Added: 3 years ago
From: soccerstar6v6
Views: 235,500
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (712)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Ugh Jason derulo stole that song!!! Ugh I hate him!

  • @ Shortcuttt: Are you on drugs?! Jason Derulo butchered an epic masterpiece! I wish him and his producer a slow and painful death before they splatter head-on into hell!

    Really, bro, you can't be that high to say something like that.

  • He'll never have what Imogen Heap has: REAL MUSIC.

  • Guys, don't criticize Jason DeRrulo, because he sampled from a song you happen to like. It's not like Imogen Heap didn't consent, and it's not like they stole the song. Criticize the song on its own merit, not because it sampled from a song, and to be honest, though I like imogen Heaps original more, I think the way it was in Jason DeRulo's was quite effective.

  • I never said this was the best version, merely that derulo's is the worst.

  • Its great because its different

  • This version is terrible, and the video is just embarrassing.

  • this was her, too... if im not mistaken, it's a live version.. you can find the video here in youtube.. the one with 300,000+ views...

  • Bullshit - his track is nothing but the latest Auto-tuned turd to fall out the machine's ass. His lyrics are fucking TERRIBLE, and voice processed and pitch corrected to hell.

    Get some taste.

  • i love her sooo much.. she can sing... i love her backup in Whatcha say w/ justin!!!! omg i love that song!!!!!!!!!1

  • should have left the mmm what you say part alone... that one just was not good..

  • i personally like the first version better but imogen heap is an innovater and i love her for taking a step outside of the normal radio music to make such as beautiful song as hide and seek.

  • It's amazing when you see someone thinking and feeling outside of the box today... amazing

  • *__*

  • Haven't herd something so beautiful in a long time...

  • Holy shit, this sucks compared to other one. Less high notes and she has a really deep voice.

  • i played the normal one iver this one and its awsome somw parts are off but if some one has a audio editing program they could realy make somthing sweet out of these songs

  • what threw you off? the long hair? breasts? higher toned voice? Enlighten me please because I'm lost...

  • Wait, I thought it was a man! I'm not joking either or trying to be offensive!

  • me too!

  • imogen heap = amazinggggggggg.

  • Speechless, just speechless.

  • She sounds weird on wat u say almost like a man I like the orignial version better and how come u can't find it for this video

  • Really beautiful, but my favourite part "Hmm, What you Say" is just... I don't know... Weird... But this is an amazing song!!!!!!!! I love it!!! (Still prefer the original though) =D

  • i like this a lot, but i kinda feel its missing a point. the part when it starts with "mm. what you say" is missing higher tones and notes. thus making it feel weak for what should be a culmination. otherwise very good.

  • I think the original sounds better, still like it, but not as emotional this way.

  • absolutely love this version. and she isnt the only person that can possibly sing it.

  • If you like this version of the song, check out Imogen Heap's vBlog #27, from about 3m50 onwards, where she talks about it.

  • This version sucks. It was all good until she changed the harmony of the last part.

  • The original version used a harmonizer effect. She sang it exactly the same.

  • Either that or a vocoder.

  • Also, if you watch the live versions, she does sing it differently.

  • If true, that I feel like a bag of Skittles (R) now...

    She has a quirky kind of beauty

    Makes someone look closer, maybe as deep as her soul

    That is where her music comes from, I think?

    :)

  • I absolutely LOVE this right here very nice

  • <3 I love this......better than the original version

  • ditto

  • Incredible!

  • Comment removed

  • The original is better.this sounds like something to meditate to.

  • i like this version a lot

    the original i could live without

  • mmm...i do like this version. not as good as the original, but still good. I don't, however, like the video. i think it kind of takes away from the song a little :P

  • Why does she remind me of Sigourney Weaver in Ghostbusters? Not looks wise...it's just something. I like the original better though.

  • I can definitely meditate to this

  • the original is for me the better one of the two,

  • wow, this version gives the song a much more powerful effect. i think i may like it more than the original...

  • IMO it was OK but the "mm watcha say" (my favorite part) got Kilimanjaroed. However if I had heard this first before the original there is no doubt in my mind that my opinion would be totally different. Its so hard to beat the original that hearing this after the original is close to a disappointment.

  • hhahahahhaha it got kiliminjaroed ? LOL funny ass comment . halo 3 freak. funny cuz im waiting for my game to load right now. you got that from halo 3 right o.O if not . embarrassing much . ?

