John Myung (Dream Theater) uses a 6 string. In this song he uses both. For the one climbing progression he uses the high C and he uses the low B on occasion for octaves, but neither are really necessary, you can translate. Decent playing, shitty quality, and you shouldn't have played along to the guitar pro track.
who cares man, hes still technically playing it correct and he did a brilliant job despite the shitty guitar pro track. it doesnt matter so dont say he shouldnt have who are you ? the decider of all? no one cares about your stupid opinion, he did an exellent job ...ohh the quality os bad boo hoo you need a tissue? stfu
Maybe tone down the aggressiveness? I guess I never said that I actually did enjoy the cover, but I did. Who are you to say my opinion is stupid though? No need to be childish. It was merely constructive criticism, and comments would be disabled if he didn't want people's opinions. So fuck you very much.
Why do you even play a 5 string? you don't even utilize the B string when needed. You know on the second riff? you end on an F, but you play the F on the E string and that is just a pain to reach on this particular song..it just makes you sound sloppy...End on an F on the B string....or just get a four string..
just cos you have 5 strings doesnt mean you need to use them all.. quite alot of 4string bass songs i play on the 4string and ALOT of 4string songs i play on my 5string
you are probabily not lefty. a right handed musician has the chance of choosing any guitar as he wishes. perhaps its colour, fret markers etc may be important to choose a guitar too. but if you were a lefty -in my country- you'd understand y i choose a 5 str. finding left handed guitars is not easy in any part of the world.
don't u play any song with the guitar that you have or you are you that rich to buy and use different guitars due to song? that was the one i had that days...
Actually, no. But I'm slowly learning it by ear. I've had some difficulty transcribing it, but I won't sacrifice what I can learn from that wonderful song by using tabs. Using tabs during the first stages of learning can help a lot with technique, ego, and motivation, but there's a point where using tabs to learn a song defeats the purpose of LEARNING the song. To me, tabs are like playing guitar hero, mindlessly pushing buttons. Fucken absurd.
I rarely use tabs, most of the time I play by ear or use sheet music. However, my point was that it would be foolish to learn Portrait of Tracy from sheet music rather than Tabs, if you had to choose between the two. It's fantastic if you're able to learn that by ear, but that wasn't my point.
However, tabs aren't absurd; they offer a precise account of what the player should do to achieve their part in the song, and they cover anything that the player might have missed by ear, which happens.
Yes, they do offer some "precise" technique (as long as the tabs are precise, which is rare.) But if you're learning Portrait of Tracy, you should be beyond tabs, and mature enough to understand that it's not the physical/visual aspect of playing any song, but the aural aspect of it. I agree, tabs are useful when you're a beginner, but one has to move on (depending on personal goals of course. If you want to be mediocre, there you go, use tabs.)
Tablature is useful for showing unorthodox fingerings without having to draw out ledger lines and then label the notes with fingerings XD.
Also, it could be argued that because all of the strings on the guitar have a slightly different timbre, tablature is a better tool for expressing exactly how something should sound.
Yes, that's what I think. Tablature addresses fingering technique perfectly, which is very useful in the early stages of learning an instrument. It's good to inculcate some technique in the student. Though a good musician can write and read exactly what he means using the right tools and resources, no need to limit the music to a button-pressing, level-based, guitar hero shit.
That is really a narrow opinion. You can spend three lifetimes playing a guitar, or bass and never master it. Some people are "technique" people. I know people who can sight read music very well and kinda suck. I know plenty of brilliant creative musicians who will often only learn entire songs if it has a technique they want or are covering. One doesn't "have" to move on from anything. But if you want to be narrow than, there you go.
I never talked about mastering anything, though I agree with that. I also agree about "technique" people. I also agree with "no one has to move on from anything," it's ok to be shallow, it's ok to be ignorant, it's ok to not know shit about music theory, I don't know a lot of music theory, but I put my best effort into learning more about it. It's a matter of choice really. I guess I should clarify my statement:
I would like to read your logic behind "it would be foolish to learn Portrait of Tracy from sheet music rather than Tabs, if you had to choose between the two."
I still don't think so, and can't see the benefit. Happy to discuss these things.
