I like how she goes from the panicking mose to complete understanding to truly reminding him that she belongs to him. My favorite line is definitely, "Shut up and we'll be fine long as you're mine." She leaves the decision entirely up to him and he realizes that he doesn't have to give her up just yet.
I could never decide whether this or Inside Your Heart is better. I prefer the recording of Inside Your Heart, just because I think the vocals are a little better (Kerry Butler pwns all, and I miss the British accent XD) But musically, they're both very good. I miss the Lovely Boy verse, but this is a lot more... interesting? I like Shelly's behaviour better in this one, but, hey, the other uses the word "normaller" and that's unbeatable. I just don't know. They're both phenomenal.
What I love most about this song is how manipulative Shelley is. She's basically saying, "I know you want to leave, but I don't care. No one will accept you--I mean us. I want you and I get what I want."
FAVORITE SONG IN THE WHOLE SHOW! Sadly though I lost my copy of the London cast recording, so the only version I have is my CD copy of the Off-Broadway Cast Recording which has "Inside Your Heart" instead of "Mine, All Mine" :*( Makes me sad. But still this song is my favorite Bat Boy song.
Musically, I think this version is a lot better. I always thought Inside Your Heart sounded a little awkward. But I like that Inside Your Heart shows a bigger change in character for Shelley
I agree this song is better musically, it has a more passionate feel than "Inside Your Heart". But I think I pefer "Inside Your Heart" in context, especially because of how it fits with "Ugly Boy" (in the American version that is).
I like how she goes from the panicking mose to complete understanding to truly reminding him that she belongs to him. My favorite line is definitely, "Shut up and we'll be fine long as you're mine." She leaves the decision entirely up to him and he realizes that he doesn't have to give her up just yet.
UsagiYokoyama90 3 weeks ago
I could never decide whether this or Inside Your Heart is better. I prefer the recording of Inside Your Heart, just because I think the vocals are a little better (Kerry Butler pwns all, and I miss the British accent XD) But musically, they're both very good. I miss the Lovely Boy verse, but this is a lot more... interesting? I like Shelly's behaviour better in this one, but, hey, the other uses the word "normaller" and that's unbeatable. I just don't know. They're both phenomenal.
WeirdAndProudAboutIt 3 months ago
love how she tells him to SHUT UP!
MrShaun42088 4 months ago
looooove
SnottyPotty987 9 months ago
What I love most about this song is how manipulative Shelley is. She's basically saying, "I know you want to leave, but I don't care. No one will accept you--I mean us. I want you and I get what I want."
IJVin 1 year ago
@IJVin ...are we listening to the same song? 0.o
beautifulpassion 3 months ago
Is this Kerry Butler as Shelly? I think people who think this is a bad female vocal are nuts. Both voices are great.
emylye627 1 year ago
@emylye627 She does that vibrato thing a LOT, and many people think that's bad singing. I can't say I'm incredibly fond of it in females myself.
beautifulpassion 3 months ago
Comment removed
IJVin 1 year ago
i'm doing bat boy and i'm playing shelly but we dont get to do mine all mine and i'm really upset because i like this better than inside your heart.
fihaprincess 1 year ago
OMG DEVEN MAY I LOVE YOU TTwTT! <3
ManaYuGiOhGX5Ds 1 year ago
im inlove with BATBOY
mischangitos 1 year ago
This is so much better than "Inside Your Heart". Unfortunately in the production at my studio we did "Inside Your Heart" instead T^T
I love this one better T^T
sasunarufangirl163 1 year ago
Well, in the London version it fits with Ugly Boy's counterpart Your Freak. You know when Shelley says "He's your freak not mine."
jedimay621 1 year ago
dramatically speaking, this is a far better song than Inside your heart. Plus, it's far catchier. The only thing I miss is the "Lovely boy" verse.
SpartaPhone 2 years ago 17
i def like inside your heart so much better!
SingingFool123 2 years ago 2
who is playing bat boy?
rinna81 2 years ago
i love this song, i also like inside you heart, i do like the pun there.... =)
quecheeracer 2 years ago
This is my favorite as well :)
smashclover 2 years ago
FAVORITE SONG IN THE WHOLE SHOW! Sadly though I lost my copy of the London cast recording, so the only version I have is my CD copy of the Off-Broadway Cast Recording which has "Inside Your Heart" instead of "Mine, All Mine" :*( Makes me sad. But still this song is my favorite Bat Boy song.
CollinsLuvsAngel 2 years ago 2
You can still get the CD from Dress Circle, can't you? Have a look online - but, yeah, this is a pretty cool song!
Ken220280 2 years ago
Musically, I think this version is a lot better. I always thought Inside Your Heart sounded a little awkward. But I like that Inside Your Heart shows a bigger change in character for Shelley
MysticWaterbender3 2 years ago 2
I agree this song is better musically, it has a more passionate feel than "Inside Your Heart". But I think I pefer "Inside Your Heart" in context, especially because of how it fits with "Ugly Boy" (in the American version that is).
refugeandstrength09 2 years ago 7
wow. the chick playing Shelly has a nice voice, but she is SO wrong for Shelly. and she is not putting really any emotion into the performance. =/
TrapDoorLurker 2 years ago
im in this play at my acting school. Im shelly!
i wish i was doing this song. were only doing part one T^T Bat Boy is awesome!
sasunarufangirl163 2 years ago 2
love the song. i feel like the shelly isn't really trying though
aproby 3 years ago