lol, why is it always the neo- hanafis who always use filthy language against people who wont follow their fiqh opinion? Then they complain about intolerance
y u r engry about ali.. Ali is the imam for Abu Bakar Umer Usman and all 124000 ashab of nabi pak.. when prophet PBUH announced in gadeer e khum Man Kum Tm Mola Hum Fahaza Ali hn Mola" then the 1st beliver of Ali's Imamat or molayet is Omer ibne Khatab..
Hazrat Ali is the imam for All Ashab e Karam and All ashab e karam are praying behind Ali... even all three khalifs... If this is wronng thn i challanged u.. ali was imam for all.. am not shia am true muslim.. challanged u..
Prophet prayed 8+3 rakats not only in Ramadhan. He prayed throughout the year. If you take this hadeeth it should be prayed thoroughout the year. In practical no one is doing this. What you going to loose if you make more sajda during Ramadhan? Alhamdulillah I enjoyed praying 20 rakat of Tharaweeh in Masjidul Haram in Makkah.
for the urdu speaking brothers plz watch this short explanation of why its 20 rakats taraawih at the 2 haraamain. BY an aalim and a teacher who teaches regularly at masjid al haraam.
the video is called "Taraweeh Prayer - What happens in Makkah | Dr. Wasiullah Abbas "
Listen to the guy and see what he is saying carefully there is nothing wrong with praying 20 coz the longer the ibadaat the better if u pray 8 there ain't nothing wrong with that if u have doubts refer back to the hadiths that he has given u as evidence seems like u guys want to fight without even knowing why u read 20 or 8 remember do not follow blindly even if it is right refer back to the hadiths to back your claims may Allah guide us all
iTne JAhil Log HaiN YAhN PAr Dr SahaB HAdith Ka HAwala De rahe HAin k Kahan KahN likha HAi Rakat Ka TAb bhi SAlay Apni hi Ghori Age RAkhein ge JAb K PAt HAi In ko K Zakr Sahab Ka Ghara Peeche RAha HAi....JAHIL JAHIL
plese people Listen t is mentioned in Book of Tahajudd so Ayesha(R.A) is talking about tahajudd not about taraweeh .
Also she said in ramadan and in other months prophet offered 11 with sequence of 4,4 and 3 so she is clearly talking about tahajudd not taraweeh.Holy prophet(PBUH) offered taraweeh in his last year .
Ayesha (R.A ) was alive when umar ,usman and Ali used to offer 2o rakaaht of taraweeh but she never objected.......
i think Hazrat Umar R.A best know sunnat from us if He had offererd 20 then i think we have no right to say someting about it and also at the end Dr Zakir said that at harmain 20 rakat are offered in one and half hour then it mean that 20 rakat are best from 8.
MASHA ALLAH.....ALL THE HADITH BOOKS SUPPORT TOTAL 8 RAKATS & THERE IS NO MENTION OF 20 RAKATS IN ANY HADITH BOOK....WHY SHOULD WE VIOLATE THE HOLY SUNNAH ? WE MUST LOVE THE SUNNAH AS GIVEN IN HADITH...WE SHOULD ALSO KNOW THAT TRAWIH & TAHAJAD ARE THE SAME NIGHT PRAYERS,WHICH WE CAN JOIN WITH SALAT E EISHA IN THE MONTH OF RAMAZAN FOR OUR CONVENIENCE...SO MINIMUM RAKATS ARE 8 + 1,3,5,7 or 9 RAKATS OF WITAR WAJIB UPTO ANY NUMBER OF RAKATS OF TARAWIH.....
WallahuAlam bisawwab. Only Allah Knows best. What ever type of prayers we offer, It is up to Allah's judgement to which one He Sees best. Allah is All-Knowing, Wise.
The sunnah of our beloved Prophet (saw) was 8 rakat. Another "sunnah" is what our rightly guided caliph Omer (ra) instituted. The Saudi ulema have stated that 8 or 20 -- either is sunnah, which is why they do 8 all over most of the Arab world, and allow 20 at the Haram and Madinah. Moderation, the middle way, that is also the sunnah, and the Prophet told us to avoid extremism in religion. There is nothing to argue about; either number is "sunnah".
mr zakir naik hazrat umar radi. known better muhammad s.a.w. rather than imam bukhari r. a. so its better to follow 2nd kaliph radi. and perform 20 rakat of taravih
bUT FROM A COMMON SENSE POINT OF VIEW, the Imam reads one spara every night. So if you are only reading 8 rakat, then you are depriving yourself most of the Quran (less than half), so surely this is a bad thing? Especially becasue in Ramadan we are meant to pray as much as POSSIBLE, not "as much as you wish" - there is a clear difference. Shame on those who only read 8 because of laziness, especially when our Nabi (PBUH) used to pray all night sometimes.
i can't believe in this day and age among our sunni/hanafi muslims, there are still people who choose to pray 8 rakaat of taraweeh. whats worse is there are people so concerned about throwing iftaar parties that they choose to have this big gathering, so much food, samosa, pakora, fruit, multiple dishes, multiple desserts, they get so busy in their food they completely neglect taraweeh and miss the whole point of ramadan with their extravagance. Allah have mercy on us all!
@usyk36 Allama ibn Taymiyyah (rh) writes that Ubay bin Ka’b (ra) led the Sahabah (raa) in twenty rak’ah taraweeh during the Khilafah of ‘Umar (ra). (Fatawa Ibn Taymiyyah, v.1 p.148). He further writes (v.1 p.191) that because Ubay led the Sahabah (raa) in twenty rak’ah taraweeh and three rak’ah witr during Ramadan, most ‘Ulema regard this to be a Sunnah because all of the Muhajireen and Ansaar performed the salah without an objection from any of them.
The famous scholar of Ahl al-Hadith Nawab Siddique Hasan believes that “’Ulema regard as ijma the twenty rak’ah taraweeh salah that was performed during the Khilafah of ‘Umar (ra). (Awnul Bari, v.4 p.307)
Those Ghair Muqalideen who accuse Umar for introducing the innovation of 20 Rakats Taraweeh in his Khilafat, ask yourselves this, are you not treading the same path with your words as the Rawafid (Shia) in the time of Ibn Taymiyyah (RA)?
Abi Abdur Rahman Salmi (RA) related: In the nights of Ramadhan, Sayyidina Ali (RA) called upon the recitors of the Qur’an (Huffaz/Qura) and ordered one amongst them to lead the people in 20 Rakats of Taraweeh. Sayyidina Ali (RA) would lead the people himself in the Witr Salah. (Sunan Kabeer Baihaqi vol 2, p496/ Fathul Bari vol 4, p219)
Hafiz Ibn Taymiyyah (RA) writes in his Fatawa: ‘Verily it has been proven that Umar made Ubay ibn Ka’ab (RA) lead the people in 20 Rakats of Tarawih and 3 Witr in Ramadhan. This is the way of the scholars of this Ummah and this is the Sunnah. This is due to the fact that Sayyidina Ubay ibn Ka’ab (RA) read 20 Rakats Tarawih in a large congregation of the Muhajireen and Ansar of the Sahabah and none amongst them objected to this practice.’ (Fatawa Ibn Taymiyyah vol 1, p191/ Al Mughni vol 1, p803)
one question for those who say this bukhari hadith refers to tahhajjud and they are different prayers
we all agree this only one witr prayer in a night?? then for eg. how can one pray witr with taraaweeh (20 +3 ) and then witr again later on in tahajjud. (8+3).
