Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (699)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Good advice McLovin.

  • The judge like to use the word "spank". Actually, if someone in the mafia were to use this same word, it means to KILL. He says she wasn't hurt, as if an eventual recovery of the body determines whether she was hurt or not. No care about her mind then...and no care about her mind in recent interview. This was as much an attack on her mind as anything else. Google David Sibley Corpus Christi. Will Sibley be to this case what Kevin Anett was to the United Church cabal in Canada?

  • BEAT THIS FUCKING JUDGE AGAIN AGAIN AGAIN AGAIN AGAIN.

    killt his wife and beat this asshole with the wife!!

  • Man the fuck up.

  • @Nazrat84 Shut the fuck up.

  • u cryied man we got it worse when we were kids. man these people don't know what an ass whoppin is.

  • the judge gave the little brat A MERCEDES... My dad never bought me a car, not even an used beetle volkswagen.

  • What is most disturbing about this video of the Judge beating his daughter is the fact that this is probably not an isolated incident. This probably happened daily. And God knows what else happened in that household.

  • i don't know how i haven't seen this video until now but i felt the same way when i first saw the video after phil posted it. i really hope this girl gets justice for the abuse she has suffered. <3

  • a degenerate sadist

  • OMG 

  • i my self am a mother and never in my wildest dreams imagine ever doing anything like that to my daughter..... that is a beating especially using a belt as a man in law shouldn know better than to do that what an a** let someone do to him like he did to his daughter

  • this conversation has turned pretty pointless. logical truth seeking people vs stubborn ignorant morons who can't evolve past whatever their parents told them to think.the debate on spanking is over on people, do a google search. save your opinions for issues that are debatable and stop spewing the things your parents engrained in you.

  • @SalivaX13 If you did some research, you would have found out that this girl did get bruised after this beating and belittling a form of abuse in in no way correct. I was spanked as a kid and so I know the difference. My punishments were never like this. It's great to post another video and everything, but when does all this bullshit stop? Instead of being completely unsympathetic to an abused girl because she "wasn't beaten hard enough," how about we try to stop this bullshit once and for all?

  • i cried ovr that to

  • @siddalee2008 It's truly amazing how many people never got a whooping.

  • who is the retarded who clicked dislike? he is really true!

  • i heard of it in cnn radio news. this is aweful

  • this is as funny as chris crocker.

  • This woman, 23-years old Hillary Adams, said on April 15/ 09 on her blog on DIGIBUCKET LIVEJOURNAL, under the username "shoe of all cosmos" that her father was her "HERO" for risking his life to save a neighbor's house from fire. She was 21 years old when she said that. She was living on her own, nobody forced her to write that.

    This same woman two years later, demonized her father by posting an old video after he refused to meet her financial demands in late 2011.

    Interesting, isn't it?

  • @Meoveragain15 I'd be borderline insane too if I'd been viciously beaten as a child.

  • @Meoveragain15 If she demanded money or did anything illegal , it does not change what he did. That would just mean both of them were in the wrong and abuse victims do have problems that take them to moral grey areas. Monkey see monkey do. I think its retarded you have such a hard on for authority that your willing to go to bat for someone that has done something like this. maybe you just see a little of yourself in this person? Ether way I fundamentally hate you as a person. ;)

  • @Meoveragain15 It does not matter her 'motives' for releasing the video. The judge is just doing what ALL abusers do, and this is trying to shift the blame on the victim instead of take responsibility for HIS actions. The video is clear, he cannot deny it was him. He cannot deny it was abuse. So he tries to take the focus off the real problem, and blame his daughter. People like you buy into it, which is why people like him do it.

  • @siddalee2008 Great comment siddalee2008. Isn't amazing how many people are on here telling us she wasn't abused? They are psychologically damaged themselves imo, to react that way. Must have been beaten by their own so called 'parents', and like many a victim, they have to make out their own abuse wasn't really all that bad. Either that or they're just stupid kids. Or just plain STOOPID.

  • @mmartini50 Thank you.

  • This is not child abuse. No where close

  • @iOctoberRain Are you fucking serious? How can you possibly say that you ignorant fuck, that video was so disturbing to watch cause out of pure abuse her dad was giving her.

  • @iOctoberRain I seriously hope you do not have an children.

  • It's just shocking to see that a judge who deals with child abuse cases,is doing something that he is usually doing cases of! she did not deserve this punishment for downloading a stupid computer game!

