Added: 2 years ago
From: SamiZaatari
Views: 4,570
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (567)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • @mossfitz You haven't read the quran. Would you like to have this conversation about this on Skype?

  • @mossfitz Why make a lie? You haven't read the quran, let alone hadiths. How do I know? The post says it all. 

  • @proudfemale

    Muslim Women are not oppressed, They have as much rights as the men do.

    Islam Honors and Liberates us.

    ''muslim women have been brainwashed/taught that they MUST obey/subjugate to male, accept wife beating & degradation of enforced inequality....and that they CANT LEAVE islam''

    Ignorance is not a bliss.

    Please do some research before claiming something that is completely false.

  • @Muslimah1011 I´ve read the Koran first 30 years ago while exploring the human heritage and was shocked by it in the extreme. I have since read it more carefully and also read some of the Hadith and my first reaction was multiply confirmed. Anyone who is not brainwashed and reads this for what it is will realize what an appalling ideology this mass murderer and child rapist has imposed on the world. The people who were at the centre of the first civilizations must be freed from this horror.

  • @mossfitz guess u wasted 30 yrs of ur life mate. too bad but u knw wat u can read COMMENTARIES from scholars like Imam Abu Hanifa [ra] his teacher Ibrahim Al Nakhai [ra] etc etc but I think I learned a thing from u u just want to hate ppl who believe the quran & true meanings of the hadiths :)

  • @younib100 The Koran reads like what it is, the self aggrandizing rantings of a criminal mind. All that endless repitition about peace - exactly like a crook telling you over and over again what a good guy he is - so one starts to suspect "methinks he doth protest too much" and sure enough, the LAST word comes- yeh i´m really nice but if you fuckin not on my side you fuckin dead. You must be completely blind and brainwashed not to see how this crap is merely there to justify tyranny. Stupifying

  • @mossfitz *yawn* u cud have done other things in that *30 yr* lifetime of yours instead of trying to prove the same old thing but then again for that u need to have a life which I guess u dont. lol 30 yrs seriously ?? xD

  • @younib100 you are a silly! I read it FIRST 30 years ago - i certainly wouldn´t contaminate my soul by spending years studying the quran! My second reading was an attempt to find out why such dreadful stuff appeals to so many. I think it has a lot to do with a basic animal fear of human conciousness - which always means CRITICAL conciousness - the ability to question what we percieve and collate information rationally - in short the painful act of thinking. That is what is great - and not AAAGH!

  • A muslim woman's body is also used for sex-marketing in the Qur'an and Hadeeth, because men are promised beautiful virgins in Jannah/Paradise if they fight in jihad and adhere to Islam.

    A woman's soul does not even have the same rights as a man, as her reward in Paradise subject to her dead physical body's gender.

  • What is "quite clear" is the fact that apostates are killed in many countries.

  • @riorio23

    yeah there is one murder every 20 min in USA and one woman raped every three minutes.

    You should be worried about your own problems intead what happends in "other" countries. your coutnry is the onyl country to have nuked not one but two cities with civilians. it does not suit you to talk about others killing people. iraq has seen more than 6 million fatalities because of the conflict brought there by your country (Lancet study)., correct your own house first,

  • @MuhammadUmerED new delhi is known as rape city...your mullahs rape little boys when they rip their bottoms & do it WITH IMPUNITY...& a doctor in karachi says his hospital alone treats 100 rape victims per day in a country where muslim women surveyed admit that cant dare report rape...to do so means beating/ostracisation/imprison­ment (right now in pakistan) or MURDER

    in US 8yo muslim child raped by a muslim is KICKED OUT from her family....re family 'shame'

  • @MuhammadUmerED correct your own house before you talk about rape...how about somalia & muslim leaders report rape/incest/abuse/pedophilia RAMPANT in your ummah - your mohammed was a RAPIST

    80 million hindus were MURDERED by muslims...your prick mhammed MURDERED innocents...and on a daily basis you SIT IN SILENCE when muslims kill muslims

    if the west is so 'bad' WHY do muslims clambour over themselves to get here???

    do tell

  • @riorio23 z

    USA still has death penalty for treason. So its alright for your system of beleif to kill those who "aid enemy" why it is worng for other beleif systems?

    Also, to clear your misconcpetion and for other muslims too, Koran does not declare any penalty for apostates at all. Unfortunately the so called "Islamic" states have this heineous punishment of death penalty for apostacy which is not right by any means. So it wrong for USA and its wrong for Islam.

  • @MuhammadUmerED

    stupid logic...first USA is not a religion..second, Treason is different for not believing anymore from djinns, ostrich egg shaped earth, and lamps in the sky...

  • @zeroweaver13

    Its less stupid thatn following American constitution which allows one to use nukes not on one, bu two civilian cities. I am definitely better off reading about jinns than invading vietnam and resulting more than million deaths. Of course most recent example is iraq where they resulted in more than 6 million deaths. By the way, earth is definitely not "round" . it is flatter at poles . read better sceince. Also just 'cause you cant see something does not mean it does not exist.

