@maalbe987 Yes I do! because it's just music, which sounds like many other music and this is because this kind of music (don't matter if you call it Rock or Pop) is just made for bring money in your pocket. Real art is not to copy other people, because they are famous - and thats why Green day aren't a good band to play Dylan! But you won't agree, anyway!
Bob Dylan is one of the best singers ever and I love this song I really respect him and cover never can be better than original, but personally I prefer this cover, cause I love Billie's voice and I'm Green day's fan. But I like Bob's songs
Man, 1NateGraham, I totally respect your opinion and all, and I know that it's been said thousands of times before, but... I wonder how you stumbled upon this video. I mean, if you don't like green day, and you don't like bob dylan, and you don't like the song... hm.
I love the lyrics Bob Dylan wrote. The way he sings however is the very reason I dislike his music. Green Day made me like his songwriting.... nothing more.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
actually, this is a shit cover. bob dylan is shit as well. not the best lyrics. all around a half ass song. especially when greenday does it. not impressed. underwhelmed.
@1NateGraham then don't fucking watch it. jesus, i don't get it. why would you go on a video and just post a pointless comment? i'm not a fan of justin bieber but you don't see me going to his videos and posting hate comments. grow up man.
@dagothurmehrunes You're absolutely right... no one goes to their shows, no one buys their music, they haven't won awards and toured the world. It's Green Day that is so absolutely clueless about the dire straits they are in as a creative force that only a random comment about the status of their lives can bring about an attack of common sense for them. Thank you for your time voicing this.
i love it .-. did you know that Kesha and Miley Cyrus are gonna be part of Bob Dylan's Tribute album? I am pretty sure that Miley Cyrus doesn't have any idea about who is Bob Dylan.
Bob Dylan's voice and intensity make this song not ever get boring and what it is. This version isn't terrible compared to most covers, but it just seems to drag on
The band didn't sell out. Nimrod was the last REAL punk GD album, if you think about it. I'm sorry, but except for Minority and Waiting, the album Warning kinda sucked. Afterwards it was Shenanigans, a bunch of unreleased songs. Then International Superhits, all of their singles. They ran out of ideas for their original kind of songs and moved into the American Idiot type of music. Personally, i think they're amazing still. Dookie, 1039, Warning, or American Idiot.
I like how some people flip out and curse and have a fit. Damn, calm down. Personally, they're my favorite band, I think it's better than the original and the original sucks. That's my opinion. Nothing against Bob Dylan, I mean, he's a legend. Just don't like him personally. There's no need for you to "kill someone" or curse a lot. Damn, so they appreciate Bob Dylan and covered his song? So what?
Granted this isn't the original and honestly im not a Green Day fan...but they didnt hurt the song's pride, and Bob didn't complain so i mean don't just troll on a B+ cover.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
this sucks lol...i came in with an open mind too but this is just awful...it takes a profound song and makes the lyrics sound meaningless. What he's saying sounds like any other crappy teenage punk band's song...Not the actual words, but how this whole cover sounds...It sounds like mainstream garbage. This is awful and I hope I never hear this ever again...
@MichaelBallack91 Dont have to be so mean. They did a amazing job and brougth back a amazing song back to young peoples eyes! Personaly, i love this lyrics and song, but i didnt understand a single word when Dylan sang it. They made me like this song even more.
1990StJimmy clean your mouth to speak about bob dylan and don't tell jokes, don't say again Billie is better than Bob Dylan or I will search you and destroy, :)
Well the John Mellencamp live version is superior to this without the help of a studio and certainly the Jimi Hendrix live at Monterrey version buries it. That said, Billy's voice isn't a bad voice. It's just the voice of a dolt. Of course that resonates very well with many of you , making it the best version for YOU.
@BarushkaLP its not disrespectful to say a cover is better than the original, look at mad world; tears for fears's version was a disgrace to music, but gary jules managed to make it one of the greatest songs ever. or all along the watchtower-not only does every human being on the face of the earth think jimi's version was better, so do jimi and bob dylan
God, Billie sings the shit out of this song! Long time Dylan fan (old guy) says this is one hell of a cover. Hendrix' version is a classic in itself, but this is the best of all the rest. (Articolo31's Italian version is also great.) Miss seeing American Idiot on Broadway - :-(
I'm a Green Day fan and even I have to say that I'm disappointed in this cover. Trying to cover a folk rock song in a pop punk manner just doesn't work.