  • I subscribed because not only do you have such passion in your videos but you are a very emotional person and seem so genuine with your emotions!

  • watching hillary adam video make me come closer towards my parents, and make me feel at least my parents are better than other parents. i hope hillary will take her full rights and she will have bright future. i hope that i will be a good mother in future :)

  • "The reason you are a parent is to love your child"

    Thank you for that statement! I was beginning to think I'm the only one who sees it that way.

    Watching the abuse video had memories coming back to me from what I had to endure as a child. I'm tired of people saying spanking is ok. I think it opens the door to all kinds of abuse and the children getting no help. The idea of inflicting pain on your child to make it comply is sickening to me.

  • This kind of beating is not for discipline. This kind of beating is only for having fun with violence by using discipline as an excuse. The whole earth is filled with criminals like this man. One day the child puts his shoes in the wrong place-excuse for barbaric beating. Another day the child plays computer game instead of studying-excuse for barbaric beating. Another day the child forget to do some cleaning-excuse for barbaric beating. Men like this always have excuses for their crimes.

  • Your commentary is wonderful. Its nice to see how passionate your emotional response was. And i agree with everything you say. That judge should go to jail. What a terrible man - i cried too.

  • They are several things out-of-order on this video.I know that small children get beaten routinely, b/c their parents don't know what else to do.But a 16y/o? It suggests something else.

  • Comment removed

  • your dad needs someone to passion of the christ shit on his ass & your mom should be put in a replica stockade from England's army in the 19th century stripped naked & flogged 250 times while the crowd jeers & throws things at her. IDGAF that you say your mom wasnt responsible due to "emotional abuse" SHE is an abuser! That BITCH must have stockholm syndrome and some cruel fetishes. To hell with BOTH of them!! Its good that you forgave her but DONT MAKE EXCUSES FOR THAT CUNT! TBC...

  • I remember I used to get beat like that but by my mother....it's not good :/ leaves traumas and insecurities that you have to deal with them afterwards with profesional help wich I have not done yet but I made my point :/

  • Seldom have I felt so sickened by something like this. Discipline in the home and schools is important, but this was not disciplining. This was an act of savagery. This man deserves to be, and indeed should be, sent to prison.

    You would think a judge is smart, but obviously not. Did it not occur to him (or his wife) just to remove the computer from her room?

  • u are so sensitive,how the hell so sensitive ppl can survive in this world?Get a girl and stroke her hair to relax ,etc.I am ten times more shocked to c male crying on youtube video then to c this child abuse video.

  • Hi..i am English and i watched that video when an American friend of mine posted it...it made me feel physically sick and i cried all the way through it. That Judge is nothing but a sadistic monster who not only physically abused his disabled daughter, but psychologically abused her too! Thank you for your response, the world would be a better place if more people had your kind and caring nature..my heart broke for her..and for you, when i saw you cry, flinching at every lick...bless u..xoxo

  • Zs

  • Few Cartel Killers would just head up to this assholes' home and torutrue his ass to death Make sure this video aired in Mexico need those Maniacs to take care of business in USA cause they surely do not fear POLICE seen enough of them KILL them in TEXAS so go for it Sinaloa show the people of USA HOW F###ed up and perverted USA is .

  • @ thefiniteknowable Definitely savage abuse, my heart just broke for this girl. :-( I know she is a grown woman now but I'm sure this is not easy for her to deal with even now. I just cannot for the life of me understand the ignorant things ppl are writing on these threads. It upsets me a lot... :-( Both parents are in that room standing there w/belts in their hands just coming @ her. Not only physical abuse but verbal abuse. It's awful & really hard to watch...

  • Ben, I have never heard of your channel before but I am subscribing. Thank you for advocating for this girl. I know that spreading the video won't undo her beating but it shows the misery, pain and terror that comes with being the recipient of this kind of shit. I hope that her mom and dad get a dose of their own medicine. I really, really do.

    And finally, thanks for leaving your reaction unedited and I totally understand how you feel. It's hard to watch this and not be able to stop it.

  • That mother should have had him thrown in jail too...That's your child, you are supposed to protect your children...What a monster & he is a family/juvenile judge??? SCARY! I give that girl all the credit in the world for exposing this poor excuse for a human being/father. DISGUSTING!!!

