Tenth Doctor/Rose Should I Stay?

[plumster80]

amazing!!!!

[JessieBlueForever]

I love this. And I'll bet the three dislikes for this clip are from Martha, Donna, and Jack wishing the Doctor was singing this to them instead.

[MEGAXSTU]

Well done!

[Torfindra]

This is a brilliant video, thank you very much for creating this.

[SuperAngelfish9]

Beautiful song, beautiful video!!

Maybe its just me, but it seems some of this could be applied to Martha and the Doctor too...U know, with Martha singing to the Doctor...

[bg922]

LOVE IT!!!!!!

[iXiaoMei]

Totally what I thought when I watched the Blackpool clip.

[metzi1981]

beautiful!! 

[DTis2SEXY]

this song makes me cry all the time! :'(

[YamiRemus]

Mwahahaha...I just watched Blackppool and I was SURE someone would have made a video with Doctor and Rose and this song!!! I'm glad I was right...! It was very nice indeed~

[Elishamarie28]

@YamiRemus Thanks!

[lenihanfighter]

The ending was a bit abrupt, but otherwise... GREAT movie you got here. :O I love how you managed to combine David singing from Blackpool together with shots from Doctor Who. That's just... Amazing!

Very nicely done, five stars and no doubt about it.

[Elishamarie28]

@lenihanfighter Thank you!

[rcijeg]

this is the third video I've found featureing this song. they are all good ,but my fav one is the one from Blackpool!! what a love story!!!

[charmedfan121]

very good video x x

[kt27rule]

i so lvoe this video it so cute and sweet

[n39smm]

I love the song choice! Great idea!

Actually gave me a video idea, I'll have to get on that :)

5 stars! <3

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks so much! :)

[Amba111]

whats the first few words spoken?

Hard to understand :P

[Elishamarie28]

I feel like I've been waiting for you...For this. :)

[saxuality3]

Great video! Combined two of my favorite things: "Doctor Who" and "Blackpool"!!! Kudos!!!

Cheers! ~Cassie

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you!

[kt27rule]

i love thsi video it so cute and sweet

[goddessportia]

Awesome! Love David doing vocals....

[DoctorWho2008]

This video is so well put together and I actually forgot he'd sung this ... great vid XD!

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks!

[leela104]

Ok. If I haven't commented this I'm an absolute dodo.

But it seems I haven't so here it goes.

The moment of truth.

I LOVED IT

[Elishamarie28]

Great, thank you! :)

[SilAquarius]

brilliant video!

[TheDoctorLoveForever]

Beautiful. His voice is amazing, hes so sweet :)

Love it.

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks!

[jimandsteveadventure]

Holy cow! Great video! Loved it! David sings rather well!

[kt27rule]

i lov ehtis video it so cute and sweet

[GlitterGlobe08]

Excellent and lovely video! Made me tear up! David's singing is brilliant and sweet. <3

[rosieposie123xp]

when he says "maybe i'm getting in your way" doesn't it sound a bit like he's going to say "maybe i'm gay"? fantastic vid aswell. nice one :D

[xXxXxcozzaxXxXx]

hehe i thought that aswell :P

[scissorhandslove9]

Haha I first thought that too!

[kittenspit]

*GASP* I freaking love this song! (Mostly when David helps sing it!) His eyes! *melts* Great editing! You are AMAZERING!!! *SQUEE*

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you! :D

[klupinwerewolf123]

3rd place, well done! i loved this one so much!! i couldn't get the song and David singing out of my head for days afterwards! I love it: it fits, its clever, its emotional and very good!

[prettykitty007]

wow ! Amazing ! What software and effects do you use ??? when the two clips are together ?

[dbvixxen]

I'm going to guess that they use Sony Vegas, but it's possible it could also be Adobe Premiere or Final Cut Pro. They seem to be the most popular of the more complicated editing programs, and they all can do that effect. :)

[xxDalekBreadxx]

wahhey!!! he sings too! gotta love 'im :P

[Lanajayb]

i love this vid :)) and Davids voice is quite good :D

[gemzn]

LOVE IT !

[PirateTillTheEnd]

Beautiful video! Loved the use of this song and of David singing!!

[Sshelly34213]

lol ok how many people have watched this about ten million times just for the song? because i have, why is it so addictive??