Maaaaaaan! What did Dylan do these guys for them to destroy his song in this way. Completely hideous. Billie's valley boy voice doesn't suit this song at all. Dylan's voice is the true sound of rock n roll. FUCK GREEN DAY!
Like a rolling stone is hands down the greatest song ever....it's up there with happy birthday, twinkle twinkle little star, and the alphabet song as a classic that has such a universal message and power that shines through the original and the covers...Bob dylan really outdid himself when he wrote this masterpiece classic...if this song doesn't move you, you dont exist....
Great! This song was absolutly great when I first heard it when Dylan first recorded it, and Green Day has done another fabulous piece of work upgrading a masterpiece in their own style, just like they did with John Lennon's "Working Class Hero" Unsensored.
The music will just die someday if someone doesn't keep it alive. Sometimes a cover is successful enough that it keeps the original alive enough - the interest will spark back far enough to the original.
it has to be said the boy can fuckin sing,and hes one of the few.......the very few who can actually cover a dylan song.fucking great effort green day.
I just found out this cover existed and was curious to how it sounded...I was blown away.
I'm the kind of person who usually hates covers. A cover song has to be really really good for me to like it, especially if it's something like Dylan.
But Green Day really hit the nail on the head here. They don't change it at all, they just update the genre to today's standards. The song's message matches Green Day's overall message; they are a perfect match.
@glane88 green day's message? ''lets keep the punk band image but make shitty pop tunes instead and make money and still try to look like hardcore mofos while we sell out''
@psych0p4t3 Some people never learn. If they were sellouts, they wouldn't care about the fans. And they care a fucking LOT about the fans. And since when was punk rock, pop? They are hardcore motherfuckers. Shut up and enjoy the music
@frankwright3 A sellout is someone or a band who makes a certain kind of music because they know they can make a billion dollars off it. I think Green Day makes the music they want to make, therefore, I would not consider them sellouts. I think they believe in the music they release. All these Green Day fans sound just like the Metallica fans who say the same thing. Grow up. These bands did. And there music changed because of it. People change, musical tastes change. It's just the way it is.
@psych0p4t3 Some people never learn. If they were sellouts, they wouldn't care about the fans. And they care a fucking LOT about the fans. And since when was punk rock, pop? They are hardcore motherfuckers. Shut up and enjoy the music
@frankwright3 yeah, because 21 guns is so fucking punk and hardcore,and being on a major label where marketing eats you is caring about the fans and the quality of music, not.
nothing will ever live up to Bob's version not even Hendrix's cover and every rock cover sounds to much like they want to show to much respect to give some change to the song or it just sounds like a repeated Hendrix cover but this song has been covered so many time that the legend still matters because of all of them. Weather I like this cover or this band they have some major balls to cover a classic Bob song and I give them props for that.
Billie´s voice is great! I think this cover is better than bob dylan´s original! You can hate me for my opinion, but it sounds clearer and tré cool´s drumming is awesome!!!
@1990StJimmy Been a Bob Dylan from the time i first heard him tn the 60;s . I have to give it to Billie Joe , that was GREAT GREAT GREAT, but he can do anything, WTG
@1990StJimmy Billy's voice firstly, is not great. Is it better than Bob Dylan's? Yes. In reality, what this cover lacks is the power and emphasis each and every single word carried in the original version. The most moving songs are the ones thar are have been sung and written by the same person.
you're wrong. First, dylan doesn't use auto tune. Second, it might be easiest for you to listen to this cause you're used to clinical, clean sounds of today.