  • Even more disturbing than this video are the comments I'm seeing on many of the uploaded videos of this. My head hurts from reading some of the ignorant & hurtful posts. Sick to my stomach that we live in a society where anyone would think this is ok or even write jokes about it. There should be a delete button for all the nasty disgusting responses I have read on multiple pg's. This guy abused her, FACT! If you see it any other way, something is wrong w/your wiring. Or you are just ignorant! :(

  • The video made me physically sick, and I could not bear to watch more than a couple minutes of it. ANYONE who fucking condones that kind of treatment should try and go through what she did. Ask your friend to beat you with a belt, THEN say its a fair treatment.

  • @zg76 90% of parent's inflict pain? Where do you get that number from?

    I'm a parent of two young kids. This parent was clearly abusive. The reason you would punish a child is to teach them that what they did is wrong. Beating with a belt is not an acceptable method.

    I've been pissed off by my kids before, but the difference is to walk away, get a hold of your emotions, calm down, assess the behavior and act on the assessment, not your emotions.

  • I was both spanked and abused and there is a massive difference. Anyone who thinks this is a "spanking" is way off base. This is beating. This is not punishment, it is an attack. He is angry and not in control. You do not punish your child when you are angry, you do not react out of anger, to do so is abuse. He enjoyed beating her, he wanted to do it, he probably looked forward to the opportunity to assert himself. He is not a disciplinary figure for her or an example for any of us but a lord.

  • @thefiniteknowable i know right? he should have been fired and put in prison obviously.

  • @thefiniteknowable THAT WAS NOT A BEATING! a beating is bruises busted lips and marks. i was punched bit and spit on as a kid but this video of this judge is the ultimate definition of something called CORPORAL PUNISHMENT.... Just because the cute little American pie white girl is going for an Oscar nod and the father is using foul language doesn't mean she was ABUSED. SHE'S FINE! Where were all of you when /watch?v=zrCuqvlKJ2E this shit happened? probably saying he deserved it huh?

  • @thefiniteknowable bull shit

  • @thefiniteknowable He wasn't angry, he was getting off to it sexually. When it was all over he came back to do it again and whispered insults into her ear.

  • @thefiniteknowable You're right.

  • It is a beating, and the father even called it that in the video. He said "Get on your stomach or I am going to start BEATING you again. I am going to BEAT you into submission." All that for downloading a game. It isn't like she pushed her brother out a second floor window or burned down the school...which is the kind of punishment the psycho father is giving her.

  • Comment removed

  • If ur parents would have beat ur ass you may have turned out straight and a man. Dude only girls cry over spilled milk.

  • Obviously chokes on dick when not leeching off the popularity of viral videos

  • blah...blah...blah, I was raised without an internet. My parents spanked me when I did things that could potentially harm me.  They also spanked me when I was rude to them or others. They would have beaten the crap out of me IF I had ever broken internet laws repeatededly. Clearly they spanked me alot...I don't own a Mercedes and nor have I been in jail/prison. I also don't hold my parents hostage when I don't get what I want.

    D

  • @zg76 because that kinda beating does more damage than good to a kid.. and some kids are not lucky and those beatings leave life marks....

    its like torture. IT WORKS. you get the information, but at what price?

    same here.... it works. the kid will obey, but at what price? you can clearly see that the parent was full of rage, and hitting her whit rage. that's not education, that's a way for him to feel better.. and that's far from good... there are more electives way to punish.

  • FAG

  • it's nothing to what my father do to me lol XDDD it's something normal dude (if course when i do something wrong )

    so we need more beats to make us good

  • I experienced the same type of abuse when I was a little boy.......over and over......and over again.

  • Cut that judge's nuts off: he doesn't deserve better !

  • I'm an Asian, grew up with only one recollection of child beating, lived vigorously through the internet and gathered a lot of my reasoning and maturity through the internet. You see misguided people, you may be right that kids won't necessarily learn by talking since they hit puberty and can't grasp basic concepts, but child abuse is only going to help the child in the decision to neglect the parents. When they grow old, they can't hit the children anymore. Then what? The hate swells up.

  • Thank you so much for making this video. Just to let you know, the fridge was hardly audible.

  • Nothing wrong with crying while watching that piece of shit judge. I feel so sorry for the poor daughter. I hope he pays for what he did.

  • Shiiiiiit youre crying, wtf man.

