The music is better on Paulas version but as always she uses way too much auto tune where as kylie doesn't need too, if only the backing track was switched kylie's version would win hands down.
First, this one is very distorted (overloaded), and second, the music is performed terribly (without bass, etc.). Its a total K.O. for a song entitled: "I'm Just Here For The Music". I don't wonder why Kylie was not happy with it. (Though her singing is good - as always.)
Paula's version is correct, actually good. The bass line is in its place, and moves us to dance.
To be honest I prefer this version, Paula Abdul doesn't even sing and her version is too much flat and rigid. Don't get what is better about that one.
well here's a thing, paula abdul wrote Spinnig around for Kylie which made Kylie her comeback to the music scene in 2000 and so, i think that it's fair that paula sang one of kylie track that was suppose to be kylie's but it didn't happen.
In all honesty Paula pulled the song off better than Kylie, but I think Kylie has the better voice. As for performance, I think Paula's way better in choreo and stuff but I mean Kylie's also good at putting on a show, so I don't really care. The problem I have is the song itself, I don't see it being a hit. I think it was good of Paula to not release a video for it. I mean, compare this to Straight Up... .Straight Up is like 20 years old and 20 times better than this.
My two cents - Paula was a bit better with this song, even though Kylie is a far superior singer/performer. Overall, this is a crap song - it won't be on the ipod.
Paula doesn't know what to do. If you listen to Paula's version you can listen to the base of the song (the base is from FIVE, the song If Ya Getting Down) so Paula has not imagination at all. Covering a Kylie song and stealing FIVE's base of that song. Paula, you better keep it in your closet! Kylie's version is the original one and remember that this song is a DEMO. Kylie's 1000 times better.
@MrBubuni According to Wikipedia the Paula Abdul version samples Indeep's 1982 hit 'last night a DJ saved my life' and the Wikipedia page about the song strangely makes no mention of the base from the five song 'if ya getting down' which is odd. I'm guessing it means that Paula samples both the base line of 'if ya getting down' and 'last night a DJ saved my life' in her version, although I've only heard Kylie's version and not Paula's version.
@MrBubuni I've now listened to Paula's version here on youtube and it does sound very similar to 'last nigh a DJ saved my life' but I couldn't hear 'if ya getting down' in there too which is odd.
"In 1997, Paula Abdul co-wrote "Spinning Around" along with fellow American Idol judge, Kara DioGuardi; a dance-pop track intended to be the lead single off her new album. The album never materialized and "Spinning Around" was given to Kylie Minogue as a single. The song became highly successful and re-launched Kylie Minogue's career"
So now its pretty much vise versa in 2003 Kylie recorded a song that didnt make it on her record and gave it to Paula which is now re-launching Paula's career.
Fuck it, both versions are great in their own respective way. Kylie's has a more retro 80's-Sheila E. groove to it, where as Paula's has a slutronica-shake your ass vibe. Either way, they both make me wanna contort all over the dance floor like a cheap and easy whore! Can a ho get a MP3, pretty please!?
u guys r just haters, kylie is great, but her version is not as cool and enjoyable as paula's, she worked out the song way better, and i'm no trying to say i don't like kylie, but think about this, paula and kara dioguardi wrote "can't get you out of my head" for her, it was about time for her to give paula thanks with a cool song, and there u go. just enjoy music, don't fuck with kylie or paula, they're great, remember that paula saved kylie's career back then, now right back at her.
In my opinion... I prefer Kylie's version. I've known of Kylie's version for a couples years now and when I think of this song, I associate Kylie to it. That's my opinion.. Respect my opinion as I respect yours.
i like kylie's better, but the song itself is terrible. at 47(?) paula abdul should not be singing about making out and turning guys on. i give kudos to kylie for ditching this song.
I'm with you, this is really just a bad song no matter who sings it. If forced, I'd pick this one over Paula's but I really hate them both about equally.
