There is a bit of a mistranslation that leads many to believe Crona is a boy; Crona is not a boy nor is Crona a girl. The literal translation would be much closer to 'it.' The problem is that calling a person an it is rather offensive and awkward to fit into dialogue, so the various translations instead use the default 'he' due to the convenience of the word. I myself interchange the pronouns depending on the circumstance. However, until Ōkubo confirms this matter no one is correct.
FUCK! If I hear one more comment on any videos about Crona due to his gender I'm gonna flip! In the manga he was a girl, the Jap vers a boy, then a girl, then a he/she, the Eng, he was a boy. Okay? Evolve into a higher species already you piles of trash! He's a boy for my opinion, but I must admit I think it was planned he was originally a girl. I say boy, you say girl, I say cool, because I don't care. FUCK! NOW SHUT UP! Anyway, fab vid fucking amazing, you kick ass!
@Mustard0981 Only in the ENGLISH remake of the anime. That is my belief too, personally, I think he is also a boy. For the sake of some things however, I often make him a girl
man.... fucking crona is just amazing!!!! love the mystery of cronas gender. and don't fucking reply this comment with ur gender bullshit. gender is nothing but a left wing conspiracy hoax made by the government to take my hard earned money to... fucking hermaphrodites.
otherwise, good job on the AMV! i liked this one alot, it was well thought out. congratulatioons on your first AMV! till later, pip pip cherrio! from nick of "the 2 stupid brits"! and from "the randomly insane alchemist"!
well, technically, crana is still a girl in the english version, this is because any asset of the original show never changes due to simple small errors in the translation of the words from japanese to english, the translations are never entierly perfect. her gender doesn't change just because of a transfer in the language she's speaking. it's not that hard to figure out.
ey can somebody tell me ..is crona a boy or a girl?? in the german tv it is said crona is a boy...in the i-net its said crona is a girl???...what does the mangas says?? i cant remember..please helt me :) <3
Me and my friend like Crona being genderless. Gender doesn't matter with him/her/it. The beauty is that he/she/it can make everything really gay or really straight. It's out here for our imaginations, and we can ship him/her/it in any pairing we want. Nice video, btw. I love this pairing ^-^
Guys, cool your beans. Crona is a heshe everyone gets to pick which one they like better. I personally like him (or her x'3) as a boy. It's all very confusing. I liked the video, and despite the gender, this song fits well! Even better if Crona turns out to be a girl.
"Hermaphrodite"? First time I ever heard this word.
But seriously: do you guys know that about at the age of 16-18, how uch Crona will suffer because of that? This genderless state is one of the biggest flaws of Soul-Eater.
Like all of us. But this transsexual middle-state is not only disturbing. That wouldn't be a problem. BUT IT IS ALSO ANNOYING, POINTLESS AND CREATES JUST MORE UNFINISHED-UNWORKEDOUT CONFLICT. This anime is half-finished. Like most animes usually are.
@qwuezalothus FUCK YOU most animes are not half finished!!!! i admit it was lazy not giving crona a gender but that doesnt make it HALF ASSED AND MOST ANIMES ARE NOT HALF ASSED EITHER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@sharbyakugon2 im really sorry, I know this was 2 whole months ago but BELIEVE me when I say some animes are half-assed XD soul eater is, but of course, not.
@qwuezalothus It could be worse, in the manga Chrona gets put back on Shinigami's list and officially hunted by Spartoi. only good part about this is that Chrona gets retribution on Medusa for all the pain and suffering she caused. Medusa undone by her own creation. IRONY!
as for the gender issue, I think Chrona's so cute that girl or boy I'd bang that in a heart beat! *grabs Chrona and drags to Mister Cor-ner.* shhhhhh, its going to be okay.
As an adult, I realised that an anime can never be better, then the manga. Only in a few sapects, but never entirely. Anime's are nothing more, than marketingproducts for TV-studios.