  • Are you crying in your reaction video there? I'm not laughing or anything I'm just asking is all.

  • Well what would YOU do if you were in his shoes? How would YOU have disciplined her for that and for not doing as told when they were told to lean over the bed and refused? What would YOU do if you were in the situation?

  • @MBlackford409 I wouldn't tell my child to lean over the bed in the first place. In this situation the problem was with a computer program. So I would remove the computer and only allow her to use the computer when being supervised until she could earn back my trust.

    Look nothing wrong with a few swats on the ass, but wiping your child that many times and seemingly getting off on it while doing so is going a bit overboard in my opinion.

    Though this guys reaction is overdramatic.

  • @zippy476 I agree with the first paragraph of your comment. As for the second paragraph of your comment...I could not hope to disagree more. The best way to get obedience, is with understanding about why you forbid/oppose something.

    As for the last line of your comment...are you moved by *nothing at all*?

  • @YTMrVulcan It isn't about being moved it is about not being shocked or surprised. People murder, rape, abuse, steal ect.....everyday.

    Look at it this way, at least she wasn't six and at least he wasn't raping her.

  • @YTMrVulcan This guys reaction leads me to one of two conclusions....he is melodramatic or he is naive about the world in which he lives. 

  • @zippy476 or he could be an hypocrite, looking for satisfaction and gratification in the attention he fools out of people.

  • @mrdotbryce Attention whore....hmmm..........possibl­e.

    He could be genuin and just a sensitive guy but then he would need to change his name to "ObviouslyMassiveFag" though the look already suggests this.

  • 3 AM in the morning, put my keys in da door, bodies lain all over the floor.

    Sorry, I just had to ad a Eminem reference

  • And my older brother who is 22 agrees with me he and his wife just had a child yesterday , just a year ago he was sitting in jail for several month and the judge ruled in his favor luckly he could of had 115 years now he is going into the air force which is why the judge let him off fact of the matter is if he had got his ass beat more it wouldn't of ever happened and he will say the same

  • @zg72

    Thing is I say everything I did being a child which if my parents didn't displen I would probably be in jail hell I'm 18 and see my little brothe who is 10 yelling at my mom and feel like knocking his block off but I don't personally he need his ass beat and my step dad got back from Iraq and saw it and he straitened up in less then cas he started to get his ass beat I'm not saying go and hurt ur child to need to go to a hospital but really some kids need disaplen and just talking won't w

  • @yugiohpanda If this was for me, my answer would be simple, where do you think you or your brother learned from, primarily, to misbehave? How did in your opinion history of your parents affected you!?

    All I am saying is you have a better, safer, more efficient way for raising children. Links and ton of information is there. Doesn't hurt to look at it, does it, especially if it can make such a huge impact in your life and life of your children!

    No fear, all the best to all of you

  • i am in seventh grade and i have seen this video. it hurt me a lot to see an authority do such a thing to his child. he should be removed from his job as a judge.

  • To the person who said parents should never hit ur child I agree and disagree some children do need to be taught what's right and wrong thru disaplen I'm not saying do anything like what that man did by anymeans I saw the video being watched by my roommate and told him to turn it off after 30 seconds because it infuriated me I know there is a limit and know not to cross it yes parents pls disaplen ur children if they need it but don't cross the line and actually cause pain emotionally tramatizi

  • Comment removed

  • @TwiIightSparkle FOR MORE WATCH:" The Judge, The Beating, and The Unreality of Outrage"

    Hitting someone (initiation of force) is just plain wrong.

    Hitting a child is monstrous.

    Hitting your own child is idiotic and monstrous, even if you call it "occasional smack". Why? Aside a moral fact, here can you find some cold facts: fdrurl com/bib

  • @zg76

    i disagree. child needs to be spanked and disciplined while young in circumstances that require it.

    but they also need to be taught and loved. and youre not supposed to fuckin enjoy beating your kid.

    theres a line between discipline and abuse and these people have crossed it.

  • @asf4321 You are saying this on a basis of what?

    It is unmoral and unproductive... you can ignore listed facts as much as you like, but it is at your own peril (and sadly, on a detriment for your children also).

  • @zg76

    on the basis of today's younger generations growing up as utter degenerates.

    and don't ask me for proof on youtube, it's all around you. children are raised with two things: the rod, and the heart, and if either it missing by the time they hit their teens - they will grow up as idiots. fact of life throughout the ages.

    and second, i don't know what listed facts you're talking about or who listed them for that matter.