  • @zeroweaver13

    Also USA constitution is one system of beleif. Bleiving in a religion is another system of beleif. If ours is different from yours, and you dont like it, its your problem not ours.

  • @MuhammadUmerED

    the topic is about apostasy? what's the ruling? and your talking about USA constitution?...i don't care about your system...but the title of the video is "That's the ruling for apostasy" ..please stick to topic..your a muslim yourself so you must know? so what's your answer?

  • @zeroweaver13

    The ruling is clear from Koran

    "No coersion in matters of faith".

    thats the ruling . No death sentence for change of faith. If there is an issue of high treason, then yes there may be a question of death punishment but not for merely changing the faith. Does that answer your question or you want any elaboration? Please do let me know.

    Regards

  • @MuhammadUmerED please DONT LIE

    your dirty ;prick mohammed INSTRUCTED those who dont believe/turn away be KILLED...and all 4 schools of islamic jurisprudence support this. Muslim families are taught they must KICK OUT/OSTRACISE any family member...and they do

    of course not all the filth re islam is in koran...are you prepared to say that people arent forced to be 'living a lie' to stay alive in 2010...muslim leaders report its the 'more educated' in groundswell of non belief

  • @zeroweaver13

    PART 2:

    In prophet Muhammad's time there were some apostates who committed treason and wee put to death for that. There were others who changed their faith, and were not killed. Our religious scholars looked at the former examples and igonored the latter and hence the law of death punishment in most islamic countries. Obviously that is wrong and needs to be changed.

  • @MuhammadUmerED

    so what happens for a muslim who will change his/her religion? it's that ok?? what's the process?? what's the ruling based on quran??

    thanks for the answer by the way..

  • @zeroweaver13 hi...muhammad is 'deceiving' you...we call such LYING, and islam ALLOWS it...its called taqiyaa

    not all the horror we see re islam is in koran

    his dirty prick mohammed INSTRUCTED penalty for non belief/turning away is MURDER, & for families to OSTRACISE/KICK OUT family member...all 4 schools of islamic jurisprudence AND most muslims actually SUPPORT this, and today MILLIONS who we think are muslims are FORCED TO BE LIVING A LIE due to fear of being killed

  • @proudfemale

    And your reference for "taqqiya" is??????????

  • @MuhammadUmerED are you prepared to STATE ON HERE that lying to further the cause of islam isnt allowed?

    are you prepared to state on here that the penalty of MURDER/BEING KICKED OUT FROM FAMILY for non belief isnt what your mohammed INSTRUCTED

    you have repeatedly LIED...repeatedly

  • @proudfemale

    YEs lying to firther the cause of islam is not allowed. Lying for any reason except for saving someone's life is permitted but not otherwise.

    you shout a lot. slow down

  • @MuhammadUmerED you ARE LYING

    you LIED about death penalty

    'muslims more sensitive' LOL....what an understatement

    they IGNORE children abused by muslims....SIT IN SILENCE when muslim women degraded/mutilated...but only manage to get annoyed when a teacher called a teddy bear mohammed LOL

    your dishonesty is shameful...as are you EXCUSES

  • @MuhammadUmerED here in Sydney we had an imam in mosque teach muslim that to 'lie/cheat/steal/defraud' is quite ok and islam ALLOWS it when its again the kafir.....presumably all those present would know islam so DIDNT object or question him

    they did get very angry later though...NOT at what was taught in mosque, but at the journalist who reported it...they wanted him DEAD too 'surprise surprise'

    go to ummah.com and see for yourself the SUPPORT for murder

  • @proudfemale oh, not you again lol

  • @Omarh96 you again eh!!

    the submissive slaveboy who cant answer even the most simple basic questions re his koran...the one who is totally controlled due to taught fears/ignorance/stupidity

  • @proudfemale please, explain to me how you won our little argument concerning muslim women. like i said before, please don't go about representing muslim women as weak and oppressed, because, like its been proven in our last argument, the muslim women don't want you representing them

  • @Omarh96 the OPPRESSED are 'weak' because theyre denied rights/choice/voice

    muslim women have been brainwashed/taught that they MUST obey/subjugate to male, accept wife beating & degradation of enforced inequality....and that they CANT LEAVE islam

    are you saying girls denied childhoods, given to old men for use/abuse/beatings without LOVE OR INFORMED CONSENT are strong/free/healthily happy women??

    are you?

  • @zeroweaver13

    "so what happens for a muslim who will change his/her religion?"

    Unfortunately to best of my knowledge all the islamic countries have this wrong law of death sentence to apostacy which is considered equivalien to High treason in other countries(punishable by death in many countries but not others).

    IT is wrong but it is there. IF someone wants to leav e islam there is no ritual. one can just beleive what he wants and talk what they feel like.

  • @MuhammadUmerED

    thanks for honest answer..so there is no death penalty or whatsoever for apostasy (includes counselling etc..)

    my question is why there is so many muslim protesting against mohammed cartoons but no one protesting against Islamic countries practicing death penalty for apostasy?