Kudos to Paula though, if at 47, she can still turn the guys on at the bar! ;-)
You all are insanely rude. Paula can sing live just look up her "Under My Spell Tour" right here on youtube. I like both kylie's and paula's version. Kylie can sing...Paula can sing.
obviously you have never heard kylie perform live?? becuz it is INSANE...oh and LIVE!!! wtf was that hot mess that paula performed on IDOL?? never showed her mouth and singing with 2 mics (yes i know one was a prop..the one attached to her the whole time. LOL) but seriously, kyle is an amazing performer live and releases crazy amounts of hits after hits. let paula have this single that kylie never released...afterall, she's gonna need some help to get her "career" back on track.
Cough, cough, Paula, cough, cough. Paula is always better in my eye. Love Paula's version!
SmartgirlA 3 months ago
The music is better on Paulas version but as always she uses way too much auto tune where as kylie doesn't need too, if only the backing track was switched kylie's version would win hands down.
iggsey82 3 months ago
First, this one is very distorted (overloaded), and second, the music is performed terribly (without bass, etc.). Its a total K.O. for a song entitled: "I'm Just Here For The Music". I don't wonder why Kylie was not happy with it. (Though her singing is good - as always.)
Paula's version is correct, actually good. The bass line is in its place, and moves us to dance.
Kylie2011DcsabaS 4 months ago
...
ameran08 8 months ago
Paula's song is better. Sorry, Kylie.
itismarco 9 months ago
Paula's all the way
ldlax17 9 months ago
To be honest I prefer this version, Paula Abdul doesn't even sing and her version is too much flat and rigid. Don't get what is better about that one.
ThoughtfulShiryu 11 months ago
@saula01 I Agree With You Paula's Version Is Better
CrazyRockstarNear 1 year ago
i like paula verison this one sucks and plus kylie minougue dont sound good she cant sing
AprilLovesPaula 1 year ago
well here's a thing, paula abdul wrote Spinnig around for Kylie which made Kylie her comeback to the music scene in 2000 and so, i think that it's fair that paula sang one of kylie track that was suppose to be kylie's but it didn't happen.
thisiswan2009 1 year ago
haha paula's version is wwaaaaayyyyy better than kylie's lol.. Love Paula Abdul!!! (:
iiMNKii 1 year ago
@iiMNKii lprefer this....
Arttir25 1 year ago
how come when Kylie sings it, it kind of sounds slower. Paula's is a bit better.
HLFBRD89 1 year ago
both version are great...I LOVE PAULA , I LOVE SO MUCH KYLIE
itsmixtape 1 year ago
I really enjoyed Paula Abdul's arrangement of this, but I think Kylie is the better singer of the two.
KDMatt 1 year ago
Yeh both versions are bad :)
UKLadNathan89 1 year ago
paulas waay better
Besties4Ever24 1 year ago
This is way better than paulas version. go kylie
kyliesboy1 1 year ago
@kyliesboy1 paulas better
2glittergirls21 1 year ago 2
In all honesty Paula pulled the song off better than Kylie, but I think Kylie has the better voice. As for performance, I think Paula's way better in choreo and stuff but I mean Kylie's also good at putting on a show, so I don't really care. The problem I have is the song itself, I don't see it being a hit. I think it was good of Paula to not release a video for it. I mean, compare this to Straight Up... .Straight Up is like 20 years old and 20 times better than this.
antionidept 2 years ago 2
i like paula better but she is still very good
AlyssaLav246 2 years ago 3
yeah love kylie to death but paula's version is way better.
remylang25 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This song sucks
atrayu90602 2 years ago
My two cents - Paula was a bit better with this song, even though Kylie is a far superior singer/performer. Overall, this is a crap song - it won't be on the ipod.
shaunwitten 2 years ago 2
I prefer Kylie to Paula but I must admit I think Paula did the song more justice.
19GayFace93 2 years ago 11
BOOO paulas version is a lot better
adamlambertfan321 2 years ago 3
@adamlambertfan321 thanks u !!! i know paula is 100xs better
2glittergirls21 1 year ago 2
kylie did it better !!
ankitsharmaisme 2 years ago
uhm. i died.
