@thegrinchl7 Ok Grinch but you're on here listening to her music too. It's your favorite season Grinch so lighten up . Joni is a magnificent artist other wise people like you and me wouldn't even be stopping here
Wow...thanks for posting this precious gem. The main focus here should be on the music and the incredible artistry displayed in this tune/video...a musical icon Joni is who deserves our utmost respect for her musical contributions throughout the years...thank you Joni...you are one class act...bravo!*****
Genius IS selfish - I suppose it has to be as it may exist outside of the ego. It takes two to make a baby - what about the dad? What did he do for the child??? Anyway, I love her music - I don't HAVE to love her as a person.
Dear h8ers. Does Picasso suck because he cheated on his wives? Does Jefferson suck because he had slaves? Do the Spanish suck for killing indigenous people with small pox? Do we trash art in the hopes of self righteous logic? I hope never! Art is what we feel despite the workings of the thought police and do-gooders. If your God teaches you benevolency and tolerance then by God practice it. Proselytize elsewhere please.
To those of you who are so terribly critical of Joni's decisions..it is cruel to judge something you know nothing about..just listen to her lyrics, her soul. She has suffered enough. So stop now.
I do not want to see clueless judgments. The term clueless is used because I do not like witless Bible preaches. Now, music is a many facets gem. You may know the crown view of a diamond but there are many more complex cuts of beauty. In thirty or more years I haven't heard such a rare combination as Joni Mitchell. I really enjoy it. Remember If you can heal as many minds and souls in time of judgment day -you just got lucky.
My name is Marcelo'm the world's southernmost country, where, after the Andes is only a long narrow strip of land. No matter how powerful creation of this wonderful artist overcame all obstacles and made this up here. In Chile for 24 years now, the incredible music of Joni Mitchell, makes me fly to distant landscapes of Canada, or walk down the streets of his adopted California. Joni, represents for me a priceless gift that life has given me.
@thegrinchl7 Maybe at that time you might just have walked a mile in her shoes. You might have done the same believing it would have been the best of alternatives for "Greens sake". Are there any dicisions you have regrets about looking back down the road of your past?
@MegaWildswan - I will quit being so nasty if her fans quit trying to make this woman into a living SAINT. We all know she's a coward for abandoning her child. Never mind her bizarre voice.
@thegrinchl7 Wow, you need help buddy! We all make choices some good and some bad! If memory serves me right Joni left her kid due to several circumstances and has now reunited. Im not anyone nor are you to judge her for that. She made amends with her daughter. But for some reason you seem to be very angry over something that is not a part of your life
@thegrinchl7 I don't pass judgement on my friends. At 38 life has changed for me and the more fingers I point at people the more that point out to me in return. My mother gave away one of my siblings and this year she found us. I am no one to judge my mother's actions however, I am beyond happy to have found a very beautiful sister. God, is good and I have seen it. I have no idea how you can compare Joni to OJ? And, no Joni ISN'T a has been.
@thegrinchl7 Damn, my apologies really! To think that you would dismiss my story as a "cliche" is just a FUCKING insult! I guess having any discussion with you about anything pertaining to REAL LIFE is out of the question! You're the type who wants their cake and eat it too! I'm glad I'm not like that and I thank God that at my age I have survived many things enough to know that "life" is complex and difficult and NOT an easy road with easy answers. Take care and good luck being sad.
What nonsense is talked about her voice. This performance is awesome, and the aging of the voice is intrinsic to the lyrics. What on earth do you critics think this song is all about FFS?
What a tragedy that the shallow greed of the music and entertainment business has blinded so many people to true genius.
There isn't another artist of the last 50 years that has this woman's talent.
that's the first live rendition of this song I've seen. I love it! I kinda like what's happened to her voice, it's different, more limited so what! She conquered the higher registers, now it's time for something different. Without the husk in her voice, I would have never discovered Joni. It was the Love actually version of both sides now which introduced me to her awesomeness! And how can I forget hejira, my favourite Joni number, even that's far from her earlier angelic voice, but I love it.
Love you, Joni, but Larry Klein was from Newark (anag). I don't believe anyone has ever made a woman's thoughts understandable to mere males. Really, really hope you've found happiness.
I think this album came out around 1984. Exceptional song, beautifully written. Another example of how much commercial music has deteriorated over the past few decades...