  • @asf4321 So you think that most of children nowadays are being raised in peaceful meaner??

    fdrurl com/bib

    With the ROD?? I see a devoted christian here. WHAT A PATHETIC LITTLE COWARD YOU ARE! So you need to beat someone 10 times smaller and hundred times weaker from you in order to feel in power!? What a f*cking prick. Go do some therapy and deal with your own sh*t, don't act it out on helpless!

  • @zg76

    and i'm sure you don't even have kids. because an adult would learn to spell immoral by that time...just putting it out there so i don't have to debate this with a some kid

  • juez hijo de perra ¡¡¡¡¡¡

  • Parents who ever hit their children are disgusting! They deserve a serious beating themselves and they should have the kids taken away.

  • fuck you William Adams you fucking cunt

  • Its now at over 6 million

  • hypocrisy 

  • That man is sick. 

  • You are such a nice and sensetive guy and I'm sure you are going to be a very kind and caring father oneday. I think the judge was probably abused himself as a child. He looked very angry and had no emotions toward his daughter. I hated the mother for backing him. A real mother can not bear her child suffer and be in pain. They are both guilty.

  • There is a video of a black kid getting his ass beat by a adult with a belt and no one gives a shit but a white kid gets their ass beat and everyone has a comment about it and makes a huge deal out of it.

  • A disciplinary spanking is still physical abuse and teaches nothing useful to anyone ever

    

  • Good reporting but hamming up the facial reactions that much makes it seem like it's supposed to be a very subtle joke.

  • It's funny to me, sitting here a week after this video was uploaded, to read the comments some people have left. To those of you who left support for Hillary (and in a way, myself) I have to say thank you. But to those viewers who choose to arm themselves with anonymous hateful words, hidden behind the safety of their computer screens, I say this:

    A) A life. Get one.

    B) Friends. Make some.

    C) Therapy. You need it.

    Now move along, trolls. You're not welcome here. :)

  • @ObviouslyBenHughes If you say stuff like that then you're just gonna attract more trolls.

  • Comment removed

  • A troll I may be but let me say this. Hillary you are good person and you did not earn or deserve this in any way. You are beautiful and wonderful and you can be and do whatever you want. You are a free person and no one ever has the right to treat you that way. I know your pain, I was abused. The farther you get away from your parents the better off you will be.

  • @ObviouslyBenHughes I had to walk away from my computer because of so many responses that are not only hurtful but completely shocking to me. There are so many videos that were uploaded of this & am completely disgusted by the responses. Ppl condoning this, saying that wasn't a real beating, she deserved it, etc. I want to throw up! There are so many ppl that are abusing their children, this is just 1 that had the courage to expose this abusive monster! That video made me physically sick! :-(

  • @Tkexpressions

    People who have not been abused do not understand abuse. They think they do, they think they are on the moral high ground because it is a disobedient child. This is savage abuse and nothing else. Only savages would condone this as warranted punishment, discipline or correction. at 1:22 he calls her a dummy. He is clearly enjoying himself. This is clearly a situation he wants to be in. He left the room and came back to beat her some more. This is abuse.

  • @62Yomamma He is not a pussy, he just has a Heart, unlike you!!!

  • @bulkforce5 shut the fuck up you worthless troll. Either you're some kind of sick piece of shit or you grew up spoiled because there's no reason to call someone a weepy fag for crying over this. You don't know what people have been through in their lives, therefore you can't tell weather or not videos such as children being clearly abused will affect them emotionally or not. People get physically abused every day and never tell anybody, its a hard god damn thing to deal with. Stfu.

  • @Nymphis69

    i don't know if your father beat you before but after that post i hope to God he starts.

  • If I would have done half the crap this girl pulled I would have gotten it worse growing up, and a few times I did. I'm not some derranged emotional basketcase from it either. But like I said in the previous post you should hear both sides of this before you post comments. I know this was overboard dicipline, but that is the problem with most of society today. It's either too much or non at all, and the kid goes wild and uses crap like this video to get back at thier parents.