@qwuezalothus Get a life. People are driven by this stupid need to categorise EVERYTHING. Sometimes it's okay to not put something in a little slot with a word above it.
There are people out there who don't fit into gender roles, and they do just fine. How can transsexuality be disturbing when it's so fascinating and beautiful?
fascinating maybe, but if we think of it as a story - nothing more or less -, than it will lead to thing, cause things. Crona Makenshi will eventually grow up, and has to face this, not just as fact, but as social problem. And in a story, a human being, especially someone with a soul like Crona, will surely suffer because of this. She was born this way, and no mather how you put it, her state of gender... is abnormal.
@VoodooSyndrome Ya Crona is my favorite charater in the show I dont care the he/she has no set gender I think it makes it a funnier charater to play around with. Crona is kind of like Ed from cowboy bebop inless you really watch closely you cant really tell what gender she is and it makes her fun to watch.
@qwuezalothus Have you really never heard that word? They don't use that term anymore, but it comes from the Greek deities Hermes and Aphrodite. It used to be used to describe transgender people.
0:00 soul face!!!
TheCron32 1 month ago
I new when i clicked on this video that all the comments would be about if crona was a girl or a boy... sigh...
selise17 1 month ago 2
chrono is a fuckin girl people i've dome the god damn reserch
dragonsrule61398 1 month ago
i like the first pic of pissed of crona, it is funny and a good way to start out a video. XD
nemuanimation 2 months ago
Lol ragnarok is chronas boyfreind XD
Sw33tDani3 2 months ago
maka did kiss a girl/boy snice chrona's gender hasn't been said really ! only we saw soul's face if maka sang this *sighs* !
Lovesmorethan1anime 2 months ago
lol someone should really make a vid of kid and crona with "i kissed a boy: x'D (its perfect since we dont know what gender crona is lol)
TsubakiYakani 3 months ago
There is a bit of a mistranslation that leads many to believe Crona is a boy; Crona is not a boy nor is Crona a girl. The literal translation would be much closer to 'it.' The problem is that calling a person an it is rather offensive and awkward to fit into dialogue, so the various translations instead use the default 'he' due to the convenience of the word. I myself interchange the pronouns depending on the circumstance. However, until Ōkubo confirms this matter no one is correct.
Brutalyte616 3 months ago 4
this is a fucking awesome video!
myworldmyrules100 3 months ago
FUCK! If I hear one more comment on any videos about Crona due to his gender I'm gonna flip! In the manga he was a girl, the Jap vers a boy, then a girl, then a he/she, the Eng, he was a boy. Okay? Evolve into a higher species already you piles of trash! He's a boy for my opinion, but I must admit I think it was planned he was originally a girl. I say boy, you say girl, I say cool, because I don't care. FUCK! NOW SHUT UP! Anyway, fab vid fucking amazing, you kick ass!
UnableToBleed 3 months ago
@UnableToBleed crona is a boy
Mustard0981 3 months ago
@Mustard0981 Only in the ENGLISH remake of the anime. That is my belief too, personally, I think he is also a boy. For the sake of some things however, I often make him a girl
UnableToBleed 3 months ago
man.... fucking crona is just amazing!!!! love the mystery of cronas gender. and don't fucking reply this comment with ur gender bullshit. gender is nothing but a left wing conspiracy hoax made by the government to take my hard earned money to... fucking hermaphrodites.
hgdge 3 months ago
Y'know, I'd like this... If Crona wasn't a boy.
flippysshotgun666 3 months ago
Can I just say I love what you've done and I'm not critizing :)
But in the manga and anime Chrona's gender is unknown :3
Love it though :D
strawberry090496 3 months ago
Despite Chrona being a boy, THIS FUCKING ROCKS!
