I know, I agree with you, Mr Slithering. There are a few songs on the record where they seem to willfully sabotage the emotional power of a song. Perhaps, in their view, to save it from a kind of generic, immediate, radio catchiness. I'm disappointed, for instance, with the funal version of Nude. I've heard versions, ten years older, that were far more affecting.
Why Radiohead didn't record Phil's drums in the robust, powerful way they sound on this live version, I'll never know. And why they added the extra section immediately after "weird fishes" on the LP, when the old transition her use to be so much more powerful? I'll never understand. They took a song with A+ potential in the studio, sapped it of it's urgency, and came out with a B recording...frustrating :(
Last night I downloaded the songs from their site and paid US$6... Great that MOST of that money goes directly to them and not to the the record company, as it happens with CDs.
also radiohead songs change all the time, so you've no idea what version will be on the album. I think Johnny would not have wasted his days of work writing out the scores that the orchestra used. Like spinning plates went through many stages, and it is always played live using a piano not a synthesiser like on the record.
It could have quite easily have changed, radiohead change their lyrics all the time, theres only a small handful of radiohead songs where every lyric points to the same meaning, optimistic is one I think. It could have started off we're fishes and changed, who knows, they both sound so similar, and radiohead make songs mainly for the sound, not the lyrics.
well thats my opinion anyway if you wanted it or not.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Marcyska12345, Bales14, and ClarenceMargundo96,
Now that it's been proven to be "weird fishes", like we've been telling all of you for 6 months, please wipe the pie off your face, put your tail between your legs, shut the FUCK up about stuff you are too unintelligent to deduce, and ask yourself why you're so inaccurate and wrong about stuff all the time. People like you are why we're in Iraq, you overconfident, unintelligent fucks.
This is by far my favorite of the new tracks. And from what I've heard of the recorded studio snippet they put on the website, this will be my new favorite radiohead track.
Comalilies, I think it's close...the Ether Version is intended to bring to the forefront just how disparate the melodies are in the piece, doubling their beauty. Yet, Phil's drumming in this version makes the song so propulsive, as to appreciate the "weird fishes" break more, and makes the outro fucking explosive. So close.
What's with this new rumor on all the Spin and NME sites that on the song "4 Minute Warning" studio version is going to feature guest vocals by American country-bluegrass star Gillian Welch?...must be coming out of New York's media market since the album is being mastered there?
p.s.- to be honest i didn't know much about her but the rumor made me listen to some of her stuff...in retrospect, I can hear how it's really an appalachian hymnal structure i.e. Allison Kraus' "Scarlet Tide.
yeah, they're all wrong, even AtEase and greenplastic.
it's definitely "weird fishes".
you can make a thread on the message board either at AtEase or greenplastic and ask, if you really need some sort of proof, heh. prepare to be yelled at and called a n00b though
it's 'little fishes'. he doesn't pronounce vowels. and i hope very much, that they don't record this song with this drum beat, or any drums at all for that matter.
the lyric was scrolling across one of scrapbook pages on the official site (i don't know if it's still there). except it was misspelled (how very Thom Yorke)..."wierd fishees", if i remember correctly.
just a side note, i'm not being a stubborn asshat for no reason, i'm always open to discussion, but here there's nothing to discuss. i don't just <i>think</i> it's "weird fishes", i <i>KNOW</i> it's "weird fishes". ok i'm done.
everything about this is great. except for eds backing vocals are a little flat. he has a great voice but somtimes he just doesnt sing in tune with thom...
This song sounds so beautiful - the twin guitars are like harps, eds backing works nicely, thoms voice is, as ususal, great, it has wonderful momentum, and it just has the soul, and pathos you expect from a good radiohead song. Its very urgent and open. Lovely.
For something just as raw and wonderful, look up the clip of Thom on the 'Henry Rollins show' performing an acoustic version of 'clock' - its better than the album version, and a real stand out!!
And EVERYONE needs to check out Ether Festival 2005 Arpeggi. Its even better than this version. I'm afraid the studio versions won't be good as these live ones, so afraid. Radiohead are so good live.
This is a very elaborate song. Reminds me of Let Down, but faster. Phil Specter, thick, convoluted music. A wall of sound. I also think Down Is The New Up is one of the best Radiohead songs I've ever heard, and I KNOW Radiohead. Spooks and 15 Step are dope too. This albums gonna kick ass. Now all we need is Radiohead to fuckin give a release date atleast. The buggers have been denying us far too long now.
Can't hope more that they make this a single, this song alone on an album that is shaping up to top Kid A and OK Computer should give them the mainstream success they deserve, even though they don't want it I just wish I could hear stuff like this everytime I put the radio on than listen to half the shit thats out at the moment, don't make us wait longer!!!