  • yeah i was going for that effect lmao MLIA cuz i havent gotten to ODST yet. But yea as for the topic, this version is very good but the original is so much better.

  • Can i have the MP3 of the song?

  • limewire dawg. . .its tha shiznit

  • the origanal is better, idk if its my phone, the vid., or its just true but she looks like a man i mean like shes post op. im jus sayin

  • Only, the original like you say uses the SAME video? :S

  • this song was actually made for a album called kids of Tibet or sumthing... many other artists contributed to the album

  • the original = better. like, MUCH better.

  • here's the jist... it's just a re-recording and this time she doesn't sound like a robot.. etc , good stuff i say

  • I may prefer this version.

  • Still prefer the original :)

  • Does anyone know the meaning behind the song? I keep thinking it is about domestic abuse.

  • my sister said it was about cheating but idk

  • On her Vlog, Imogen talks about this song and the vocals are completely new and re-recorded. This is not an amateur remix. The tone in the background is a mix between an instrument her mother gave her as a gift (its sort of like a mini-acordian). and the song is titled "Hide & Seek 2." That is the title she gave it.

  • the only difference is that the other one seems harmonized... both effin amazing nevertheless i didn't think i would keep coming back to a simple song like this, it seems like the more i listen to it the more i zone out into my imagination

  • the beginning was beautiful, but then it got bad after 2:50 Mmm whatcha say. Your ruined that part big time. But beautiful beautiful beginning job.

  • dude i love this!

  • Not the Original but still very good..

  • Thats why it says Hide and Seek 2 =_=

  • That's true :-)

  • PS: I love this version, especially the continuous piano note in the background. reminds me of the joker from the dark knightf or some reason lol

  • this isn't acoustic..

  • haha... i can see why you say that, but that is what this song is labeled on the cd, on itunes, and by Imogen Heap herself....

  • no it's not...

  • Amazing to hear this decompiled version of this epic song!

    Very interesting!

  • In my opinion this version is more monotonous than the original.

    's bad.

  • the only difference between the two is she isnt using her voice-vocoder.

  • If you actually listen to the song you'd notice that the singing tune is very much different.

  • its the same tune, with a second overlapped version of imogen harmonising herself

  • It's not the same tune, and there aren't harmonics everywhere, mostly it's just echoes of the lead.

    The fact that the tune is not the same most easily noticed during the "mmm what you say..." part.

    Trust me.

  • i thought a guy sung it ! I like the original more!

  • lolwut

  • i feel stupid, sicne when was imogen heap a person? i htought it was a band and by the original version i thought a guy sung it

  • Only I prefer the original version?

  • well... just incase none of u noticed... there isnt accoustic... it has no guitar... or any shit... haha

  • awesome

  • incantevole

  • id like to see utada hikaru sing this :3

  • No, I agree..I definitely like the original better. Sorry everyone..hate me if you must haha. If this version stood alone, it might be good, but look at what it's being compared to: the original that we all fell in love with, gonna be HARD TO TOP that.

    Regardless, she's a very talented musician! Hopefully she keeps songs like this coming out...

    Later.

  • This version, in my eyes, is so much better than the original.

  • This song is about when she had to move when she was a little girl.

    "oily marks appear on walls, where pleasure moments hung before the take over" talking about the pictures that were hung on the wall before being taken down.

    "crop circles in the carpet" -the indents from the furniture sitting on the carpet.

    "hmm. what did you say? you only meant well?" referring to moving somewhere else.

  • maybe the guys you hang out with sound like girls?kinda gay but whatever floats your boat . . .

  • This song just gets better and is so very moving. Imogen's talent knows no limits it seems!

  • it's about the holucost (sp?) very sad, but very true song.

  • I'm listening...

  • I think that's the beauty of music. Even if the artist intends for one meaning it could mean something completely different to the listener. There's an artist who uses her chorus as his chorus for song that is about him cheating.

  • FREE TIBET!!!

  • i like her music,she's brilliant and defnatly and individual in her music genre love u imogen

  • the final of this song is better

    "You dont dont dont care a bit"

    :D

  • both versions r beautiful in their own sublime ways

  • I like both versions! XD

  • The original is way better,

    she kinda sounds like a guy |:

  • how does she sound like a guy? ... really.

  • i thought that too

  • Yeah the original version makes me feel like Im gonna die one day and people said I lived a good life at my funeral. And Im not making fun of you.

