give her a break. She never does the notes in "Fighther" because it's unesscary. She sings tons of songs live probably more than you guys speak. She continously nails notes in all her songs except this one, whereas other singers get nodules for even attempting their songs live (Joss Stone)
Sorry but I'm not gonna give her a break. Ever heard of Patti LaBelle? She has always been on point singing live, and always sings the high notes in her songs, and sometimes goes even higher. And she's been doing it for 30+ years, and sounds better than ever! If she can do it, so can xtina.
so you see the uk has 3 steps to knowing alot about music 1)school 2)college and 3)uni. go to uni you might learn something new. even i know for a fact christina is known as one of the best singers live listen to her beautiful performace at the grammys its amazing. chow.
oh and this is a mans world live was amazing to watch that and she isnt aiming for a while register note its ment to be raw and natural when she screams.
That's just wrong to say she doesn't hit that last note live. I saw her in Kansas City and she nailed that note. There are also several lives videos where she hits in on youtube. As someone else said, she sings live to 20something songs every concert, along with dancing. I saw her on a night where she had a concert the night before and she blew me away. She hit every note perfectly and, at times, held them longer than the studio version of the songs.
For Waynee8 ... Ummm negative. xtina is " one of the best "live" singers" New York Times. She is known for singing live.. U mmm it does not surprise me ... U got something to say. u must be a mariah fan... Dont post ur comment on here.. Thank you.. Love xtina.. ur the best.
Who gives a shit what the new york times think. They are getting PAID to write what they feel like. And they know nothing about singing or the voice. They haven't spent years in college studying voice. I HAVE And yes, I'm a mariah fan. The old mariah. Not the new water up dry ass fake version. and the mariah back then would sing xtina under a fucking table. Xtina isn't know for LIVE singing, she's just know for her voice. Her voice is great, yes. But live, she sounds like shit. It's the truth.
Xtina isn't know for LIVE singing!! OH MY GOD. what college did you go to because it must have been a shit one. christina is known for her amazing vocals recorded and live. she hits high notes she can now hit 7 octave but chooses not to due to it is very damaging to your vocals and she only uses this when she has the erge to which isnt very often. and she does not want to turn into a dried up vocal whore bag mariah.
no no it was everywere that mariah lost her voice due to the whistle register. the whistle register can kill a voice because of the strain you put the vocal cords through. and mariah cant sing like she ust to at all. but christina's is taking it safe with her voice and she has people making sure her voice stays the same way. and actually christina's voice has gotten ten times better from her first album if you listen to it you can see it. chow
Lmfao. Mariah didn't lose her voice to a whistle register. MAs you get older your voice darkens...which has happen to mariah. Mariah no longer has a younger sound. Her voice has aged. Ask ANY teacher who has a degree in voice and they will tell you that's what happens as you get older. The same will happen to Xtina in years to come. You can even read about it
huhu 8month xD i'm a bit late :P so but patty's voice has also aged and didn't get worse and celine dion is 40 now and her voice is better than it ever was! christina has an extremly strong voice and it gets better the longer she's in the business(1998-2008 right now)
wtf? explain that beter to me... i can do the whistle like mariah.. and im 11 ... literallyy i can do it and i dont put ANY strennght to do it.. its like another voice i hav REALLLLYYY!
Yes Xtina has been onstage for a long time, but she NEVER hits those notes. On anything. Any other tv show where she has sung this song, she NEVER hits those high notes. Never once. She's a studio singer to me. She sounds great on the cd, but live, it's really never to talk about.
She's a "studio singer" now, but that's only because of excessive wear and tear on her larynx. She never had the right people around her when she started to look out for her (as she's mentioned in many print interviews) and this is the result now.
yall are idiots!! this is the end song to her tour... .when she gets to this song she had already sang and danced for 2 hours!! she's been hitting some difficult stuff on this tour! I dont blame her for not going up to the E in this song...
i LOVE christina ... but she NEVER does the high notes for this song. it gets really disappointing. the reason you go to her show is to hear her hit the high notes .... which she rarely attempts to do them. oh well. she is still my FAVOURITE female singer.