I think that what turns radiohead in such a brilliant band is the fact that they can get much deeper that anyone else doing music nowadays... simply beautiful.
I can't love to see all the comments and just nod in agreement...RADIOHEAD is the BEST band out there NO DISCUSSION (who competes? Yeah Strokes are fun but not nearly as complex or varied)
stuff like Bangers, Open Pick and Bodysnatchers is not that chill- we really don't know exactly what direction the new record will be and that's one reason why they are a great band
no, what i meant wasent chill as in the formal way...but in the ideas...compared with hail to the thief where there was a lot of political stuff, the new song sounds more like...music for the music...its like a fresh restart...lets hope
Thanks for the comment, I have a bunch of other videos I haven't gotten around to posting so keep an eye out....This video is amazing though, you must have been really close.
Not a bad song. I really don't understand why it's one of the most popular of the new songs though. I find it a bit dull. Good, but not as exciting as some of the other new songs.
Never though I would like the full band version as much as the original but OMG! I could hardly see a thing all night at Wolves so thank you for this....The footage is great. Not surprised its jumpy with people knocking around everywhere!!!!
still a great live version
getting2 3 years ago 4
I always liked that outro MUCH more than what they went with in the end. The studio transition kind of jars...but I reckon that was the intent.
Vincecouk 3 years ago 4
wanted to go to this gig so bad,looks fuckin amazin!
431972 4 years ago 4
Live is so much better..
xGhostoftheRiverx 4 years ago 5
wow nice seats
SKETCHbomb30 4 years ago
best song on in rainbows, best of a great bunch, superb stuff!!
kev22990 4 years ago 3
I love the way he sings "weird fishes" here.
BlizzardOfThyDoom 4 years ago 3
I agree as well but can you imagine what a bitch it must have been laying that song down in a recording.
JimB667 4 years ago
I know, I agree with you, Mr Slithering. There are a few songs on the record where they seem to willfully sabotage the emotional power of a song. Perhaps, in their view, to save it from a kind of generic, immediate, radio catchiness. I'm disappointed, for instance, with the funal version of Nude. I've heard versions, ten years older, that were far more affecting.
smoocher6 4 years ago
Why Radiohead didn't record Phil's drums in the robust, powerful way they sound on this live version, I'll never know. And why they added the extra section immediately after "weird fishes" on the LP, when the old transition her use to be so much more powerful? I'll never understand. They took a song with A+ potential in the studio, sapped it of it's urgency, and came out with a B recording...frustrating :(
slitheringinterstate 4 years ago 2
You're so right.
xemy101 4 years ago 2
This band has such great energy
leftynk 4 years ago
Postminimal, I couldn't help but notice despite your criticism that your YouTube website is a Radioehead shrine. Good prank bud.
p.s.- and yes, you're right... "In Limbo" and "Fasttrack" are very "soccermom" and "yuppie" lol. Good one.
slitheringinterstate 4 years ago
rocks!!!
lilrosa89 4 years ago
such a good song, though i wish they'd kept the name to just arpeggi. weird fishes/arpeggi doesnt sound as good
opensourcethong 4 years ago
'spose you could call it either one though?
WeirdAndGeeky 4 years ago
i love that drumming
debutrans 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
music for moms and yuppies...
postminimal 4 years ago
AMAZING, can't wait til IN RAINBOWS!!!!
free!!!!!!
fakechic 4 years ago
Thumbs down because of the Free!! part.
Last night I downloaded the songs from their site and paid US$6... Great that MOST of that money goes directly to them and not to the the record company, as it happens with CDs.
Ingenierotop69 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
my mom would like this....
postminimal 4 years ago
At 1:10 Jonny's guitar is so amazing.
It looks like he is posing for the camera.
simonpra 4 years ago
The drums really do it.
MeshGearFox 4 years ago
also radiohead songs change all the time, so you've no idea what version will be on the album. I think Johnny would not have wasted his days of work writing out the scores that the orchestra used. Like spinning plates went through many stages, and it is always played live using a piano not a synthesiser like on the record.
Fynch101 4 years ago
like spinning plates is 'i will' played on the piano backwards and then reversed i believe
Iplayajazzmaster 4 years ago
It's not a synth on the album :P:P:P It's a backward clicking sound
RVLVNGDRS 4 years ago
wow you intrigue me as to how you know?
Fynch101 4 years ago
I believe you could check that out yourself by simply reversing LSP and listening to the result. :)
RVLVNGDRS 4 years ago
actually Iplayajazzmaster is only half right...there's no reversed piano in the recorded version.. those are all reversed synths.
you can hear it for yourself, just search for "like spinning plates reversed" here on youtube.