Still, this cover is not so bad. But not better than the original
@IC3dMelee you think this sucks then check out their cover of elvis's "that's all right" or their cover of the who's "a quick one". i like all of them though, n i think this one is the best of the three covers, but i know there's better covers of this out there
@TomThumbsBlues1965 EXACTLY! I don't get why people waste their time arguing about which cover is better, or "the original is best", etc. We just need to appreciate that they're paying homage to a great artist and exposing his songs to the younger generation.
punk rock is 50% music, 10% fashion and 40% doing kids' stuffs!.. it's not how fast or slow the songs are. it's about the quality and the attitude of the song. that's what punk rock is. they did slow ones but still they kicked ass! it's not just by one song you judge them, it's the whole album. it's still punk! :))
@mjandicehockey4ever fans always say that.. even i am.. but compare the old greenday to the new one.. they ve changed a lot.. they ve started creating an image on stage.. if someone says greenday, they l be reminded of guys with make up in a black uniforms with a red tie on stage..lol the music they make has also become slower and is'nt raw anymore and they made american idiot a broadway musical.. anyway this is my opinion..
@99tuberats93 yeah sure they changed, but that's just normal after so many years ;) and yes, they made some reaaaally slow songs, but there are still some faster ones and i think it's really a pity that the most just know the slow songs like 21 guns or blvd of broken dreams
the thing with the musical....well, ....i think it's brave that they did that xD ...i mean...no other punk band did that before xD ...ok....you can call that "the most punk thing ever" or "not punk anymore"....idk....xD
It sucks!
gabixolaa 1 day ago
For me the Best cover ever
duckdalf55 6 days ago
A very nice cover, but I feel like they could have put a *little* more personality into it.
MyBloodRedApple 1 week ago
I don't like that guitar, sounds pretty bad for me, it kills this beautiful song.
Juanmaesgay 1 week ago
<3
HeroNeskos 1 week ago
Great cover!
Arthur1965trudy 2 weeks ago
Green Day are always the best in making covers. I'm not saying their versions are better than the originals, of course.
I really like Bj's voice in this one, the way he screams "how does it feel?" :3
Carolauz 3 weeks ago
Billie Joe has got awesome voice! :)
BarushQaV 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
BarushQaV 3 weeks ago
<3<3<3<3<3<3<3<3<3<3<3<3<3<3<3<3
misszindri 4 weeks ago
It's like Rihanna would play Johnny Cash....
areaP6 1 month ago
@areaP6 i'd listen to that
JAYKENNYmusic 3 weeks ago
@areaP6 Did you just compare Green Day to Rihanna? ...Where's my shotgun?
maalbe987 1 week ago
@maalbe987 Yes I do! because it's just music, which sounds like many other music and this is because this kind of music (don't matter if you call it Rock or Pop) is just made for bring money in your pocket. Real art is not to copy other people, because they are famous - and thats why Green day aren't a good band to play Dylan! But you won't agree, anyway!
areaP6 6 days ago
@areaP6 So by that logic, all covers are bad. But even Dylan had a couple covers scattered throughout his albums.
maalbe987 6 days ago
ya que nadie habla español dire que soy gay.
Green day lml
TheMsHerok 1 month ago
Like a Rollingggg Stoneeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Thumbs up if you scream like that xD lol
francescaschi1 1 month ago
takes a lot of nerve to cover this song
IRONJOEPAWLOWSKI 1 month ago
Sounds great, great cover, Green Day is a great band and I say that at the age of 51!!
borntrippin 1 month ago
@borntrippin -hugs you- grandpa is that you?
VFloresTalent 1 month ago
Like a rolling stone ...
n7275 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is good.
NotSoEngineered 1 month ago
Comment removed
NotSoEngineered 1 month ago
i've seen both bob dylan and green day live and neither played this :(
finnstralian 1 month ago
Bob Dylan FTW
SDloco100 1 month ago
Bob Dylan is one of the best singers ever and I love this song I really respect him and cover never can be better than original, but personally I prefer this cover, cause I love Billie's voice and I'm Green day's fan. But I like Bob's songs
bgsgbja 1 month ago
Man, 1NateGraham, I totally respect your opinion and all, and I know that it's been said thousands of times before, but... I wonder how you stumbled upon this video. I mean, if you don't like green day, and you don't like bob dylan, and you don't like the song... hm.
museofthedamned 1 month ago
Dylan sings awful, but is that what makes him a fuckin' genius....this cover is good, but nothing as the old voice of Bob and his oldie armonic...
