Selena Gomez & The Scene - "Who Says" - Concert for Hope LIVE for the first time!

[AnaliaLovesBen1995]

this is officially my theme song it de3scribes mee i love selena

[danypooh1994]

Getting really TIRED of these haters hating on Selena.! JUST STOP.!! She is better than u at singing, she has Justin so give it up

[o0odestiny29o0o]

oh selena i will LIKE you when you stop singing plz plz plz plz

[1oneinabillion]

she cant sing

[kenijoe77]

i saw you and i was the girl at the demi meet and greet sept 18 who was infront of you

[hays99]

Selena is great live(:

Well, atleast better than Miley//:

[Zanessaloverxoxox]

Her singing can be worst i mean i saw horrible.

Shes trying she know she needs a lot more "practice"

i advice selena to go do singing lessons if she has time.

[VamiBlood]

i just LOVE the Lyrics.. SOO GOOD.

and she can really sing actually. so dont judge her about that.. she just needs singing lessons more.. But i actually more like her when she's acting. thats kinda her thing. :)

[MotherChipmunk]

It's sad when your background vocals sound better than you. Just saying.

[lissbg59]

I like selena(not a fan) but even though she's not the worst singer in the world she's not even close to be the best a and her perfomance is boring and just REALLY BAD. if she at least could perfom or sing that would be great.

So besides llike four songs that she didnt even write i dont see anything special in her.

[Sakura52296]

Selena, don't listen to the complainers. What right have they to evaluate your

singing., You have your own style that they can't comprehend because they are

trying to define your talent in singing to someone else. You are a good singer

and soon you will be great and these critical ones will soon eat their words. They

are just jealous because your Justin's girl and they want badly to bring you down.

Ignore the ignorant remarks that comes from envy and bitterness. Love you Selena! Don't stop.

[SFisLove]

I really do love selena and I have been listening to this song nonstop... but girl needs a lot, and i mean a LOT, of improvement. She's very talented, but she sings as well as the next person on the street. She was absolutely out of tune for this entire thing.

However, I'm glad she is pursuing this dream of hers, so why should we stop her? And at least the song sends out a good message. As long as she's happy, I'll support her. You need some work on those vocals, honey, but you go girl!!! :)

[Sakura52296]

@SFisLove - No more out of tune than her boyfrieneJustin Bieber when he sings. Well they can both make beautiful music together. I'm sure those two are used to all the critics.

[SFisLove]

@Sakura52296 yeah actually she was very out of tune. I mean I'm not criticizing her for that, because I have a lot of respect for her, but it's true - whether you believe or not.

[meetdacousins]

wow. i think i need earplugs. she's okay in acting but singing? NO SHIT SHERLOCK. i think in the cd they edit her voice cause man her voice in the cd is far from reality. SORRY SEl, but please stop SINGING LIVE! :)

[padfoot877]

Well this is way Selena is an actress first and second a singer...because truthfully this is not very good. But she has the face and PR to sell her album...whatever...music these days

[alexastock2]

She's no singing queen

She's just a stupid wannabe

XD

[tnaplusjonasbrosrox]

i like selena, but i think she should stick to acting.

[flamourglitz]

in the high notes...its obvious that she cant sing..she's shouting. not singing. Just act selena

[JoleyStationForeverG]

okay i like selena , she seems nice and she is pretty. but i honestly don't think she sing. and i will support her with acting but NOT singing. this is a good song but she shouldn't keep singing : /

[anniej1630]

i love her so much

[luuhwj]

i like her too, and i LOVE this song, but that was soooooo bad. 

[Megaane84]

I love Selena with all my heart, she is my idol and I'm crazy about the song "Who Says" I listen loop but without being nasty here, I think it's horrible, Sel has really bad singing, it's a disaster. I expect to see another live of "Who Says" in hoping to be better but this is really bad. Sorry Selena, I love you anyway.

[Megaane84]

I love Selena with all my heart, she is my idol and I'm crazy about the song "Who Says" I listen loop but without being nasty here, I think it's horrible, Sel has really bad singing, it's a disaster. I expect to see another live of "Who Says" in hoping to be better but this is really bad. Sorry Selena, I love you anyway.

[xcrazylittleme]

@Megaane84 I love you so much. Finally a fan who isn't lost.

[nhwwrestling]

Her singing isn't going to be amazing the way she runs across the stage and stuff. She's tired and is out of breath.

[Zafrina33]

shes beautiful and everything but, this is not really her best live ...