Zinsery 2 years ago 3
Paula's version is sooo much better
makann15 2 years ago 2
i think singing wise kylie is better but paula has definately put some charm
hasn100 2 years ago 5
I love Kylie loads!! I went to see her, but i prefer Paula's version.
xHorseLoverX08 2 years ago 5
kylie singing is better than paula paula is so much flat if u really focus!!!
hasn100 2 years ago
no offence but paula sings it better it than kylie
megantan789 2 years ago 2
Wow this sucks. Paula Abdul did so much better than this shit.
livelovePJA 2 years ago
Paula doesn't know what to do. If you listen to Paula's version you can listen to the base of the song (the base is from FIVE, the song If Ya Getting Down) so Paula has not imagination at all. Covering a Kylie song and stealing FIVE's base of that song. Paula, you better keep it in your closet! Kylie's version is the original one and remember that this song is a DEMO. Kylie's 1000 times better.
MrBubuni 2 years ago
@MrBubuni According to Wikipedia the Paula Abdul version samples Indeep's 1982 hit 'last night a DJ saved my life' and the Wikipedia page about the song strangely makes no mention of the base from the five song 'if ya getting down' which is odd. I'm guessing it means that Paula samples both the base line of 'if ya getting down' and 'last night a DJ saved my life' in her version, although I've only heard Kylie's version and not Paula's version.
7039TS 1 year ago
@MrBubuni I've now listened to Paula's version here on youtube and it does sound very similar to 'last nigh a DJ saved my life' but I couldn't hear 'if ya getting down' in there too which is odd.
7039TS 1 year ago
i L-O-V-E Kylie, but i think Paula did better.
DudinhaMeloSaulaFan 2 years ago
Paula's version is waaaay better
DudinhaMeloSaulaFan 2 years ago
paula's version is better...kylie's is techno and stuff
PaulaFanxxx1 2 years ago
Too crunchy... it kills my ears :(
Wow, finally an unreleased Kylie track I don't like!
LadyLottimort 2 years ago
i love both equally, they're my idols, but Paula's version just tops this one
number1paulaabdulfan 2 years ago
paulas is sooo better
xniks101x 2 years ago 3
Kylie's DEMO sounds better than Paula's SHIT SINGLE.
ec2031 2 years ago
"In 1997, Paula Abdul co-wrote "Spinning Around" along with fellow American Idol judge, Kara DioGuardi; a dance-pop track intended to be the lead single off her new album. The album never materialized and "Spinning Around" was given to Kylie Minogue as a single. The song became highly successful and re-launched Kylie Minogue's career"
So now its pretty much vise versa in 2003 Kylie recorded a song that didnt make it on her record and gave it to Paula which is now re-launching Paula's career.
RandyGauthier 2 years ago
Fuck it, both versions are great in their own respective way. Kylie's has a more retro 80's-Sheila E. groove to it, where as Paula's has a slutronica-shake your ass vibe. Either way, they both make me wanna contort all over the dance floor like a cheap and easy whore! Can a ho get a MP3, pretty please!?
hebleedsglitter 2 years ago 3
Slutronica... hahaha. That's classic. :P
LadyLottimort 2 years ago
They're both great performers, but I just really think Paula's version is much better. =)
dancestar05 2 years ago
Is that Meryl Streep at 0:29?
spellher 2 years ago
Yeaaa it is(L)
kminogue123 2 years ago
Im sorry Kylie as much as i love you i like paula's version its more energizing than this one.
MissAmericanIdol123 2 years ago
Love Paula's!
SoulAndRnBFan 2 years ago
u guys r just haters, kylie is great, but her version is not as cool and enjoyable as paula's, she worked out the song way better, and i'm no trying to say i don't like kylie, but think about this, paula and kara dioguardi wrote "can't get you out of my head" for her, it was about time for her to give paula thanks with a cool song, and there u go. just enjoy music, don't fuck with kylie or paula, they're great, remember that paula saved kylie's career back then, now right back at her.
