The point where you play the left hand in a low octave with a grace note should be an 8ve lower...and the beginning could be a tad faster while the middle "plus vif" does not have to be presto! It's ok to put some emotions into this :).
Yes, strange that she has some really fabulous articulation in the faster moments, and power, yet can't play the simple opening rhythms!! They sound like a real amature. I also used to play the piece from memory, though couldn't manage the detail so fast. I wonder if she's been listening to MacGregor's distorted recording? Stick to Berof...
This is the first time I've heard Messiaen. Very interesting music! Thank you for posting this so I could discover it! Good luck to you in your work and pursuits!
xalamac: a bit harsh, I admit. But with such excellent music it´s a pity to do a 90%-performance. Especially when it obviously isn´t about technical or musical abilities (she clearly got'em) but not reading the score closely enough. Its good, but she could(should) do even better!!
Even more beautiful if she actually played what is in the score! (Now I admit being sensitive to other interpretations of "Vingt Regards", but p l e a s e play the rhythms right.)
She absolutely can hit the right notes, so don´t destroy an otherwise not bad performance (considering the poor piano)
I like it a lot, very well played
uutbchh 1 year ago
The point where you play the left hand in a low octave with a grace note should be an 8ve lower...and the beginning could be a tad faster while the middle "plus vif" does not have to be presto! It's ok to put some emotions into this :).
jannokas85 3 years ago
The ending is really too slow but the musicality is good!
NICOLAS000099990000 3 years ago
Yes, strange that she has some really fabulous articulation in the faster moments, and power, yet can't play the simple opening rhythms!! They sound like a real amature. I also used to play the piece from memory, though couldn't manage the detail so fast. I wonder if she's been listening to MacGregor's distorted recording? Stick to Berof...
SeanMcHugh02 3 years ago
Beautiful...T_T
Merami2 3 years ago
This is the first time I've heard Messiaen. Very interesting music! Thank you for posting this so I could discover it! Good luck to you in your work and pursuits!
glassnipple 4 years ago
Bravo!!!!!!!!!!
Pianoloverok 4 years ago
xalamac: a bit harsh, I admit. But with such excellent music it´s a pity to do a 90%-performance. Especially when it obviously isn´t about technical or musical abilities (she clearly got'em) but not reading the score closely enough. Its good, but she could(should) do even better!!
Messiaen 4 years ago
Excellent performance! I haven't heard this in a long time. Hearing it now reminds me how great the whole work is.
ssprokofiev 4 years ago
What a fantastic music!!
goldnotebook 4 years ago
This is truly beautiful music, thank you for posting :)
mayablanca 4 years ago
Mess, I don't know how to play piano, I love listening. But I think you're being WAY too harsh. This is a FIVE-star parformance! :-)
xalamac 4 years ago
Even more beautiful if she actually played what is in the score! (Now I admit being sensitive to other interpretations of "Vingt Regards", but p l e a s e play the rhythms right.)
She absolutely can hit the right notes, so don´t destroy an otherwise not bad performance (considering the poor piano)
Messiaen 4 years ago 2
Beautiful!
pianistbk 4 years ago