Carl Sagan on Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence -1979

[NetTubeUser]

4:20 - Every time I hear this beautiful music from Vangelis, I think about Carl Sagan and I imagine him floating in space, his hands around our planet earth, saying to us, softly and gently: "Don't worry, everything is fine. You are not alone". I know, it sounds childish but this is my very naive homage for our friend Carl... :)

[Estranged68]

Stephen Hawking may be very smart and can predict alot of things but Carl Sagan is the man and he will live on forever.

[Manicfrizz]

R.I.P Dr. Sagen

[DigitalSound22]

Goldeneye!

[Jaska124]

The way i see it and will see for the rest of my life, the only answer i can get is that we are the first intelligent race in this universe. Nuff said.

[021311]

lve the bgm, anyone knows what it was?

[Ashitaka255]

Am I the only who doesn't care about food, clothing, paying the bills etc as much as space, interstellar travel etc?

I have so many issues and personal problems to deal with but I don't care. I just want to go to space, even if it means certain death. Sometimes its painful.

[JasonDamisch]

Maybe they are afraid of us?

[ZaaaaaM7]

@JasonDamisch Aliens who can travel between galaxies sure are scared of our weapons.

Shit you are dumb.

[Kibate]

@ZaaaaaM7 To be fair, they might not be scared of our weapons, but of our aggresive nature. Maybe they advanced so much because they only knew peace, and so a planet where kids play pranks on each other, teenagers rebel against their parents, adults go to war etc., even if they don't have the same technology, such a society might cause more harm than the strongest weapon in the universe.

[knoxvilleguy2]

@Kibate - What about this - If there are advanced E.T. civilizations out there that have managed to monitor our feeble radio signals & make some sense out of them, assuming they're quick studies & can get a rudimentary understanding on our language. Then they conclude that this planet is a BIG ** lunatic asylum **, & they should stay away because we're a bad influence.

[azimebrahimi60616]

im gone miss u carl

[MrKillJoy200]

I'm an alein from planet x-13, does any-one know what "Earth" is? :p

[british123able]

government know about aliens, dont be fooled. they own your minds.

[ChuckSchuldinerRIP0]

@british123able Schizophrenia bullshit. The government doesn't control the populace with mind control.

[avzett]

If aliens find us they will likely want to have nothing to do with us.

[banana1337kivi]

I am currently reading Sagan's book Contact and it is awesome!

[KARTRACE9]

mankind isnt ready to find other beings we are way too stupid

[Anet000]

@KARTRACE9 you bet that aliens are the ancient gods that we used to hear about so many times as well as formers of all religions in the world

[KARTRACE9]

idk about that but if they came and we knew it now we would kill each other

[Anet000]

@KARTRACE9 why so???

[blackknight509]

Whatever possible life form exists/existed or will exist will most likely be nowhere near our perceived notions,

[Aemasone]

@blackknight509 Finally, you are the only person I see who also sees this. I don't believe we will recognise 'life' if it did exist.

[2CSST2]

@99tran the pope can go fuck himself

[Jman21UK]

yh wouldn't it take ages 4 radio signals to travel thru space ? well im sure we dont know everything about space itself. after all u cant detect something without a detector LMAO

[KARTRACE9]

radio waves travel at light speed the signal we sent havent even to the nearest star yet

[Aemasone]

@KARTRACE9 Yes, which would also take years to reach. There's no point wasting the time unless we know what we're sending, and where to.

[blitzenpunk1]

wuuuujuuu Puerto Ricooo yaayy!!! love it

[fleeboyful]

this guy really makes you wonder.who does know if there is life out in the universe other than us? but my question is, are we the first? are they more advanced with technology than us?god did not make this HUGE universe just for us. There must be more life than just this puny planet of ours. if they are more intelligent than us, they could teach us so much.....

[GhostHunter1986]

our takes lol

[faronzkimaruh]

carl sagan is the red & blue blur ^__^

[neoContraVo]

No your wrong the ohther guy had it right. contact tottaly stole this Idea. and everyone that left a Paragraph sized statement just wants to have sex with an alien.