For all those who says, 20 rakaah is bid'a and that 8 rakaah is the correct statement, has deviated from the Salaf saliheen, and thus deviated from Ahlus Sunnah wal Jamaah. Unfortunately those who call themselves "Salafis" are abandoning the Salaf Saliheen´s way, and some of them are blind followers of Abdul Wahab Najd and Albani, Zakir Naik, and many more.. May Allah guide us all to the Aqida of Ahlus Sunnah.. Amin
why ask a dawah expert to give rulings he isnt qualified to give, he isnt a fiqh expert. all 4 schools are unanimously agreed as were the sahaabas that taraawih is 20 rakkats, they pray this in makkah and medina and masjid al aqsa etc, 8 is tahajjud not taraawih
@kareemabdullah Yes, they pray 20 at makkah at madinah -- perhaps to assure people that 20 is permissible. Elsewhere all over Saudi and the middle east they pray 8. The ulema have made it clear that while 8 is the sunnah, 20 is permissible as set by Umar (ra).
@Serenity97531 actually, 8 is not the sunnah, 20 is the consensus of the sahabas, and therefore the sunnah of rasoolullah s.a.w, 8 is the new invention of the salafi sect, and the prophet s.a.w only prayed tahajjud for 8 rakkats as mentioned in bukhari by a'isha r.a
@kareemabdullah just to note: even those who argue that 20 is correct, admit that one of the narrators in the chain of hadith was one with Shia leanings. Many people who pray 20 concede that the Prophet prayed 8 rakas. While we are encouraged to follow rightly guided scholars in any matter that isn't clear, there is nothing in Islam that says we should reject what our Prophet did. There was no such term as "tarawih" back then - tahajjud means the night prayers, so does tarawih.
@Serenity97531 thats a lie than one narrator had shia leanings, and also, the prophet saw prayed 20 rakaats, thats why the sahabas implemented that and theummah has kept it up, also, the hadith salafis use to prove 8 rakkats is clearly talking about the prayer that is done only in ramadhaan a.k.a tarawih, its clearly not tahajjud meantioned because tahajjud is all year round
@kareemabdullah astagfarAllah, accusing fellow Muslims of lying! subhanAllah. The document where I learned that information - that one of the narrators in the chain had shia leanings - was written by someone who SUPPORTS the notion of 20 rakats. They admitted that, but said that person's character was deemed "ok" anyway. Do your research. And please, for the sake of Allah, do not accuse people of lying just because they express something different than you believe.
@kareemabdullah where did u get this information??? give references. u say zakir is unqualified u have no right to say that unless u have proof. how do u know u know that all 4 schools of thought and sahabas are unanimously agreed that its 20. where is proof?
@1994mrmysteryman all 4 schools of thought have always said its 20 rakaats, ask any muslim who has been around for more than 30 years, before then nobody prayed 8 rakaats, its a new salafi bida' based on weak hadiths that isnt founded in the practise of the sahabas, i have all the quotes you need to prove my point, and makkah and madina have alwways prayd 20, the prophet s.a.w said my ummah wont have consensus on falsehood, well the majority of the ummah and scholars say 20 rakaats
@kareemabdullah brother. thanx for the reply. But u speak about weak hadiths. i thought zakir naik gave you quotations from sahih ahadith. that the prophet (pbuh) prayed 11. ... 8 then 3. in tahajjud we dont pray odd number i think... and he gave quotations abt sahabas praying different number of rakats which prophet(pbuh) permitted. so there is nothing "falsehood" about praying 8 or 20. your reply?
@1994mrmysteryman the hadith about 8 then 3 from bukhari he said about is about the tahajjud prayer, i will said you a really good video audio lecture on the subject
@kareemabdullah All over Saudi Arabia and the middle east they pray 8 rakats, even though in Makkah and Madinah they pray 20. If the Saudi Ulema believed that 20 rakat is the only "sunnah", then none of the masajid would be allowed to pray 20. The Saudi muttawa (religious police) are quite strict and would ensure than the masajid did have 8 rakat tarawih prayers. (The muttawa go around gathering people for prayers, making sure businesses are closed and no men are standing about!)
@Serenity97531 * correction: if the Saudi Ulema believed that 20 rakat is the only "sunnah", then none of the masajid would be allowed to have tarawih pray for LESS THAN 20.
@Serenity97531 Yeah that's right, I live in Riyadh & the Imam of my mosque always prays 8 rakats. I've lived there for 15 years and the same Imam always does it the same way.
@Serenity97531 Yeah that's right, I live in Riyadh & the Imam of my mosque always prays 8 rakats. I've lived there for 15 years and the same Imam always does it the same way.
Though in Makkah & Madina & in some larger mosques they do offer 20 rakats but mostly in the kingdom we offer 8 rakats
@kareemabdullah 8 is not wrong 20is not wrong 40is not wrong 100is not wrong because the hadith is clear on this pray 2 2 2 and so on and its clear in Bukhari 8+3 is sunnah you dont need to be an Ulema to understand that 8 is 8 And one more thing Prophet Muhammad s.a.w comes before the sahabas you dont follow the sahabas and then the prophet s.a.w you follow the prophet. s.a.w and then the sahabas.
@kareemabdullah 8 is not wrong 20is not wrong 40is not wrong 100is not wrong because the hadith is clear on this pray 2 2 2 and so on and its clear in Bukhari 8+3 is sunnah you dont need to be an Ulema to understand that 8 is 8 And one more thing Prophet Muhammad s.a.w comes before the sahabas you dont follow the sahabas and then the prophet s.a.w you follow the prophet. s.a.w and then the sahabas.
@kareemabdullah Why you play with words, why not straightly say the true "4 sects" instead of "4 schools" and Dr. Zakir Naik is quoting from the Qur'an and Mohammed's sayings so if you claim he's incorrect your going against the Qur'an and Saheeh Hadith's. Further more he also said it is not forbidden to pray 20 rekats also he said the more the better. So your kinda putting holes in the air as they say...
@kareemabdullah Hazrat Umar (RA) orded 8 rakat tarawee and in makkah and madina they also do rafa yadain before and after ruku but you blind followers dont .
@choudry1231 where is your proof??? The fact is that umar r.a ordered 20 and thats why since his time, 20 rakaats has never once siesed to be prayed in makkah or madinah, they have never once prayed 8 rakaats and this opinion is a new salafi opinion based on misinterpretation of hadiths, also, the imams of makkah and madinah do rafa yadain because they are hanbalis, so if im a blind follower for following the hanafi madhab then so are they for following the hanbali madhab
@choudry1231 i have the evidences that umar ordered 20, where is your evidence??? Also, the sahabi that narrated the hadith in bukhari about rafa yadain has also narrated a sahih hadith saying the prophet s.a.w never did it, the hanafi ruling is that the prophet s.a.w for most of his life didnt do rafa yadain, then he did it for a short time, then stopped again, so rafa yadain has been abrogated.