RenIchigoku 2 years ago
kara and Paula didn't write "can't get you out of my head" for her...
it was Cathy Dennis who wrote it....
TheBadMagnetics 2 years ago 2
Paula wrote "Spinning Around"
spellher 2 years ago
Uh, Paula and Kara wrote "Spinning Around" not "Can't Get You Out of My Head"
antionidept 2 years ago
In my opinion... I prefer Kylie's version. I've known of Kylie's version for a couples years now and when I think of this song, I associate Kylie to it. That's my opinion.. Respect my opinion as I respect yours.
caliboiblu 2 years ago 2
i like kylie's better, but the song itself is terrible. at 47(?) paula abdul should not be singing about making out and turning guys on. i give kudos to kylie for ditching this song.
darlingdan 2 years ago
I'm with you, this is really just a bad song no matter who sings it. If forced, I'd pick this one over Paula's but I really hate them both about equally.
Kudos to Paula though, if at 47, she can still turn the guys on at the bar! ;-)
FriarFred82 2 years ago
Paula's was much better!
keithey77 2 years ago
You all are insanely rude. Paula can sing live just look up her "Under My Spell Tour" right here on youtube. I like both kylie's and paula's version. Kylie can sing...Paula can sing.
Lipscombe23 2 years ago 4
paula cant sing. she cant SING live. kylie CAN sing LIVE. PERIOD.
rejohnny17 2 years ago
Paula's version is wayyyy better.
DJMusic16 2 years ago
sorry but i like paula's version, i think paula's version was more lively and enjoyable..
yoshino0611 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
First of all paula is a man
second she is syrian
third she have a dick
forth she have hair all over her chest
and over her dick
fifth she have credit crunch
sixth she look like the rabay fucking his mom
so how could a person have all this sing better then kylie
SexxxAndTheCity 2 years ago
she needs to stick with her vibeology...her V-I-B-E-ology!!
arrowbrooke 2 years ago
obviously you have never heard kylie perform live?? becuz it is INSANE...oh and LIVE!!! wtf was that hot mess that paula performed on IDOL?? never showed her mouth and singing with 2 mics (yes i know one was a prop..the one attached to her the whole time. LOL) but seriously, kyle is an amazing performer live and releases crazy amounts of hits after hits. let paula have this single that kylie never released...afterall, she's gonna need some help to get her "career" back on track.
arrowbrooke 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
who the hell is Paula Abdul???
CruiseControl09 2 years ago
paula abdul is sooo much better than kylie in the way that paula can actually sing this song or any other
better
GO PAULA YOU RULE
abbz1900 2 years ago
no offense but kylie sounds like a robot. just saying.
PearleGoalie 2 years ago
i like Paula's version better. Less techno in it.
DuCaineFan 2 years ago 2
paula sins better than kyile.....paula is way better!
barajas9878 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Paula it's awful!!! first boombox then this!! Kylie obviously it's better than her!!! i hate paula abdul!! ihate her!! it's a bitch!!
eduardoalejandrito 2 years ago
kylie and paula are both good.
StevieGuy07 2 years ago 4
kylie is better than the bitch! kylie rules but paula ruins!
hydehan17 2 years ago
It's a bad song no matter who sings it. Certainly not single material.
8eight8 2 years ago
i have to agree this is aweful. paula is WAY better
kagomegirl021 2 years ago 4
its just a really shit song, neither vocals save it. thank god Kylie had the sense to ditch it.
richh18 2 years ago
Paula is way way better than kyile :D
1234567890ghghghghgh 2 years ago 4
are u tone deaf???
absolutelebanon 2 years ago
um, i think you are tone deaf, kylie isnt very good. paula is MUCH better. and thats that
PearleGoalie 2 years ago
No im not tone deaf ,it doesnt take a genius to work out paula is way better :D
1234567890ghghghghgh 2 years ago