[williamr4400]

LOL you're dumb... that's like saying the design for a red jacket was stolen from the "beat it" video. sending a set of prime numbers seems like the best choice to broadcast an indication of intelligent life, considering it takes an intelligent being to deduce prime numbers. go learn something, dipshit.

[Seannyskillz]

the movie contact totally stole the idea from this

[kailefipne]

Well, since the movie "Contact" was based on the novel by Carl Sagan, I wouldn't exactly call it "stealing".

[dudlemann]

or that there are very, very few planets with life on them in the universe

[dudlemann]

another possibility is of course that interstellar travel is only possible at sub-light speeds

[researchityourself]

Here is their message Carl.. We don't want you to know we are here. We aren't going to tell you why either. If you can't be open minded or evolved enough to begin to accept our existence which we have already made by flying over your bases and your white house back in the 50s, and/or your military is going to attempt to shoot us down and use our technology to make bigger and greater weapons, then the very last thing we are going to do is going to want to blue-tooth you for drinks at TraderVics

[Enleuk]

the pope is a delusional man. since the 3rd(?) century, humans have elected a human to embody God inheriting the shift between the old roman emperors to the last emperor/first pope and disciple of jesus, namely Petrus. but the pope is not the first to claim divinity, so have countless monarchs and pharaohs et cetera done in history. silly little monkeys think god exists cuz they dont want to realize theyre monkeys, despite all the evidence pointing out our similarities.

[uscdave1124]

idiots like you will be the reason humanity destroys its self, your ignorance and blind belief in superstition will damn the entire beautiful human race to a new dark age of ignorance and fear, all because you are too goddamn dumb to see how much more beautiful than any religion, is the universe science has revealed to us, how old, how vast, how wonderful,how sad that you deny it and cling to the outdated beliefs of the vestigial mental organ that is religion

you have your bible, i have hubble

[sohyunfx]

He knew what he didnt know

[DoubleDutchBust]

O- 8:00

My Apologies StephenHawkin-kaliel

Eye Switch to Signal Stephen-gsean

My Apologies StephenHawkin-kaliel

other 8:07

ther

her

er

redball 7:05

[DoubleDutchBust]

P O I N D E X T E R ST E PHE NHAWKINK

DoctorCarter EyE PresumeCoastToCoast

Extraterrestrial Intelligence -1979 A-ZBCE

DoctorCarter EyE PresumeCoastToCoast

P O I N D E X T E RST E PHE NHAWKINK

suttleilak coast to coast to coast

kaliel beep' beep' beep' beep' 2:51

suttleilak coast to coast to coast

[smokingkaya]

E T is out there waiting for our signal.

[UnknownRex]

Well, I think the ETs are out there, as for waiting, maby, maby not :P

[Fujimoto420]

I've been in Puerto Rico for about 5 months now and I still haven't gotten to see the Arecibo radio dish. I really need to do that.

[rbolo29]

WE miss you Carl Sagan; may E.T bless us.

[rogerthat155]

depending on the gravitational pull of their home star, an ET being could be totally different to us. i mean, what if the gravitational pull is stronger than here, and they still evolve and make it out of their atmosphere, to us. not only would their ships be much much faster than ours on this planet, but the creatures would be stronger, faster, and live longer here too. a bit like kryptonians and superman lol

likewise if their gravitational pull is less than here.

[ukidding]

100 million years from now, man will have evolved into something else. computers will have life

[rogerthat155]

computers WILL have life? mate, they have it now!! i swear sometimes my computer is laughing at me, that videogames i play have sinister agendas

[torolof]

100 million year from now

we would be here now!