JdInmortal 1 month ago
Love this cover...Dylan is amazing but sometimes his singing is a little weird
lestat83bv 1 month ago
I love the lyrics Bob Dylan wrote. The way he sings however is the very reason I dislike his music. Green Day made me like his songwriting.... nothing more.
tm12333 2 months ago
Nice !
LantzucAndrei 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
actually, this is a shit cover. bob dylan is shit as well. not the best lyrics. all around a half ass song. especially when greenday does it. not impressed. underwhelmed.
1NateGraham 2 months ago
@1NateGraham then don't fucking watch it. jesus, i don't get it. why would you go on a video and just post a pointless comment? i'm not a fan of justin bieber but you don't see me going to his videos and posting hate comments. grow up man.
sweetchildren80 2 months ago 8
@1NateGraham holy shit youre a dumbass
kingrandomthe13th 1 month ago
VERY GOOD COVER ¡¡¡
MrRHCP456 2 months ago
@NoLiefVlogs The lyrics made the song for me.
razorath92 2 months ago
Long time Green Day fan here. Bad choice of song to cover for them IMO.
chickenthr33 2 months ago
i love green day!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
littlebilliejoe73 2 months ago 16
Green Day fucking sucks.
dagothurmehrunes 2 months ago
@dagothurmehrunes arsehole
CODGOD7771 2 months ago in playlist 21st century extra songs
@dagothurmehrunes you are the few of 202 people i want to kill
ExitLeft522 2 months ago
@dagothurmehrunes then why the fuck are you looking them up and listening to them?
TheJudgesDaughter48 2 months ago
@dagothurmehrunes You're absolutely right... no one goes to their shows, no one buys their music, they haven't won awards and toured the world. It's Green Day that is so absolutely clueless about the dire straits they are in as a creative force that only a random comment about the status of their lives can bring about an attack of common sense for them. Thank you for your time voicing this.
theartisanrogue 3 weeks ago
Is the cover of The Rolling Stone version, is most like that version...
(Im not saying The Rolling Stone version is the original, im only say this cover is of that version)
renaldoisis 2 months ago
I love Green Day and I love Bob Dylan...so I'm not sure why I didn't like this cover lol
LoLzerzzzz 2 months ago
i love this song
TheDavidgrohl 3 months ago
not as bad as i expected
mddbassdude727 3 months ago
This sounds like the end to a really cheesy movie.
I love it.
ilyjoesphadam 3 months ago
@ilyjoesphadam lol
lunakiitty 2 months ago
now my second favorite cover besides the one by the stones :D
David56583 3 months ago
i love it .-. did you know that Kesha and Miley Cyrus are gonna be part of Bob Dylan's Tribute album? I am pretty sure that Miley Cyrus doesn't have any idea about who is Bob Dylan.
thatgreengirl12 3 months ago
I dont get why people is so pissed about Green day doing a cover of this song? i mean come on...!
cevie11 3 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Thats so fucking sad, this stupid ass band does a cover
OF THE LEGEND BOB DYLANS song, What a disgrace...but whatever
wowsdeath 3 months ago
@wowsdeath Take it as a compliment that they love Bob Dylan enough to do a cover.
jackakaemo 3 months ago
@wowsdeath better than the original, just sayin' ;)
oXHorizonXo 3 months ago
@oXHorizonXo this doesnt even touch the original! it isnt bad but it isnt Dylan
MrGillby 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
OHHHHH How does it feel
KeenanBradfordBen 3 months ago
Bob Dylan's voice and intensity make this song not ever get boring and what it is. This version isn't terrible compared to most covers, but it just seems to drag on
bentskies 3 months ago
The band didn't sell out. Nimrod was the last REAL punk GD album, if you think about it. I'm sorry, but except for Minority and Waiting, the album Warning kinda sucked. Afterwards it was Shenanigans, a bunch of unreleased songs. Then International Superhits, all of their singles. They ran out of ideas for their original kind of songs and moved into the American Idiot type of music. Personally, i think they're amazing still. Dookie, 1039, Warning, or American Idiot.