[isasch123]

she can't sing and she has no stage presence at all.. i don't know why she keeps trying... she's stick to acting selena

[swe3t23]

@isasch123 agreed singing isn't her fortay. Maybe for Kid Bopz 

[isasch123]

@swe3t23 haha i know right... i really don't know why she wants to be a singer i mean what's the point of being a musician when you can't sing, you can't play instruments, you can't write your own songs? what.is.the.point.? haha whatever she has no future in this anyway

[jonasLOVEnkj]

love this girl!

[zakkista]

She is incredible. It's the first time that I am really proud to support her.

[JonasBrothersDENISE]

but she is beautiful and her dress too!

[JonasBrothersDENISE]

I don't like this....

[xOniley007]

Omfg o_o this is so bad... Sorry Selena but that was so bad

[DramaFreakxoxo]

i LOVE selena with all my heart butt some parts of thiss songg when she was singing it live suckss. sryy but i still love her.

[allright35]

ohhh sorry i like her but that was soooo bad

[xParamorexxFreakx]

I love her dress <3 <3

[ChristianBeadlesSWE]

BAHAHAHAHAHAA OMG She sucks soooo bad, hate that bitch -.-'

[MissDanger171095]

this was really bad.

[wizardsdisney12]

GUYS! Stop being so rude to her! She is only doing what she loves! If you think she sucks well i think YOU are the one who sucks...Because you just came here, watch the video and be RUDE! That's mean! If you know that this was her FIRST time performing this song well is obvious that is not going to be PERFECT! Is the first time! Wait until she tamed this! So just go back to you bitchy land and STOP BEING RUDE! Nobody likes it when you mistreat someone! Get a life!

[hope1dragon]

the sound of your camera is not great, her voice was great^^ really she improved so much^^

[SGomezSupport]

I love it (: Shes amazing and so gorgoeus <3

[prettypuhlease]

0:11 - :017 made me cringe

[Patrywasmer]

Diosss no canta una mierda!! No entiendo como puede ser cantante

[MsJonasBrothersFan96]

orrible.

[MartinezAbel93]

I was there and I have to say that it sounds much better live. The quality of the video makes it sound crappy but Selena Gomez can actually sing!

[togwapff]

You mean u were unlucky enough.

The Girl cant sing. OMG i need new earplugs.

[TheDollyyy]

LOL IT WAS...AWFUL

[lilprecious14w]

im sorry but she cannot sing all that great..i know their are tons of fans who claim shes amazing..but shes really not shes average

[kukuwiya]

Is she wearing shoes or not? :p

[TheMoSoShow]

Did Christina Grimmie meet Selena Gomez and become her backup vocals because Selena saw her on Youtube? Or how did they meet?

[filipecaramelo]

@TheMoSoShow christina went to Dream Out Loud photoshoot (selena's clothing line) and they actually meet there !!

[livelaughlovek21]

this was actually a good performance. she still isnt the best singer and i think shes better at acting, but it didnt sound bad. the song is catchy.

[jazab99]

she cant sing. nuf said.

[rockingxgummybear]

good background voices :)

[agaton161]

she can't sing.

[Ochirbatb]

Awww poor Selena. She cant regulate her breath, she needs more voice lessons. Even i can sing this song better than her :)

[GyMnAsTiCsL2]

SELENA <3

aww i love her, i wish i could see her live!

[NickStudMuffin1]

great sound :D

[lgcatlover]

She sucks. Needs a lot more work live.

[Pinky09x]

She is the best :) i know her voice isnt the best but her songs say everything ♥

[PiinkBlack95]

really good :)

[Zanessaloverxoxox]

But she really needs to work on her high notes for example, when she says the who says your not star potential and close to the end of the video she needs to practice saying that high note, obviously she can't go low on every high note knowing her band isn't going to back her up on that...

[bluec1212]

she sounds better than usual, but the background vocals carry the song.

[TeachMeToDemi]

K i love her, but she cant sing! We all think she should stick to acting. Just sayin. (does anybody know if demi was there? Confirmations?)

[Leahsiphonehelp]

lol you guys she doesn't even sing the nananana parts. shes not lip syncing and the timing is not off.

[butterflyx457]

if you listen carefully the 'na na na na na' bit (which is played in the background) sounds off, and selena's not even singing it. which means the camera is a bit off. SO, don't criticize selena and say that she sucks because she doesn't :)

[SweetAuby]

She's always amazing ;)

[4evermuziclover]

people need to remember that this is her first time singing it and shes walking around trying to keep everyone entertained. PLUS shes doing this for charity selena loves singing and shes followed her dream that isnt something we can judge. I mean shes been rich and famous since she was 6

WHERE WERE YOU WHEN YOU WERE 6 ?? KINDERGARTEN ?

[sinars92]

amazing as always.