THE HADEETH QUOTED FIRST - SAHIH BUKHARI VOL 1 BOOK OF SALAT HADEETH NO. 472 is Error it should be HADEETH NUMBER SAHIH BUKHARI CHAPTER 8 (BOOK OF SALAT) HADEETH NO. 462
i left islam my muslim brothers islam is false like all other religions ,i am now atheist happy and free , (atheism akbar) peace and now i relly mean it, thank you
That's beside the point. To present one hadith that doesn't refer to taraweeh prayers to prove your point about the raka'ahs in taraweeh is misleading. 20 raka'ahs of taraweeh have been established since the time of Umar (RA). To hold on to the sunnah of the khulafa has been commanded by Rasoolullah (SAW). Therefore, to go against that and suggest that following the practice as established by 'Umar (RA) is going against the sunnah, then that is ignorance plain and simple.
@u124n1um Ibn Taymiyyah (RA) writes in his Fatawa:‘Verily it has been proven that Umar made Ubay ibn Ka’ab (RA) lead the people in 20 Rakats of Tarawih and 3 Witr in Ramzan. This is the way of the scholars of this Ummah and this is the Sunnah. This is due to the fact that Sayyidina Ubay ibn Ka’ab (RA) read 20 Rakats Tarawih in a large congregation of the Muhajireen and Ansar of the Sahabah and none amongst them objected to this practice.’ (Fatawa Ibn Taymiyyah vol 1, p191/ Al Mughni vol 1, p803)
Tahajjud is meant for the later part of the night. Taraweeh as has been established by 'Umar (RA) is joined with 'Isha and prayed in the earlier part of the night. Those who have the taufeeq, perform tahajjud after having offered their taraweeh prayers as well. So don't make a ruling out of thin air.
Note @ 1:47 Dr Zakir says: "While offering Qiyamul Layl in Ramadan PBUH use to offer only 11 rakas" I didn’t know Tharavih was also prayed outside Ramadan month; Has Zakir got this right? could someone explain this.
@mainufo Well if my grammar correction is right XD, you are definately a idiot and need teaching. Buy some books, visit other countries, do intense research. Maybe then you will be a little less stupid. Maybe...
HAHAHAHA look at you muslim.. you dont have any knowlegde of quran .. read and understand instead of asking Zakir.. your allah didnt gave you brain to understand only zakir naik got brain ?.
@mainufo LOL I read the Quran 4 times untranslated and 6 times translated. I have perfectly good knowledge of the Quran. What on earth makes you think I rely on Zakir Naik all the time?
@mainufo From what the bullshit media tells me is that they are protesting for justice. I couldnt care any less though. How does that relate to anything in the Quran. I got better things to do then play Q&A with a idiot. Buh bye.
@starshine7861 Dear Brother, it is not ignorance. Tahajjud and Taravih both are qiyam ul lail. You have to confirm it. As for as my knowledge is concerned, Prophet S.A.W. did not offer Tahajjud in ramdan as he had offered Travih. Wallaho Aelum
MASHA ALLAH GREAT REPLY.NO DOUBT ALL THE HADITH BOOKS CONTAIN THE HADITH THAT OUR HOLY PROPHET(PBUH) USED TO PRAY EIGHT RAQATS AS NIGHT PRAYER.WE SHOULD RESTRICT TO SUNNAH,WHICH IS AUTHENTICATED AND SUPPORTED BY MANY HADITH....
Rasolullah sallallahu alaihi wasallam said from where Umar passes Shaitan will change his route, one who excepts that it was hazrat Umar's opinion of 20 rakath and then rejects it who he belongs to? In short Muslims all over the world try to offer more in the month of Ramadhan, some are debating to cut short.
taraweeh is 20 not 8. i think zakir naik didnt get the meaning of the hadees.
the hadees is A PERSON ASKED AYESHA FATIMA(RA) THAT WHAT ARE THE PRAYERS DONE BY HUZUR(SA). SHE REPLIED THAT HE PRAYED 11 RAKATS. THE PERSON DOESN'T ask AYESHA FATIMA(RA) ABOUT TARAWEEH.
AND ANOTHER THING- RESPECTED DR NAIK IS A STUDENT OF COMPARATIVE RELIGIONS! HE IS NOT A SCHOLAR! SO PLEASE PLEASE I REQUEST YOU DO RESEARCH LEARN FROM HIGHLY RESPECTED SCHOLARS NOT STUDENTS THEMSELVES
AND HOW DO YOU EVEN KNOW THAT THE PRAYER THAT WE DO OFFER IS ACCEPTED OR NOT? WHY RISK THE CHANCE BY OFFERING LESS PRAYER INCREASE THE CHANCE OF ACCEPTANCE
Salaam BROTHERS AND SISTERS! I find it annoying when people are arguing over silly things- Teach urself through a teacher NOT YOUTUBE! You want knowledge seek it do not sit at home debating on YOUTUBE! 1ST OF ALL 8 RAKAATS OR 20 RAKAATS? WHY ARGUE OBVIOUSLY DO 20 MORE REWARDS- WE ARE IN THIS DUNIYA TO BUY FOR OUR AKHIRAH! THE MORE THE BETTER! AND WHO CARES WHAT DR ZAKIR NAIK SAYS! WHY SHORTEN YOUR PRAYER? WHEN WE DIE WERE TAKING DEEDS WITH US THATS ALL! PRAY EVERY OPPORTUNITY YOU GET
@RASHEEDAK12... PLEASE GIVE ME THE ARABIC TEXT OF THAT HADITH AND SANADH. IF IT IS MORE POWERFUL THAN THE HADITH THAT BROTHER ZAKIR NAIK QUOTED. I WILL ACCEPT THAT. PLS DONT SAY UMAR R.A AND ALI R.A ACCEPTED 20 RAKA'TH........I HAV HADITH. UMAR R.A TOLD IMAMS TO DO NAMAZ 11 RAKATH
@satholiful Muwatta Imam Malik :: Book 6 : Hadith 6.2.5
Yahya related to me from Malik that Yazid ibn Ruman said, "The people used to watch the night in prayer during Ramadan for twenty-three rakas in the time of Umar ibn al-Khattab."
book of thahajjud saying not about tharaveeh and not only for ramzan
Volume 2, Book 21, Number 223:
Narrated 'Aisha:
Allah's Apostle used to offer eleven Rakat and that was his prayer. He used to prolong the prostration to such an extent that one could recite fifty verses (of the Quran) before he would lift his head. He used to pray two Rakat (Sunna) before the Fajr prayer and then used to lie down on his right side till the call-maker came and informed him about the prayer.