I would think that it would be downright inconvenient to put Portrait of Tracy onto sheet music because bass guitar harmonics (namely those ones) are nearly impossible to read (and inconvenient to write) in such a manner, not to mention that the same harmonic note can be played multiple ways.
Depends really. I have one student who wanted to learn a piece in a reaaaaaal pinch. Her fingers are quicker than her eyes so we went through the tabs over a day. I dunno it depends on what you need or want to do.
first of all it was 3 years ago that i recorded this video. so i know i were playing erotomania just like a beginner. =)
i have to say that i live in turkey n it's really hard to find a lefty bass guitar in here. i ordered my trb1005 from germany n i used that guitar for 2 years. after that i used a cort b5. and i've been using a lefty schecter stiletto 6str which i ordered from usa =)
having a x str bass doesn't mean u have to play the song written/played with x str bass. or is it? :s
Hello, bass players. i have been searching the internet for a cheap and decent upright bass. i came across one called the Florea Midnight Bass Outfit(3/4 size black). if anyone could give me some feedback on it, i would greatly appreciate it. thanks.
What is this?.... like the keyboard version of erotomania? Anyway.... sounds great with bass, but I personally like the live version better.....and, again it sounds great man.
Good job! I think your speed could use a little work, to be honest, but other than that, you have good technique, and you keep track of time well. Keep up the good work.
at first i said to myself, 'you know i had no idea that elijah wood was so talented'. then i said, isn't that the theme music for contra. then i said, 'alright, the bass is nice looking'.
HOLY SHIT! IT'S FRODO!
CROGrof 8 months ago 5
so frodo started playing bass after he destroyed the ring ha
mynameisMRPIG 9 months ago 2
Nice job!
xxxpersonnxxx 10 months ago
@elecoCz yes us lefty's shall take over the world!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
thedukesrule 10 months ago
What if hes not a lefty, its the camera!
Speedoman1978 10 months ago
he blatantly is a lefty because if you use a thing in-between your ears it tells you that he is actually a leftie. duh
jenjen4550 10 months ago
@jenjen4550 Well aren't you the resident expert on lefty bass players. Can you tell us how his cock tastes too?
Speedoman1978 10 months ago
@Speedoman1978
CEREBERAL LAWLSY
But srsly, too funny
redfruit1993 8 months ago
Erotomania :)
Nice job :)
idangin2007 10 months ago
working on learning this song, except the one part at 1:08, when it goes to the first fret, is making that impossible for me >_<
ikeeln00bz 10 months ago
Comment removed
ikeeln00bz 10 months ago
is not crazy o_O
benjigoenitz 10 months ago
@eleoCz I'm a lefty and play on my right o.O
iConverseMyLife 11 months ago
sweet cover man, nice to see another left handed bassist.
metalheadneji 11 months ago
easiest song of dream....... good cover any ways
CristianTejadaU 1 year ago
boss stage?
TristanMachuwano1998 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Dream Theater song \m/
zakhusna 1 year ago
Dream Theater song \m/
zakhusna 1 year ago
i am a left handed bass player too kick ass :)
TheChancegomez 1 year ago
when i watch a lefty play it hurts my brain >.< it looks so wrong lol
ELFKRUNCH 1 year ago 2
I like your style kid...keep rockin' Greetings from a fellow bass player from Boston......Peace
lecram0 1 year ago
shia lebouf
Tang526 1 year ago
Oh god... Im sorry... But this is uncomfortable to watch. Haha
It looks like the bass should be the other way:P
Is that just me?
SnideWolfDaddy 1 year ago
I was wondering why the song sounded like complete shit...It's Guitar Pro, is it not?
WeCamefortheDead 1 year ago
Eh... the bass is wrong-sided - how can you play like that? :D
Well played though I don't like the Song
Less timing problems than most hobby bass players would have with this song
topfpflanze83 1 year ago
@topfpflanze83 It's called being left handed.
sarkenx 1 year ago
@topfpflanze83 It's a lefty bass dude...
bassman071 1 year ago
@bassman071
I insist that It's not a lefty bass, it's a wrong-sided bass :)
I have a wrong handed guitarrist in my Band and he always smashes his frets//*tunethings* against my left wrist...