SaintJaded 3 months ago
This is one of the best covers I've ever heard. Makes me want to dance. Give Green Day some credit. They took on a Dylan song and didn't ruin it.
dpbucknall1992 4 months ago
I like how some people flip out and curse and have a fit. Damn, calm down. Personally, they're my favorite band, I think it's better than the original and the original sucks. That's my opinion. Nothing against Bob Dylan, I mean, he's a legend. Just don't like him personally. There's no need for you to "kill someone" or curse a lot. Damn, so they appreciate Bob Dylan and covered his song? So what?
Archie8Manning 4 months ago in playlist Archie8Manning's favorites
FUCK you guys. the fact that green day covers this song actually makes me want to kill someone
TrumpetCase 4 months ago
@TrumpetCase Anger management much?
Chrissysen 4 months ago 4
@TrumpetCase I don't advocate violence... but if you're looking for someone to kick around... *points at Newt Gingrich*
theartisanrogue 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Granted this isn't the original and honestly im not a Green Day fan...but they didnt hurt the song's pride, and Bob didn't complain so i mean don't just troll on a B+ cover.
Beatlesmania737 4 months ago
THIS SONG IS SO LONG AND SO AWESEOME PLAYED BY OUR FAVOURITE BAND - GREEN DAY, IF U DIDN'T KNOW!
AAFGreenDay 4 months ago
@AAFGreenDay 6 minutes isn't long.
Get grammar lessons.
BleachTW 4 months ago
Stop discussing, everybody has the freedom to like and to dislike this.
Osch78 4 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
What a fuckin' cover CRAP!!
Only Bob ist the best!!
Cash sucking fuckin' "Emo" Punks
MsHappyLilly 4 months ago
Crackin cover our band do this one it's given us a new slant on classic song. Green day are the daddies!!!!
middleageddirtbags 4 months ago
Above Billie's head there's Beach Boys' Surfer Girl picture. Awesome.
BeatleBoy93 4 months ago
Not a green day fan, not a horrible cover though. Dylan's will always be the best, followed by The Stones.
ryanw7385 4 months ago
american idiot killed Green Day , 21st century breakdown buried Green Day . don't get me wrong , i was one of their biggest fan ..
noburega 4 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this sucks lol...i came in with an open mind too but this is just awful...it takes a profound song and makes the lyrics sound meaningless. What he's saying sounds like any other crappy teenage punk band's song...Not the actual words, but how this whole cover sounds...It sounds like mainstream garbage. This is awful and I hope I never hear this ever again...
MichaelBallack91 4 months ago
@MichaelBallack91 Dont have to be so mean. They did a amazing job and brougth back a amazing song back to young peoples eyes! Personaly, i love this lyrics and song, but i didnt understand a single word when Dylan sang it. They made me like this song even more.
nathaliasarczuk 4 months ago
CRAP.
FUUUUUUUUUUUUUNGI 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@FUUUUUUUUUUUUUNGI Why are you talking about yourself???
Ohwow979 4 months ago
This is actually a song only someone with an incredible voice can sing. u have to actually shout at points and keep the perfect pitch
chanstar9 4 months ago
Kyaaa!!!! I Loooove it!!! Better than the original!!! The perfect song... Now with the perfect band!!!
<3
nathaliasarczuk 4 months ago
All right! Way to go, Billie!
smvc90 5 months ago
Good cover!! Green day never makes a bad mistake musically! They have always been on top of their game!! Joey Vaughan "World Blues Attack"
cjoey39 5 months ago
It's not bad, it just doesn't work.
zachy7777 5 months ago 2
There are songs nobody should ever cover - it's one of them.
MrPhobs 5 months ago
@MrPhobs Too bad it has already been covered by around 20 bands.
v0ngolavsky 5 months ago
Grandi!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
falange99 5 months ago
dylans great. but shit this was better
Disturbed1127 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1990StJimmy clean your mouth to speak about bob dylan and don't tell jokes, don't say again Billie is better than Bob Dylan or I will search you and destroy, :)
pedrobaza1996 5 months ago
Comment removed
pedrobaza1996 5 months ago
For me the 1968 Jimi Hendrix version is easily the best.
insaneme92 5 months ago
Well the John Mellencamp live version is superior to this without the help of a studio and certainly the Jimi Hendrix live at Monterrey version buries it. That said, Billy's voice isn't a bad voice. It's just the voice of a dolt. Of course that resonates very well with many of you , making it the best version for YOU.