I'm not suprised she didn't hit the high notes; she's probably been on stage singing for a long time and and she's moving around lots, it's still amazing!
don't get me wrong (i love christina) but she barely sang half the song. and... i can sing the entire thing on pitch like in the music video. but i've heard her live. she's usually better. what happened?:(
just to say xtina is the greatest, and i was wondering if anyone knew if and when xtina is gonna release this tour on dvd. i went and had the best time of my life! Thanks
I hate when singers don't sing the high parts but but avoid it. She never sings the octave she always avoid it she sucks. Mariah always goes for her high parts even when her voice is horse. Christina don't sing freakin notes on the cd if you can't hit them live! it's the whole point of seeing you in concert to hear you sing and hit the notes you sing on cd
i've watched that one and listen to it it's her back record (studio recording) that hits the high notes. now patti that's a lady who its notes on her cd and beyond performers period should take a page out of her book. ms patti will put on a show no matter what!
GREATEST SONG&SINGER HANDS DOWN
almelund1997 2 years ago 2
Her voice is amazing!!!! and thats one of her best songs love it!
xxxNathalie90xxx 4 years ago 6
christina is AMAZING live.
hannahSUGARbaby 4 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is the only song by xtina that sounds bad live
dancindude03 4 years ago
i think it is before it is very hard
adka1515 4 years ago 4
give her a break. She never does the notes in "Fighther" because it's unesscary. She sings tons of songs live probably more than you guys speak. She continously nails notes in all her songs except this one, whereas other singers get nodules for even attempting their songs live (Joss Stone)
shaunmikex 4 years ago
Sorry but I'm not gonna give her a break. Ever heard of Patti LaBelle? She has always been on point singing live, and always sings the high notes in her songs, and sometimes goes even higher. And she's been doing it for 30+ years, and sounds better than ever! If she can do it, so can xtina.
waynee8 4 years ago
so you see the uk has 3 steps to knowing alot about music 1)school 2)college and 3)uni. go to uni you might learn something new. even i know for a fact christina is known as one of the best singers live listen to her beautiful performace at the grammys its amazing. chow.
godseesnocolour 4 years ago
They study music but still produce bad songs and bad albums. It's a dry place to find musical talent as Simon Cowell has said time and time again.
bluejuelz 4 years ago
oh and this is a mans world live was amazing to watch that and she isnt aiming for a while register note its ment to be raw and natural when she screams.
godseesnocolour 4 years ago
I went and found one of the videos for anyone who wants to argue. Look up any of her videos in Rotterdam singing fighter. It's there.
cemcalex 4 years ago
That's just wrong to say she doesn't hit that last note live. I saw her in Kansas City and she nailed that note. There are also several lives videos where she hits in on youtube. As someone else said, she sings live to 20something songs every concert, along with dancing. I saw her on a night where she had a concert the night before and she blew me away. She hit every note perfectly and, at times, held them longer than the studio version of the songs.
cemcalex 4 years ago
For Waynee8 ... Ummm negative. xtina is " one of the best "live" singers" New York Times. She is known for singing live.. U mmm it does not surprise me ... U got something to say. u must be a mariah fan... Dont post ur comment on here.. Thank you.. Love xtina.. ur the best.
javierxtina 4 years ago
Who gives a shit what the new york times think. They are getting PAID to write what they feel like. And they know nothing about singing or the voice. They haven't spent years in college studying voice. I HAVE And yes, I'm a mariah fan. The old mariah. Not the new water up dry ass fake version. and the mariah back then would sing xtina under a fucking table. Xtina isn't know for LIVE singing, she's just know for her voice. Her voice is great, yes. But live, she sounds like shit. It's the truth.
waynee8 4 years ago
Xtina isn't know for LIVE singing!! OH MY GOD. what college did you go to because it must have been a shit one. christina is known for her amazing vocals recorded and live. she hits high notes she can now hit 7 octave but chooses not to due to it is very damaging to your vocals and she only uses this when she has the erge to which isnt very often. and she does not want to turn into a dried up vocal whore bag mariah.
godseesnocolour 4 years ago
Dummy. Mariah voice has changed because she has gotten older. And Mariah will sing Xtina into a brick wall.
waynee8 4 years ago
no no it was everywere that mariah lost her voice due to the whistle register. the whistle register can kill a voice because of the strain you put the vocal cords through. and mariah cant sing like she ust to at all. but christina's is taking it safe with her voice and she has people making sure her voice stays the same way. and actually christina's voice has gotten ten times better from her first album if you listen to it you can see it. chow
godseesnocolour 4 years ago
Lmfao. Mariah didn't lose her voice to a whistle register. MAs you get older your voice darkens...which has happen to mariah. Mariah no longer has a younger sound. Her voice has aged. Ask ANY teacher who has a degree in voice and they will tell you that's what happens as you get older. The same will happen to Xtina in years to come. You can even read about it
waynee8 4 years ago
i very doubt it. and ask any teacher who has a real degree in voice and they will tell you that the whistle register is very bad for your vocals.
