Gush Katif - Nadia Matar betrays | מעוז הים - נדיה מטר

[cymer00]

Nadia Matar should go back to Belgium where she came from.

[danielschapiro]

idiot



[AbuAvital]

for centuries the world told us to go home. so we reastablished our national home so they tell us to go back to Europe USA etc. Who cares what the goyim want (they don't even know) Eretz Isreal is ours!!

[Tsiklag]

Cynthia

If you're sick of us, welcome. We couldn't care less. I wish you to get sicker and sicker as time goes by and finally.....

[CynthiaGM]

You israelites have no shame do you? try living an honest life by going back to your countries of origin and getting a real job. Quit killling for land. Im an american canadian and the world is sick of yous. Try making an honest living for a more peaceful world :) Dont you have shame..?

[GUNDOWNHUNTERS]

THEY ARE TOO PASSIVE TOO GOOD. TOO SAD

[GUNDOWNHUNTERS]

BURN THE LEFTISTS W- THE TERRORISTS

[Sefardi123]

I would have refused an order as a soldier,

but would not start milkhamet akhim.

That's what these people feared - and I think they were right.

The REAL WAR is, has been and always will be - in the field of EDUCATION. Educate Israelis, young and old. Win over their hearts, and by that we would have Akhdoot and win big.

[succmgmt]

Hmmm. Let's see.

The Expulsion forces used brute force, threats, intimidation, etc. The Settlers used love, singing, hugging, etc.

The Expulsion forces won.

The settlers lost their homes AND the nation's respect. I didn't hear a single Israeli say "I was for the expulsion, but I admire the settlers for not fighting the army."

In the real world, you cannot respect someone who won't fight for himself and his family.

No one in history ever defeated tyranny by singing kumbaya.

[succmgmt]

I've always been an admirer of Nadia Matar. But this video raises some serious questions. I believe she owes the Jewish people an explanation.

[pfpalya]

what does it mean if someone gets killed "tomorrow we can say that the block has been erased" What exactly does he mean by that phrase? What is he referring to? They may not have fought, but maybe they learned a lesson here. Amona was different, and Nadia got brutalized and thrown down on rocks by a huge policewoman. Rather than assume they were agents, maybe they really thought their idea in Gush Katif would work, wrong as it was? Just throwing that out there.

[rafvrab]

Had they not listened to Nadia, would we still have Gush Katif today, or would there have been just another Amona, and the Gush would have been lost anyhow.

If the later is the answer, was it the idea to lose the Gush with blood and not in surrender?

[succmgmt]

Nadia Matar said at Amona, "If we would have done this in Gaza, the 'disengagement' would have failed."

Either she was admitting that what happened here was wrong, or she's playing both sides.

Either way, she's got some explaining to do.