OK. So if Joni Mitchell was in a competition with fellow Canadian Celine Dion, who would come out as most talented song writer, musician, singer, artist, etc etc etc?
@hoof2001 Joni blazed a trail for so many artists; she writes more than songs, her lyrics are magical and poetic. Her songs are a beacon for anyone who has felt the odd one out (man or woman). At such a young age she was able to nail big issues like love, loss, artifice, innocence. Celine didn't even write her big, fat, but at the end of the day, ordinary, commercial hit. I would never put these two in the same league.
Thanks for posting, remember this on a video tape of The Old Grey Whistle Test and whilst I was still a teenager (just) was stunned, fantastic performance
Actually, she released this song in 1982 on the Wild Things Run Fast Album though not sure when it was written, though presumably around that time. I recall repeatedly watching this exact piece on a video tape of The Old Grey Whistle Test's review of the year in 1982/1983! What I was doing obsessing about a song about midddle age when I was 16, I just don't know. I love the contemplative mood of this song and the tinge of regret. Fantastic! Thanks for posting.
she released this in the early 70's, probably 1973 or 74. It's a combination of her own story of having to put her daughter up for adoption because she became a pop star in the late 60's and knew she would never be around to be a good mom. Obviously, half the song is from the original song "unchained melody' from the 50's.
@jmiller05 over her carrer joni has had truly wonderful journey, i love the fack that she dose what she wants when she wants. She often changed her style and didnt give care in the world whats the press thought. She writes the most deepful meanful lyrics i have ever heard and i turly love her work and especially the geffen albums " Night Ride Home " and " Wild thing run fast" being my favorites. Songs Like "Love" using the biblical context are amazing , Ethiopia from dog eat dog, love it all
Joni in her forties and returning to what she had become famous for. Her previous album MINGUS had been misunderstood and largely slated ( although she never sang better) All of a sudden, the high register has gone and this song is easily the best thing she did throughout the eighties. Not until TURBULENT INDIGO (1994) did her genius return and by then, not many people were listening - a real shame, since it's up there with BLUE and HEJIRA.
@3373157 I'm always slightly conflicted about her eighties stuff.
The music was indeed still 'hers', but i felt the Geffen years really inhibited her true creative craftmanship. Too much emphasis on production, rather than the true portrayals and characters, themes and messages in her music. After all, what is Joni Mitchell if not a companion to the listener.
If you feel what Joni feels, then the work is immediately more gratifying.
Flawless as Always ~~~
BluesMistress 1 month ago
Wonderful Joni, love her.
jellyjukebox 1 month ago
пиз*ец это а не музыка!!!!!!!
fucking music!!!!!!!!!!
EnnnJey 1 month ago
zhorik12 do you know where I can hear that concert? I used to have it on tape but it is long gone :( I agree, it was much more wistful and laid back.
scarey66 2 months ago
her version in London which was broadcast on radio London was better, less hurried and more depth.
zhorik12 2 months ago
The great Vinnie Colaiuta on drums and Michael Landau on guitar ... when they were pups.
stretch54 2 months ago
Seasons of LOVE for us Joni. IMPECCABLE words and song!
bachwoman098 2 months ago
@thegrinchl7 Ok Grinch but you're on here listening to her music too. It's your favorite season Grinch so lighten up . Joni is a magnificent artist other wise people like you and me wouldn't even be stopping here
jen8rve 2 months ago
nobody can touch this artist.......nobody...
her lyrics and phrasing are that good that even a blind person listening to her would see colourful landscapes appear in his head....nuff said.
misterbracks 2 months ago 3
Wow...thanks for posting this precious gem. The main focus here should be on the music and the incredible artistry displayed in this tune/video...a musical icon Joni is who deserves our utmost respect for her musical contributions throughout the years...thank you Joni...you are one class act...bravo!*****
makissoflife 3 months ago
Genius IS selfish - I suppose it has to be as it may exist outside of the ego. It takes two to make a baby - what about the dad? What did he do for the child??? Anyway, I love her music - I don't HAVE to love her as a person.
crimsonrush 3 months ago
pure brilliance.