  • You obviously aren't over the age of 40. Yes it was a severe beating, and I"m sorry for that, but you only know what you are seeing. This was in port aransas texas and she was doing alot more than uploading a program. Can you say drugs, alchohol, and online sex chats which is how this all started. You need to educate yourself with all the facts before making your comments, but she isn't as innocent as the video depicts, or you make her out to be. I don't agree with it and there is more to it

  • Anonymous Haced a camera in williams doughter's room when he beats her upp by using internet

  • i dont think i even blinked watching it.

  • get over it, like i did ^^

  • you might be helping somebody/people, but my point is that people need to get over things and look around for a second,people still bring up 911 and divine it when they don't really care and stand up for hundreds of christians dying in iraq everyday. and for me, as an immigrant, what do you think i should do with all this hate that i keep inside from people that hurt me directly or indirectly? oh well,i was beaten hard by iraqi ip for some speech misunderstanding when i was 17 ^^ least mentioned

  • video reaction doesn't matter, at least not a reaction to 2 girls 1 cup.however, i'm surprised that you got touched by this lil video that i merely watched and said "atta girl,she recorded it" means that something good is gonna happen. as for a kid from iraq like me,allow me to ask you this, did/do you feel the same for iraqis as for this girl what happened to them? do you have any idea what's going on in this world at all? if so,i suppose you'll spend your whole life crying, not helping anyone!

  • i have 2 agree with other people it seems like watching the vid then posting u watching is jsut kinda fishing for views or some b/s

  • cut it short you stupid backwards cunt! you talk SHIT! fag

  • lol.

    a grown-ass man crying in public over a video he watched. disgusting.

    I want to run you down with a cement truck and beat your face in with a crowbar.

  • @bulkforce5 So your saying that a man crying in public is wrong? What kind of person are you.

  • You put it better than I ever could.

  • I am not a violent person but after watching the video, I feel nothing but rage for that man. I speak for myself and probably 99% of the people here, I would not hesitate in beating that man myself. I know the quote "Don't fight fire with fire" is somewhat true but in some situations, it can't be helped. I have nothing but love for that girl. <3

  • See so many people think the mom is to blame but on TV the daughter said many times she likes her mom and they're like friends. I do think the mom was trying to make her punishment end sooner but unfortuntely it only made it longer (because of her interruption). Many people condemned the mom judging fromj what she did on the video, but her daughter said she's a good mom, ....

  • Comment removed

  • ...because, she sees what we don't see & she is better able to understand her actions. For we to judge the father based on what he did on the video therefore is most likely not all accurate, because we don't see what they see and so, we may not easily understand his action.  I think the mom is not a bad person but her problem is she doesn't have too much of her own thinking. That's why she went along with the father and now she's divorced she goes along with her daughter. ....

  • ... Her thinking seems a bit clouded and seems she doesn't totally understand why she's doing what she does. And this quality may also be what the daughter has as, we got our genes from our parents. She's likely doesn't always understand why she's doing what she does, let alone understand the consequences. This might well be why this is not an ideal family situation & therefore the dynamic would not be a regular one that we see. I think it's a bit unfair to totally blame the father.

  • @luifuksang You make a good case for not rushing to judge. But alongside caution in judgement, should go research. If you look into the behaviour of physical and mental abuse by such persons, you can see here the usual personality traits - eg it's all being done to him, he has no responsibility, (very ironic in a Texan judge) - and that he has practically brainwashed the family into thinking his opinions are normal. Very typical. Outside the house - a pillar of the community.

  • both parents should be arrested.

  • I don't think the mom is to blame. I think she was trying to protect her, if you can see the subtle details. I heard her say "I already spanked her" before the monster came in the room. I also think the mom was thinking if he saw her whip her once he would leave her alone. Abusive families are complex. Abusers are controllers and manipulators. The mom is a victim too.

  • The video was disturbing but you cried when you watched it? You then posted a video of you watching the video and crying? You're a weenie.

  • @fall22123 At one extreme you have a man who weeps at the sight of a young girl being violently beaten by a man who is supposed to be her protector. At the other extreme you have a man who is strong emotionally because he is able to control his emotions and so his thinking and behaviour. This is what makes him fit to be a judge.(Supposedly.) Having seen this, you tend to think that not controlling "weaker" emotions is bad ? Ok, moderation in all things, but I know which way I'd prefer to err...