  • @zeroweaver13

    For any paradigm shift to happen in society, there has to be a certain critical mass of people who can bring about the change. At the moment even in my own islamic coutnry, if I talk about disregarding hadith when it contradicts quran is probably gonna get me into trouble. There are other people and schools of thought like me but still we are far from that "critical mass" level. thats why you dont see "us" on the streets.

  • @zeroweaver13 he WASNT honest...dont be gullible

    ALL 4 schools of islamic jurpridence support MURDER as penalty for apostacy...as per what mohammed INSTRUCTED and muslims also support, AND WHAT HAPPENS to this very day

    he's practising his taqiyaa on you...that means muslims are ALLOWED TO LIE to further the cause of islam

  • @zeroweaver13

    In paksitan there is a case under media focus where a chrisitan woman apparently insulted prophet muhammad and was given a death sentence. Fortunately she will get a presidential pardon and will end up soemwhere in europe or US which is good. So as I said, it is an unfortunate situation but it is nevertheless true. what would happen if you openly declared your own president a traitor in public? whats the ruling in your country. In china, they would be jailed or something I think

  • @MuhammadUmerED sadly MANY are kille for such....speaking about your pedo/rapist/liar/necrophile/th­ief/MURDERER of innocents

    and this woman has already been in prison for 15 months...AND her children denied their mother's care

    so much for the deceit muslims dribble about islam having superior family values etc

    WHY if islam is true, and your sicko mohammed such a great guy LOL....would islam be SO INSECURE that any person who dared speak up be KILLED - it proves how WEAK the hoax is

  • @MuhammadUmerED

    who da fuck is your pig mohamed

    i would spit on his face if i see him

    fuck him and burn this pedo in hell

    fuck off pig nmuslim

  • @zeroweaver13

    Recently USA has banned a teenageer for ever entering USa because of an insulting email he wrote to Obama. Muslims are more sensitive to our prophet but I agree that a death sentence is quite extreeme no doubt about that.

  • @MuhammadUmerED

    your DISHONESTY is shameful/disgraceful...but is what muslims are known for

    you say 'if someone wants to leave islam there is no ritual...one can just believe what they want and talk what they feel like'

    evidently we know islam and what goes on in your ummah MORE than you do

    I had a muslim tell me even certain questions re teachings are forbidden...he called them illegitimate

    why do you LIE

  • @zeroweaver13

    Ruling based on quran:

    The quote from quran is as follows:

    2:256 THERE SHALL BE no coercion in matters of faith

    One is free to beleiove whatever one chooses to. you can see for your self in Qoran on website:

    h t t p : / / al-quran.info

    Remove spaces.

    On this site you can llook at many translations for comparision. I highly recommend to look at Muhammad Assad's translation (he was a jew who converted to islam and wrote this masterpiece).

  • @MuhammadUmerED WHY are you wanting to IGNORE what your prick mohammed instructed...and all 4 schools of islamic jurisprudence SUPPORT

    muslims SUPPORT MURDER for non belief/apostacy...MILLIONS who you think are muslim are forced to be 'living a lie' and youre dribbling about koran

    WHAT credibility does the man made book even have LOL

    LOOK what it says re embryology...and would you agree sun doesnt really set in muddy water?

    and are stars really missiles to chase jinns away with

  • @zeroweaver13

    Muhammad Asad..... contd

    In my opinion, convertees are better muslims than us (the "born" muslims) since they look at quran in an unbiased manner free from any political desire and hence their translations are way better than those by so-called muslim "scholars".

  • Respond to this video... I also suggest you look at Verse 4:137 since it talks about poeple who leave islam, enter islam again and leave it again . obviously it is talking about repeated apostacy which is possible ONLY if they wre not punished with death for apostacy. there is no mention of "go kill them". it merely warns that not heeding to Creator's message will bring suffering to them. it does not say anywhere "Go and kill them all". let me know if you need more answers. Regards

  • @zeroweaver13

    Another important verdict is that only two crimes are punishable by death and they are clearly spelled out by quran in e) 5:32 :

    1) Muder

    2) spreading mischeif in earth (soceity). eg if one is raping women, then this may warrant a death sentence. If one is spreading terrorism, that may warrant death sentence depending upon individual circumstances. Have I answered your question?

  • @MuhammadUmerED I am NOT PREPARED TO LET YOU AWAY with such dishonesty...in shariah there is NO PENALTY for killing one's offspring

    re spreading mischeif...and your reference to rape, your mohammed RAPED

    of course as we all know muslims who question or criticise are 'accused of spreading mischief' but mullahs who rip the bottoms of small boys do so with impunity

  • @zeroweaver13

    I hope that this punishment of apsotacy will change in decades to come through education of correct understanding of islamic law instead of following fabricated hadiths which has happened in many coutries. the process has begun already at level of individuals but will take time to get completed.

  • @zeroweaver13

    "Thanks for the answer by the way.."

    You are welcome.