UnableToBleed 3 months ago 2
I ship Maka x Crona( as a guy ) XDD
TokkaFan41 3 months ago
Who cares if Chrona is a girll or boy? CHRONAXMAKKA 4 EVERRRRR
FawnyPunkPanda 3 months ago
@FawnyPunkPanda crona is a boy in anime but in manga is he a girl...so for me is he a boy but:))) SOULXMAKA 4 evvverer
TheBlackPrinsses23 3 months ago
otherwise, good job on the AMV! i liked this one alot, it was well thought out. congratulatioons on your first AMV! till later, pip pip cherrio! from nick of "the 2 stupid brits"! and from "the randomly insane alchemist"!
the2britts 4 months ago
well, technically, crana is still a girl in the english version, this is because any asset of the original show never changes due to simple small errors in the translation of the words from japanese to english, the translations are never entierly perfect. her gender doesn't change just because of a transfer in the language she's speaking. it's not that hard to figure out.
the2britts 4 months ago
@the2britts He doesn't have a gender lol. The creator doesn't even know. I just think Chrona's a guy XD But that's just me.
TokkaFan41 3 months ago
:3 ............*claps*
TsubakiYakani 5 months ago
OMG! seriosly Crona is a boy, get your facts right
MrKrazyKupcakes 5 months ago
ehohoaehfsduofguiorfguiero
PEOPLE
Chrona is whatever gender he/she wants to be
Hush and enjoy the video
It's just a TV show
HONESTLY~~
ValFilppulaRocks51 6 months ago
i loved this vid till i found out wat u were saying
crona not chrona is a boy not a fucking girl so if u got a problem
talk to me!!!!!!!
bunnery515 6 months ago
crona is genderless. no arguement.
123456patches 6 months ago
ps. really good video :)
EmoAtzin 6 months ago
ey can somebody tell me ..is crona a boy or a girl?? in the german tv it is said crona is a boy...in the i-net its said crona is a girl???...what does the mangas says?? i cant remember..please helt me :) <3
EmoAtzin 6 months ago
i loved it haha good job!
sapphiremoon23 6 months ago
Awesome video love the song!Hey are you interested in Visting my Youtube channel! that if you find this comment! Thanks
Envylover24 6 months ago
Comment removed
Envylover24 6 months ago
Comment removed
Envylover24 6 months ago
GUYS. SERIOUSLY? CRONA IS A GIRRLLL!!! she dont belong w/ maka, soul belongs w/ maka !!
Laurenx781 6 months ago
Crona is Medusa's Daughter .......
omegazeroleegmail 6 months ago
I want Chrona as a boy :(
HelloImKeila 6 months ago
CRONA IS A HE/SHE
supercutehanachan 6 months ago
Boy Boy Boy f***ing Biy CRONA IS AN F'ING BOY
MewHugz 6 months ago
CRONA IS A BOY EVEN SEARCH ON YOUTUBE PROOF CRONA IS A BOY HE IS ONLY CONSIDERED A GIRL IN THE JAP VERSION OF SOUL EATER >:(
vanillacupcake286 6 months ago
@vanillacupcake286 YEAH ONLY CONSIDERED A GIRL IN THE ORIGINAL SERIES YOU KNOW, LIKE THE ORIGINAL SERIES. THE GENUINE ONE. HURRR
VoodooSyndrome 6 months ago 14
@VoodooSyndrome Actually in the original series the creator said "It's your choice."
VideoGamer869 5 months ago
@VoodooSyndrome not to be rude, but even in the jap version they reffer to crona as a boy, but i dont really care
coolnaruto56 3 months ago
@vanillacupcake286 YEAH ONLY CONSIDERED A GIRL IN THE ORIGINAL SERIES YOU KNOW, LIKE THE ORIGINAL SERIES. THE GENUINE ONE. HURRR
VoodooSyndrome 6 months ago 6
@VoodooSyndrome he is a dude in the jap (just a girl dose his voice)
mymusicvideo1 6 months ago
@vanillacupcake286 if crona is a girl in the orginal verson she is a girl
benjaminNH 5 months ago
@vanillacupcake286 they say the creator of the manga never even decided crona's gender
I like the idea that crona's a boy but you don't have to pick it up and SHOVE IN PEOPLES FACES. :U lol
NadiaEveStudio 4 months ago
@vanillacupcake286 Yah this originally was made in Japan the english version came out you stupid idiot Chrona is a girl
sonicwolf102 2 months ago
@vanillacupcake286 it's called Crona's to awesome for a gender! Who agrees?