  • @HollyLimbo These might be 2 extremes but the one sympathize so much as to weep is just based on what a video shows while the one viewed as montrous (as it APPEARS) is based on his own situation (which no one knows better than him). It looks horrible but by now we know these days things cannot be automatically taken at their face value. Should we at least not be so hasty? Even for murders it can be homicide or different degrees of manslaughter based on the story. The story is ALL IMPORTANT.

  • I watched this video ... And am sick to my stomach.... What I saw was terrorism... This was not a spanking... It was a beating... You don't treat humanbeings or any living creature like this .. The

    Mother is just as guilty...what did the father teach his daughter?.. If you can teach right and wrong , then it's ok to beat and verbally terrorize your child?... Their was far more damage done than just the beating we saw...you don't beat to teach a lesson...

  • -->He should have his license removed.(as a judge)

    -->He should never be called SIR again.(animals dont even do that)

    -->The mother is just as guilty.

    -->He should be sentenced for what he did!

    & nobody can judge her reaction. She has been abused for ever, she did not know different!!

    And it's so true....An abuser does not have a specific way of dressing!! It can be any body...most often, people you would never expect it to be!!

  • ... you used to be a nice girl now you lie cheat & steal " & "is it fun to disobey mom & dad?!" "Do you think I was fooling (when I asked you not to)". At the beginning we hear the mom telling her "you think it's no big deal & that's why you do it." We also heard the parents talking, of the problems that were caused by the computer. So it seemed it has already caused them problems. What's next to do? This was not sudden but ongoing & it would seem she didn't listen and continued to do what .

  • ....she was asked not to do, repeatedly. This wasn’t real abuse. I've seen abused child, setting up camera is the last thing on their mind. A truely abused would be too busy worrying about what's coming, to actually go & set up the camera. She said beating was common & she thought it’s normal. Then why would she think to put a camera? What prompted her to do that out of nowhere? And it happened to record the worst beating from her father? Or was she setting it up because she's spiteful? .

  • ... She said her father wanted her to do well to reflect better on him only and not out of love. We're not sure if that's the father's intention but the part that's true is she didn't do well as she admitted it & said “I could’ve done better.” Then why didn't she? He's a judge so it's quite reasonable he wanted her to do better than part time retail. That's normal for any parent. She also said the reason her father gave her money and car is to control her, then one wonders ...

  • ..why would he now take them away? Maybe b'cuz she quit school?! A father who controls with materials would not wait till you're old enough,like 23 so you're capable of getting away from him, to then take them away. That doesn't sound true. So she knew her father ddi that to control her why would she even accept them? She responded to her father's statement that he provided for her financially by saying he's not the primary support, primary financial support is from her live-in boyfriend .

  • .... So she took the money knowing he’s trying to control her with it, & she doesn`t even need that money?! What kind of thinking and value system is that? Now the money & car are taken away the video came out? She said it's not because her father's taking away the car & stop support that she posted the video. So she had nothing to do with the timing? She said she didn`t plan to record her beating, it's just happened to happen. Can she at least be a little honest!? She told on TV .....

  • This judge is a fucking douche. If i ever meet him, i'll beat the shit out of him.

  • This guys deserves to be beat himself because he is a low piece of shhit, he deserves to be hung by a tree fucking ass hole go die

  • you did awesome Hillary! Do not, for even a moment, feel guilty about releasing this. I love computers too and the internet, and this is why!

  • My brother is 12 and watched the video so chill, while I'm 17 and had to pause and exit out of 1:35 mins of the video rofl.

  • my brother is 12 and watched the video so chill

  • The girl deserved it. The girl was a fucking idiot, the father could have been put in jail for years and his family ruined.

    The idiot girl pirates games, risking her family's stability. When her father takes away her Mercedes, the spoiled idiot decides to post the video in revenge.

    In turn for risking her whole family, she gets a 5-6 minute spanking. No big deal, especially for an idiot like her.

  • @tusharsingal How many people do you know who have lost their stability for downloading games and music over the Internet ?!!?!?! If that was true, none would have stability anymore. Excuses...

  • @tusharsingal Then, my dear tough little friend, how about I give YOU a goddamned good lashing? I believe you are one of those people: emotionally unstable, erratic temper, feel the need to be uselessly domin-- excuse me. I hear my mother hitting my baby sister downstairs. I will be back in a while.

  • @tusharsingal ...continuing on. In short-- Fact: You are a dumbass.; Fiction: My previous statement is a personal belief.; Good day to you, whoever the hell you are supposed to be.