[thesixshot]

its a small chance that there will be humans in 100 million years,,,we would of had to evolve to a type 1 civilization,, and close to type 2

[Enleuk]

whats type 1 and type 2 civilization?

its kinda hard to imagine human evolution because human civilization has changed so much and so fast the last 50k years and basically without any evolution at all. so its not easy to imagine how we would evolve in symbiosis with other forms of development that could accelerate, prevent, circumvent or create unexpected or expected evolution and/or (and) development.

[lardchef]

WOTS ALL THIS

[scotters201]

Man hope for long term survival is in space..He must colonize other worlds and grow like a weed..ever expanding so when one world no longer is hospitable..he has hundreds of others..just like the creation of the world wide web..was to survive a nuclear war, one server/computer goes down..hundreds of other in the web,can survive and go on..same idea man needs for it's long terms survival in the galaxy and beyond..

[FRIENDOFOURS2]

it maybe radio emissions have nothing to do with it , maybe there interdimensional

beings or just maybe they have lived right here all along an not to be et's at all , as you all know we might know more about the face of the moon than the bottom the the ocean floor , now am i right or worng ?

[ekutatakewt]

WOW ! 400 billion stars in the Milky Way ?And billions of galaxies ?

fLABBERGASTING !

[JeremyBechen]

You've just experienced what I like to call "The Carl Sagan Effect". :D

When you begin to contemplate the sheer size of the Universe, that is. :D

[Kaarel314]

It takes a really long time to get a message 200 lightyears away. So we must wait until it gets there and they send an answer back. So we should start waiting after several hundred years. I dont want to wait several hundred years.

[rogerthat155]

Yeah we need laser radio systems! lol

[Fujimoto420]

look up LISA

"Laser Interferometer Space Antenna"

It's NASA's latest project.

[scdlbrdr]

I think if a species intelligent enough to ever reach earth, and come in contact with humans; they would realize everything is deeply connected, and therefore would make peace with us. Humans are still on the "dominate the land and people" mindset. If humans ever really want to explore the universe, we need everyone to realize we're all one species, and we should be taking care of each other.

[stopjunkscience]

Well said...

[k3lp00]

1 is not a prime number as far as I know. But other than that I am a fan of Carl Sagan. Had similar ideas to me although I do not think that there are millions of civilizations in our galaxy...maybe 5-10 in my opinion.

[plevyman]

I'm not sure why you got voted down for correctly pointing out that 1 isn't a prime number.

I really like Carl Sagan, but I think even here he understates the problems of the size of the cosmos and another question (which no-one ever thinks about) which is the amount of time a civilization would have to stick around for us to meet them. Human civilization has only existed for about 10,000 years, that's 1/500,000-th the age of the earth. Even if aliens existed, do they exist *now*?

[k3lp00]

I do not know either why they voted me down...a bunch of ignorants they are :D

well I think that the lifespam of a civilization depends on several issues.The industrial revolution which we are in recently. So far as a civilization manages to expand to other planets it gains great survavibility. Because from that point on there is a little possibility for a disaster to happen on all of the colonized worlds at the same time.

[LastCynicStanding]

If the question of why we are watching him instead of you ever comes up you now have your answer.

[k3lp00]

I do. But what exactly is your point?

[foxbat68]

Just think of some of the junk these other planets, light years away, will have been receiving from us. Pop Idol, Big Brother, Iraq War coverage....my god! No wonder they don't bother getting in touch.

[curlyrocks1]

Well they either would have 1 of 2 thoughts

1: let's go help these people overcome there fucked up leaders and achive peace cuz things there are fucked

or 2: ohh new sorce of slaves

[Reido2828]

I doubt slaves. were to lazy to work hard

[anotherfinemess962]

Though SETI and SETI@home in a planet grid level is a very ambitious notion, its a very primitive technology that we have been using for the last 100 years out of the millions years of the excistance of possible planets out there.

[Blacksun1942]

You're not a good person.

[UnevenMatrix]

OMG. WOW!!! <<<---- @ the jackass. The man was WAY smarter than you, and my personal hero... So stfu...k pumpkin? Jealousy? Is that why people make fun of other people...? I don't get it, but whatever... Anyway... he may not have had the "nicest" voice... but what does that have to do with anything anyway? It's not the delivery system that matters... it's the message.