    Inreference to "proudfemale" telling you about some thing called taqqiya, I have no frikkin idea where did she hear this. Taqqiya is the honest following of a high moral code fo dignity and respect which is preached by pretty much all faiths and not only islam. This religious following of a such code is termed a s taqqiya in arabic language. Its translation into english would be "high moral standards and piety".

  • @zeroweaver13

    "taqqiya"

    I would be greatful if you could forward any "references" that she gives you in support of her argument. I am not sure whre is she coming from.

  • that is a BS LOOK IN THE ISLAMIC COUNTRIES AND SEE WHAT HAPPENED TO APOSTATES, YOU ARE LIVING IN A ISLAMIC FANTASY

  • Though if the country is Islamic the sharia law clearly states that apostasy is dealt with a death penalty.

  • SamiZaatari, You explaination seems quite rational, why then do you have so many different opinions on this issue in Islam ?

    And unfortunatly the worst opinions are the ones that dominate.

    Nearly 50% of Muslims live in countries with the death penalty for apostacy, at least another 40% would face jail and/or serious social problems.

    The people do not accept apostates and this alone is a threat.

  • the quran says something about death penalty. so do many hadiths too.

    and becoming a member of a religious group and leaving one are not quite the same. not even remotely.

    islam might not force anyone directly but indirectly. as soon as they are able to gain political and military power it`s opression, third class citizen status, jizzia and jizzia plus so you can`t effort the rent anymore till you fuckin convert.

    islam can`t keep itself private just like other hobbies.

  • apostasy is when you LEAVE a religion. it has nothing to do with joining one.

    the hadith are perfectly clear on what to do with the 'traitors' who leave islam after accepting it.

    "whoever changes his islamic religion, kill him".Sahih Al-Bukhari (9:57)

    so, do you reject your hadith or do you accept it?

    or do you just pick the ones that are acceptable and ignore the rest...

    mthinks you cherry pick.

  • @humbletim10 seems you cherry pick right over what The highest Authority in Islam says and that is the Quran. Like he said here in the Video The Quran mentions apostasy several times and never mentions a death penalty. Quran 4:137,Quran 20:124,Quran 16:107,Quran 24:54,Quran 3:143,Quran 5:54 and more. So instead you just totally over look the Quran ( islam highest authority) and you pick another source over the Quran. Hmmm seems the problem is yours.

  • @MrIslamAnswersback does the qur'an specifically forbid the death penalty in any of those passages?

  • @humbletim10 Have you read those passages? Yes they do forbid the death penalty. Some even mention that the person believed and then apostates a fews times. If there was a death penalty , then why does the Quran ,mention that the person goes back and forth several times? How could they go back and forth if they were killed the 1st time?????

  • @MrIslamAnswersback do you claim Sahih Al-Bukhari is a weak hadith?

  • @humbletim10 do you claim Bukhari rules over the Quran???

  • @MrIslamAnswersback Ah, so when the Messenger of Allah said, “Whoever changes his religion, kill him." I guess he was full of shit.

    But everything ELSE he said was true. NOW I understand completely.

  • @robtbo Ahh so when the Quran tells Muhammad that he is only to deliver the message and whoever turns back is not his concern ( Quran 5:92,Quran 24:54,Quran 20:124) is all bull shit!? But a book LESS than the quran attributes a statement to Muhammad over rules the quran???? Plus other hadith explain that he didnt mean just changing their religion. Bukhari Vol 12 #6878 explains its those who leave Islam and come back fighting the muslims. So read more before you put forth your silly ass info ok

  • @MrIslamAnswersback I've read enough to know that the quran is a very good foundation for morals. My issue is with historical references documenting the messenger engaging in activities which are the exact opposite of the message. There's too many instances to rationally disregard them all, regardless of how many scholars get together to denounce them hundreds of years after the fact.

    There's no basis for believing the words of a murderer who tells you not to murder.

  • That's some harmonization you got there. People shouldn't be forced to remain Muslim... unless there are people infiltrating Islam to report on it. In this case, everybody will be forced to remain Muslim, least treason go unreported.

  • Im an ex muslim from Turkey and the way you say kuran is really ugly.

  • @miregrc as islam believe your religion is your and our religion is ours.

    it is you and God..no compulsion in religion.

  • I would like to accept your argument but..what about this? talking about treatment towards people rejecting Islam Sura: 4.89 - "They desire that you should disbelieve as they have disbelieved, so that you might be (all) alike; therefore take not from among them friends until they fly (their homes) in Allah's way; but if they turn back, then seize them and kill them wherever you find them"

    Why should people who reject Islam flee their homes or be killed? and which homes are in "Allah's way"?

  • @daveyjjj29 i just suggest you read quran entirely..you forget what is the context and you forget to read a whole chapter. to take verse randomly is not smart way

  • @daveyjjj29 thanks to ask my religion, people may talk about anything only from one verse. i sugest you to open youtube. title "does quran say kill christian and jew? yusuf estes. He will explain you what the context of this verse. when you dont know do not judge. ask a question. listen both side. then you can find the truth.