yetiflicker 3 months ago
Dear h8ers. Does Picasso suck because he cheated on his wives? Does Jefferson suck because he had slaves? Do the Spanish suck for killing indigenous people with small pox? Do we trash art in the hopes of self righteous logic? I hope never! Art is what we feel despite the workings of the thought police and do-gooders. If your God teaches you benevolency and tolerance then by God practice it. Proselytize elsewhere please.
jaluman 3 months ago
To those of you who are so terribly critical of Joni's decisions..it is cruel to judge something you know nothing about..just listen to her lyrics, her soul. She has suffered enough. So stop now.
redone2422 3 months ago
I do not want to see clueless judgments. The term clueless is used because I do not like witless Bible preaches. Now, music is a many facets gem. You may know the crown view of a diamond but there are many more complex cuts of beauty. In thirty or more years I haven't heard such a rare combination as Joni Mitchell. I really enjoy it. Remember If you can heal as many minds and souls in time of judgment day -you just got lucky.
MegaWildswan 3 months ago
Te amo para siempre y por todos los tiempos, Joni !
RicOshayed1 4 months ago
My name is Marcelo'm the world's southernmost country, where, after the Andes is only a long narrow strip of land. No matter how powerful creation of this wonderful artist overcame all obstacles and made this up here. In Chile for 24 years now, the incredible music of Joni Mitchell, makes me fly to distant landscapes of Canada, or walk down the streets of his adopted California. Joni, represents for me a priceless gift that life has given me.
felinorampante8 4 months ago
@felinorampante8 - Yes, she "overcame" obstacles. However,
If you would just get up off your knees and quit groveling at the
feet of a celebrity you might want to consider that life is hard for
EVERYONE. Joni does not have a monopoly on suffering.
Personally, I find abandoning a daughter to pursue a singing
career to be nothing less than abandonment. Of course, you
can always come back later and spin a noble story. Which she
did. I have no doubts she cries. All the way to the bank.
thegrinchl7 4 months ago
@thegrinchl7 Maybe at that time you might just have walked a mile in her shoes. You might have done the same believing it would have been the best of alternatives for "Greens sake". Are there any dicisions you have regrets about looking back down the road of your past?
TheSteveNSac 4 months ago
@TheSteveNSac - I have many regrets but none about my children.
They have always been my compus. They are a litmus test for all that
is important. While I might lie, cheat or steal for myself...I hesitate,
pause and reflect when I think of them. "What is the right thing to do"
is always asked with them in mind. ABANDONING them for a singing
career would be the height of vanity and cruelty. Cruelty not only to
them but to myself. If I saw Joni in a cafe I would spit on her. She's no
hero.
thegrinchl7 4 months ago
@thegrinchl7 don't be a grinch
MegaWildswan 3 months ago
@MegaWildswan - I will quit being so nasty if her fans quit trying to make this woman into a living SAINT. We all know she's a coward for abandoning her child. Never mind her bizarre voice.
thegrinchl7 3 months ago
@thegrinchl7 Wow, you need help buddy! We all make choices some good and some bad! If memory serves me right Joni left her kid due to several circumstances and has now reunited. Im not anyone nor are you to judge her for that. She made amends with her daughter. But for some reason you seem to be very angry over something that is not a part of your life
mrfrogbutt1 3 months ago
@mrfrogbutt1 - What you would never tolerate in a
friend you tolerate in a celebrity is typical idol worship.
It seems to me suspicious that you would foist undue
PRAISE on a ethically challenged woman as it is for
someone to exhibit anger over her past life. You'll have
to excuse me, I do not genuflect at the altar of any celebrity,
least of all someone like the musical has-been Joni Mitchell.
How a celebrity behaves in their private life matters. Just
ask O.J. Simpson.
thegrinchl7 3 months ago
@thegrinchl7 I don't pass judgement on my friends. At 38 life has changed for me and the more fingers I point at people the more that point out to me in return. My mother gave away one of my siblings and this year she found us. I am no one to judge my mother's actions however, I am beyond happy to have found a very beautiful sister. God, is good and I have seen it. I have no idea how you can compare Joni to OJ? And, no Joni ISN'T a has been.
mrfrogbutt1 3 months ago
@mrfrogbutt1 - Wow! Your post is just one cliche
after another....with the "one finger pointing, always
have three pointing back at you" routine! "God is
good" unless you're one of the 200,000 men, women
and children who lost their lives in South East Asia
or Japan. I did not compare Joni to OJ. I used O.J
to illustrate the idea that what a celebrity does in
their private life MATTERS. Joni Mitchell abandoned
her daughter for a singing career. THIS WAS A
VANITY BASED DECISION.