[novan3]

tou·ché

[XmegaPresident]

How do we say "fundamentalist, creationist and conspiricy theorist? = DRMABUSA.

[bloodstone1445]

This guys knew something :)

[resubscriber]

They send one powerfull enough signal to reach one location. If anyone there, they will probably not be listening for a signal from one specific location of our solar system, or even have their listening equipment turned on all the time; like we dont either.

[prayfertrey]

He's always saying, "they" and "we". "We" don't destroy ourselves, the dumb people do. "We" didn't make scientific discoveries, a few, or one, smart guy did. "We" aren't violent and irrational; just the people who were born with a brain problem. "We" didn't go to the moon. A group of smart people pulled that off. "Mankind" didn't come up with the printing press, Gutenberg did. Much of mankind has been getting dragged through history on the coat tails of their betters.

[aikiboy1111111]

Now that I agree with you on. This is why it is so difficult to engage most people in critical thinking. Only the few truly intelligent people such as the likes of Carl Sagan, Einstein, Asimov and Shermer really get it and help translate it for us.

[prayfertrey]

I think the best of us have this tendency to think of the rest of us as being better than we are... so they talk to us as if we're able to get it. That's why Ralph Nader will never get elected to diddly. He doesn't lie, he doesn't even prevaricate when it is in our best interest. So ppl. think he's a freak.

[Ophiuchus24]

Agreed. We're a high quantity, low quality species, with very few diamonds in the rough. Lucky us.

[prayfertrey]

What scares me is that it took thousands, hundreds of thousands of years of bloody violent history before mankind worked out free democracy and human rights. This seems to be pretty substantial evidence that civilization isn't in their nature and it's only technology (printing press) that allowed the smart few to have more say in the structure of things, as oppose to the powerful... Still, ya gotta laugh. ;)

[defdeezy]

human rights? they haven't been worked out quite yet...

[prayfertrey]

Sure they have, although one or two have been left out... the problem is that most humans aren't really all that interested in them, not really. Ppl. don't have a problem with slavery as long as they're comfortable. They draw the line at beatings.

[defdeezy]

you think they've been worked out?

haha. dude. bro.

take a trip to a third world country (i was born in one). then tell me that they've been worked out.

[prayfertrey]

My post refers to the long history that took place before America was founded. I didn't say the whole world has human rights. Oh wait, this is the internet.

[defdeezy]

not in america either dude. katrina victims? detroit? washington, dc? visit an american ghetto sometime, or a white-trash trailer park.

[prayfertrey]

I'm sure we haven't "arrived"; which is beside my point, dude.

[IntelligentHoodlum]

(to your original reply to defdeezy's human rights post):

To say that most humans don't have problems with slavery or aren't interested in human rights is ludicrous. The slavery abolitionist movement--people just kind of did that for fun? Same with the civil rights movement or the womens suffrage movement--those were just lackadaisical occurrences?

[prayfertrey]

History shows that those movements are mostly confined to the middle/upper middle class. Why isn't it typical for ppl. to think about it? Why isn't there a common objection to wage slavery? Why is 90% of tv programming painfully insipid and fatuous and lowest common denominator? Why do politicians manipulate as oppose to communicate? You need to ask the whole world why they think most folks are just wondering through life waiting for next wks episode of their fav tv program.

[defdeezy]

yes, i agree with you here.

[IntelligentHoodlum]

We do destroy ourselves, even if it is the "dumb" people--we allow it to happen and continue by not intervening or preventing whatever it is. Why do you think Sagan always emphasized the possible destruction of our civilization by a nuclear war? Or was he just commenting that we as a species should just sit back and let the technocrats do the work and save the day?

[prayfertrey]

I wasn't able to make heard or tails of that.