  • Read what Sheikh Yusuf AlQaradawi wrote on this subject (Apostasy: Major and Minor) for full explanation

  • Comment removed

  • Also the apostasy punishment was carried out by some of the companions like Ali ibn Abi Talib

  • Salam brother,

    Please read this hadith: The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said: "The blood of a Muslim individual who bears witness that there is no god but Allah and that I am the Messenger of Allah, is not to be shed except in three cases: in retaliation (in murder crimes), married adulterers (and adulteresses), and the one who abandons his religion and forsakes the Muslim community." (Reported by the Group). It is clear there is punishment for apostasy

  • I think its quite OBVIOUS they we can not murder someone, even if they committed apostasy.

  • Sahih Bukhari, Volume 4, Book 52, Number 260:

    Ali burnt some people and this news reached Ibn 'Abbas, who said, "Had I been in his place I would not have burnt them, as the Prophet said, 'Don't punish (anybody) with Allah's Punishment.' No doubt, I would have killed them, for the Prophet said, 'If somebody (a Muslim) discards his religion, kill him.' "

    We have one life - 80 years if you are lucky. Why waste them praising a supernatural dictator who is a construct of man? LIVE YOUR LIFE FREE!

  • I like your hair.

  • 2) But what we DOES find in the quran ..... the words : 'THERE IS NO COMPULSION IN RELIGION'!

    3) Number of apostacy puinishment case during Muhammads time : ZERO, and if there REALLY is such law of apostacy, it is they themselves who probably want to vote for it and does not come from Allah Himself because NOTHING IS EVER SAID ABOUT PUNISHMENT FOR APOSTACY IN THE QURAN!!!!!!!

  • @juujuubie the truth is the christian felt it is their duty to convert the muslim to christianity even by the worst means such as humiliating them! BUT true muslims will know that the ESSENSE of Islam is simply to do good deed as donation and pray to Allah again and again and again and again and again........not human head!

  • why does non muslims such as christian still wants to talk about this? if they think the true muslim will feel totally humiliated by this, and leave islam, then i'm sorry, it wont work that way. i would like to repeat this again :

    1) NO WHERE IN THE QURAN DOES ALLAH ORDER FOR THE APOSTATES OF ISLAM BE KILLED! OTHER PUNISHMENT BY ALLAH, YES AND MANY, BUT PUNISHMENT FOR APOSTACY, NONE!

  • It really is quite clear-cut - Bukhari "if a muslims leaves his religion, kill him".

    Sounds like you only believe in what you want to believe. Thats not Islam.

    I left Islam because I was objective and the only way of ascertaining the real truth.

    Sounds to me like you are not interested, you desperately want to believe Islam is what you think it is, and are prepared to perform countless mental gymnastics to meet this end.

    Good luck to you. I'm out.

  • @ExMuslimUK the apostasy is mention in the Quran 22 times . and there is no evidence that prophet Muhammad killed any one for only the apostasy.

    we classify them as Ahad ( isolated narration ) by the hadith study , and it is the opposite of Mutawater ( that was narrated by large number of people ) = which can not be false because of the large number of people .

    And Quran teaches the freedom of faith

    2:256 There should be no compulsion in religion.

    10:99, 24:54, 42:6 ......

  • Jeez I wonder why so many Muslim countries have death penalties for apostates. Hmmm.

    So let me get this straight can I publicly go on TV in Saudi and say I left Islam and became an atheist? or convert to Christianity? Shall I take you word for it?

  • unfortunately the explanations given are both inadequate, inconsistent, and improper.

    the ambiguity and contradictory relationship and content between the Quran and Hadith just makes the whole concept of "Islam = Perfect For All times" mantra very much laughable and nonsensical.

    thank allah i am an apostate...even if that would make me wajib-ul-qatal :)

  • In all the Muslim world it is well known that you are highly likely to be killed for Apostasy. What don't understand about that?

    Also - You are a person who has been indoctrinated by Islam from childhood and you expect to be taken seriously?

    You also say there is no compulsion - that is pure Taqiyya - have you ever heard of "Dhimmi"? That's "Dhimmi" - don't pretend you don't know it or conveniently forget it.

    As with all Muslims - when you try to excuse Islam you fall flat on your face.

  • One more question. Do you think the decision made by the prophet to kill all apostates for being spies was justified?

  • If you can't force someone to stay in the religion (Islam), then why is apostasy punished with death in some Islamic countries?

    Genuine question.

  • your missing the point.......its what the religion does.. the Cult of islam Kills apostasy... and if you make fun of the Cult to any member....and yes it does... SUra 3:34 Lop-off their heads..

    Islam Kills .... it's happens.. watch the news.. The cause of war is islam..

    you llike most islam is so full of shit.. your bull shit is so good.. its beLIEvable..

  • The verse about "no compulsion in religion"and other verses about peace are ABROGATED !

    Stop lying to yourselves please.

  • i suggest every one to go to google: "Is Apostasy a Capital Crime in Islam?". click the first page that comes up.

  • @meSGdude : i suggest you read this article "Is Apostasy a Capital Crime in Islam?". click the first page that comes up.

  • deutronomy 13 orders the death of apostates.