[Sshelly34213]

JEEZE LOUISE THIS SONG IS ADDICTIVE!

[Sshelly34213]

aw David's voice is pretty

[Sshelly34213]

wow very well done

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks!

[romana55]

Excellant video

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you!

[DTis2SEXY]

BRILLAINT! im ona try and get a ticket 2 c hamlet ;)

[MusicDoll28]

Geez, I can't believe I've seen this video like a hundred times and still haven't commented. I've had the song stuck in my head now for like days, so I just keep watching the video. It's absolute genuis. Adding David singing was brilliant *faints*. I love all the manips you did. Great, great job.

[Elishamarie28]

I really appreciate the comment, thank you!

[iiidotcom]

This vid is well made. Well done.

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks!

[tardis360]

At 0:59, it feels so much as if David is singing along!

Alexander Cole, TARDIS360

[Elishamarie28]

He is :)

I got these clips from him singing on Blackpool.

[dbvixxen]

This video is absolutely stunning. I'm kind of disappointed that I didn't think of it, but I'm glad *someone* did! :D

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks!

[c13diz]

I absolutely love this, kudos you talented little goddess!! xox

[Elishamarie28]

Aww, thank you! :)

[c13diz]

What program did you use for the editing?

d.

[Elishamarie28]

Sony Vegas

[leftknee]

Absolutely, absolutely brilliant. Oh, my God.

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you!

[gloriatraveler]

I'm not a Rose shipper at all, but I love the way you pieced in blackpool and secret diaries. Very well done.

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks, I appreciate the compliment from a non-shipper! :)

[lostinlost]

You've certainly used the blackpool clip well. youve done a great job on this, seeing/hearing "the doctor" *COUGH* not quite the doctor *COUGH* actually singing the lyrics makes it so much better. Good job.

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you!

[englishstudent01]

absolutly beautiful

[rivera2622]

JUST AMAZING!!!

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks! :)

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks!

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks! :)

[bast713]

very cool! I love the ending bit :D

[minvaineth]

OMG this is ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!!!! I love that song... GOOD JOB!!!

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you so much! :)

[RJ4Chlois]

That is some INSANELY good editing. Magnificent job.

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you!! :)

[smeagolita]

Beautiful editing. XD

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks!

[Phoenix404]

kk cool thx

[Ayeon]

Luv this song, and let's be honest, I think every girl would love to have David sing this to her, for those who want the song if you have Itunes that's where I got the song, singer Gabrielle. However it doesn't have david's part in it.

[Phoenix404]

Where did you get this version of the song please?

I've tried to find it everywhere

[Elishamarie28]

I ripped it directly from the Blackpool DVD. I will have to save the song as a separate file and then upload. I will let you know when this is done :)

[Asfer]

M'kay. I'm trying so hard to FIND just the song....where can I get it? It's a beautiful song that I can relate to and I'd really like to get it.

[Elishamarie28]

I will have to save the song as a separate file and then upload. I will let you know when this is done :)

[Asfer]

Thank you thank you thank you! ^^

[nolaespoir]

It's a really sweet song, that made for a very sad/sweet video. I really liked it :) It was quite beautiful, and your clip choice was excellent. Bravo!

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you!

[CSIWho]

this is great! i love how you did the split screen to show david singing and you have him singing to rose. sigh, i want david to sing to me lol!!

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks! Me too :)

[Tinkytumps]

Its so amazing and beautiful <3

and shes come back:D!!!

So excited:D

and thank yuo made me cry:)xx

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you so much, that is a great compliment!

[HogwartsHonorRoll]

Absolutly beautiful :D

Soo glad you used the "Blackpool" version of the song.

David singing is just too cute to pass up :)

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you! I know, I love that version!

[DaYoghurtQueen]

was recommended to watch this

and it is amazing

love it

the music is brilliant

well done

xx

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you! :)

[xXxXxcozzaxXxXx]

i am truely edicted to this video amazing !! even got me singing along XD 5/5 favs and subs !

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you so much!

[NoobsOfTheWorld]

amazing video, can't stop watching it

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks so much!

[cwfairy]

I love this. I think I've watched it over 10 times now. It's really well done, especially how you've managed to use clips from their other shows without it being obvious. And the song fits them perfectly.

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you so much!