[IntelligentHoodlum]

"We" do destroy ourselves and not a "few idiots"; Sagan always talked about the possibility of a nuclear war because the few idiots are allowed to play games with the world, while "We" stand by.

[prayfertrey]

You have it the wrong way round. I never said, "few idiots". Neither did Sagan. Smart ppl. are vastly, vastly out numbered by average and below average bears.

"It is unfortunate that the people who know best how to run the country are too busy cutting hair and driving cabs." - George Burns

[IntelligentHoodlum]

My mistake, "dumb" people. And privileged people usually take advantage of opportunities when presented w/them--so I dont disagree that there are few "smart" people.

"I am somehow less interested in the weight and convolutions of Einstein's brain than in the near certainty that people of equal talent have lived and died in cotton fields and sweatshops." -Stephen Jay Gould

[EthanJM]

Ok, lets say that the average person was as smart as carl sagan. That would mean that there would be a few out there vastly outnumbered by the average folk as smart as carl sagan. The fact is, people are very smart, that is all I am trying to say.

[prayfertrey]

Then why is 90% of commercial tv programming painfully insipid? Why do tv commercials and advertisements talk to people like they're emotional robots and childish idiots? Why do politicians manipulate emotionally, instead of communicate to the intellect? And why does the average bear stand for it? And why is the most popular use of YT looking at videos of Paris Hilton?

[prayfertrey]

Hmm, what if the other civilization evolved such that intelligence was a common trait instead of a rare one like it is on earth; then that would be why they didn't self destruct and getting their signal wouldn't necessarily mean anything for "us". Just sayin'.

[fivish]

Carl clearly changed his mind about life in the universe because I heard him say that we (mankind) are almost certainly the first life in the universe.

[wiffybiffy]

Yeah, thats what Huttrghhey from Mananananron 3 tells me when he beams into my shed on a Monday evening every month.He always smells of brandy too.

[KJS72]

People will laugh at some of my comments but thats what humans are like. They laughed at Galileo, they laughed at the thought of flight, then reaching the moon ect. Its the same old same old.

[KJS72]

Imagine what a civilization 1 million years ahead of ours thinks of humans and their primitive sciences. 100 years ago the fastest thing in the sky was a hot air balloon. They thought if you went any faster than 30mph you would disintegrate. Now we are travelling at 40,000 in space. Science will keep moving at a fater and faster rate until we can travel interdimensionaly or at super luminal speed even though its against our 'present understanding'.

[KJS72]

We have something Carl Sagan doesnt. New Cern discoveries and advancments in zero field gravity and cold fission propulsion thanks to the U.S black projects which are 50 years beyond anything you can imagine. Thats what the head of Lockhead Skunkworks said before he died. VROOOOOOMMMMMMM :)

[Leonards1]

Sagan's hair helmet was so awesome :)

[fivish]

Dawkins is deluded about himself! Sagan was a giant in comparison to Dawkins. Sagan believed that humans are the first inteligent life in the univers and that one day we would go out and populate the universe.

[maurice]

That is exactly what Sagan didn't believe. He kept saying it is statistically certain the Milky Way is full of civilisations "far more advanced than us", who would for certain be benign because high-science societies advsance beyond war. As even his biographer Keay Davidson noticed, Sagan had no evidence for this extraordinary claim, it was his equivalent of God, dreaming of help from the sky.

[xKCBEx]

fivish, There's a difference, Carl Sagan had the COSMOS series, Dawkins does not, not that that's any guarantee, have you ever heard of Donald Johansson? Carl, unlike Richard didn't spend his time saying things that are unpopular. COSMOS was hope, and a dream, Richard Dawkins is the low after the high

[muskratsrule]

Why must you demean Richard Dawkins? Have you read The Selfish Gene? Or Blind Watchmaker? The guy is a genius and was revolutionary in his day. I remember taking a course in Evolutionary Biology in college and selfish gene was required. It was radical and opened the door on Sociobiology, Naked Ape etc. He played a huge part in moving that field forward. He's not as passionate and compelling as Carl, but he is still a great contributer IMO.