  • @jihadulnafs thats for the fully jewish state that is supposed to completely follow god and which did witness miracles of god himself this israel, with a king the temple etc, this israel no longer exists

  • thts nt evrythng ,,,, I'M a muslim .. !! the problem is ( whn Muslims discuss wth non Muslims !! thy used Quraan to prove their Ideas .. !! becuz Non muslims doesn't knw how how clash Quraan is ,,!! they dont knw wht;s going on with ( ALnasikh wal mansokh ) the prophet of Islam call for killin non muslims nd PP who give up believin in Islam

  • It don't matter what you say ,you talk about truth and evidence .

    Here's the Truth ,it IS done in Saudi Arabia and Iran and other places .But what are muslims doing ?Are you out protesting against this ? do you you lobby your politicians ? are you joining Amnesty International ? .There is an unwillingness for muslims to criticize other muslims .I think this is rather stupid of you ,there will be those who will take full advantage ,it's just human nature .

  • @Radicalindifference apostasy is in all the monosthetic religions including christianity and judaism.

    get ur facts straight

  • @theEBKman What facts The Death penalty for apostasy is implemented is predominantly islamic these days ,is this something you agree with ?

    I'm an atheist I don't defend any religion

  • @meSGdude Oh look it's the same law as given to Moses and Jesus. Wow you really proved your point.

  • Great explanation!

    Al Taquiyya?

  • al taqiyah is hiding the fact that you are muslim if you feel you will be harmed or killed.

  • Arab christians kill their kids when they become muslim. See the story of Ruba Qewar.

    So many coptic christians who became muslim have been slaughtered. Jordanian, syrian, lebanese, and palestinian converts to islam as well.

  • As A Religion Teachings Only Islam Order The Killing Of Apostasy.

    There May Be Some Non-Muslims Doing This But This Act Is Against Your Religion.

    -Narrated Ikrima: Ali burnt some people and this news reached Ibn 'Abbas, who said, "Had I been in his place I would not have burnt them, as the Prophet said, 'Don't punish (anybody) with Allah's Punishment.' No doubt, I would have killed them, for the Prophet said, 'If somebody (a Muslim) discards his religion, kill him.' "

    Sahih Bukhari 4:52:260

  • Don't Ever Mix With Religious Teachings And With People Reaction.

  • I'm sorry. The Prophet Mohamed saws spoke arabic not english.

  • lol .. they were not atheists ...!!

    enought to see how dochbag you are.

  • this why we need freedom and seperation of religion and state

  • He gave you a clear answer. It doesn't matter how you feel about it but it is clear and right.!

  • we see communists countries did this and ooops they failed

  • Hadiths are NOT "what people used to say to each other"! Hadiths are the saying of only the Prophet and who ever denies them exits from Islam. btw An authentic Hadith found in Bukhari and Muslim says, "Grow your beard and trim ur mustache..." May be u should follow the full Islam and just a part of it...

  • how is that relevant to this video.

  • The way u interpreted the verse, explain why did the 1st Caliph Abu Bakr r.a fought with people who refused to pay zakat after Prophet's death? Secondly if prophet ordered excecution of only the "spies" then why would apostates not become spies today? Your explaination of apostates in muslim history suites more on hypocrites than apostates and Prophet never ordered execution of hypocrites. (because only Allah knows whats in their hearts i.e true faith or not).

  • Yes I need God. But I do not need Islam. God will reward you in heaven whether a muslim or not , That is in the Quran.God did not create Islam - Mohammed did. In the early years of Mohammed's life there were no muslims nor was there Islam It did not exist. Thjis video is meaningless and without foundation This video is meaningless

  • prove it. Cause I can prove the opposite

  • Religion is degrading to mankind. Stand up for reason!

  • Islam is reason.

  • Islam is not reason. Are you an idiot? Faith is a rejection of reason - what other definition is there? "the evidence of things unseen?" Because faith frees you from a concrete, objective universe, faith is an *excuse,* a license, the roadblock that will bar humanity from coming to a consensus on a universally applicable ethical system, common understanding, and peace through reason, the highest expression of our humanity. Islam/Christianity/Judaism are not reason - they are insanity.

  • @urvil man, you apparently haven't seen what the Quran said over 1400 yrs. regarding science, etc. And no I'm not talking about a few of the translations in english that were translated wrong either.

  • Right so you are always challenging non-believers to find contradiction in the Quran and Hadith, and when it's found you 'harmonize' these contradictions so they make sense...Surely the word of God would need to be harmonized as it's perfect to start with!

    You live in a bubble. Everything is proof to you...When it's proof you're wrong you ignore it. You're basically a waste of air.

  • @rogan71 people out there may speak what they like. we never force people to believe in islam indeed islam as the fastest religion in west and europe. and islam did not teach to kill the apostasy simply by leaving it peacefully. Allah even mentioned three times for forgiveness if they believe and then disbelieve and then believe and then disbelieve. Allah give them chance till Allah seal their heart for their hipocrite and none can guide them anymore.