[kt27rule]

i love this video it os cute and sweet

[doctorwhofangirl22]

This was really really lovely.One of the best fanvids I have ever watched.

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you so much!

[Lanajayb]

if u want 2 see the song with David Tennant singing type in Should I Stay? Blackpool and click the first one

[THEpowerOFme]

Oh and he sings! XD lol. Great vid! Beatifully edited. 5* and *faved*

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you! Check back for my new one tomorrow :)

[Lanajayb]

wow that is brill i was welling up and when it shows David Tennant singing and pictures of his face and Roses together its edited really well it was sweet =)

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you!

[nolaespoir]

FairyFlossHunny was right, the ending was a bit abrupt, but I adored the rest of the video. I love that you used Blackpool for this! The song worked perfectly. Aww... the video made me really sad, and really nostalgic for all the the Doctor and Rose's little moments. Bravo, it really was beautiful.

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you!

[FairyFlossHunny]

The ending was a little abrupt...but the rest of it wast just beautiful. Perfect editing and clips to match and joining clips and everything was just gorgeous. I loved Blackpool and I love the Dr/Rose story! :)

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks! It was hard to cut the song smoothly but I'm glad you thought everything else was good :)

[davidtennantaddict13]

I love that you used the version of this from Blackpool with DI Carlisle singing! And, when you think about it, the lyrics to this go along perfectly with how Rose is feeling a lot of the time.

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you!

[amy2171987]

wow this is so beautiful..

*sniffs*

you did such a fantastic job with the effects and brilliant song choice!! hehe

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you very much!

[Dollarbob]

can you say EMO.

[hazeling]

Alright I've looked, and looked and can't seem to find. Where on earth do I get that MP3? Looked on itunes and all they have of course is the original version with just Gabrielle.

[RosetylerProductions]

what such a beautiful video and song. I <3 this version of this song it made me cry :( Fantastic vid. And when you saw the clips of david singing tis song, it just...it made my heart melt. This is a VERY touching vid. and shows how much the doctor can't live without rose. I <3 david Tennant and Billie Piper, i <3 doctor who, I <3 blackpool and i <3 this vid. 5 * and faved <3 and i'm subscirbing to you're channel. well done! :D

[gracefulangel47]

Ok I can't BELIEVE I didn't comment the first time I watched, Iw as so sure I did maybe youtube is just lame- but in short I loved this, I love Blackpool and I've even read a few fanfics bout Carlisle and Rose shacking up lol- I loved your use of split-screen- I think that'sd what it is? And I love 1:26 and 2:05 in particular, just coz- and another thing, you always use scenes/shots no one else does, which I like. Another fantastic vid!

Tara

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you so much! :)

[wiskeychitto]

...very nice Elisha...captured tha emotion well...

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks!

[cazzykay23]

i love this video it so cool

[Elishamarie28]

thank you!!

[xxelm0xx]

This is Amasing :) Love Billie and David :) There like my Heros ! Im Abasulty in Love with David Tennant and i dont care if the whole world here's it. His Voice is Perfect in this . Blackpool was Amasing Drama.

The Whole Doctor and Rose thing just makes Doctor who the little bit more special.

This Song Works Wonders. I was singing with it lol :o

Cant wait for more Videos From you :) Specaily the Doctor and Rose Ones. You should do one with Rose Returning. Sorry Long Comment.

x

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you sooo much!

[ladymajavader]

lovely vid! Some excellent clip choices - I love it how the clips of Martha and Donna you chose are kind of parallel, very nice touch.

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks! I was worried people might feel it detracted from the Rose/Doctor shippiness.

[DavidsGirl841444]

So sweet I like the effects and the song, it is nice. Kind of sureal.

[Elishamarie28]

thanks!

[kazaapals]

I't Coold Not Be More Of A Great Fit Have A Good Day Sis!!

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks Robert!

[annabellina3991]

Oh wow! It's so clever how he looks like he's really singing along!

Great vid :)

[AisicsRule]

Aww, that was great! Brilliant use of Blackpool and Secret Diary of a Call Girl.

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks so much!

[ratation]

wonderful ;)

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you!

[xxelm0xx]

Omg Brilliant :)

Fits Perfectly XD Best Should I Stay Video!

xx

[Elishamarie28]

Thank you so much!

[Inasphyxiation]

Love the vid and the song. XD

[Elishamarie28]

Thanks!