Added: 11 months ago
From: IGNentertainment
Views: 28,627
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (816)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Harry potter and the Deathly hallows part 2 absoloutely shits on all of these (except Return of the king)

  • ohh damn... i would pay everything i have just to see lord of the rings my first time again.... easy the best movie in the world!

  • In some cases, I think of the Henson-directed "Labyrinth" being a good companion piece to "Your Highness"...as Leezar is loosely based on Jareth and there's one part which both heroes have to make the decision to save their brothers or just go home and do nothing...of course, there's a LOT of great '80s fantasy movies they reference in it. :)

  • fuck harry butthole pussy potter

  • lord of the rings is amazing, and watching the extended verison that are around 4hrs each, just adds to it's awesomeness :)

  • the man in green is hilarious pans labyrinth has got a really sad ending lord of the rings is awesome

  • The most beautiful movie "the lord of the ring"

  • I'm going to make my grandchildren watch LOTR, it's the most epic movie ever made.

  • I'm not going to lie, but Pan's labyrinth gave me nightmares 5 years ago when I watched it aged 10. The creature thingy eating those fairies or whatever scared the shit out of me. Even now, when i'm 15, I wouldn't have been scared normally but surprisingly I am!

  • Frodo could totally pass as Harry Potter's brother

  • I have seen all of these except pans labrinyth

  • Pan's labirint is my number one!

  • lord of the ring's is epic.

  • I was worried lord of the rings wouldnt show but still.....where is Conan the Barbarian? and Krull?

  • harry potter most on number 1..

  • hahaha danny seems bored

  • LOTR movies are amazing! music, actors everything is great! Peter Jackson did a great job with these movies. i just hope that The Hobbit part 1&2 (2011-2012) will be good as well

  • People keep posting their version's of how the list should have.

    I say fuck that, don't put the lord of the rings trilogy in three separate movies, I say they're one big movie, a 9 hour movie of epic proportion's,

  • "We travel light. Let's hunt some Orc."

  • @limesgamer Agreed

  • ok this was good especially cuz Lord of the rings is FTW!

  • The Neverending Story

  • IMO what really sets LoTR apart from other Fantasy Movies is how succesfully it immeresed you into tolkeins world. Each character has his own flaws that they must overcome or face certain doom. And unlike most fantasy movies every decision by every character feels extremely real in terms of the sacrifices they choose to make and where their alligences lay.

  • @Bsuperflu word.

  • @Bsuperflu it was just so good all round, and unlike all other mainstream movies good doesnt always win or if it does it comes at a cost

  • Harry Potter is the best out of all that FUCK WHAT YOU SAY! :)

  • @FlyYouFoolz cheers man :)

  • 1. The Return of the King

    2. The Fellowship of the Ring

    3. The Two Towers.

    This is the correct list, And for those who say the Fellowship was boring, It wasn't, it might not have had as much action as the other two, but the characters and there story, and how they came to together, how to story came to be was more exiting than any battles.

  • You Gotta Love The SoundTrack of LOTR

  • @ShiftJay08 Oh my God, yes! :D Every time I hear it I have a sudden urge to watch all three films again!

  • Wait, if The Fellowship of the Ring is #1, then how are its two sequels which are clearly better in just about every way not even on the list at all?

  • LOTR FOTR sucked ass it was so boring and dumb no where near as good as the other 2

  • @grkpektis Ah, no. The other 2 had 'lots of big fighting stuff' but the first one required an explanation to the plot of the Lord of the Rings. Just because there wasn't a fight every 5 minutes doesn't make it a bad movie at all. I really enjoyed getting into the story, and explain to me how the hell it was dumb?!

  • @musaholic755 yea but even when it did have a fight I was bored to tears. Also there was nothing really special about the story until the second one (frodo being corrupted for example)

  • Pan's labyrinth scares the shit out of me

  • My best memory from my childhood was watching the lord of the rings in surround sound.

    I hate these retards that say they love the lord of the rings without reading the books

    but most important read the hobbit first!!!!

  • Should have been the Lord of the Rings Trilogy as #1, but whatever. At least they realize that it's the greatest movie adaptation ever made, as well as the greatest book trilogy ever made.

  • fellowship of the ring was a big pile of shit fuck it

  • I miss the lord of the rings.

  • I would kill for another Lord of the rings...literally

  • @MexRobe1222 George Lucas.

  • @MexRobe1222 Kill for LOTR and just 'wait' for the 'The Hobbit - Part 1' to come out in 2012 December, and Part 2 a year after! :D

  • do fairy tales fall under the fantasy genre?

  • harry potter is terrible! :/

  • lotr! lotr! lotr!

  • Woop, fucking love Danny McBride

  • LOTR? More like the the most boring fantasy film :/

  • Harry potter can't be compared with Lord of the Rings, Lotr is the best movie saga based on a book, it's the best movie saga off all time!

  • peter Jackson is making the prequel to lord of the rings as we speak thumb up so people know

  • @SlyCooperVideos you mean the hobbit :P dont refer to it as a prequel :)

  • @SlyCooperVideos Peter is producing it, not directing it. The know and loved Ian Mckellon is playing Gandalf thankfully!