pls brother naik this is the refe of sahih buhari vol1 book no9 472 there is not saying about tharaveeh
Volume 1, Book 9, hadeeth Number 472:
Narrated Ibn 'Abbas:
Once I came riding a she-ass when I had just attained the age of puberty. Allah's Apostle was offering the prayer at Mina with no wall in front of him and I passed in front of some of the row. There I dismounted and let my she-ass loose to graze and entered the row and nobody objected to me about it
This is where you can see the difference between the knowledge of Dr Tahir ul Qadri and Dr Zakir and this is the exact reason why everyone should not pass Fatwas. Please refer to:
THE TERM THRAWEEH CAME LATER........... ITS KIYAMULLAIL. SO KEEP THE STRONGER AND SAHEEH HADITH IS BETTER. THAT IS 8+3, AND MAKE IT LONGER .......I THOUGHT THAT IS THE RIGHT WAY
THE TERM THRAWEEH CAME LATER........... ITS KIYAMULLAIL. SO KEEP THE STRONGER AND SAHEEH HADITH IS BETTER. THAT IS 8+3, AND MAKE IT LONGER .......I THOUGHT THAT IS THE RIGHT WAY
1. Imam Tirmidhi (rh) [passed away 279 AH] states that ‘Umar (ra), ‘Ali (ra), Sufyan Thawri (rh) and Imam Shafi’i (rh) all accept the taraweeh salah as being twenty Rakaahs. He quoted Imam Shafi’i (ra) as saying that he saw the people of Makkah performing twenty Rakaahs. (Tirmidhi, v.1 p.99)
Why Mr Zakir Naik forgot this hadith IT is related from Sayyidina Ibn Abbas : ‘The Prophet :pbuh: would pray 20 Rakats and then witr inthe month of Ramadhan.’ (Musnad ibn Abi Shaybah vol 2, p294/ Sunan Baihaqi vol 2, p496/ Tibraani Kabir vol 11, p393/ Musnad ibn Hameed p218)
THIS HADITH CLEARLY INDICATES THAT 20 RAKATH IS A SUNNATH OF OUR BELOWED PROPHET sallahu alai hi wasallam
8 Rakat is a sunnat in tahajjud namaz and 20 rakat is a sunnath in taraweeh namaz in ramzan it is the clear
I go at a Masjid where there are two Imams. one leads for first 8 rakas, then other leads the remaining 12. Can we leave after 8 since the imam changed?
from watching this i have come to my own conclusion the longer the "duration the better" meaning time not rakats .Therefore 20 rakats is better then 8...if 20 rakats takes longer which it does, but you shouldn't read 8 rakats in a mosque where they are doing 20 and then walk out i reckon its discouraged if you do because you won't get the reward of qiyaam al-layl.
Ive read that different people read different amounts even 39. To get over the dispute of rakats is simple. Do what the prophet (peace be upon him) did because he was the perfect muslim wasn't he not??? So 8 rakats followed by 3 witr...but if a mosque does 20 i will do 20...but if there is a mosque that does 8 rakats i will go there.
This is what i think from what i gathered from sources...what do you guys think?
Brother, I agree with you....Prophet (PBUH) had expressly allowed one to pray as many rakats as per his wish. Yet at the same time, he had always prayed 8+3. So Muslims instead of fighting with each other on this topic & telling that 20+3 rakats is bidath (unwanted innovation in the religion), they should quitely choose whichever they want & abide by it.
I will go to my nearby mosque & irrespective of the number of rakats they pray, I will start and finish with the Imam.
@boxingfan786 SALAAM I THINK YOU HAVE MISUNDERSTOOD- TARWEE IS 20 RAKAATS! IT IS THE SUNNAH OF THE PROPHET SO WHY ARGUE AGAINST IT- DR ZAKIR NAIK IS QUOTING HADITHS FROM TAHJUT PRAYER WHICH HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH TARAWEE- YOU CAN NOT PRAY ODD NUMBERS OF TARAWEE BUT TAHJUT YOU CAN,
Respond to this video... Oh and do not come to conclusions watching videos and links on you tube- to understand something you need reliable sources i.e. books or lectures that are well in depth and are longer then 10mints! im not insulting just givin advice. learn through teachers not you tube. forgive me if i have in any way insulted you JZK
Dear brothers and sisters,this point has been dealt with by ALLAMA YOUSUF LUDIANAVI in his book APKE MASAIL AUR UNKA HULL in great detail,please read it there and any one will be convinced that TARAVIH are 20 for sure.It is my humble opinion that Dr sahib should not discuss IKHTILAFI masail and lose his standing.
@boxingfan786 why ??? ....because he is not qualified alim in the science of fiqh its not allowed for anyone to go out and start giving fatwas when ur not authorised to do so despite being knowledge in issues like comparative religion like dr naik is .. its like a brain surgeon starts giving lectures and advice about the heart when thats not their field... u see my point bro ?? ...do u know how many years u have to study to become a alim in science of fiqh ??? it take years and years ...d
For those who keep emphasizing about the terminologies and their late appearance in jurisprudence, should know that the scholars of hadith have chapters on Tahajud as well as Tarawih, yet this hadith is not included in the chapters of tarawih.
3) In addition if this hadith was concerning tarawih, then why did Aisha (RA) the narrator of the hadith not reject the consensus reached by Umar (RA)? she could have informed him in some way or the other that the correct number of rakats for tarawih was eight.
Besides this hadith which clearly is referring to Tahajjud, and is found only in the chapter of Tahajjud in every book of hadith and not in the chapter of Tarawih, the other hadith supporting 8 have strong weaknesses in it. Therefore the muslims as an Ummah are to follow the Ijma, the consensus of the Sahabas which was reached during the time of Umar (RA). And this Ijma has been followed for the last 1300 years.
3) In addition if this hadith was concerning tarawih, then why did Aisha (RA) the narrator of the hadith not reject the consensus reached by Umar (RA)? she could have informed him in some way or the other that the correct number of rakats for tarawih was eight.
3) In addition if this hadith was concerning tarawih, then why did Aisha (RA) the narrator of the hadith not reject the consensus reached by Umar (RA)? she could have informed him in some way or the other that the correct number of rakats for tarawih was eight.
Therefore she could not have been speaking about tarawih since you only perform tarawih in Ramadan, so the question of Abu Salmah was about tahajjud.
2) Many compilers of hadith, such as Imam Muslim, Nasa'i, Abu Dawud, Tirmidhi, Ibn Maja, Ibn Khuzayma, and Imam Malik, have also not included this hadith in their chapters on tarawih, despite it being such a rigorously authenticated hadith. Instead, they mention it in their chapters on tahajjud or witr.
1) The prayer mentioned in the hadith is clearly not tarawih but rather tahajjud prayer. Abu Salama's inquiry was regarding whether or not the Messenger SAWS performed any extra rakats of tahajjud during Ramadan. Aisha (RA) answered by stating that the messenger SAWS would perform no more than 8 rakats of tahajjued throughout the year, regardless of what month it was. Hence she was speaking of prayer performed both in and out of Ramadan. As she states "neither in Ramadan nor out of it."
@Khaatab716 wasalaam. I am not a brother- see how you jumped to that conclusion? and what book are you refering to? i wasnt debating with anyone- just saying why can people not read 20? why debate whether its ok to read 8? why would anyone shorten their prayer? all i was trying to say was that we shouldnt even talk about this topic and read maximum as we need the deeds for our sakes!