[xKCBEx]

Muskratsrule, yes Indeed I have read The Selfish Gene and Unweaving the Rainbow. I do not doubt his genius at all. I was merely expressing the opinion that compared to Carl Sagan who talks about Aliens and space travel sociobiology is downright depressing in comparison.

[muskratsrule]

I respect your opinion and agree that Astrobiology is probably a more interesting, exciting field, but disagree entirely that sociobiology is depressing. How so? I think its entirely revealing and casts a bright light on who we are. We are mildly polygamous primates. I personally delight in the truth that I'm a naked ape. Its very honest.

[LLACEM]

he will be missed a true legend

[jerryaltman]

An before Dawnkins there was Sagan :-)

[hellomynameisshun]

dawkins is an asshole

[enclave2k1]

Carl Sagan is my hero!

[mazdaplz]

mine too :)

[KJS72]

Although Carl Sagan is obviously a great mind I think he's missing a few points...What if they can travel faster than light? or are from one of the other ten dimensions CERN has discovered? What if NASA are lying under instruction of the CIA? What if...theyre already here and dont want to communicate through radio signals and would rather watch the 'children' playing ..ie.. humans.

[Leonards1]

"ZOMG!!1! The alienz is gunna break all da lawz uf physics!!"

[KJS72]

Leonard: Aliens dont have to break the laws of physics to travel here.

There are more advanced physics out there which we havent come to yet. Thats why we cant yet explain the moment of creation. But it happened..hence ...there has to be more advanced sciences we have not yet discovered.. Only the primeval arogance of a human would presume that they know it all.

[KJS72]

What do all of you think about the disclosure project?

[hellomynameisshun]

disclosure project was good (Stephen Greer) but never got too much momentum, and pretty much 9/11 is the cause of all that...

[Trocom01]

"Ethic of non-interference." He just may have been one of the first to conceive the "Prime Directive"! Never heard of it? Watch Star Trek. Carl was a genius.

[CheeseBread1987]

BREAD: this is the basis for the plot of his novel 'Contact', for those of you who would like to read about it.

[gmihut]

"CONTACT"One of the best movie,..so far!

[lemansbmwracer]

I love the last minute of this video, most cant read what hes hiding.

[Dirtfire]

Carl Sagan sounds like Bullwinkle Moose.

[breezeesjeb]

Yes, it makes sense, simple as that.

[Midicmpsr]

So according to Sagan we are all just made up of random chances and mutations. No intelligence required. But to look for life on other planets we are to search for intelligent signals and design. Does that make sense?

[infinityspiralsout]

yes, yes it does.

[kimrabb]

yes, it makes perfect sense if you stop and think about how old and big the universe is and how new the earth is in comparision with other planets. We are basically the new kids on the block. Being the new kids on the block we would have more to learn. We can't be the only living things in the whole universe, that would be arrogant thinking. There is this extremely large universe out there and it's so interesting and wonderful

[red3yz]

goldeneye!

[tremblebeforemymight]

I don't give a shit what you people think. Extraterrestrial life form does exsist. Many of us want to believe but are always doubted by videos that people make that turn out to be a hoax which.. people love doing that to fuck with us. Im not saying all are hoaxes but some are. I just know that we are not alone and we do not live in peace. We hate, critisise and do a lot of stupid things to cause harm to one another around but to this planet too.

[Hoblin]

I agree...although you spelled "criticize" rong.

[bunnybooties]

The world is a ghetto. I think that's what he was trying to say. Earth is the backwater drecks of the galaxy.

[ccaptorchen]

remenber our tecnology made major advances through war. if they are more advance then we are, I don't think they are any more peaceful then us. if they DO some I don't think it'll be for saying hello.