  • @ilamsayang

    so help me out here...at SOME point the hypocrite ( who is a fake Muslim and actively works against Islam) these people should be killed? Is it because they have acted against Muslim people or is it their willful failure to too see truth of Islam. Was this a historical need or is it a truth that endures today?

  • @rogan71 Indeed

  • Can you please explain your assumption that God was the author of the Quran ?

  • @theH0UNDSofD00M Read it for yourself and then judge .

  • And if the Quran (Bible or Talmude) originated from God, why is it that so many men were involved in their manufacture, either as writers or promoters.Why would a super powerful all seeing being with permanent and eternal cosmic address choose to communicate by riddles and open to interpretation rules that couldn't even predict the future. At least I'm not aware on any ban on nuclear weapons in the Quran, neither on anything else invented after it's first versions.

  • Where in the Quran does it say this?

  • Is there a punishment for drinking alcohol in the Quran?

  • Also can you substantiate your claim that the order to kill apostates in the hadith was meant only for "spies"?

  • The Qur'an states quite clearly that apostates should be killed.

    Q4.89 : They but wish that ye should reject Faith, as they do, and thus be on the same footing (as they): But take not friends from their ranks until they flee in the way of Allah (From what is forbidden). But if they turn renegades, seize them and slay them wherever ye find them; and (in any case) take no friends or helpers from their ranks;-

  • Good foundation, but comical argumentation in the end.

    Why would a spy make himself more suspicious by renouncing his (cover) religion?

    Renouncing your religion is just a declaration, if one wanted to desert, one would do so without announcing it to everyone.

  • hear this my dear friend...

    by pronouncing his apostasy towards muslims...

    muslims will have doubts on Islam...and the goverment will fall a part...

  • The reason there is no killing for apostasy is because islam is an army of terrorists. If you don't want to fight for this army than they don't need you. They will soon kill you when they kill the rest of the non muslims.

    Volume 1 Book 8 Number 387

    Allah's Apostle said, "I have been ordered to fight the people till they say: 'None has the right to be worshipped but Allah.' And if they say so, pray like our prayers, face our Qibla and slaughter as we slaughter

  • On YouTube's "Islam: 'Whoever Changes His Religion - Kill Him' I," TheTrueIslamImam has recently written that "in all couwntries traytors are punished by death. so WHY U FUCKING FILTHY KUFFARS ARE SO FULL OF HATE WHEN SOMONE TRAITORS LAND AND!!!! RELGION TO DIRTY IMPURE UNBELIEVERS??? THEY DESERVE NOT ONLY DEATH BUT ALSO TORTURE AND SLOW AND PAINFUL DEATH!!! ISLAM WILL DOMINATE!!! ALLAHU AKBAR!!!" He is evidently living in the United Kingdom. Gordon Brown, direct your attention here, please.

  • "evidence"!? "facts"!? The koran is exactly like any other book of fiction -- full of stories and opinions, nothing more. To base one's life in the teachings of a 1400 year old book of meaningless metaphors is the height of irrationality. It does not matter what your book says, polls indicate that a majority of muslims worldwide say that apostates deserve death. Muhammad was a psychopathic serial killer and pedophile! SIC SEMPER TYRANNIS!  ALL gods are MYTHS!

  • well it sounds like you've done your research the only problem now is why do other muslims still call for apostates to be killed?

  • cus other muslim are stupid they dont know thier own relgen thats why

  • ok so theres not actually 1.5 billion muslims in the world because half of them have no idea what they're talking about. why not educate them first before you try and convert people, and not just you but muslims in general

  • many tri to but some shaks are more concerned about noncence insted of things that matter

  • BRAIN CONTROL

    In the 1990s apostasy case against Hussein Qambar 'Ali, the court ruled that "the [Kuwait] constitution respects freedom of religion but it does not mean that a Muslim should be allowed to convert from his religion to another." In the 2007 decision against Lina Joy, Malaysia's Federal Court ruled that "a person who wanted to renounce his/her religion must do so according to existing laws or practices....a person cannot at one's whims and fancies renounce or embrace a religion."

  • When Afghanistan's Abdul Rahman was found two or so years ago to be carrying a Bible after having converted to Christianity, he was formally charged with "rejecting Islam." The prosecutor said he should be put to death, a fate that surely would have befallen him had Western powers not intervened. If not, then it seems Islam merely threatens death to Muslims who exercise their God-given right to freedom of thought. Muslim words and Muslim deeds are frequently at variance with each other.

  • It seems a good idea to add here that in the May 30, 2007, decision against Lina Joy, Malaysia's Federal Court ruled that "a person who wanted to renounce his/her religion must do so according to existing laws or practices of the particular religion. Only after the person has complied with the requirements and the authorities are satisfied that the person has apostatised, can she embrace Christianity....In other words, a person cannot at one's whims and fancies renounce or embrace a religion."

  • It also seems a good idea to ask how a court could possibly arrogate to itself jurisdiction over what goes on in people's brains, especially concerning wholly unprovable faith. Such decisions as these support the inescapable conclusion that Muslims intend to reject human governance of Islam but instead continue allowing the private god of a self-serving, seventh-century "prophet" to rule the world as extensively as they can. To that end Muslims bend their lies about Islam's no-exit disposition.