godseesnocolour 4 years ago
huhu 8month xD i'm a bit late :P so but patty's voice has also aged and didn't get worse and celine dion is 40 now and her voice is better than it ever was! christina has an extremly strong voice and it gets better the longer she's in the business(1998-2008 right now)
luvdasexyass 3 years ago
wtf? explain that beter to me... i can do the whistle like mariah.. and im 11 ... literallyy i can do it and i dont put ANY strennght to do it.. its like another voice i hav REALLLLYYY!
heather121212 4 years ago
Yes Xtina has been onstage for a long time, but she NEVER hits those notes. On anything. Any other tv show where she has sung this song, she NEVER hits those high notes. Never once. She's a studio singer to me. She sounds great on the cd, but live, it's really never to talk about.
waynee8 4 years ago
She's a "studio singer" now, but that's only because of excessive wear and tear on her larynx. She never had the right people around her when she started to look out for her (as she's mentioned in many print interviews) and this is the result now.
tbd 4 years ago
shes the best !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
321654987asdfghjkl 4 years ago
yall are idiots!! this is the end song to her tour... .when she gets to this song she had already sang and danced for 2 hours!! she's been hitting some difficult stuff on this tour! I dont blame her for not going up to the E in this song...
Radiomite 4 years ago
i LOVE christina ... but she NEVER does the high notes for this song. it gets really disappointing. the reason you go to her show is to hear her hit the high notes .... which she rarely attempts to do them. oh well. she is still my FAVOURITE female singer.
brittneereynolds 4 years ago
look up this song in her stripped tour, fighter live stripped world tour! she dus do the high notes, not having a go lol just thought id say
buffboyrich 4 years ago
I'm glad to hear she does hit them .. I haven't seen that performance yet, but I'll go look it up! =)
brittneereynolds 4 years ago
Well, I really love this song, it's her best, but, wtf is she doing to it???
I can barely say it's fighter, poor Christina.
alexzjay 4 years ago
I'm not suprised she didn't hit the high notes; she's probably been on stage singing for a long time and and she's moving around lots, it's still amazing!
gchunni 5 years ago
Christina just prefers to go for strong, middle notes while Mariah Carey goes into the whistle octave quite often... check Wiki. =P
toomart4u 5 years ago
don't get me wrong (i love christina) but she barely sang half the song. and... i can sing the entire thing on pitch like in the music video. but i've heard her live. she's usually better. what happened?:(
PrincessKat22 5 years ago
just to say xtina is the greatest, and i was wondering if anyone knew if and when xtina is gonna release this tour on dvd. i went and had the best time of my life! Thanks
pinkcandy2006 5 years ago
WTF how can u say dat coldnovemberrain. she rocks this world !!!! hi 2 all the ova xtina fans :P
xtinarox9 5 years ago
Christina never delivers.
ColdNovemberRain 5 years ago
I hate when singers don't sing the high parts but but avoid it. She never sings the octave she always avoid it she sucks. Mariah always goes for her high parts even when her voice is horse. Christina don't sing freakin notes on the cd if you can't hit them live! it's the whole point of seeing you in concert to hear you sing and hit the notes you sing on cd
tyee2005 5 years ago
look up christina in lady marmalade, with the ova girls and patti labelle, i think it was at the grammys, then say she never hits her high notes!!
buffboyrich 5 years ago
i've watched that one and listen to it it's her back record (studio recording) that hits the high notes. now patti that's a lady who its notes on her cd and beyond performers period should take a page out of her book. ms patti will put on a show no matter what!
tyee2005 4 years ago
BULL. It changes from each concert. I've watched a dozen videos. Sometimes she holds it long. Sometimes she holds it short.
It IS LIVE. Christina has vastly improved her vocals.
darrenstomas 4 years ago 9
I guess she's now feeling well that day,she transposted everything down, poor workaholic :) We got cha back Christina!!!
Thomasmama 5 years ago
I guess this was the only show she didn't hit the final note!
thiagofreitas89 5 years ago
she still got it! :D
always my angel!!!
DirrtyHoney 5 years ago
Danke.
resusu 5 years ago