  • shes kinda cute

  • wow....nice but the original version is better.

  • lol I know it doesn't mean anything..

    But I am trying to do a cover of it..

    It should be cool.. :]

    But sure, put thumbs down on me because you dont care to hear me. xD

  • Both versions are great in their own way.

  • i dont care which version is better. this version is absolutely beautiful. i love it.

  • yea the normal v is much better

  • I like the original cuz it sounds a little darker

  • coure its a girl u nmbskull, can u not see the video?

  • The normal one is much better :)

  • swag.

  • i believe i hear a bagpipe!!

  • You'd be surprised what it actually is! You can see it on her video blog v=KCVg82yvAoE at time 2m56s :-)

  • mmm watcha say sounded better first time around

  • no way. in this version its way better.

  • i have given her so much time but still i do not like her a bit.

  • impressive restructuring.

  • ,..superrrr...dzieki..

  • this is breathtaking.

  • i liked the aussie idol guy's acoustic version better.......

  • I prefer this version. even if it does make me a little blue hehe nice to listen to.

  • i do like the other version better, but this version rocks my whole world! its so raw and different! ah Imogen you never fail us!

  • just great, thx.

  • This version is so raw. I love it to death. The expression she has in her voice is outstanding.

  • couldnt say it better myself

  • This song is amazing!!!!I totally love it!!!:D:D:D

  • I like both versions!! Gosh I cannot decide which one I like better.

  • it's amazing that she sings without any accsent but she have a brittish-ish accsent

  • I like this version wayyy better! LOVE HER VOICE!!!

  • I love this song! I just don't know wich version is better

  • just download applian player. it lets you download any video posted on the internet lol. and you get the audio an the video

  • this song is amazing. i have listened to it many many times.

  • I just heard Love Is A Story's version of the first Hide and Seek. And it's atrocious.

  • I have to say i love this song so much I keep on playing it it make me feel good in side.

  • Me too :) Absolutely love it!

  • yeh.. what a moose. lets tell him to take it down so all these people cant get to hear this great song. yeh??

  • read the discription then you'll know what i mean

  • love is a story's version is..better xD

  • you do realize that imogen heap wrote this?

  • no, but, I'm not going to waste my time arguing

  • Yeah, the original is better.

    Love is a story's version i wouldn't even call a "cover" is a poor, cheap imitation.

  • cant we all just agree to disagree?

  • thank you EJY, for agreeing. love is a story added in drums and other bullshit that completely ruin the song. :D

  • I hear the song 800 times and i love it <3

    I dont know why, but the voice and the lyrics of Hide and Seek so Amazing *_*

  • This was nothing short of amazing. I didn't think it would be THIS good!

  • Raw and uncompromising, even more emotional than the original. An excellent improvement on a fantastic song.

  • hmm - think it may be time for a new optik version - didn't know it came without the vocoders

  • I'm just not entirely sure that this video works particularly well with this version of the song, great version though...great fucking song man

  • Kocham to ! :P

  • Comment removed

  • Intense indeed.

  • Intense!!!

  • Like Camping!!!!

  • Very intense!! : )

  • omg intense

  • I've probably already posted on this video, but I'm going to do it again anyway.

    What makes this version of this song different from the other is, primarily, the harmonies. In the other version (Hide and Seek 1), her harmonies are machine-made. In this one, she actually sang over her own voice and layered the tracks. The harmonies here are, as a result, tighter, yet more raw and emotional in nature. Far and above the best version of this song around.

  • So beautiful. Her vocals against a simple Carnatic drone. Favorite! Along with the originial.

  • Comment removed

  • orgasmic-ly good

  • I still laugh at "mmm watcha saa-aaay"

  • lmao it soudns funny in this version

  • "mmmmm thatcha only ment weeeeeeeeeeeeell"

    It's not as funny here though.

  • I know, and I hate it! It's such a beautiful and intense song and then the "mmm watcha saa-aay" comes and I snap out of my trance and burst into laughter.

  • *gun shot*

  • you retarded man. lol!!!

  • SNL's amazing wiff the soongs they have XD

  • Wow! Great version! I wonder if I don't like it better than the original... I'm going to buy it right now.

    Don't think I'll buy the whole compilation but this song defo, she did a great job with mixing her song with Buddhist monastery music, brilliant!

    Hopefully I'll get to see her live someday.