MyBloodIsMyTears 2 months ago
@vanillacupcake286 Caplocks Rage!!!!!
TheSoundwave1234 2 months ago
crona is not a girl
spotabc123 6 months ago
Me and my friend like Crona being genderless. Gender doesn't matter with him/her/it. The beauty is that he/she/it can make everything really gay or really straight. It's out here for our imaginations, and we can ship him/her/it in any pairing we want. Nice video, btw. I love this pairing ^-^
KneeSocksEaterXD 8 months ago 2
crona can't deal with kissing a girl!
amy3lmo 9 months ago
Guys, cool your beans. Crona is a heshe everyone gets to pick which one they like better. I personally like him (or her x'3) as a boy. It's all very confusing. I liked the video, and despite the gender, this song fits well! Even better if Crona turns out to be a girl.
TwistedSenseOfHumor 10 months ago
i lovee 0:24
shuantea 11 months ago
"Hermaphrodite"? First time I ever heard this word.
But seriously: do you guys know that about at the age of 16-18, how uch Crona will suffer because of that? This genderless state is one of the biggest flaws of Soul-Eater.
qwuezalothus 1 year ago 14
@qwuezalothus GENDER DOESNT MATTER BECAUSE CRONA CAN BE WHATEVER SHE/HE WANTS
SEXY ALL AROUND. I CALL IT AN ASSET BRO
VoodooSyndrome 11 months ago 37
@VoodooSyndrome
Like all of us. But this transsexual middle-state is not only disturbing. That wouldn't be a problem. BUT IT IS ALSO ANNOYING, POINTLESS AND CREATES JUST MORE UNFINISHED-UNWORKEDOUT CONFLICT. This anime is half-finished. Like most animes usually are.
qwuezalothus 11 months ago
@qwuezalothus I think you're getting a little too worked up honestly. oh well, not everyone can be a genderless entity of the cosmos
VoodooSyndrome 11 months ago 11
@qwuezalothus FUCK YOU most animes are not half finished!!!! i admit it was lazy not giving crona a gender but that doesnt make it HALF ASSED AND MOST ANIMES ARE NOT HALF ASSED EITHER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
sharbyakugon2 11 months ago
@sharbyakugon2
Oh no? Than answer me a few questions, even if they seem obvious:
- Are Marie and Crona put back to Shibusen?
- Do we ever get to meet Crona's father or Maka's mother?
- How is the crisis is changing things inside Shibusen?
- If Crona will be somewhat older, will the child have or can DESIDE the own gender?
- Will Kid has to become successor as Deathgod (Shinigami) one day?
- Will Marie and Stein stay together?
- And Soul and Maka?
- Will Shibusen have rival-schools?
qwuezalothus 11 months ago
@qwuezalothus yes, yes (in my continuation plot), ?, he is a guy in the anime and a girl in the manga, yes, possibly, i hope so, and no
sharbyakugon2 9 months ago
@sharbyakugon2 im really sorry, I know this was 2 whole months ago but BELIEVE me when I say some animes are half-assed XD soul eater is, but of course, not.
aqua4land 8 months ago
@qwuezalothus It could be worse, in the manga Chrona gets put back on Shinigami's list and officially hunted by Spartoi. only good part about this is that Chrona gets retribution on Medusa for all the pain and suffering she caused. Medusa undone by her own creation. IRONY!
as for the gender issue, I think Chrona's so cute that girl or boy I'd bang that in a heart beat! *grabs Chrona and drags to Mister Cor-ner.* shhhhhh, its going to be okay.
