my "all powerful being" lifted me from darkness, then who cares if I am right or wrong? If heaven is real, then I will go there in due time, and if it's not, well then, I made the most of living thru hell on earth. Either way, I win. Peace & Love my friend.

  • @Angnic22

    there are many different circumstances in life

    i have a good friend that also experiences dark even suicidal moods - but for her the good times take the upper hand and she lives

    for me, the other way around - so i am searching for ways to cure myself so that i will be able to live and see things her way too - or your way

    but it does take a certain mental state to see things as you do

    and sometimes, when not possible to heal, it's best to end life respectfully than suffer

  • @Angnic22

    but that's not to do with this song - this song is about passion, about love

    about realizing that after the one you love is gone you wish to be together with them

    it's a very natural and normal decision to make - especially if it was great love

    thought non conventional - it has nothing to do with depression or whichever sorrow

  • Its not the saddest song I've ever heard the saddest songs I've ever heard were by otep Jamestown tea and Daddy's little girl by Cretin

  • @Mozarttheflower Lol Grindcore cannot be compared to something like this. Both are good only in their own way.

  • If you apply the principle of Occams Razor to life, then it practically tells you to commit suicide.

  • the music is good ,.. but the picture really terrified me__-

  • I Agree With Most Of Your Comments,However For SOME People It's The Only Way Out.I Think It Takes Guts As Well,I'm Not Advocating It,I Just Don't Think Those People Who Have Taken Their Lives Should Not Be Criticized.

  • @simon01ize Not criticizing, but, suicide is the EASY way out, not the only. It takes more guts to live through hell then to plummit yourself there. I had very close friend of mine commit suicide and my friend's dad. I love them dearly and pray for them, but they copped out. It doesn't take guts to die, it takes guts to live.

  • @Angnic22

    I committed suicide

    and it's gay...

    just gay.

    it will kill you. l

  • @simon01ize

    i don't think they are here to care ;p

    of course, i agree with you

  • ive thought about suicide a few times, but the only reason im still around is because of (like the other comments say) its the affect on other people it will have. that and i got over the problems at what i felt was the right time, after setting myself on fire which really brought me back to reality. bottom line, life, no matter how much it hurts is worth living, its the stuff that pushes you to the edge that makes you a better person.

  • @lampshade123321 Well said. Way to handle that edge and come out of it a better person.

  • @Angnic22 thank you much

  • la letra mas bonita que eh escuchado en mi vida..

  • you died on a sunday. it has been a month. and i am still grieving.

  • This song makes me shiver everytime I hear it.. no matter what version it is.

    The music is just so sad..

  • From the Hungarian movie "Szomorú Vasárnap".

    Lyrics: László Jávor

    Music: Rezső Seress

    from: Hungary

  • its fucked up

  • Really I can't feel what I feel listening to the original song...

  • If your gonna commit suicide, this would be a good song to have connected to it somehow. But it has to be an epically tragic poetic suicide. Then ppl will take it seriously so you wont be written off as another statistic.

    Sarah McLachlan can better than she always recieved credit for.

  • my dad commited suicide on a sunday, this song always reminds me of that day, always cry when i hear it. very sad song.

  • @bonvelyx Naw. It's not sad at all. In fact I head bang to this WHILE I'm cutting myself.

  • @bonvelyx this is dubbed the "suicide song" by the way

  • @bonvelyx may he rest in peace!

    

  • Although i love Sarah so much this is the worst version of this beautiful song i've ever heard!

  • @quatortersius

    really? its my favorite

  • @quatortersius I love Sarah too.. but you're right. I love Heather Nova's version best...  =^.^=

  • @quatortersius weird. my fave. really beautiful. though for a creepier effect i like Billie Holidays rendition.

  • wow..thats the sadest think ever!!!! together with bresso-lacrimosa are the more sad sons ever!!!!! i dont know why..but it makes me relax...

  • 1:56 - fuckin hell that's creepy

  • hope this is played at my funeral service followed by stonesours bother and a pic of me flipping everyone off ,,i,,

  • dont commit suicide just dont because there will always be something beter and if you decide to die your never gonna think of anyone you love your never gonna feel happiness everyone that knew you will cry just dont do it

  • @ancona246 You'll die eventually anyways. *shrug*

  • @kilderok ya and eventually humans will evolve should we just kill the whole race early

  • traumhaft^^ wndervoll

  • 2:52 and 3:52 I can see clearly now

  • beautiful

  • super.....