  • FREEDOM? Then there's Afghanistan's Abdul Rahman. In 2006, his family reported him to the police, who arrested him when they found him to own a Bible. Calling him a "microbe" and traitor, prosecutors asked for the death penalty. The Afghan Attorney General said he should be hanged. Judge Ansarullah Mawlawizadah said "Muhammad said that those who convert from Islam should be killed if they refuse to come back. Islam is a religion of tolerance, [so] if he regrets what he did we will forgive him."

  • The Qur'ān at 4:89 says "They [we unbelievers] but wish that ye should reject Faith, as they do, and thus be on the same footing (as they): But take not friends from their ranks until they flee in the way of Allah (From what is forbidden). But if they turn renegades [this can mean nothing but apostatize], seize them and slay them wherever ye find them."

  • AHADITH: Bukhari 52:260: "...The Prophet said, 'If somebody (a Muslim) discards his religion, kill him.'" Bukhari 83:37: "Allah's Apostle never killed anyone except...a man who fought against Allah and His Apostle and deserted Islam and became an apostate." Bukhari 84:57: "[In the words of] Allah's Apostle, 'Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him.'" Bukhari 89:271: "A man who embraces Islam, then reverts to Judaism is to be killed according to "the verdict of Allah and his apostle."

  • RE: Bukhari 52:260, 83:37,84:57

    Read the context...These are refering to the time of the prophet...I thought you've watched the vid?

    Tut, tut...

    A muslim cannot kill an ex-muslim for MERELY accepting the Christian/Buddist/Hundu concept of God..

    I hope this is clear now.

  • Abul A'lā Maudoodi said Qur'ān 2:256 "means we do not compel anyone to come into our religion. And this is truly our practice. But we initially warn whoever would come and go back that this door is not open to come and go. Therefore anyone who comes should decide before coming that there is no going back." Bernard Lewis wrote "For [apostasy] there is no human forgiveness, and according to the overwhelming majority of the jurists, the [male] renegade must be put to death." Females are flogged.

  • Quran 2:256..Let there be no compulsion in religion...whether the person goes or stays is up to Allah...PERIOD.

  • 4:89 They wish that you disbelieve as they have disbelieved, then you become equal. Do not consider them friends, unless they mobilize along with you in the cause of GOD. If they turn against you, you shall fight them, and you may kill them when you encounter them in war. You shall not accept them as friends, or allies.

    NOW...READ 4:90...

  • Do the added verses seem significant to you, Guru? You seem to want me to suppose they alter the threat of 4:89. But they merely dither over what to do about apostates, 4:88 saying Muslims shouldn't bother over them because Allah decides who believes (in which case everyone is apparently an unbeliever), 4:90 offering an amnesty to those who "withdraw from you." They do not cancel 4:89's "seize them and kill them" order. Islam says apostates are to be killed.

  • Added verses? No added verses sweetheart...I made it easier for you to understand...

    This is how it is...This is the opinion of the Islamic world and people who translate and understand Arabic...

    You, my friend are embarrassing yourself with YOUR interpretations!!!

  • I must also recommend that readers take a look at YouTube's "Islam: 'Whoever Changes His Religion - Kill Him' I" site. What could so thoroughly have gouged out these people's heads, then put them back together looking like actual humans? This is the Islamic submission we hear about. Here are normal-looking people sitting around agreeing that others shouldn't be allowed to go on living, for having changed their minds! They are madness incarnate! Let's hear no more about the goodness of Islam.

  • Muslims are gangland guys with a god. At "Mexico's indigenous minority converting to Islam 14 Mar 08," no one who reads Kellystarr's "if u ever say ur racist ingorant insult & views in public abt Muslims & Irish u literrally be dead" could doubt it. Nearby, she said "The christian concept of love and peace has not worked." So we understand her opting for Islam, where the murder of those who don't play along is the way business is done and the perfect have God's right to kill the imperfect.

  • RE: where the murder of those who don't play along is the way business is done and the perfect have God's right to kill the imperfect

    Play along to WHAT? No one is perfect...

    We are ALL infallible.

    Have you seen watched Bro Sami's vid?

    Why waste time exposing your stupidity?

  • Only the infallible could assert knowledge of what's infallibly true, as Muslims often do on YouTube.

    Why waste time exposing my stupidity? Obviously, I just don't know any better.

  • RE: Obviously, I just don't know any better..

    I appreciate your honesty...

    Now stop posting rubbish and watch this vid again...

  • Yeah, sure thing boss. There I was, doing my own thinking. I don't know what came over me.

    Did my comment about infallibility upset you? One of history's most consistent lessons is that Muslims expect to brook no opposition, so I can understand your pique.

  • How can you possibly upset me?

    Everything you've put forth is junk...

    Take my advice and watch the vid P-R-O-P-E-R-L-Y...

    The only way you'll upset me is if you don't watch this and carry on posting more messages...

    Peace.