@txr573 Salam, apologies, for assuming your a brother, its just that your username really doesnt give me much to work with. Secondly if you read what I wrote I am not against 20 I am for it, lol, so it seems that you are assuming. Nor was I trying to debate with you, frankly I only responded to you when you asked me. Sister please read what I wrote. I wasnt even attacking you lol. And its a book by Abdur Rahman Ibn Yusuf, fiqh al imam
@Khaatab716 lol i didnt realise i asked you something.. I thought you was picking on me lol! yes no problems. I see where i commented now.. sorry about this :)
The word TARAWIH it self is a innovated name. He never mentioned about that. He himself used that word. The correct word is KHIYAAM UL LAIL. We should Follow the sunnah. It s 8+3 rakah. when we have clear proof for 11(8+3). then y confusion
@Almumin11 "KHIYAAM UL LAIL" as you put it brother means standing at night, and refers to Tahajjud the night prayer. Dr. Zakir knows this and there referes to it in the traditional wording.
11 rakaats are only for tahajjud not for tarawih as he said also praying in other months too this clearly means that this is not tarawih it is specially for tarawih as it is written in book of tahajjud in bukhari as he gave the reference...
At 0:48, he is giving an incorrect reference. There is no hadith number 472 in Book of Salaah under Volume 1. I have searched and searched all over the place for the hadith that is quoting. There is none. Can someone please point me to this Hadith in Sahih Al Bukhari so I can correct my misconceptions about this, if I have any that is?????
Naik is a GENIUS! To be able to throw out quotations like that from the Quran, Hadith, bible and Hindu scriptures is AMAZING. May Allah protect him.
mohamadaqil 1 month ago
confused ans
azharp02 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
MUSLIM, (ا ل إ س ل ا م) { I S L A M } إن الدين عند الله الإسلام , Sunni Islam, Ahle Sunnat Wal Jama'at, SALAFI
hammadghulam 2 months ago
lol, why is it always the neo- hanafis who always use filthy language against people who wont follow their fiqh opinion? Then they complain about intolerance
alithelin1234 5 months ago
so 20 rakahs seems more suitable for a holy month
he answered a difficult question
crook4real 5 months ago
y u r engry about ali.. Ali is the imam for Abu Bakar Umer Usman and all 124000 ashab of nabi pak.. when prophet PBUH announced in gadeer e khum Man Kum Tm Mola Hum Fahaza Ali hn Mola" then the 1st beliver of Ali's Imamat or molayet is Omer ibne Khatab..
Hazrat Ali is the imam for All Ashab e Karam and All ashab e karam are praying behind Ali... even all three khalifs... If this is wronng thn i challanged u.. ali was imam for all.. am not shia am true muslim.. challanged u..
piyar1234 5 months ago
Prophet prayed 8+3 rakats not only in Ramadhan. He prayed throughout the year. If you take this hadeeth it should be prayed thoroughout the year. In practical no one is doing this. What you going to loose if you make more sajda during Ramadhan? Alhamdulillah I enjoyed praying 20 rakat of Tharaweeh in Masjidul Haram in Makkah.
armrizwan 6 months ago
for the urdu speaking brothers plz watch this short explanation of why its 20 rakats taraawih at the 2 haraamain. BY an aalim and a teacher who teaches regularly at masjid al haraam.
the video is called "Taraweeh Prayer - What happens in Makkah | Dr. Wasiullah Abbas "
abdussamad002 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
NEW BOOK (Donated) For Debates And Governance
Topics: THE WEAPON THAT CAN BREAK THE CYCLE OF WAR AND TERRORISM, Debated Issues, Politics, Religion, Philosophy, Science, Others.
Websites: balancedway.yolasite.com
balancedway1.yolasite.com
balanceddiet.yolasite.com
balanceddiet1.yolasite.com
See Announcements at announcements-balancedway.weebly.com
announcements-balancedway.yolasite.com
SPREAD THIS BOOK AND CONQUER THE SPREADING EVIL BEFORE IT'S TOO LATE - FOR FREEDOM AND PEACE.
TheServiceWeb 6 months ago
Listen to the guy and see what he is saying carefully there is nothing wrong with praying 20 coz the longer the ibadaat the better if u pray 8 there ain't nothing wrong with that if u have doubts refer back to the hadiths that he has given u as evidence seems like u guys want to fight without even knowing why u read 20 or 8 remember do not follow blindly even if it is right refer back to the hadiths to back your claims may Allah guide us all
doczify 6 months ago
iTne JAhil Log HaiN YAhN PAr Dr SahaB HAdith Ka HAwala De rahe HAin k Kahan KahN likha HAi Rakat Ka TAb bhi SAlay Apni hi Ghori Age RAkhein ge JAb K PAt HAi In ko K Zakr Sahab Ka Ghara Peeche RAha HAi....JAHIL JAHIL
manaybhai 6 months ago
So incorrect he shouldn't be on tv, because of him we have mosques praying only 8rakat taraweeh
BadBoiGK 6 months ago
Prophet offered 8+3 =11 this is about TAHAJUDD NOT TARAWEEH
Taraweeh offered by umer(R.A) ,usman(R.A) and ali (R.A) offered 20 taraweeh.
ahmed34537 6 months ago
plese people Listen t is mentioned in Book of Tahajudd so Ayesha(R.A) is talking about tahajudd not about taraweeh .
Also she said in ramadan and in other months prophet offered 11 with sequence of 4,4 and 3 so she is clearly talking about tahajudd not taraweeh.Holy prophet(PBUH) offered taraweeh in his last year .
Ayesha (R.A ) was alive when umar ,usman and Ali used to offer 2o rakaaht of taraweeh but she never objected.......
ahmed34537 6 months ago
He is not an Alim. He is misguiding the Muslims by giving his fiqh verdicts.
oigeezer 6 months ago
kareemabdullah !!!!! Brother what will you comment about the Hadith he mentioned ???? Don't you see other aspect !!!!
venome447 6 months ago
i think Hazrat Umar R.A best know sunnat from us if He had offererd 20 then i think we have no right to say someting about it and also at the end Dr Zakir said that at harmain 20 rakat are offered in one and half hour then it mean that 20 rakat are best from 8.
ahmadvu1 6 months ago
MASHA ALLAH.....ALL THE HADITH BOOKS SUPPORT TOTAL 8 RAKATS & THERE IS NO MENTION OF 20 RAKATS IN ANY HADITH BOOK....WHY SHOULD WE VIOLATE THE HOLY SUNNAH ? WE MUST LOVE THE SUNNAH AS GIVEN IN HADITH...WE SHOULD ALSO KNOW THAT TRAWIH & TAHAJAD ARE THE SAME NIGHT PRAYERS,WHICH WE CAN JOIN WITH SALAT E EISHA IN THE MONTH OF RAMAZAN FOR OUR CONVENIENCE...SO MINIMUM RAKATS ARE 8 + 1,3,5,7 or 9 RAKATS OF WITAR WAJIB UPTO ANY NUMBER OF RAKATS OF TARAWIH.....
haqkahan 6 months ago 2
WallahuAlam bisawwab. Only Allah Knows best. What ever type of prayers we offer, It is up to Allah's judgement to which one He Sees best. Allah is All-Knowing, Wise.
ried90 6 months ago
The sunnah of our beloved Prophet (saw) was 8 rakat. Another "sunnah" is what our rightly guided caliph Omer (ra) instituted. The Saudi ulema have stated that 8 or 20 -- either is sunnah, which is why they do 8 all over most of the Arab world, and allow 20 at the Haram and Madinah. Moderation, the middle way, that is also the sunnah, and the Prophet told us to avoid extremism in religion. There is nothing to argue about; either number is "sunnah".