Everything that causes pain to me is wrong sided
topfpflanze83 1 year ago
whos playin super mario bros 3 in the bosses castle? lol
13cdsmith 1 year ago 2
Is this an Ibanez bass?
YiannisMetallas96 1 year ago
A lefty 5-string?!?! Sssssssweet!!!
flurng 1 year ago
hey im a lefty too and this is one of the first songs i learned. :D
mikeysstorage 1 year ago
Power Left!
onelovega 1 year ago
dude sounds like a nintendo game soundtrack.. AWESOME playin man
antmantkant 1 year ago
epic. great job man
omgwtfbbqalekx 1 year ago
lefty1 :D sameee
patian9 1 year ago
It's good playing, I just find the whole thing boring as can be. Keep playing though. you're good.
MST3Killa 1 year ago
don't beat up a good bass player!
therickshow1 1 year ago
OMFG NICE PLAYING!!!!!
idiotbox1111 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
5 string bass are for douchebags
Capitallog 2 years ago
whats the name of the track?
Christophoros 2 years ago
Dream Theater - Erotomania
symeo06 2 years ago
this would be better with the origonal song in the background. much better.
nice playing man
RyanTF2 2 years ago 2
awesome!!
BMTH105 2 years ago 3
awesome.!!..Happy New year... *\o/*
cornflakesnwater 2 years ago
cool.
hereg2007 2 years ago
erotomania rocks!!
Rafescow 2 years ago
John Myung (Dream Theater) uses a 6 string. In this song he uses both. For the one climbing progression he uses the high C and he uses the low B on occasion for octaves, but neither are really necessary, you can translate. Decent playing, shitty quality, and you shouldn't have played along to the guitar pro track.
omgwtfcj 2 years ago
who cares man, hes still technically playing it correct and he did a brilliant job despite the shitty guitar pro track. it doesnt matter so dont say he shouldnt have who are you ? the decider of all? no one cares about your stupid opinion, he did an exellent job ...ohh the quality os bad boo hoo you need a tissue? stfu
lu5tic 2 years ago
@lu5tic
Maybe tone down the aggressiveness? I guess I never said that I actually did enjoy the cover, but I did. Who are you to say my opinion is stupid though? No need to be childish. It was merely constructive criticism, and comments would be disabled if he didn't want people's opinions. So fuck you very much.
omgwtfcj 2 years ago
@omgwtfcj
it's a nice cover, just sayin'
but damn, you got him on the GP xD
patapirate 2 years ago
ahhh a fellow lefty....
keep it up man!
m333tt 2 years ago 26
@m333tt lefties for the win :D
leonpal14 1 year ago
@m333tt lol same here any tips on finding a bass for lefties? Im sick of having my strings inverted :/
AxleTrade 9 months ago
@AxleTrade try musician sfriend.com...if not there just type in on google "left handed bass guitar" or "lefty bass guitar" thats all got, lol...
m333tt 9 months ago
sounds pretty good
Muenchies 2 years ago
sounds greaaaaaaaaaaatttttttttttttttt,
sarcasm x)
zarigunn 2 years ago
lol at the midi. Nice cover btw
renzolikescheez 2 years ago
this sounds fucking great, good job dude
bluenova159 2 years ago 3
This kids jacket looks like it came from the star trek set :P it bothered me the entire video
Weefles 2 years ago
the actual kid looks like he came from star trek...
even though.. he reminds me of one of the hobbits from LOTR?
Adeazz 2 years ago 3
I think he's quite adult...
GDevourer 2 years ago
Yeah that's what i tough to!
rsguitarfan 2 years ago
sloppy audio/tone... but nice
mrnitro30103 2 years ago
sounds like yo use tux guitar pro lol
6ftUnder92592 2 years ago
erotomania
LithiumRock101 2 years ago
really nice job. sounded great. i rarely see lefty bass players too. 5 stars
TimIsAwsome12 2 years ago
lefties unite!