Geepsterr 5 months ago
shut the fuck up !
You can't say that this version is better than Dylan's.
Losers, it's called RESPECT.
BarushkaLP 5 months ago
@BarushkaLP its not disrespectful to say a cover is better than the original, look at mad world; tears for fears's version was a disgrace to music, but gary jules managed to make it one of the greatest songs ever. or all along the watchtower-not only does every human being on the face of the earth think jimi's version was better, so do jimi and bob dylan
danieldrums9 5 months ago
I really like Green day, but nothing can compare to Dylan ! Such a genius
robhans2 5 months ago 3
At least 50% better than I was expecting.
hmp22 5 months ago
God, Billie sings the shit out of this song! Long time Dylan fan (old guy) says this is one hell of a cover. Hendrix' version is a classic in itself, but this is the best of all the rest. (Articolo31's Italian version is also great.) Miss seeing American Idiot on Broadway - :-(
GregMichelena 5 months ago
Nobody sings Dylan like Dylan.
But, I will say, that I was surprised to find this cover to be better than any other cover of the song.
twsx 5 months ago
i like jimi hendrix's cover better
cph645 5 months ago
This is horrible.
RasLuineAQW 5 months ago
awesome cover! =)))
but still.... nothing beats the original... =)))
love greenday!
love dylan!
=))))
CurlAudio 6 months ago
O hell no. Dont mess with the classics.
socom908 6 months ago
O hell no. Dont mess with the classics.
socom908 6 months ago
Omg.. green day is the best cover-makers EVEEER!!
COBtranquillity 6 months ago
I'm a Green Day fan and even I have to say that I'm disappointed in this cover. Trying to cover a folk rock song in a pop punk manner just doesn't work.
stevebruleiscool 6 months ago
oh no...
Pmitsou123 6 months ago
Maaaaaaan! What did Dylan do these guys for them to destroy his song in this way. Completely hideous. Billie's valley boy voice doesn't suit this song at all. Dylan's voice is the true sound of rock n roll. FUCK GREEN DAY!
eminemdisstopia 6 months ago
@eminemdisstopia shut up, fucker!
xXMinkeStaukenXx 6 months ago
@xXMinkeStaukenXx u mad, bro?
wickedlady666 5 months ago
@eminemdisstopia Billie isn't from The Valley, he's from The Bay. Let's keep our California geography in mind.
mattking165 5 months ago
This song suits Billie's voice perfectly. Amazing job. Mr Armstrong - again.
sharonlynnemitchell 6 months ago
Like a rolling stone is hands down the greatest song ever....it's up there with happy birthday, twinkle twinkle little star, and the alphabet song as a classic that has such a universal message and power that shines through the original and the covers...Bob dylan really outdid himself when he wrote this masterpiece classic...if this song doesn't move you, you dont exist....
elephantman243 6 months ago 2
This makes me sick to my stomach.
What a travesty.
GodspeedJoshua 6 months ago
this song should have never been touched
SteakNamedJake 6 months ago
I absolutely hate Green Days music, but I'm willing to hold my hands up and admit this is a good cover
laddy933610 6 months ago
Dylan, Stones, Hendrix, Green Day..... All the versions are fcking incredible!!! the soul and spirit of the song its AMAZING! Cheers for all of them!
erns88 6 months ago 3
they sound better tyhan the stones doing this song
frank02111 6 months ago
Great! This song was absolutly great when I first heard it when Dylan first recorded it, and Green Day has done another fabulous piece of work upgrading a masterpiece in their own style, just like they did with John Lennon's "Working Class Hero" Unsensored.
barrybrookens 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey guys i do a cover of this amazing song on my channel and I'd appreciate it if you could check it out. Cheers.
SeanFlanagan1000 6 months ago
Wow gotta admit I didn't except this to be good but it's fucking amzing.
peacenow05 6 months ago
The music will just die someday if someone doesn't keep it alive. Sometimes a cover is successful enough that it keeps the original alive enough - the interest will spark back far enough to the original.