  • @musaholic755 Jackson is directing it, he was producer but has now taken over as main man. Who do you think's directing it?

  • @SlyCooperVideos i hope you know what the prequal is because if not that's sad read the book first

  • @MrBitbyter i do its the hobbit its all about how frodo got the ring and how Bilbo gave it to him

  • @SlyCooperVideos it is "the hobbit"

  • The lord of the rings fuck all harry potter's books and films

  • Lord of the rings first, correct, the others, i don't care...

  • The lord of the rings FTW!!!

  • If you're gonna have Danny McBride present you top 5 fantasy film, at least make him be a little funny. Totally pointless otherwise.

  • YEAHHHHHH great choice

    

  • Legend is my favorite fantasy movie of all time.

  • @sergioelmejor1 yes sci-fi is a SUB GENRE of fantasy and if they were to put star wars into a top 5 category it would be SCI-FI not fantasy, as sci-fi is not generally accepted as fantasy. (Apart from those who are anal film buffs who pick apart the meaning of a word to twist it to fit whatever the hell kinda meaning they want to)

  • @ianlolsatyou *cough*Science fiction is a genre of fiction. It differs from fantasy in that, within the context of the story, its imaginary elements are largely possible within scientifically established or scientifically postulated laws of nature *cough*

  • @ianlolsatyou

    You are correct. What I was complaining about was your attitude. I know this is the internet and whatnot but you make a fool out of yourself when you go around insulting people for shit that isn't worth it to begin with

  • @sergioelmejor1 I'm sorry if calling you an "ass-hat" has emotionally scared you xD

  • @ianlolsatyou

    It wasn't me who you called ass-hat, but yeah, whatever.

  • lol have of this vid is just random lotr scenes

  • willow

  • i would totally bang that tyler chick

  • Oz and Lord of the Rings owned Harry Potter. Epic!

  • I have to say I agree wit this top 5 :D

  • i started watching LOTR's last night fukin class film

  • FUCK THE RING WHERE ARE THE ELF GIRLS WANT ME SOME LIV TYLER ELF GIRLS DAMN

  • am i the only one who hates LOTR?????

  • @darthchris19 No, best movie ever made. (Warning: In my opinion, in no way, shape, or form do you have to agree with my opinion.)

  • @darthchris19 Yes

  • @darthchris19 Yes, most definitely.

  • @darthchris19 Yes

  • WTF ARE YOU JOKING THE 1st LOTR was shit the last two will own it badly!!

  • If you want a movie that puts you to sleep a half hour into it and when you wake it still isn't over, then yes LOTR is perfect. This is the only book to movie film that I actually enjoyed reading the books more, really disappointed with how shitty and overrated these movies are. Pans Labyrinth is the best on this list.

  • I never liked none of this movies

  • those hobbits are extremely sexually attracted to eachother...lol

  • 60 orcs did not like this video...

  • ive actually seen all these movies. LotR would be my last choice. out of these, id go with Princess Bride

  • my god, those movies are mostly crap.... apart from the nr1 and 5

  • Lord of the Ring is the greatest fantasy movie ever!

  • Pan's Labyrinth is my top favorite!!!

  • i wouldn't class some of those as fantasy. What about Willow ffs.....

  • Very true , Lord Of The Rings will always be the best fantasy movie ever seen and made , you can't compare him with any other ..... It's unique and perfect !

  • PANS LABYRINTH <3! the movie is infinity times better in you can understand spanish.

  • awesome picks

  • The LOTR extended editions are coming on blu-ray soon. SO getting those

  • The list should have been:

    1. The Return of the King

    2. The Two Towers

    3. The Fellowship of the Ring

    No movie trilogy even comes close to the perfection that is The Lord of the Rings

  • @rwwas32 how about half life 2?

  • @souljaryanboy you are too stupid to be alive go die

  • @rwwas32 I'd say maybe the Toy Story trilogy does. You can't fault Pixar in that

  • @rwwas32 rong it should have been:

    1.the two towers

    2.the return of the king

    3.the fellowship of the ring

    and then just end the list

  • @rwwas32 maybe

  • For the first time I agree with all five of their choices, even the order of them, and I'm surprised by this. Is that weird?

  • I dont like LOTR The fellowship......... I LOVE THE ENTIRE SEIRES!

  • @dedwilson LOL :D well they all sound like blockbuster hits

  • song for LOTR?

  • @evanll1997 May it be

    

  • song for LOTR (sounds like enya)

  • to this day i still have not watched a Harry Potter movie or Lord of the Rings movie and i'm 18! :D

  • @aflacworld ....LotR binge...NOW

  • @aflacworld

    Buy a Blu-ray player, buy the entire LOTR trilogy on Blu-ray. Unplug your phones and switch off anything that may distract you. Make sure you have 9 hours to spare and enjoy the greatest trilogy of all time.

  • @rwwas32 haha ya maybe one day, i WANT to see Lord of the Rings and all but first i need me some money to rent/buy it and the time to watch all 3 lol, good advice though :)

  • @Mountaind3ws actually he did but he somehow comes back as the white wizard

  • I cried at the end of return of the king because I knew the trilogy was done

  • I do not get the appeal of Danny McBride.

