MANY TOO MANY/GUIDE VOCAL - GENESIS

[mypalchester]

I like a lot of the songs that these guys perform and this one is musically well done but let's face it.... the lead singer was not cut out for this song. Just my honest opinion.

[gardenwall07]

@mypalchester i guess you're right ;-)...Thanks a lot !! 

[eleventhearlofmar]

percoco sacrificato :°D

[genesisinsideme]

excellent songs from And then there were three and DUKE ... two albums era Phil ... Tony and Mike....!

[sinsistema]

I like this version, congratulations from Argentina, seems Peter and hackett playing, very, very cool!!!!

[gardenwall07]

thank you amigo !!

[fulcrum100]

you know what/ fair dues to you guys...... italy seems to have a great love for Genesis music. The muscianship is top notch, really ace..... but yes, the vocal can be improved. but, hes got a good voice.. its just hard to swerve in and out of the words the Collins does. So, easy to get slightly wrong. Are you guys still playing? I'll foir sure come to your show.

[gardenwall07]

you're very kind, and i appreciate a lot your not superficial examination of this performance..as i wrote in most of the  previous replies, this was a bad performance of our singer due to a loss of voice he had beacause of a cold wind blowing theat night, or just beacuse the set list was terrible..imagine singing supper's ready, musical box ..dancing with the moonlit knight, and so on..really hard..then i have to say he's not confortable with collins vocal..he's more close to gabriel's tone!

[gardenwall07]

so..thanks a lot again for your words and your appreciation..and please when you can take a look to all the other clips of garden wall palying genesis..bye bye.. :-)

[gardenwall07]

sorry ..i forgot..we are currently on a pause ..it's a hard life..always problems..most of us is not professional musician ..and the time is so few..hope one day we could have a gig filmed in high quality... :-)

[genesisinsideme]

what ?...this song is from And then there were three ... Peter and Hackett were out of Genesis ... the name of the album dont say something to you? Phil , Tony and Mike.... Guide Vocal is from DUKE ... album 1980...only were three again,,,,Phil, Tony and Mike...!

[blindonion]

While not Genesis this band is hopefully keeping the interest in Genesis music alive!! Good work-let us all enjoy the music

[gardenwall07]

i'm so sorry to be so late..i forgot this comment ..thank you so much for your words!!

[behindthelines72]

totaly the wrong key for the guy.

this is just one of those songs only phil can sing

[gardenwall07]

i do agree..thanks a lot for the fair style of your comment ;-)

[genesisinsideme]

but we have to thanks to the bands that play songs of Genesis not only era Peter...

[genesisinsideme]

there a lot of songs that only Phil can sing...I m thinking that is one of the reasons that there are more Tribute bands playing Genesis era Peter...

[TheJman2600]

The music's fine. The vocals, uh no.

[gardenwall07]

yeah..we already knew!! eh eh ..thanks for watching and commenting..:-)

[bassmanjoe]

I think Phil sounds better, not Peter on this. Sorry the vocals are pretty bad here.

Music sounds great though!!!!

[gardenwall07]

no doubt about it! :-)..you are right, the vocals are bad..it's been already discussed a lot, as you can read above..our singer is not confortable with most of early phil's parts...thanks a lot for your kind comment!!

[myg0tBUTTPLUG]

i love this song/Genesis.

the guy singing...errr needs to stick one of his

fingers in his ear to listen to himself as he is singing.

other than that....sounds great.

[gardenwall07]

thanks for watching!!

[spinedoc4U]

I don't want to be brutal, so let's be as kind here as I can.

Emphasize I am a HUGE Genesis fan.

Ok....

The guitar and keyboard are right on.

The vocals,...let's just say,...not so much.

[gardenwall07]

ah ah ah ...i like your style, thanks for having been so kind..;)..but if you are a huge genesis fan, please watch the other stuff of garden wall..:-)

[salmacis81]

I think musicians should have got lower the key of the song so that the singer do not make such a great effort to get the right note. By the other side, nothing to say about the music. It was very good.

[gardenwall07]

thanks a lot for your comment..and yes..you're right, that is not the right key for our singer, but in the reharsal it was better..at that point of the gig he was almost totally out :)..

[smadurski]

So this what Many Too Many would sound like if Pete sang it.

[gardenwall07]

yes..a kind of..if only the singer was not out of voice :)..during the rhearsal the effect was a little bit like pete sang many too many..thanks for comment!!

[philric74]

ehi, pure tu hai la voce vagamente gabriellena... mica male... l'attacco tra le due è molto fico.... Quando volete fare una cosa con due batterie chiamatemi che ci organizziamo.... Canticchio pure... Ciao!

(hai visto Slipperman? l'ho fatta l'altro giorno....)

[gardenwall07]

ah ah ..grazie mille, come è umano lei!!..si ho visto slipperman..già sai come la penso su di te, bravo!!..:)

[philric74]

il cantante fa bene a non imitare Phil... Una cosa che non sopporto sono i cantanti imitatori.... Solo che forse avrebbe dovuto abbassare un pò le tonalità ... Si sa che le canzoni di Phil sono sia come estensione che tecnicamente molto più difficili di quelle di Peter... Tant'è vero che di discreti imitatori di Gabriel ce ne sono fin troppi... di Phil ancora non mi capita di sentire niente di simile a lui... Comunque il gruppo è bravissimo... Mi piacciono tanto anche le chitarre!

[gardenwall07]

grazie mille..almeno qualcuno non spara a zero e motiva le critiche pur giuste..il ns. cantante non sarebbe proprio capace di imitare phil neanche lontanamente..voce diversissima..comunque hai ragione almeno di mezzo tono andava abbassata, ma abbiamo provato nell'originale per tentare di riprodurre piu fedelmente la canzone..invece hai visto che perfetta imitazione della voce di phil che ho fatto io(batterista) in guide vocal?? ah ah ah ah ah...che vergogna..vabbè ma era solo uno sfizio..:)

[maxgenesis81]

non trova sia tanto brutta certo non tra le migliori vostre, ma il cantante a parte essere senza voce ha una voce troppo lontana da phil, cosi poco cristallina, mentre con gabriel va bene

[squonkness]

fucking awful!!!

[gardenwall07]

i respect your opinion but it'd be nice and useful for us if you specificate what exactly you don't like..i'm experencied that there's lot of people around who enjoy only in criticizing, and for opposite if the like something they never express themselves..anyway ok it's not a good performance the singer at the end of the show was totally out of voice but the instrumental honestly is not so bad..;) please see also the other videos..:)

[squonkness]

Look it is not a personal attack, I just feel it is not very good, specify not specificate, and yes I will take a look at the other stuff :O))

Peace.

without a critique where the hell would we be.

[gardenwall07]

dear squonkness..there's never been war!! :) peace of course!! everyone is free and have the right to criticize, but if it is construcive it's better..if we post a video of our performance we don't expect that everyone says: WOW AMAZING! we expect and accept advices too of course!! anyway if people is complimenting..it's better!! eh eh..bye !!

[gardenwall07]

oh sorry..i wrote specificate instead of specify..ah ah ..shame on me..i'm completely losing my english..

[gardenwall07]

thank you :)

[MrFloydPink]

atrocious