RadeonZero 6 months ago
HOW DOES IT FEEL!! :D ♪♫ it feels awesome! this cover is fucking amazing, I love both Green Day and Dylan!!
DeaDCorE45 6 months ago
and 178 dislikes.............178 dylan fans before he went electric no doubt.
amk68sco 6 months ago
it has to be said the boy can fuckin sing,and hes one of the few.......the very few who can actually cover a dylan song.fucking great effort green day.
amk68sco 6 months ago
ya im a huge greenday fan, i hate gylan but this is awsome
adamsbrandon16 6 months ago
This is actually sort of kind of phenomenal.
I just found out this cover existed and was curious to how it sounded...I was blown away.
I'm the kind of person who usually hates covers. A cover song has to be really really good for me to like it, especially if it's something like Dylan.
But Green Day really hit the nail on the head here. They don't change it at all, they just update the genre to today's standards. The song's message matches Green Day's overall message; they are a perfect match.
glane88 6 months ago 26
@glane88 green day's message? ''lets keep the punk band image but make shitty pop tunes instead and make money and still try to look like hardcore mofos while we sell out''
psych0p4t3 5 months ago
@psych0p4t3 Some people never learn. If they were sellouts, they wouldn't care about the fans. And they care a fucking LOT about the fans. And since when was punk rock, pop? They are hardcore motherfuckers. Shut up and enjoy the music
frankwright3 5 months ago
@frankwright3 A sellout is someone or a band who makes a certain kind of music because they know they can make a billion dollars off it. I think Green Day makes the music they want to make, therefore, I would not consider them sellouts. I think they believe in the music they release. All these Green Day fans sound just like the Metallica fans who say the same thing. Grow up. These bands did. And there music changed because of it. People change, musical tastes change. It's just the way it is.
metalupyourthrash 5 months ago 37
@metalupyourthrash AMEN!!
ilike757 2 months ago
@metalupyourthrash That is the most intelligent comment I've seen in a long time on YouTube. Thank you for this.
greetlesday13 1 month ago
@psych0p4t3 Some people never learn. If they were sellouts, they wouldn't care about the fans. And they care a fucking LOT about the fans. And since when was punk rock, pop? They are hardcore motherfuckers. Shut up and enjoy the music
frankwright3 5 months ago
@frankwright3 yeah, because 21 guns is so fucking punk and hardcore,and being on a major label where marketing eats you is caring about the fans and the quality of music, not.
psych0p4t3 5 months ago
nice one!
999rockandroll 6 months ago
Good Job!
Thecodi55 6 months ago
nothing will ever live up to Bob's version not even Hendrix's cover and every rock cover sounds to much like they want to show to much respect to give some change to the song or it just sounds like a repeated Hendrix cover but this song has been covered so many time that the legend still matters because of all of them. Weather I like this cover or this band they have some major balls to cover a classic Bob song and I give them props for that.
lovelaj0149 6 months ago
Billie´s voice is great! I think this cover is better than bob dylan´s original! You can hate me for my opinion, but it sounds clearer and tré cool´s drumming is awesome!!!
1990StJimmy 6 months ago 66
@1990StJimmy Better than the original??? Ha! Not hardly...
205whiteboy 5 months ago
@1990StJimmy maybe bob dylan version.... but the rolling stones version is better ;)
dedo91ska 5 months ago
@1990StJimmy Bob Dylan's style was exactly not to sing clear xD So if you like to hear it clearly, this is just for you ^______^
Remember that the original is so old that clarity would be considered a miracle :p
0LaPola 5 months ago
Comment removed
1990StJimmy 5 months ago
@1990StJimmy wow he was complementing you on your opinion and you were a dick to him
70sdude117 5 months ago
@1990StJimmy Been a Bob Dylan from the time i first heard him tn the 60;s . I have to give it to Billie Joe , that was GREAT GREAT GREAT, but he can do anything, WTG
maemaesmusic2 5 months ago
@1990StJimmy Billy's voice firstly, is not great. Is it better than Bob Dylan's? Yes. In reality, what this cover lacks is the power and emphasis each and every single word carried in the original version. The most moving songs are the ones thar are have been sung and written by the same person.