thegrinchl7 3 months ago
@thegrinchl7 Damn, my apologies really! To think that you would dismiss my story as a "cliche" is just a FUCKING insult! I guess having any discussion with you about anything pertaining to REAL LIFE is out of the question! You're the type who wants their cake and eat it too! I'm glad I'm not like that and I thank God that at my age I have survived many things enough to know that "life" is complex and difficult and NOT an easy road with easy answers. Take care and good luck being sad.
mrfrogbutt1 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@mrfrogbutt1 - There you go again! "you want your cake and eat it too"? My god, don't you have any original thoughts or sentences?
thegrinchl7 3 months ago
... all hail Joni Mitchell ... and the late Steve Jobs. Visionaries help make this world a more interesting and pleasant place in which to live.
art101tv 5 months ago
What nonsense is talked about her voice. This performance is awesome, and the aging of the voice is intrinsic to the lyrics. What on earth do you critics think this song is all about FFS?
What a tragedy that the shallow greed of the music and entertainment business has blinded so many people to true genius.
There isn't another artist of the last 50 years that has this woman's talent.
ricadia 5 months ago 5
@ricadia - Joni is compensated quite well for what she does. She
has your money...and in case you haven't noticed, she's not asking
for anything else. Joni's, ahem...UNUSUAL voice and all-over-the-map
vibrato rubs many the wrong way. It always has. It's not just the industry
that sometimes tires of her. As for criticism, I'll tell you what: I WILL
STOP "CRITICIZING" JONI MITCHELL IF YOU QUIT TRYING TO
TURN INTO AN EVER SUFFERING SAINT! Geez! The 60s are over!
Move on!
thegrinchl7 4 months ago
joni, joni...i love you...
themar22 5 months ago 2
My favorite video and rendition of this song. :):):)
tall32guy 6 months ago
that's the first live rendition of this song I've seen. I love it! I kinda like what's happened to her voice, it's different, more limited so what! She conquered the higher registers, now it's time for something different. Without the husk in her voice, I would have never discovered Joni. It was the Love actually version of both sides now which introduced me to her awesomeness! And how can I forget hejira, my favourite Joni number, even that's far from her earlier angelic voice, but I love it.
kbkushalutube 7 months ago
I love Joni as much as anyone, but her voice is going and that's the end of that.
MonacoBlast 7 months ago
@MonacoBlast Yep, I guess you're the final word on that, eh?
unclebobunclebob 5 months ago
@unclebobunclebob We all deal with grief in our own way.
MonacoBlast 5 months ago
@MonacoBlast how can you think that you don't understand I'll give you a 70's fact I'ts out of your understanding music and voice
MegaWildswan 3 months ago
Love you, Joni, but Larry Klein was from Newark (anag). I don't believe anyone has ever made a woman's thoughts understandable to mere males. Really, really hope you've found happiness.
pundit19 7 months ago
oh my gosh, she does just fu*k my soul!
rochelenz1 9 months ago
Good song good voice!
SuperKarakis 9 months ago
This song is about Saskatoon Saskatchewan, Joni's hometown. Singing about her roots...she is brilliant
123pinecone 9 months ago
@123pinecone All Joni's early material was about herself and her friends. Checked out her first 3 releases? If not, do. They're killers!
gordbard52 6 months ago
Perfect.
davidsurn1 9 months ago 12
Joni is dressed to the nines. She has so many talents, so many positive
features. Songbird.
spoildn8410 10 months ago
that's Larry Klein on bass , not Berlin.... Landau on guitar and Vinnie on drums. If you like this pick up refuge of the roads dvd.
5four 10 months ago
jeff berlin + joni mitchell is one of the best tings this world had seen.
SunCMF 10 months ago
this isn't just a song, it's a poem
misskoool 10 months ago
wow, i've never heard this song, and it's simply fantastic
misskoool 10 months ago
I think this album came out around 1984. Exceptional song, beautifully written. Another example of how much commercial music has deteriorated over the past few decades...