Mearann 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
that is not how it was done.
DannyTen985 3 years ago
How was it done?
Vincecouk 3 years ago 4
It could have quite easily have changed, radiohead change their lyrics all the time, theres only a small handful of radiohead songs where every lyric points to the same meaning, optimistic is one I think. It could have started off we're fishes and changed, who knows, they both sound so similar, and radiohead make songs mainly for the sound, not the lyrics.
well thats my opinion anyway if you wanted it or not.
Fynch101 4 years ago
calm down retard christ so we were wrong get over it
Bales14 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Marcyska12345, Bales14, and ClarenceMargundo96,
Now that it's been proven to be "weird fishes", like we've been telling all of you for 6 months, please wipe the pie off your face, put your tail between your legs, shut the FUCK up about stuff you are too unintelligent to deduce, and ask yourself why you're so inaccurate and wrong about stuff all the time. People like you are why we're in Iraq, you overconfident, unintelligent fucks.
slitheringinterstate 4 years ago
Can't Wait for the 10th!!!!!!! I was lucky enough to see them 3times during their last tour and ever since i've been anticipating this day!!!!
jetatan2001 4 years ago
album's available for download on october 10th. check radiohead's website
boyep2 4 years ago 5
aaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh i cant wait for the album<3
aestivazomer 4 years ago
much passion!!! i love it, tto pretty
TEZCA13 4 years ago
oh man! OH MAN! thats AWESOME!
BoyOnAString7 4 years ago
will this version be on the next album ? or the first one ?
clarencemargondu96 4 years ago
this one
rukus24 4 years ago
its one of their best songs!
TEZCA13 4 years ago 2
Great music!
jadeevalley 4 years ago
This is by far my favorite of the new tracks. And from what I've heard of the recorded studio snippet they put on the website, this will be my new favorite radiohead track.
Decept 4 years ago
Nah you didnt xD. but i get the jist of it man =)
Bales14 4 years ago
Comalilies, I think it's close...the Ether Version is intended to bring to the forefront just how disparate the melodies are in the piece, doubling their beauty. Yet, Phil's drumming in this version makes the song so propulsive, as to appreciate the "weird fishes" break more, and makes the outro fucking explosive. So close.
slitheringinterstate 4 years ago
I agree that this song sounds better with orcastra nd no drums
but its sounds great this way as well
Radiohead5510 4 years ago
I like both versions about equally, I'm glad this is the one on the album though
sometimesphylan 4 years ago
no what the fuck? this version is so much better....what the fuck?! Besides, this is the version that they are putting on the album anyway.
deluca1 4 years ago
y'all are with me abouth this song being a million times better with the orchestra and no drums right?
thecomalilies 4 years ago
i like both versions, but i prefer it with the drums and guitars more.
ServerNotFound 4 years ago
ok, did i make sense there? don't think so... i'm kind of tired right now.
try again... i like both versions, but i prefer the one with the drums and guitars.
ServerNotFound 4 years ago
What's with this new rumor on all the Spin and NME sites that on the song "4 Minute Warning" studio version is going to feature guest vocals by American country-bluegrass star Gillian Welch?...must be coming out of New York's media market since the album is being mastered there?
p.s.- to be honest i didn't know much about her but the rumor made me listen to some of her stuff...in retrospect, I can hear how it's really an appalachian hymnal structure i.e. Allison Kraus' "Scarlet Tide.
slitheringinterstate 4 years ago
yeah, they're all wrong, even AtEase and greenplastic.
it's definitely "weird fishes".
you can make a thread on the message board either at AtEase or greenplastic and ask, if you really need some sort of proof, heh. prepare to be yelled at and called a n00b though
Mozggg 4 years ago
it's 'little fishes'. he doesn't pronounce vowels. and i hope very much, that they don't record this song with this drum beat, or any drums at all for that matter.
thecomalilies 4 years ago
Look on any Arpeggi lyric site and it says We're Fishies. How can all of them be wrong
Bales14 4 years ago
"everybody leaves
if they get the chance
and this is my chance
eaten by worms" - i'm fishies :-(
marcyska12345 4 years ago
You should check out the Frames album "Burn The Maps" for a Radiohead/Coldplay/Doves-esque sound.
This is such a beautiful song. Thanks for filming and posting!
sprunkner 4 years ago
i like very much how jonny moves his head when he's playing concentrated.
matu2983 4 years ago
i'm high right now.. and this is so fucking amazing.
slicebo123 4 years ago
we fishies
Flitzman 4 years ago
fuck! Thom sings - we're fishies!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
marcyska12345 4 years ago
no :p
weird fishes
the lyric was scrolling across one of scrapbook pages on the official site (i don't know if it's still there). except it was misspelled (how very Thom Yorke)..."wierd fishees", if i remember correctly.