Samsasrenjet 4 months ago
@1990StJimmy
you're wrong. First, dylan doesn't use auto tune. Second, it might be easiest for you to listen to this cause you're used to clinical, clean sounds of today.
Still, this cover is not so bad. But not better than the original
diemalibu 4 months ago
@1990StJimmy i wouldnt quite go that far, but i think its better than hendrix's and the stones' versions
8down10 4 months ago
This song seems longer than Jesus of Suburbia. It's still a great cover though.
MissILuvGreenDay 6 months ago
This is... no... just no...
LuffarLinn 6 months ago
@IC3dMelee you think this sucks then check out their cover of elvis's "that's all right" or their cover of the who's "a quick one". i like all of them though, n i think this one is the best of the three covers, but i know there's better covers of this out there
RetardedAndRandomTV 6 months ago
great!!
TexPerryc3 6 months ago
Yes, the best cover it's by Jimi Hendrix,
lobinaloca007 7 months ago
Love the cover, Billie's voice is great.
AxuRamone 7 months ago
love to see bands keeping this alive. cheers green day
TomThumbsBlues1965 7 months ago 2
@TomThumbsBlues1965 EXACTLY! I don't get why people waste their time arguing about which cover is better, or "the original is best", etc. We just need to appreciate that they're paying homage to a great artist and exposing his songs to the younger generation.
JadedJabberwocky 6 months ago 2
Best cover ever!!!!!
sugarmagnolia787 7 months ago
@sugarmagnolia787 no....the best cover it's by Jimi Hendrix
LedZepXXX 7 months ago
smh 2 haters
birdy713 7 months ago
I dont think the organ is well used in this cover.
GeoffWilde 7 months ago
punk rock is 50% music, 10% fashion and 40% doing kids' stuffs!.. it's not how fast or slow the songs are. it's about the quality and the attitude of the song. that's what punk rock is. they did slow ones but still they kicked ass! it's not just by one song you judge them, it's the whole album. it's still punk! :))
nilikha13 7 months ago 7
viva bob dylan and green day!!!
destroiz 7 months ago
how could you hate this. if you did your obviously arent a dylan fan
johndzwonar1 7 months ago
ha...haters....when we're in the 1960's and Bob Dylan cover some old songs....people will also hate him.....people are such hypocrites...
greendayrocksmuch 7 months ago
@greendayrocksmuch He mostly arranged traditional songs though, it's not the same.
GeoffWilde 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Oh, for fuck's sake.
RDBeatnik 7 months ago
I like green day but this doesn't sound very good
munierinho 7 months ago
fucking jizzed when i found out green day dida dylan cover
greatfelixo 7 months ago
AWSUM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
TheJohnny990 7 months ago
Great Cover! :-)
TheGroUndsOfficial 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
good but not a touch on dylan
mick2141 7 months ago
sad green day sold out.. they were an awesome which band made good music and did nt give a shit about what people thought about them
99tuberats93 7 months ago
@99tuberats93 no one sold out
skakky 7 months ago
@99tuberats93 1. as skakky said: no one sold out and 2. they still don't give a shit what people think about them ;)
mjandicehockey4ever 7 months ago
@mjandicehockey4ever fans always say that.. even i am.. but compare the old greenday to the new one.. they ve changed a lot.. they ve started creating an image on stage.. if someone says greenday, they l be reminded of guys with make up in a black uniforms with a red tie on stage..lol the music they make has also become slower and is'nt raw anymore and they made american idiot a broadway musical.. anyway this is my opinion..
99tuberats93 7 months ago 2
@99tuberats93 yeah sure they changed, but that's just normal after so many years ;) and yes, they made some reaaaally slow songs, but there are still some faster ones and i think it's really a pity that the most just know the slow songs like 21 guns or blvd of broken dreams
the thing with the musical....well, ....i think it's brave that they did that xD ...i mean...no other punk band did that before xD ...ok....you can call that "the most punk thing ever" or "not punk anymore"....idk....xD
mjandicehockey4ever 7 months ago