Serenity97531 6 months ago
Subhanallah... i heard the similar answer from other scholars ...Mashallah...Allah and Mohammed Sallelaho alaihivasallam (PBUH)
sanki08 6 months ago
@jummaniyan brother are you trying to say all of the other ummah who is not following Salafi are totally wrong??
I am no scholar of islam but only knows best!
hapeedays 6 months ago
Mashallah good message to mushriks
SuperMirpur 6 months ago
Taraweeh 20 hi hain 8 ka zikar jehan bhi ayya woh Qiam ul Lail hai. jo k ramazan se khas nahi hain
tauqirehsan 6 months ago
mr zakir naik hazrat umar radi. known better muhammad s.a.w. rather than imam bukhari r. a. so its better to follow 2nd kaliph radi. and perform 20 rakat of taravih
09081986ful 6 months ago
@09081986ful he is a wahahbi kafir
fahd090078601 6 months ago
Absolutely agree with Dr.Zakir!
draslrus 6 months ago
bUT FROM A COMMON SENSE POINT OF VIEW, the Imam reads one spara every night. So if you are only reading 8 rakat, then you are depriving yourself most of the Quran (less than half), so surely this is a bad thing? Especially becasue in Ramadan we are meant to pray as much as POSSIBLE, not "as much as you wish" - there is a clear difference. Shame on those who only read 8 because of laziness, especially when our Nabi (PBUH) used to pray all night sometimes.
moewishaw 6 months ago
i can't believe in this day and age among our sunni/hanafi muslims, there are still people who choose to pray 8 rakaat of taraweeh. whats worse is there are people so concerned about throwing iftaar parties that they choose to have this big gathering, so much food, samosa, pakora, fruit, multiple dishes, multiple desserts, they get so busy in their food they completely neglect taraweeh and miss the whole point of ramadan with their extravagance. Allah have mercy on us all!
jumar1281 6 months ago
Read as many as u want in rakats of 2. If u read with an imam then follow what he does and read as much. Simple. One Islam, one ummah
usyk36 6 months ago 18
@usyk36 Allama ibn Taymiyyah (rh) writes that Ubay bin Ka’b (ra) led the Sahabah (raa) in twenty rak’ah taraweeh during the Khilafah of ‘Umar (ra). (Fatawa Ibn Taymiyyah, v.1 p.148). He further writes (v.1 p.191) that because Ubay led the Sahabah (raa) in twenty rak’ah taraweeh and three rak’ah witr during Ramadan, most ‘Ulema regard this to be a Sunnah because all of the Muhajireen and Ansaar performed the salah without an objection from any of them.
mrwaqy 6 months ago
The famous scholar of Ahl al-Hadith Nawab Siddique Hasan believes that “’Ulema regard as ijma the twenty rak’ah taraweeh salah that was performed during the Khilafah of ‘Umar (ra). (Awnul Bari, v.4 p.307)
mrwaqy 6 months ago
Those Ghair Muqalideen who accuse Umar for introducing the innovation of 20 Rakats Taraweeh in his Khilafat, ask yourselves this, are you not treading the same path with your words as the Rawafid (Shia) in the time of Ibn Taymiyyah (RA)?
mrwaqy 6 months ago
Abi Abdur Rahman Salmi (RA) related: In the nights of Ramadhan, Sayyidina Ali (RA) called upon the recitors of the Qur’an (Huffaz/Qura) and ordered one amongst them to lead the people in 20 Rakats of Taraweeh. Sayyidina Ali (RA) would lead the people himself in the Witr Salah. (Sunan Kabeer Baihaqi vol 2, p496/ Fathul Bari vol 4, p219)
mrwaqy 6 months ago
Hafiz Ibn Taymiyyah (RA) writes in his Fatawa: ‘Verily it has been proven that Umar made Ubay ibn Ka’ab (RA) lead the people in 20 Rakats of Tarawih and 3 Witr in Ramadhan. This is the way of the scholars of this Ummah and this is the Sunnah. This is due to the fact that Sayyidina Ubay ibn Ka’ab (RA) read 20 Rakats Tarawih in a large congregation of the Muhajireen and Ansar of the Sahabah and none amongst them objected to this practice.’ (Fatawa Ibn Taymiyyah vol 1, p191/ Al Mughni vol 1, p803)
mrwaqy 6 months ago
For someone who holds Yazeed (la) in high esteem, yeah, he is really credible.
raficsulejmanovic 6 months ago
@raficsulejmanovic He is not credible
mrwaqy 6 months ago
@mrwaqy Yes, I agree. I was being sarcastic.
raficsulejmanovic 6 months ago
one question for those who say this bukhari hadith refers to tahhajjud and they are different prayers
we all agree this only one witr prayer in a night?? then for eg. how can one pray witr with taraaweeh (20 +3 ) and then witr again later on in tahajjud. (8+3).
abdussamad002 6 months ago
For all those who says, 20 rakaah is bid'a and that 8 rakaah is the correct statement, has deviated from the Salaf saliheen, and thus deviated from Ahlus Sunnah wal Jamaah. Unfortunately those who call themselves "Salafis" are abandoning the Salaf Saliheen´s way, and some of them are blind followers of Abdul Wahab Najd and Albani, Zakir Naik, and many more.. May Allah guide us all to the Aqida of Ahlus Sunnah.. Amin
GamereviewerPs3 6 months ago
why ask a dawah expert to give rulings he isnt qualified to give, he isnt a fiqh expert. all 4 schools are unanimously agreed as were the sahaabas that taraawih is 20 rakkats, they pray this in makkah and medina and masjid al aqsa etc, 8 is tahajjud not taraawih
kareemabdullah 6 months ago 10
@kareemabdullah Yes, they pray 20 at makkah at madinah -- perhaps to assure people that 20 is permissible. Elsewhere all over Saudi and the middle east they pray 8. The ulema have made it clear that while 8 is the sunnah, 20 is permissible as set by Umar (ra).
Serenity97531 6 months ago
@Serenity97531 actually, 8 is not the sunnah, 20 is the consensus of the sahabas, and therefore the sunnah of rasoolullah s.a.w, 8 is the new invention of the salafi sect, and the prophet s.a.w only prayed tahajjud for 8 rakkats as mentioned in bukhari by a'isha r.a
kareemabdullah 6 months ago
@kareemabdullah just to note: even those who argue that 20 is correct, admit that one of the narrators in the chain of hadith was one with Shia leanings. Many people who pray 20 concede that the Prophet prayed 8 rakas. While we are encouraged to follow rightly guided scholars in any matter that isn't clear, there is nothing in Islam that says we should reject what our Prophet did. There was no such term as "tarawih" back then - tahajjud means the night prayers, so does tarawih.