[mattbourke]

but you must also realise that if they are so advanced there weapons would be soooo advanced that they would have wiped them self out if they didn't find a way to peace

[maoomph]

Haha this thing is bogus cause earth is the only thing that has advance technology because it has all the necessary things for a liveable planet

[norduk]

I dont think it's a good idea send out a message... we dont know what is up there!! it can be out there nothing... but... if there's something... they can be very friendly or... a predatory civilization... As we do not know what is up there... and we do not know how defende our selfs from a hipotetical advanced civilization seeking natural resources... we should be carefull... :)

[quasarsphere]

In other words, in the highly likly event that there are other civilizations out there, we'd better hope they're not little green Americans.

[nawitus]

Stop with the NASA Ufo, moon hoax, aliens, JFK, zionist super conspiracy, illuminati and all the other bullshit you spam with.

I just don't give a shit.

[drutter]

Sagan WAS in our generation. He only died a few weeks ago, you know. But I agree with that I think you mean - we need more people like him, to carry on the work. In any case, thank you for putting up this clip! Awesome stuff.

[rebtareva]

He died in 1996!

[drutter]

Oh, crazy! I was going my wikipedia's entry on him, which said Dec 20 2006... which obviously was a type, and has been fixed now. Sorry about that. It's odd that he's getting so much attention on youtube in the last short while, though. Maybe because it's the 10 year anniversary of his death.

[HanifXHier]

I suspect it has more to do with the growing Atheist culture on Youtube.

All Atheists are secretly in love with Carl Sagan, male and female alike.

[ronny2471]

"growing athiest culture" your a funny little shallow man.

[HanifXHier]

I am curious as to your meaning. Where did you get shallow? Or little, even?

[ronny2471]

shallow as in intellect or little as in intellect. I mean c'mon, you make a statement like "growing athiest culture on youtube" and dont expect to be called on it? on a carl fucking sagan video? I suppose you know all about the REAL GOD and think the rest of us are not "in the know", whatever, haniflfxerexel

[HanifXHier]

I still have no idea what you're talking about. I suppose it's possible you were unable to glean the humor from my original comment.

There is no "REAL GOD", just a lot of fake ones.

[ronny2471]

now I'm confused, I obviosly misunderstood your comment, have a nice day.

[HanifXHier]

My bad. People frequently have trouble with my particular humor.

[alanshvetz]

And you must be gay for Jesus... I'm an atheist, and I think Carl Sagan did a lot of great work. I don't worship him, I don't make any assumptions that he has supernatural abilities, and I don't think he was omnipotent. Try to refrain from making ignorant comments in the future please.

[HanifXHier]

I implore you to go over your comment again and explain exactly what it is you are addressing. It seems to have come straight out of your ass.

I don't remember anyone attributing omnipotence to Carl Sagan.

[alanshvetz]

"All Atheists are secretly in love with Carl Sagan, male and female alike."

I was making a reference to Jesus. I thought you were mockingly saying that atheists "worshiped" Carl Sagan.

[HanifXHier]

Are Christians "in love" with Jesus? That's not any particular sect I'm aware of.

I was being facetious.

[dirzu]

Carl Sagan era un Maestro!! que increíble volver a ver estos videos!

[muchilus]

excelent piece of video

[samueldrdr]

Search: Discloser project, Hoax, NASA moon, Bob Lazar,

Greatest Story Ever Denied, UFO Black Box, The Grays Agenda, The Big Picture. NASA UFO...

[samueldrdr]

Search: Discloser project, Hoax, NASA moon, Bob Lazar,

Greatest Story Ever Denied, UFO Black Box, The Grays Agenda, The Big Picture. NASA UFO...

[clupet]

Thank you so much for this. We badly need a Carl Sagan for our generation.

[quasarsphere]

Dawkins is on the way.

[snubsEXE]

If only there were more people putting up programs like this on YouTube.

Thanks for uploading this treasure :)

[samueldrdr]

Search: Discloser project, Hoax, NASA moon, Bob Lazar,

Greatest Story Ever Denied, UFO Black Box, The Grays Agenda, The Big Picture. NASA UFO...