PowerSlave1094 2 years ago 4
what song is this?
biggiestickz 2 years ago
dream theater..erotica...wrong title but some shit like that i think
nycbassist76 2 years ago
song is erotomania by dream theater
xHeartagram32 2 years ago 20
@xHeartagram32 i was just going to say that dam lol
TheSonsofHorusx 10 months ago
Its hard to see but he does use the 5th string, so i guess that extra money was worth it. Thanks for coming out.
boarderfreak158 2 years ago
Sick! Great playing! Also, to tarantino929, he looks more like a young John Entwistle circa 1964.
zzzxxyy 2 years ago
0:03 - 0:04 He looks like Pete Towshend lol
tarantino929 2 years ago
EROTOMANIA =]
TheJPfanboy 2 years ago
is he really lefty or is it a mac?
da1c2345 2 years ago
lol i am really lefty =)) it's the yamaha trb1005l that i was playing on this vid.
buraksend 2 years ago
mmm... i didn't like it, i mean, he's good, but i don't know, there's something i didn't enjoy, maybe the tabs program
grungemanjr 2 years ago
This kind of sounds like Super Nintendo video game music.
ByTor190 2 years ago
Why do you even play a 5 string? you don't even utilize the B string when needed. You know on the second riff? you end on an F, but you play the F on the E string and that is just a pain to reach on this particular song..it just makes you sound sloppy...End on an F on the B string....or just get a four string..
HelloMirror 2 years ago
the tab he read was for a 4 string lol
bluetoad12 2 years ago
just cos you have 5 strings doesnt mean you need to use them all.. quite alot of 4string bass songs i play on the 4string and ALOT of 4string songs i play on my 5string
unknownsixsixsix 2 years ago 2
Sorry, if you're not gonna use the strings when needed, then why the fuck would you spend the extra money for a 5 string? it's just stupid.
HelloMirror 2 years ago
you are probabily not lefty. a right handed musician has the chance of choosing any guitar as he wishes. perhaps its colour, fret markers etc may be important to choose a guitar too. but if you were a lefty -in my country- you'd understand y i choose a 5 str. finding left handed guitars is not easy in any part of the world.
don't u play any song with the guitar that you have or you are you that rich to buy and use different guitars due to song? that was the one i had that days...
buraksend 2 years ago
you don't always play it dumb ass. i could say the same about your brain. i presume you have one, but you're not using it.
killakobra 2 years ago
any need to answer this uncunning little boy/girl?
1337FreshNoodles 2 years ago
I think it's just that this song doesn't require the extra string. He probably uses it in other situations.
dusthillguy 2 years ago
He's a TABBERRRRRRRRRRRRR!!!!!!!!!
No music here.
backline112 2 years ago
Have you ever tried reading sheet music for Portrait of Tracy?
If you deny the necessity of Tabs there, you're a fool.
Marlowann 2 years ago
Actually, no. But I'm slowly learning it by ear. I've had some difficulty transcribing it, but I won't sacrifice what I can learn from that wonderful song by using tabs. Using tabs during the first stages of learning can help a lot with technique, ego, and motivation, but there's a point where using tabs to learn a song defeats the purpose of LEARNING the song. To me, tabs are like playing guitar hero, mindlessly pushing buttons. Fucken absurd.
backline112 2 years ago
People always call me a fool for trying to go beyond, LEARN, and improve things. "They call me the working man, I guess that's what I am."
So, Marlowann, please keep using tabs and leave the music to serious people.
backline112 2 years ago
I rarely use tabs, most of the time I play by ear or use sheet music. However, my point was that it would be foolish to learn Portrait of Tracy from sheet music rather than Tabs, if you had to choose between the two. It's fantastic if you're able to learn that by ear, but that wasn't my point.
However, tabs aren't absurd; they offer a precise account of what the player should do to achieve their part in the song, and they cover anything that the player might have missed by ear, which happens.
Marlowann 2 years ago
Yes, they do offer some "precise" technique (as long as the tabs are precise, which is rare.) But if you're learning Portrait of Tracy, you should be beyond tabs, and mature enough to understand that it's not the physical/visual aspect of playing any song, but the aural aspect of it. I agree, tabs are useful when you're a beginner, but one has to move on (depending on personal goals of course. If you want to be mediocre, there you go, use tabs.)
backline112 2 years ago
So are you saying essentially that learning by ear is better than learning by tablature?
Marlowann 2 years ago
Yes.
backline112 2 years ago
Then I agree.
Marlowann 2 years ago
Tablature is useful for showing unorthodox fingerings without having to draw out ledger lines and then label the notes with fingerings XD.