Serenity97531 6 months ago
@Serenity97531 thats a lie than one narrator had shia leanings, and also, the prophet saw prayed 20 rakaats, thats why the sahabas implemented that and theummah has kept it up, also, the hadith salafis use to prove 8 rakkats is clearly talking about the prayer that is done only in ramadhaan a.k.a tarawih, its clearly not tahajjud meantioned because tahajjud is all year round
kareemabdullah 6 months ago
@kareemabdullah astagfarAllah, accusing fellow Muslims of lying! subhanAllah. The document where I learned that information - that one of the narrators in the chain had shia leanings - was written by someone who SUPPORTS the notion of 20 rakats. They admitted that, but said that person's character was deemed "ok" anyway. Do your research. And please, for the sake of Allah, do not accuse people of lying just because they express something different than you believe.
Serenity97531 6 months ago
@kareemabdullah lol what Muhammad s.a.w.s did is called sunnah and not invention.. do try to be an alim..
artimahalla 3 months ago
@kareemabdullah
I have seen in Makkah in Salat Taravhi that Imam Asudais prayed 40 rakats
salmankhan12000 6 months ago
@kareemabdullah where did u get this information??? give references. u say zakir is unqualified u have no right to say that unless u have proof. how do u know u know that all 4 schools of thought and sahabas are unanimously agreed that its 20. where is proof?
1994mrmysteryman 6 months ago
@1994mrmysteryman all 4 schools of thought have always said its 20 rakaats, ask any muslim who has been around for more than 30 years, before then nobody prayed 8 rakaats, its a new salafi bida' based on weak hadiths that isnt founded in the practise of the sahabas, i have all the quotes you need to prove my point, and makkah and madina have alwways prayd 20, the prophet s.a.w said my ummah wont have consensus on falsehood, well the majority of the ummah and scholars say 20 rakaats
kareemabdullah 6 months ago
@kareemabdullah brother. thanx for the reply. But u speak about weak hadiths. i thought zakir naik gave you quotations from sahih ahadith. that the prophet (pbuh) prayed 11. ... 8 then 3. in tahajjud we dont pray odd number i think... and he gave quotations abt sahabas praying different number of rakats which prophet(pbuh) permitted. so there is nothing "falsehood" about praying 8 or 20. your reply?
1994mrmysteryman 6 months ago
@1994mrmysteryman the hadith about 8 then 3 from bukhari he said about is about the tahajjud prayer, i will said you a really good video audio lecture on the subject
binty86 6 months ago
@binty86 look please tell me whether we pray ODD or EVEN number of rakaats in tahajjud.???
1994mrmysteryman 6 months ago
@kareemabdullah All over Saudi Arabia and the middle east they pray 8 rakats, even though in Makkah and Madinah they pray 20. If the Saudi Ulema believed that 20 rakat is the only "sunnah", then none of the masajid would be allowed to pray 20. The Saudi muttawa (religious police) are quite strict and would ensure than the masajid did have 8 rakat tarawih prayers. (The muttawa go around gathering people for prayers, making sure businesses are closed and no men are standing about!)
Serenity97531 6 months ago
@Serenity97531 * correction: if the Saudi Ulema believed that 20 rakat is the only "sunnah", then none of the masajid would be allowed to have tarawih pray for LESS THAN 20.
Serenity97531 6 months ago
@Serenity97531 Yeah that's right, I live in Riyadh & the Imam of my mosque always prays 8 rakats. I've lived there for 15 years and the same Imam always does it the same way.
UmayrTakwir 6 months ago
@Serenity97531 Yeah that's right, I live in Riyadh & the Imam of my mosque always prays 8 rakats. I've lived there for 15 years and the same Imam always does it the same way.
Though in Makkah & Madina & in some larger mosques they do offer 20 rakats but mostly in the kingdom we offer 8 rakats
UmayrTakwir 6 months ago
@kareemabdullah so they are fools
TheAlsalaam 5 months ago
@kareemabdullah 8 is not wrong 20is not wrong 40is not wrong 100is not wrong because the hadith is clear on this pray 2 2 2 and so on and its clear in Bukhari 8+3 is sunnah you dont need to be an Ulema to understand that 8 is 8 And one more thing Prophet Muhammad s.a.w comes before the sahabas you dont follow the sahabas and then the prophet s.a.w you follow the prophet. s.a.w and then the sahabas.
Allah knows best / Selam
RealName007 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kareemabdullah 8 is not wrong 20is not wrong 40is not wrong 100is not wrong because the hadith is clear on this pray 2 2 2 and so on and its clear in Bukhari 8+3 is sunnah you dont need to be an Ulema to understand that 8 is 8 And one more thing Prophet Muhammad s.a.w comes before the sahabas you dont follow the sahabas and then the prophet s.a.w you follow the prophet. s.a.w and then the sahabas.
Allah knows best / Selam
RealName007 5 months ago
@kareemabdullah hes giving opinion based on knowledge which is what all great knowledgable people do its an opinion and u take it as his opinion
iloveafg123 5 months ago
listena bit better to his quoting please
iloveafg123 5 months ago
@kareemabdullah Why you play with words, why not straightly say the true "4 sects" instead of "4 schools" and Dr. Zakir Naik is quoting from the Qur'an and Mohammed's sayings so if you claim he's incorrect your going against the Qur'an and Saheeh Hadith's. Further more he also said it is not forbidden to pray 20 rekats also he said the more the better. So your kinda putting holes in the air as they say...
Peace
Solocidi 4 months ago
@kareemabdullah Hazrat Umar (RA) orded 8 rakat tarawee and in makkah and madina they also do rafa yadain before and after ruku but you blind followers dont .
choudry1231 2 months ago
@choudry1231 where is your proof??? The fact is that umar r.a ordered 20 and thats why since his time, 20 rakaats has never once siesed to be prayed in makkah or madinah, they have never once prayed 8 rakaats and this opinion is a new salafi opinion based on misinterpretation of hadiths, also, the imams of makkah and madinah do rafa yadain because they are hanbalis, so if im a blind follower for following the hanafi madhab then so are they for following the hanbali madhab
kareemabdullah 2 months ago
@choudry1231 i have the evidences that umar ordered 20, where is your evidence??? Also, the sahabi that narrated the hadith in bukhari about rafa yadain has also narrated a sahih hadith saying the prophet s.a.w never did it, the hanafi ruling is that the prophet s.a.w for most of his life didnt do rafa yadain, then he did it for a short time, then stopped again, so rafa yadain has been abrogated.
kareemabdullah 2 months ago
THE HADEETH QUOTED FIRST - SAHIH BUKHARI VOL 1 BOOK OF SALAT HADEETH NO. 472 is Error it should be HADEETH NUMBER SAHIH BUKHARI CHAPTER 8 (BOOK OF SALAT) HADEETH NO. 462
banjarq 6 months ago
Dr. Zakir Naik is mentioning wrong that Trawih is 8 + 3 and it is sunnah and more than eleven is permissible
yourservant71 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i left islam my muslim brothers islam is false like all other religions ,i am now atheist happy and free , (atheism akbar) peace and now i relly mean it, thank you
allahussainpak786q 7 months ago
Alhamdo lila
zia8122 7 months ago
Why you people are creating chaos (A state of extreme confusion and disorder) among Muslim Ummah.