BitterrPill 4 years ago
... Just look at Green Plastic for the lyrics, it says We're fishies.
Bales14 4 years ago
Green Plastic has been wrong about different things many a time.
it's "weird fishes", trust me...or don't. i don't care either way.
BitterrPill 4 years ago
Just think about it. from the other versuses in the song. Dont you reckon we're fishes makes more sense
Bales14 4 years ago
it's "WEIRD FISHES" believe it or not. this is getting ridiculous.
BitterrPill 4 years ago
just a side note, i'm not being a stubborn asshat for no reason, i'm always open to discussion, but here there's nothing to discuss. i don't just <i>think</i> it's "weird fishes", i <i>KNOW</i> it's "weird fishes". ok i'm done.
BitterrPill 4 years ago
no you're wrong it's "we're fishes"
clarencemargondu96 4 years ago
'weird fishes' is what appears on radiohead . com and it's clearly exactly what he sings.
rukus24 4 years ago
weird fishes. fact! lol
shero66 4 years ago
who me...no nothing =)
pinkfloyd5422 4 years ago
its with fishies
Radiohead5510 4 years ago
pretty sure it's "weird fishies"
Mozggg 4 years ago
Ed's vocals make this song perfect for me, but i'm sure it'll be Thom on the album...I think it would be cool if Ed did it tho. rambling=)Radiohead<3
pinkfloyd5422 4 years ago
we fishies
pixel1799 4 years ago
A little Coldplayish..........
kyluv5994 4 years ago
lol u dont know shit about music do u
fabdub 4 years ago
radiohead invented coldplay. lol. so its allowed.
effteapea 4 years ago
i agree with you, almost bands like muse, travis, doves and many others get influenced by them.
matu2983 4 years ago
I AGREE TOO!
ranchoelcarajo 4 years ago
wicked to the ends of the earth!!! x
luketheleonard 4 years ago
everything about this is great. except for eds backing vocals are a little flat. he has a great voice but somtimes he just doesnt sing in tune with thom...
seapockets 4 years ago
Hmm, sounds perfectly fine to me.
FishyRishi 4 years ago
It's always a cool thing to watch Jonny bug out on the guitar.
StudioGuyMN 4 years ago
reminds me of some old pink floyd stuff and avand garde classical music
debutrans 4 years ago
probably The Best song of the new album....
matu2983 4 years ago
really good song
doctorcorn2002 4 years ago
I love this song.
yungb254 4 years ago
exelente
jmandrad 4 years ago
This song sounds so beautiful - the twin guitars are like harps, eds backing works nicely, thoms voice is, as ususal, great, it has wonderful momentum, and it just has the soul, and pathos you expect from a good radiohead song. Its very urgent and open. Lovely.
For something just as raw and wonderful, look up the clip of Thom on the 'Henry Rollins show' performing an acoustic version of 'clock' - its better than the album version, and a real stand out!!
thepeterholland 4 years ago
aww man the anticipation for the new album is killing me!
MarchPets 4 years ago
this song too good
darkworld8 4 years ago
Wow..just wow
cdw2005 4 years ago
You have had a bloody good view there!! well done!
I was there as well!!
me and my missus loved it!!
simon1975 4 years ago
They come over to my house everyday.
namedjosh26 4 years ago
And EVERYONE needs to check out Ether Festival 2005 Arpeggi. Its even better than this version. I'm afraid the studio versions won't be good as these live ones, so afraid. Radiohead are so good live.
namedjosh26 4 years ago
This is a very elaborate song. Reminds me of Let Down, but faster. Phil Specter, thick, convoluted music. A wall of sound. I also think Down Is The New Up is one of the best Radiohead songs I've ever heard, and I KNOW Radiohead. Spooks and 15 Step are dope too. This albums gonna kick ass. Now all we need is Radiohead to fuckin give a release date atleast. The buggers have been denying us far too long now.
namedjosh26 4 years ago
you don't know radiohead....
antony716 4 years ago
I agree.