  • I love this song best version too I agree with guitaraddict29 it is a lot more courageous to "end it all" than to live... one day soon.

  • @44crow444 No it isn't more courageous to "end it all". But i don't think it's cowardly to kill yourself. People shouldn't judge those who kill themselves, because clearly anyone in exactly the same position would have done the same.

  • I love this version and Bjork's 8D <333 I don't find it depressing, though. I just dig the tune of it.

  • love love love this song, I know its s'posed to make you all depressed but its just soooo awesome!

    hehehe :D

  • úžasné video ... ty oči dítěte !!

  • if this ever winds up on an aspca commercial im done for

  • I did a cover of this... Not a very good one i must admit. Tell me what you think

  • Nice song,beautiful pictures

    People say NO to suicide your life is too precious to destroy

    You are original cant be replaced !!!

  • My favourite version of this song.

    Video is too emo.

  • Ive listened to this like a dozen times and im still not dead.. WHAT GIVES!?!?

  • beautiful song, i love it, more than my life, serious,

  • gyönyörű! így angolul is ...

  • @encianci

    Ugye? Pedig ez a verzió nem nagyon hasonlít az eredeti magyarra, mármint a dallam sem egészen, már ahogy én hallom, de a maga nemében tökéletes, olyan kétségbe ejtő és elkeseredett, hogy a világ legboldogabb embere is elszomorodik egy kicsit, ha meghallja.

  • I don't understand why people think this is a suicide song. I was singing it a while ago on the bus and someone asked me why i wanted to die which was a bit weird.

  • @Izzy13gale It's a song about thinking about suicide and sometimes its called the Hungarian Suicide Song. It's pretty obvious, you should know since you sang the lyrics, I mean it's not even veiled in the slightest.

  • people can make their own decisions in life - see the wealth for what it is - who knows what death is people have an drive to live so if they kill themselves on propose kinda proves they were really dumb as mud or that they made a decision based on psychosis .

  • @LoveIsDead oh you poor poor thing... Please don't listen to this song... it'll make you even more depressed... And just to say love is a stupid thing anyways, why would you want it, find joys in other things!!!

  • @HarukaHatter Actually when I stop and think a minute I love this cover!!!!! My opponion has changed! Beautiful cover... Yeah I guess it is rude to compare emilie autumn and sarah mclachlan... They are completly different... I admit my mistake XD

  • Absolutely beautiful, heartfelt song and a fantastic cover

    Just wish the 'Second "dreaming" Ending' never existed. Completely takes away the sadness in the song

  • I agree completely guitaraddict29. I've heard people say that suicide is the cowards way out....well consider how much balls it takes to put a loaded 30-06 into your mouth and pull the trigger. RIP my friend.

  • 3:01 BOOBIEZ!

  • hopefully no abandoned pets were injured during the filming of this video i don't wanna have to donate to the humane society

  • I actually prefer Emilie Autumn's cover because her voice is so much more... theatrical. But Sarah's cover is beautiful, too.

  • I am proud that the original version of the song is in Hungarian which is my mother tongue. But if somebody, Sarah has the talent to sing it to the English-spaeaking audience.

  • WTF Favole?

  • Such a sad sad sad song....THE BEST VERSION SO FAR...

  • @thepanostube

    second best... for the best, check out Poka Angela's version here on youtube. She sings it in Hungarian, but you should get the feeling even without understanding the lyrics

  • vampires are people too...ya know...

  • She's very good, but this does not fit the style nor feeling of the song and I don't like it.

  • i think Portishead does the best cover of this amazing song

  • @giz1aeon u should hear the Emilie Autumn cover ^_^

    it's awesome

  • @giz1aeon

    agree!!!!!!!

  • im kinda shocked this is a beautiful song and sarah has a beautiful voice i thought i'd have loved this version but I don't, at all. I think strayed too far from the original trying to be innovative.

  • people should stop being self-pitying vampires and GET A JOB.

  • Comment removed

  • cool song........

  • @glancecook actually depression is not temporary. I would know, I'm depressed but there's nothing causing it. it just a part of who I am.