AnimeShinigami13 6 months ago
@AnimeShinigami13
As an adult, I realised that an anime can never be better, then the manga. Only in a few sapects, but never entirely. Anime's are nothing more, than marketingproducts for TV-studios.
qwuezalothus 6 months ago
@qwuezalothus Get a life. People are driven by this stupid need to categorise EVERYTHING. Sometimes it's okay to not put something in a little slot with a word above it.
There are people out there who don't fit into gender roles, and they do just fine. How can transsexuality be disturbing when it's so fascinating and beautiful?
Mouseagent 4 months ago
@Mouseagent
fascinating maybe, but if we think of it as a story - nothing more or less -, than it will lead to thing, cause things. Crona Makenshi will eventually grow up, and has to face this, not just as fact, but as social problem. And in a story, a human being, especially someone with a soul like Crona, will surely suffer because of this. She was born this way, and no mather how you put it, her state of gender... is abnormal.
qwuezalothus 4 months ago
@qwuezalothus Your clearly not looking deep enough into the whole genderless thing :O
Theres more to it than it just being a randomly unfisished thing in the anime because its also like that in the manga.
strawberry090496 3 months ago
@VoodooSyndrome cronas a boy dude
MartinBoi111 8 months ago 2
@VoodooSyndrome
AkasunaNoTayuya 6 months ago
@VoodooSyndrome Ya Crona is my favorite charater in the show I dont care the he/she has no set gender I think it makes it a funnier charater to play around with. Crona is kind of like Ed from cowboy bebop inless you really watch closely you cant really tell what gender she is and it makes her fun to watch.
trentsims 4 months ago
@qwuezalothus
Frankly, that's the least of Chrona's problems. He must have YEARS of therapy in front of ...in store for...whatever.
MQuinny1234 11 months ago
@qwuezalothus Have you really never heard that word? They don't use that term anymore, but it comes from the Greek deities Hermes and Aphrodite. It used to be used to describe transgender people.
MegaRandomPanda 8 months ago
@MegaRandomPanda
That was almost half a year ago. I know today exactly, what it means.
qwuezalothus 8 months ago
@qwuezalothus Oh, ok. I tend to not pay any attention to the dates, so it's like I just assume that they're all recent or something, lol.
MegaRandomPanda 8 months ago
Okay children calm down. Chrona is hemphrodite! Then the people who think Chrona is a girl or vise versa gets both! XD
narutofan6781 1 year ago
CHRONA =BOY
IS NOT A GIRL
AlessiaCool 1 year ago
@AlessiaCool the manga never spesifyed nither did the anime. but i do agree cus he is too strange
abbieains 1 year ago
Crona has an Mangina! There.....That......Solves it.
emogirl123emo 1 year ago
Crona: *SOBBING* I kissed a girl.. :C
Maka: And I liked it >:(
BunnyBabyGirl33 1 year ago 40
I know how to settle this - Chrona is a HERMAPHRODITE! :D
flyingvfactorchick 1 year ago 4
chrona = boy
bebeberry109 1 year ago
@bebeberry109
Actually, Medusa refers to Crona as her daughter in the series several times. However, her gender is purposely ambiguous.
lotrpippen 1 year ago 2
@lotrpippen in the manga cronas a girl in the anime cronas a boy you cant always relie on fan sub....
tifftigershark 1 year ago
@lotrpippen That's not true, whenever Crona is mentioned, they don't use specific japanese gender prefixes. They say it literally, as an "it".
ihateyouperson 1 year ago
Good one,ya beat me to making this.5/5
ArisaThePKMNtrainer 1 year ago
Liked Souls smile. "Nah, I don't mind."
PhantomDark221 1 year ago 38
Great!
Moloci 1 year ago
i like it =D 5/5
jstails 2 years ago
I don't have it in me to disown you for using this song. D:
KoganeAirisu 2 years ago