Mas122862 1 year ago
Comment removed
spoildn8410 1 year ago
OK. So if Joni Mitchell was in a competition with fellow Canadian Celine Dion, who would come out as most talented song writer, musician, singer, artist, etc etc etc?
hoof2001 1 year ago
@hoof2001 Joni blazed a trail for so many artists; she writes more than songs, her lyrics are magical and poetic. Her songs are a beacon for anyone who has felt the odd one out (man or woman). At such a young age she was able to nail big issues like love, loss, artifice, innocence. Celine didn't even write her big, fat, but at the end of the day, ordinary, commercial hit. I would never put these two in the same league.
almondgrrl 10 months ago 24
@almondgrrl Absolutely. The post was meant in the sense of irony/mischief. But you are spot on right!
hoof2001 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@almondgrrl пиз*ец это а не музыка!!!!!!!
fucking music!!!!!!!!!!
EnnnJey 1 month ago
Saw Joni with Larry in Edinburgh on this tour around 82/3.Sat 10 feet in front of her and was MESMERISED
solobolo1 1 year ago
Joni looks extra beautiful here. And this is a deep song, so cool!
TK549 1 year ago
Thanks for posting, remember this on a video tape of The Old Grey Whistle Test and whilst I was still a teenager (just) was stunned, fantastic performance
synthjack1 1 year ago
makes me wonder if these musicians were aware at the time of how classic this music would be--its just damn good ------thanks for posting
jrmrinaz 1 year ago
Simply the best female songwriter in the world! And with Neil they're the best ones ever!
riccardino82 1 year ago
god i love her musics R I P.. FOR EVER YOUR MY IDOL
chenchneerr 1 year ago
@chenchneerr She isn't dead.
banner74 1 year ago
@chenchneerr R I P??? She isn't dead!
djbethell 1 year ago
@chenchneerr She isn't dead. I think you've been folllowing the wrong person. Buttmunch.
jmiller05 1 year ago
Joni Mitchell speaks from my heart,
simplyDiann 1 year ago
love it. beautiful voice singing beautiful words
oscatable 1 year ago
She is amazing singer ..love all her songs..
suzuko817 1 year ago
Actually, she released this song in 1982 on the Wild Things Run Fast Album though not sure when it was written, though presumably around that time. I recall repeatedly watching this exact piece on a video tape of The Old Grey Whistle Test's review of the year in 1982/1983! What I was doing obsessing about a song about midddle age when I was 16, I just don't know. I love the contemplative mood of this song and the tinge of regret. Fantastic! Thanks for posting.
andyd66 1 year ago
she released this in the early 70's, probably 1973 or 74. It's a combination of her own story of having to put her daughter up for adoption because she became a pop star in the late 60's and knew she would never be around to be a good mom. Obviously, half the song is from the original song "unchained melody' from the 50's.
tjkeasyboy 1 year ago
Please tell us when she wrote and released this tune.
durgaaa 1 year ago
a simply magical performance.
5four 1 year ago
@jmiller05 over her carrer joni has had truly wonderful journey, i love the fack that she dose what she wants when she wants. She often changed her style and didnt give care in the world whats the press thought. She writes the most deepful meanful lyrics i have ever heard and i turly love her work and especially the geffen albums " Night Ride Home " and " Wild thing run fast" being my favorites. Songs Like "Love" using the biblical context are amazing , Ethiopia from dog eat dog, love it all
ejrocks01 1 year ago
Joni in her forties and returning to what she had become famous for. Her previous album MINGUS had been misunderstood and largely slated ( although she never sang better) All of a sudden, the high register has gone and this song is easily the best thing she did throughout the eighties. Not until TURBULENT INDIGO (1994) did her genius return and by then, not many people were listening - a real shame, since it's up there with BLUE and HEJIRA.
3373157 1 year ago
@3373157 I'm always slightly conflicted about her eighties stuff.
The music was indeed still 'hers', but i felt the Geffen years really inhibited her true creative craftmanship. Too much emphasis on production, rather than the true portrayals and characters, themes and messages in her music. After all, what is Joni Mitchell if not a companion to the listener.
If you feel what Joni feels, then the work is immediately more gratifying.
jmiller05 1 year ago
@3373157 i dono night riide home hadf its hits , come in from the cold
ejrocks01 1 year ago
Comment removed
3373157 1 year ago