[akshaygomes1707]

She's actually good in this song! i mean her voice suits perfectly for this type of songs.And i think she sounded gr8 live, and i think its because of the camera it sounded a bit rough, But I'm sure it was gr8 out there!! I wish to see her live, she became so awesome! And yes i think she shud do vocal exercises b4 signing but anyways that gr8 performance. can't wait to see her on ELLEN to perform this song live again!! People can then see how she actually sings live this song!

[kestra79]

To me she seems to be struggling a bit like her voice was tired or something like that. Sounds like she straining to sing the higher notes I love this dong though so it's ok

[missbasketball2010]

she is getting betterr...she jus really has to learn how to control her breathing...if she cud do tht...she wud b great

[selurockmyworld]

@mvpluvr is talented! 

[didi5180]

Ok not trying to bring up JB, but look up his concert for Dublin 2011. Totally lip syncing (his voice is pre puberty, just like the video, so obvious). But then again 10 year old girls wouldn't even care!!! Look up "Love Me". At least she is singing live and trying.

[SmiLeY8853]

Remember, this is the first time she's ever performed this live before. All of her other songs had drastically improved since I last saw her perform in October. She's getting a lot better, just wait for her summer tour!

[Zanessaloverxoxox]

@SmiLeY8853 I agree because people are just judging her like that but shes actually trying...

[KleeD813]

she sucks becuz she screaming it but she has to scream it for the crowd to hear it better....

[MotherChipmunk]

The songs on her albums are amazing to hear, but why not live? I think they morph her voice in the studio to make her sound better. And if so why is she singing then? She's an amazing actress and it's not like she writes her own music. I'm confused.

[weinbergFAN]

@MotherChipmunk

Frank Sinatra, Elvis Presley, Celine Dion, Beyonce, Lady Gaga, …, Miley Cyrus, etc used songwriters.

How many songs have you already written and published?

[MotherChipmunk]

@weinbergFAN yeah but they write MOST of their #1 songs. I've written songs too but I'm not a singer. So what's your point???

[FokhoJonas]

nice :)

[parik2005]

I love this song but not live, she try hard is her job and i admire that but she is not a singer

[Sunnyvale877]

Her voice, she sounds ,its over worked.. I still am a fan of her music! Great effort Selena........{!}

[liddlemissme]

her voice is raspy, which is to be expected. you try singing about ten songs in a row. no, shes not the best singer, but she has a nice sweet voice that i love listening to.

[didi5180]

No one really sings well live........no one! But she did great. Selena rocks!

[MotherChipmunk]

@didi5180 um yes they do. Beyonce, Lady Gaga, Jonas brothers, Demi Lovato, Colbie Cailat, Miranda Cosgrove, Ariana Grande, Victoria Justice, and the list goes on. Her voice is just terrible to hear. She needs some training still not a lot, just a little she's almost there though.

[didi5180]

@MotherChipmunk Jona brothers are you serious!! Wow....look them up first. I will give you Beyonce and Lady Gaga...they are adults so their voices are much stronger. But you are right her voice is on training...at least she is not doing what JB is doing. Lip-syncing on his world tour.....now that is bad!!!

[sinars92]

@didi5180 you're so dumb its unbelievable he's not lip syncing it might be in the background but that's because his voice is getting deeper.. and did u not see his performance on Wetten dass or whatever that show is.. he sang live.. and amazing..

[MotherChipmunk]

@didi5180 What you mean look them up? I have been to 4 Jonas concerts and never have I heard them lip signing.

[naomichg]

No sirve para cantar, nomas para actuar.

[xXxlolapolaxXx]

i hate to be a hater but she sounds awful tbh.. your kidding yourself if you think she can actually sing

[weinbergFAN]

@xXxlolapolaxXx

She is a singer who needs more volume. (The problem Selena Gomez knows himself)

But she puts the emphasis on the quality of their songs (lyrics, rhythm and sound).

She sings because … music is fun … so she also has several cover songs and share this fun with their fans and that’s what counts alone.

None of you will be forced to visit one of their concerts.

(We all know how bad the sound is at major events. Then another bad video camera and you can criticize it)

[weinbergFAN]

Respond to this video...

Who allows us to criticize music?

Music is in the feel of the individual and represents a means

Feelings to express more directly and more deeply than words could.

Music is the rhythmic order of noise, sound and tone.

Metal or Punk or Rocker or Classic music fan … everyone understands music other!

[Mcyrusthebest]

i loved

[xxWordsUnfoldxx]

She is just so EPIC =D

[F3A4N5]

Love her!! can't wait to see her preform again when she goes on tour!

[cm95xo]

she's come so far with her singing, and she's definitely going to keep improving (: selena has so much talent!