Human Nature/Family of Blood--"Dear Valentine"

[HelenaHermione]

That just perfectly captures the story of the Doctor for this episode, the juxtaposition of John Smith and everything that the Doctor had done in the past, especially haunting is how it comes to 'a holiday' and then the battle sequence...very moving, excellent song choice.

[pokexdiversity]

Ooooh, this is great! I'd never think this song would fit but it's perfect, and you matched up the clips fantastically. I loove it! <3

[gamwyn]

So glad you enjoyed it! :-)

[Elanel]

I loved the character John Smith. I know he techincally is the Doctor, but I'm glad someone made a vid about him instead of the Doc.

[gamwyn]

I LOVE these episodes! And I agree, John Smith is a really interesting character!

[Dagger33]

Haven't seen Doctor Who, but I love this song and you've done a great job on the video.

[twolfard]

Favorite band...favorite song. Is this from a TV series or a movie? Nice work on the video

[gamwyn]

TV series. :-) Glad you like the video! And I agree, fantastic band, fantastic son.

[Dilligar]

I really like this video. Nice use of Black and White and Color clips with the song.

[gamwyn]

Thanks, glad you enjoyed it! :-)

[Thebigbluemeany]

Oh this is a nice video :-) How did i miss this one... :-O Particularly love the bit where everything in the book comes to life and Joan saying he was braver that you... *sobs uncontrolably/ mourns for John Smith*

[gamwyn]

aw glad you like it. I know... POOR John Smith. Poor Joan. :-( :-(

[MissTay26]

That was brilliant!

[AnimatedEntropy]

I love the change of perspective with the b&w vs. color footage; nice job!

[PickThisCar]

This is my favorite Guster song. I listen to it when I'm driving at night.

[PhunkyAnastasio22]

This has always been my favorite song by Guster. It is magical, and it makes me think about so many things in life. I have no idea what Doctor Who is...but I find myself mesmurized by John Smith's life because of this video. This is absolutely amazing.

[gamwyn]

Yes I love this song!! You should watch some Doctor Who if you ever get a chance, it's pretty awesome. Thanks for the comment!

[DreamerM]

When an everlasting Time Lord, a being that exists outside of time and space and is a hareld of wonder and ruin.. when he makes himself a human body and mind in an effort to foil a family of hunters, what he becomes is John Smith. The man who lives in the heart of a god.

[tardis360]

Brilliant!

[rachelcs92]

I really like this. Brilliant.

[iAmLostGirl]

Im going to crie;)So sad,and great-5*

[antiplastic]

Really well done. I liked the "ancient and forever" speech; the clips went really well with the words. I also liked the voiceover of Joan holding the journal.

[gamwyn]

So glad you liked it! Those were amazing episodes...

[ShannonInOurHearts]

That was a really cool video! I love how you have taken recent clips and combined them with old ones, Your so clever! Please may i ask where you got the clips from and could you reply to me on my profile page? I would be ever so grateful! Thank you!

[gamwyn]

Glad you liked it! I've gotten really obsessed with Guster lately and thought the dearth of Guster/Doctor Who vids was quite tragic. :-)

[LadyTinidril82]

I also just wanted to say I think it's completely horrible that you put those last few clips of John Smith/Joan in black & white, as if to say they've just been added to the long list of the Doctor's memories, that nothing good ever lasts for him, etc. Absolutely horrible! Good job.;)

[gamwyn]

Haha yes, that was the intention. :-(

[LadyTinidril82]

This is so sad. :-( Which is to say, it's awesome! And the audio layering is pretty impressive; how did you get it to sound so good? It doesn't sound like you did it the way I did it.

[gamwyn]

I know!! It is sad. :-( Yay, fun with audio layering... I don't think I did anything different than you. We'll have to compare techniques.

[pinktails6]

this is so amazing 5 star!!

[gamwyn]

thanks, glad you like it!!