DarthAres 4 years ago
Quite superb...
coxon123 4 years ago
jezus tittyfricking christ, i'd rather take a dump on my own vomit
debutrans 4 years ago
phils bits during the "we're fishes" part is amazing. really helps emphasize the delicate breakdown... sounds like glass mosaic.
slicebo123 4 years ago
first!
debutrans 4 years ago
the best song of all time?
staticsprinter 4 years ago
maybe...
ranchoelcarajo 4 years ago
Can't hope more that they make this a single, this song alone on an album that is shaping up to top Kid A and OK Computer should give them the mainstream success they deserve, even though they don't want it I just wish I could hear stuff like this everytime I put the radio on than listen to half the shit thats out at the moment, don't make us wait longer!!!
mevil314 4 years ago
This song is what makes me so excited about the new album...it isn't jus one of their best new songs.. its one of their best songs.
vman510 4 years ago
that's one of the best.
Emilianlalev 5 years ago
better with every listen
VisualFixation 5 years ago
The great thing is, their music makes you FEEL as well as listen...it's a rush.
panzageneral 5 years ago
i couldn't agree more man.
ADrollSolecism 5 years ago
soothsayer
dilloncar03 4 years ago
OH. MY. GOD.
OH.
MY.
GOD.
this video is incredible.
ADrollSolecism 5 years ago
i wish i could do that...
dave0549jv 5 years ago
02:51' is great!!!
marcyska12345 5 years ago
the song is incredible.
VisualFixation 5 years ago
I think that what turns radiohead in such a brilliant band is the fact that they can get much deeper that anyone else doing music nowadays... simply beautiful.
tsc17633 5 years ago
I can't love to see all the comments and just nod in agreement...RADIOHEAD is the BEST band out there NO DISCUSSION (who competes? Yeah Strokes are fun but not nearly as complex or varied)
tico285 5 years ago
They are so good, they make other bands just look stupid..!
jamestampere 5 years ago
I fully agree
wickedsingh 4 years ago
doesn't make sense...fuck they're brilliant.
mathfife 5 years ago
this isnt chil out, this has killer drums, and hevy emotional punch, not chill out, was at hammersmith gig, took the roof off with this trk!!
suncity22001 5 years ago
looking forward to new album 2007
joyinbl 5 years ago
thoms voice is more clear in this version i like it
slicebo123 5 years ago
lol i was there
was fuckng amazing
tommcmillan 5 years ago
My sister was at this gig (or the other date at Wolves as they did too)! Lucky!
brandybuck1984 5 years ago
wooooow. that is fucking awesome dude. were you this close?
sudajmahi 5 years ago
nice move at the end there thom hahahha
rataplan 5 years ago
god if they only could come to southamerica
delorean404 5 years ago
shit, phil always adds a perfect beat.
lazyoldsun 5 years ago
i love the end to this song its so anticlimactic
thanx for the vid!
rgautam 5 years ago
i thing this next album will be like a chill one...great album, but nothing like hail to the thief... they look more chill
Eikon07 5 years ago
stuff like Bangers, Open Pick and Bodysnatchers is not that chill- we really don't know exactly what direction the new record will be and that's one reason why they are a great band
saintheathen 5 years ago
no, what i meant wasent chill as in the formal way...but in the ideas...compared with hail to the thief where there was a lot of political stuff, the new song sounds more like...music for the music...its like a fresh restart...lets hope
Eikon07 5 years ago
Except Down is the New Up. Hahahaha. Good song, but sooo political...
This album's going to be fantastic.
minestrone11 5 years ago
good quallity for a home video
zultanaX 5 years ago
Excelente! O melhor Grupo do mundo!
Flash20 5 years ago
A fantastic link between ok computer and kid a. Awesome
Gun6Colour 5 years ago
this is brand new baby, for the new album in 2007
HystericalAndUseless 5 years ago
this song is one of the new best the other i like is videotape and 15 step
svohljott 5 years ago
de las nuevas la mejor?posiblemente!!!!
y tienen buenas, muy buenas
amutesss 5 years ago
What a incredible fuckin' song!!! Radiohead Rules!!
ranchoelcarajo 5 years ago
de puta madre, si señor
rol2 5 years ago
Good clip. This song is great.
BenjiBestFriendji 5 years ago
Thanks for the comment, I have a bunch of other videos I haven't gotten around to posting so keep an eye out....This video is amazing though, you must have been really close.
Christomaras 5 years ago
We're fishes, we're fishes.
Thom, you are the sea.
Amazing song!!
theinterlude 5 years ago
Not a bad song. I really don't understand why it's one of the most popular of the new songs though. I find it a bit dull. Good, but not as exciting as some of the other new songs.
thedude78 5 years ago
Never though I would like the full band version as much as the original but OMG! I could hardly see a thing all night at Wolves so thank you for this....The footage is great. Not surprised its jumpy with people knocking around everywhere!!!!
religionLobotomy 5 years ago
great video quality (a little jumpy, but who's complaining?)... sound's not as good as the copenhagen video; still awsome though.
GreySpot19 5 years ago