Also, it could be argued that because all of the strings on the guitar have a slightly different timbre, tablature is a better tool for expressing exactly how something should sound.
:-P :-P :-P
Svelthos 2 years ago
Yes, that's what I think. Tablature addresses fingering technique perfectly, which is very useful in the early stages of learning an instrument. It's good to inculcate some technique in the student. Though a good musician can write and read exactly what he means using the right tools and resources, no need to limit the music to a button-pressing, level-based, guitar hero shit.
backline112 2 years ago 2
That is really a narrow opinion. You can spend three lifetimes playing a guitar, or bass and never master it. Some people are "technique" people. I know people who can sight read music very well and kinda suck. I know plenty of brilliant creative musicians who will often only learn entire songs if it has a technique they want or are covering. One doesn't "have" to move on from anything. But if you want to be narrow than, there you go.
Coldmystery 2 years ago
I never talked about mastering anything, though I agree with that. I also agree about "technique" people. I also agree with "no one has to move on from anything," it's ok to be shallow, it's ok to be ignorant, it's ok to not know shit about music theory, I don't know a lot of music theory, but I put my best effort into learning more about it. It's a matter of choice really. I guess I should clarify my statement:
backline112 2 years ago
Tabs are not recommended for people who would like to lead the life of a serious, professional, versatile musician.
I still don't get why it's narrow... Maybe I'm slow? Too late? =/
backline112 2 years ago
I would like to read your logic behind "it would be foolish to learn Portrait of Tracy from sheet music rather than Tabs, if you had to choose between the two."
I still don't think so, and can't see the benefit. Happy to discuss these things.
backline112 2 years ago
I'm happy to discuss this too.
I would think that it would be downright inconvenient to put Portrait of Tracy onto sheet music because bass guitar harmonics (namely those ones) are nearly impossible to read (and inconvenient to write) in such a manner, not to mention that the same harmonic note can be played multiple ways.
Marlowann 2 years ago
i thought sheet music was better then tabulature?
lucasregan1986 2 years ago
I never claimed otherwise.
Marlowann 2 years ago
Depends really. I have one student who wanted to learn a piece in a reaaaaaal pinch. Her fingers are quicker than her eyes so we went through the tabs over a day. I dunno it depends on what you need or want to do.
Coldmystery 2 years ago
Or if you can read music and can do it that way, then that's the way you could do it without being a fool, dumbass....
HelloMirror 2 years ago
I'm not entirely sure what exactly you're responding to.
Marlowann 2 years ago
first of all it was 3 years ago that i recorded this video. so i know i were playing erotomania just like a beginner. =)
i have to say that i live in turkey n it's really hard to find a lefty bass guitar in here. i ordered my trb1005 from germany n i used that guitar for 2 years. after that i used a cort b5. and i've been using a lefty schecter stiletto 6str which i ordered from usa =)
having a x str bass doesn't mean u have to play the song written/played with x str bass. or is it? :s
buraksend 2 years ago
Comment removed
buraksend 2 years ago
I'ma gona slap your face with my dick. Bitch.
flaxtothamax 2 years ago
im left handed as well :D
but i suck :(
gam3rman 2 years ago 2
Why does he doing it?
Johnbloodbath 2 years ago
He looks and plays like the Ox!!!
Walmartassasin 2 years ago
yeah...
roloman4 2 years ago
It's Erotomania from Dream Theater
An0therBassPlayer 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hello, bass players. i have been searching the internet for a cheap and decent upright bass. i came across one called the Florea Midnight Bass Outfit(3/4 size black). if anyone could give me some feedback on it, i would greatly appreciate it. thanks.
tubamanKevinU8 2 years ago
dude, it stinks!
djxfime 2 years ago
Have you ever played on it?
tubamanKevinU8 2 years ago
what song is this its awesome?