  • my fav LOTR book is the hobbit. LOTR FTW

  • Great picks!

  • 1/ When a "Top (insert number and noun here)", it is usually the done thing to discuss the merits of said thing and explain WHY you think it's great. Even if it's subjective.

    2/ We've all seen the LOTR trilogy. There is no need for some fan-wank, amature "video-montage-to-my-favourite­-music" video, especially for as long as your vid was. Before I hit "stop" out of boredom, I was wondering where the "Naruto/Twilight/FF7-footage-t­o-Marilyn-Manson" vid was.

  • Liv Tyler is my fantasy

  • @Mountaind3ws That's not trooooo... That's impaasssible!!!!

  • what the fuck is this?????

    where is the fuck is the Godfather, THE greatest trilogy of all time, followed closely by starwars, then the dollars trilogy, then the prequel star wars trilogy, THEN lotr trilogy

  • @MaadDawg1 fantasy moron

  • @MaadDawg1 read the tittle fantasy movies,why would the godfather be there???

  • @MaadDawg1 Even if it didn't clearly say fantasy it's still IGN's top 5, not your top 5. Your mother must have been smoking crack on the reg when she was pregnant with you

  • @MaadDawg1 read you idiot top 5 fantasy movies not top 5 movies

  • LOTR:FOTR FTW!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    I just watched them last week and now...I want to again!! Lol

    MY FAVORITE MOVIE EVER (the trilogy)

    Love the Lord of the Rings!!!!!!

  • The music of Lord of the Rings is some of the best works of art in the history of man-kind.

    Props to Howard Shore.

  • your goddamn right lotr is #1

  • Lotr is deffinatly the best choice for number 1 . Great job IGN .

  • @Mountaind3ws Spoiler : The ring barrers name isn't Frodo.

  • finally a #1 pick everybody agrees with

  • I think this is the best top five list you've ever put together. I can't disagree with any of them!

  • @stephenrodgers1000 most movies are, so that doesn't really say much.

  • well I definitely can't argue with them for selecting LOTR as first place

  • i bet all this Top 5 was just for LOTR :P this makes me watch it for the 100th time ^_^

  • I thought they would just say the entire trilogy. I also think the fellowship is the best of the three but it's so not cheating to say them all. But to agree with one of the other comments, that said Harry potter hasn't been quite as good since askaban.

  • LOTR is the bst fcking movie franchise ever made. hands down.

  • Youu Shall Not Dislike!!

  • was anyone else on the verge of tears when they first saw lotr and boromir died

  • @LaV0lpe I cried at the end of Return of the King.

  • LOTR is way too nerdy for my taste but i respect it

  • @1996bonny Thats just lame, basically you care what other people think about you... Lame

  • oh that was pans labyrinth? i thought it was hellboy 2

  • @diecaste123

    Both were done by the same guy.

  • @diecaste123 lol same director thats why they look so similar

  • 51 users couldn't walk into Mordor...

    *sniffles* who doesn't cry when watching the LOTR trilogy?

  • return of the kings the best imo

  • I totally knew LOTR was going to be number one.

    The music is so touching...reminds me of all the memories i have of reading the books and watching the LOTR movies. So beautiful...

  • God....the music to LOTR gets me everytime......

  • @Mountaind3ws FFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUU

  • DAM that made me watch lotr all over again

  • Finally an IGN list I can agree with. Although, that's probably because it wasn't actually made by IGN.

    Love Lord of the Rings. One of my favourite trilogies. The others are Toy Story, Back to the Future, Pirates of the Caribbean, Star Wars Original Trilogy and Indiana Jones.

    I really don't get why they couldn't have made Harry Potter 4-7 as good as 3. After 2 films, they got the format right for the films but they messed it up after that. Not saying the others are bad. Just not as good as 3

  • The final 3 should be Lotr Fellowship, Lotr two towers, Lotr return of the king

  • OH great , I never WATCHED lord OF the RINGS and I already KNOW the GRAMPA die IN the MINES and THE bearded GUY dies IN the FOREST ... something ELSE you WANNA tell ME ?

  • stop thumbs upping comments!!! the top comments section is updating like mad!

  • I guess Jedis and Superheros don't count as "fantasy".

    And how exactly did fellowship beat two towers? Insane.

  • @VirtuesPenumbra Return of the King and the Fellowship of the Ring are much better than Two Towers. Even Tolkien would tell you that.

  • @mikerules999

    You're insane. Two towers is the darkest and most suspenseful of the three. You don't know where Gandalf is, everyone is about to die, shits all fucked up. The other two are book-ends, existing only to provide context for Two Towers.

  • i'm so glad lotr is ageing so well

    it's becoming timeless

  • I still have a morbid fear for Enya...

  • i would have said the first potter.....why would you pick the third one??

  • Harry Potter? Really?

  • Am I the only one that thinks that the Pan's labyrinth is worthless ?

  • boil em mash em stickm in a stew

  • spoiler: the hobbits have a gay trilogy

  • Methinks the 50 dislikes were people partial to Potter.

  • Good taste. Lord of the Rings Yeeeeesssssssssss