  • Comment removed

  • Vampires? The popular image of vampires seems to be created to invoke fear. They are more like murderers, even in their own deaths. I just see self hatred in suicide. These are just opinions. I'm sure there are many arguments to refute it all.

  • Suicide-The greatest natural drive a human being has is survival. When that is gone, something is pathological. Meaning, it is not a voluntary decision of a sound mind.I believe people as deeply depressed as someone who ends their life would truly believe the world is a better place without them. They see their very core in contempt. They are not selfish, they are out of control and out of touch with reality, that is if you believe in the reality that there is value in all human souls.

  • @BLewisbliss Totally agree with all you said.....made me cry 'cos so true. From someone who tried and failed :-( One day.....

  • no doubt this version is very very depressing but nowhere close to d original one even the tune is different in d original one...written by seress rezso hungarian composer!!!

  • suicide is a permanent solution to a "temporary problem".

  • Comment removed

  • @GlanceCook Then why even mention it? Not all people who come here want to commit suicide or some even want to take that idea of their minds, some, like me, just come to enjoy the song as a musical piece, why even mention suicide?

  • @jkfrv38 I come here to listen and enjoy the songs but most of the comments here is all about negativity and suicide, so i posted that up to enlighten people not the other way around.

  • @jkfrv38

    good question :D

    it's a great song, regardless of whatever

  • @GlanceCook is there an impermanent solution to it?

  • @pockEclipse sure there is.. stop being shitbag thinking about suicide and fight with your head up high! ;)

  • @GlanceCook why commiting suicide instead killing anyone else?

  • Comment removed

  • her version is probably the most depressive one... depressed people don't listen to it

  • @crazymelomanka TOO LATE... : (

  • Rest in Peace Lee McQueen..your work will live on. Bjork did a good rendition of this song for him!

  • @goldenshoes123

    Do you know where is this song from? Cuz not Lee Mcqueen is the first actor who played this...

  • The best version of this song. Sarah McLachlan. I feel too depressive today... I wish I could join all my dead loves... I wish somebody loved me some day... So sad...

  • this is the best version

  • r.i.p. alexander mcqueen .

  • billie holiday still has the best version.. but this is very very good compared to some of the others i've heard. You have to sing with emotion and a lot of it to pull this song off and a lot of singers you don't hear the emotion, or sense of pain in the voice.. that sound of pain makes it a beautiful thing in a weird twisted way.

  • Not true, you can kill yourself because of a song. I'm proof, i've killed myself twice listening to this song. I might just do it again before it's over.

  • I think this is really beautiful song, not creepy at all.

  • @PinkuNamida this is the beautiful version

  • I have to say, the vampire theme to this song seem pretty inappropriate. Not in an offensive way, it just seems like it doesn't fit.

  • @FenrirLupei It's "gothic" theme not a "vampire" one... No one said anything about vampires...

  • @FenrirLupei You have completely missed the point of this song if you don't think vampires fit...vampires are the epitomy of suicide.They are moody petulant dead gothic classic poster kids for self involved pity and decadence.They are dark,cold and have an air of apathy and/or disregard for human life...suicidal people tend to be of the sad moody wallowing ilk.Suicide is a selfish act that leaves everyone asking why?

  • @FenrirLupei I kinda think it fits pretty well. I mean, think about it. Who would want death more than a vampire? Seeing as how vampires are immortal they have to watch their loved ones die and who wouldn't want to die when everyone you've known and loved eventually died leaving you here alone.

  • @FenrirLupei I actually think that it does NOT fit, completely, but, I do believe that they were shooting for a sort of.....Darker theme. Yes?

  • @FenrirLupei I think the same.

    

  • @FenrirLupei I agree with you. But, on the contrary, I find this sort of thing extremely offensive. This song is about suicide, a serious issue that hurts a lot of people. It's been romanticized by popular culture, but it's not glamorous or goth. People should keep their vampire fetishes out of it.

  • @FenrirLupei

    Absolutely agree, really like someone said, people should leave their goth tendencies where they belong.

  • @FenrirLupei Totally agree dude, everybody knows vampires prefers "Bloody Sunday"

  • @FenrirLupei

    Yeah. I really don't like when people put pictures that just seem kind of insincere and cliche to a song so meaningful.

  • @kmacmuzikmafia27 I totally agree.