OrkSlayer3434 2 years ago
alot of webcams flip the image.. hes probably righty
longneckbassist 2 years ago
this is pure quality!
i'm one of the only bass players i know and i'm the only left handed bassist i know!!
eddykahn14 2 years ago
Comment removed
snarfsnarf105 2 years ago
:S is very bad men
tedelanegra2 2 years ago
TRB 1005 :D
Sweet... I had one :D
Emberlajz 2 years ago
Lefty bass players are the coolest :D I wish I was lefty :P
Kha096 2 years ago 2
haha thanks =D
Moiez101 2 years ago
LEFTY 4 THE WIN XD
superchuck333 3 years ago 2
Hellz yeah, people told me to switch to right, but i always refused! :P
Moiez101 2 years ago
story of my life :P
algazino 2 years ago
Amen! Lefties are rare, basissts are rare.....Lefty bassists are kryptonite. ;)
Moiez101 2 years ago 2
yes noromt this is a Dream Theater song "Erotomania" :)
nympis 3 years ago
wow
really good!:)
is this dream theater?
noromt 3 years ago
woah... lefty...
meeebit 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Very Nice...
I suggest you upload the same in 'Dynamycdesi'.It is a online talent contest site for people and gives an award to the 'Best Talent'.
sdhanyam 3 years ago
the rbx rocks.. keep it up bro ;)
thoreevos 3 years ago
are you wearing a woolen jumpsuit?
bradz6980 3 years ago 5
Sounds good. I think he is using guitar pro 3 or 4 and erotomania's tabs as a background for a bass. Anyway, good job!
Http1121 3 years ago
i wanna kill myself listening to this
crazyfool95 3 years ago
What is this?.... like the keyboard version of erotomania? Anyway.... sounds great with bass, but I personally like the live version better.....and, again it sounds great man.
IdontCheckMyEmails 3 years ago
lol dude its just midi recording.
probably done on guitarpro or something
ZOMGItsRobot 3 years ago 3
sorry but his name is Burak not Jonathan, this is only a similarity :)
nympis 3 years ago
omg he is Jonathan LaPaglia
Nom3xx 3 years ago
your brother looks like matt bellamy with bass,hahaha
anyway,nice cover dude!
agttru 3 years ago
hahahyahahahah pretty crazy ha
sparkinsons 3 years ago
que vergas fue eso
Frusciante2009 3 years ago
Nothing special...
SynysterGates911 3 years ago 3
This is erotomania.
What do you mean by "sleeper"?
WestonMossman 3 years ago
wat song?! plz tell me plz o god plz tell me wat song?!?!?!
garrett20101 3 years ago
Good job! I think your speed could use a little work, to be honest, but other than that, you have good technique, and you keep track of time well. Keep up the good work.
olnoname 3 years ago
Please use RSE next time:P I forgot how terrible the midi sounded in Guitar Pro:P
Matroosje89 3 years ago
i'm way better.
xOutRagex 3 years ago
Niyet ettim allah rızası için erotomania çalmaya.
ProfRabson 3 years ago 2
Gpro? xD
bassharris 3 years ago
yeah...
brunotrema 3 years ago
his A string is untuned...
basuu0 3 years ago
at first i said to myself, 'you know i had no idea that elijah wood was so talented'. then i said, isn't that the theme music for contra. then i said, 'alright, the bass is nice looking'.
orientedelcampo 3 years ago
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
hellfish271 3 years ago
Did you use a midi file for the background that you are playing over?
peifferjr1 3 years ago
yep i used a midi file that i made by guitar pro.
buraksend 3 years ago
he looks like one of those dudes in star treck
basssblood 3 years ago 7
props to you man. i respect your skill. do you have a tabliture of that. where could i find it?
brandenlizardi 3 years ago
All I say is: DO THAT STANDING!!
p3pp3rb0ss3 3 years ago
LEFTY 0_o
JackBass11 3 years ago
good.... now go on with metropolis
daspidrr 3 years ago
giutar pro ruless
Santander93 3 years ago
guitar pro ;D
CrowBoomer 3 years ago
very good, i think you can go on your own without the background, but in the terms of the song very good.
badelf99 3 years ago
guitar pro haha
shadow1854 3 years ago
dang you kind of look like john entwisle of the who when he was really young
RyanJoelBoone 3 years ago
Burak !
windriderrr 3 years ago
Sounds like Castlevania! awesome... Nice playing! 5*
zidusseus 3 years ago
LOL it's true!
alvarokas 3 years ago
he dose look a little crazy
theslapingfrog 3 years ago