Are shaba was unaware of it, and you are better scholars then them........???????????
ahlehaq1 7 months ago
Comment removed
ahlehaq1 7 months ago
Unsatisfactory reply by Dr Zakir Nai.
Various evidences are available from Ahaadees and Sunnah of Sahaba in support of 20 Rakat Traveh.
Do Dr Zakir know hadees and sunnah better than Sahaba.
ahlehaq1 7 months ago
@ahlehaq1
the hadith he quoted "Al-bukhari" is from the time of the sahaba
So yes, dr zakir is quoting what the sahabah have mentioned, including what the wife our beloved messenger (pbuh) said about how much he prayed
so stop with this foolishness, it is permissible for everyone to pray as much rakats as they please, but it is a sunnah to pray 8
u124n1um 7 months ago
@u124n1um
But the bukhari quote is not for taraweeh .. it's for tahajjud ... he is misleading people by claiming that that hadith refers to taraweeh
jj77hh 6 months ago
@jj77hh
whether or not you're praying tahajjud or taraweeh, both are very highly rewarded and are considered 'voluntary' prayers,
so yes, taraweeh does come under 'voluntary' prayer, and it is a sunnah to pray 8, but pray as many as you wish as its permissible
no one is wrong for praying either 8 or 20, pray until you are satisfied (I.A)
u124n1um 6 months ago
@u124n1um
That's beside the point. To present one hadith that doesn't refer to taraweeh prayers to prove your point about the raka'ahs in taraweeh is misleading. 20 raka'ahs of taraweeh have been established since the time of Umar (RA). To hold on to the sunnah of the khulafa has been commanded by Rasoolullah (SAW). Therefore, to go against that and suggest that following the practice as established by 'Umar (RA) is going against the sunnah, then that is ignorance plain and simple.
jj77hh 6 months ago
@u124n1um Ibn Taymiyyah (RA) writes in his Fatawa:‘Verily it has been proven that Umar made Ubay ibn Ka’ab (RA) lead the people in 20 Rakats of Tarawih and 3 Witr in Ramzan. This is the way of the scholars of this Ummah and this is the Sunnah. This is due to the fact that Sayyidina Ubay ibn Ka’ab (RA) read 20 Rakats Tarawih in a large congregation of the Muhajireen and Ansar of the Sahabah and none amongst them objected to this practice.’ (Fatawa Ibn Taymiyyah vol 1, p191/ Al Mughni vol 1, p803)
mrwaqy 6 months ago
@jj77hh DURING RAMADAN THE TAHAJJUD AND TARWAEEH IS ALL SAME...
banjarq 6 months ago
@banjarq
Tahajjud is meant for the later part of the night. Taraweeh as has been established by 'Umar (RA) is joined with 'Isha and prayed in the earlier part of the night. Those who have the taufeeq, perform tahajjud after having offered their taraweeh prayers as well. So don't make a ruling out of thin air.
jj77hh 6 months ago
@jj77hh good point
kareemabdullah 6 months ago
Unsatisfactory reply by Dr Zakir Nai.
ahlehaq1 7 months ago
Huge society still dragging this. in a way its good to find the right way how prophet did, but
....
ASNNetwork 7 months ago
at my mosque a lot of people leave after the 8t rakaat, i usually stay untill 20.
khisrow456 7 months ago
Note @ 1:47 Dr Zakir says: "While offering Qiyamul Layl in Ramadan PBUH use to offer only 11 rakas" I didn’t know Tharavih was also prayed outside Ramadan month; Has Zakir got this right? could someone explain this.
Keralasutra 7 months ago
@Keralasutra
he was on about tuhujjud prayer, which is offered outside of ramadhan
u124n1um 6 months ago
If taraweeh was pryed 20 racket from the time of Hazrat Umar bin Khattab (ra) in Mecca and Medina, why change it to 8. It has always been 20.
Faruk1189 7 months ago
there is tahajud in other months and taraweeh in ramdan...
sega9011 7 months ago
Muslim are like a cartoon.... they ask idiotic question...
mainufo 8 months ago
@mainufo How would you know if this is a idiotic question or not. Are you muslim? No? You wouldnt understand this question unless you were. Idiot.
DjJayOfficial 7 months ago
@DjJayOfficial
It looks like all muslim are without brain dont have any knowledge and looks like zakir is smarter than all muslim..
mainufo 7 months ago
@mainufo Well if my grammar correction is right XD, you are definately a idiot and need teaching. Buy some books, visit other countries, do intense research. Maybe then you will be a little less stupid. Maybe...
DjJayOfficial 7 months ago
@DjJayOfficial
HAHAHAHA look at you muslim.. you dont have any knowlegde of quran .. read and understand instead of asking Zakir.. your allah didnt gave you brain to understand only zakir naik got brain ?.
mainufo 7 months ago
@mainufo LOL I read the Quran 4 times untranslated and 6 times translated. I have perfectly good knowledge of the Quran. What on earth makes you think I rely on Zakir Naik all the time?
DjJayOfficial 7 months ago
@DjJayOfficial
If you really read quran and understood than tell me in how many days allah created the earth ?.
mainufo 7 months ago
@mainufo 2 days. Stop trying to prove me wrong, it wouldnt benefit either of us.
DjJayOfficial 7 months ago
@DjJayOfficial
What happened to innocent muslim who got killed by syrian millitary ?.
mainufo 7 months ago
@mainufo From what the bullshit media tells me is that they are protesting for justice. I couldnt care any less though. How does that relate to anything in the Quran. I got better things to do then play Q&A with a idiot. Buh bye.
DjJayOfficial 7 months ago
@DjJayOfficial
So u wANT TO know abt Quran.. lol tell me in how many days allah created earth ?.
mainufo 7 months ago
Six days...
mohsinsaboowala 6 months ago
@mohsinsaboowala
IF it is six days than how come surah says it is in 8 days ?.
mainufo 6 months ago
How could Zakir Naik be that ignorant between Tahajjud and Taraweeh? Why does he quote from the book of Tahajjud for proof for Taraweeh??
umaralfarooq 1 year ago
@umaralfarooq Exactly! Same question in my mind. Let's ask Mr Zakir Naik.....Why Mr Zakir Naik??
starshine7861 9 months ago
@starshine7861 Dear Brother, it is not ignorance. Tahajjud and Taravih both are qiyam ul lail. You have to confirm it. As for as my knowledge is concerned, Prophet S.A.W. did not offer Tahajjud in ramdan as he had offered Travih. Wallaho Aelum
Farooq697 7 months ago
thanks,brother zakir,
TheIslamians 1 year ago
MASHA ALLAH GREAT REPLY.NO DOUBT ALL THE HADITH BOOKS CONTAIN THE HADITH THAT OUR HOLY PROPHET(PBUH) USED TO PRAY EIGHT RAQATS AS NIGHT PRAYER.WE SHOULD RESTRICT TO SUNNAH,WHICH IS AUTHENTICATED AND SUPPORTED BY MANY HADITH....
youpak1 1 year ago
Rasolullah sallallahu alaihi wasallam said from where Umar passes Shaitan will change his route, one who excepts that it was hazrat Umar's opinion of 20 rakath and then rejects it who he belongs to? In short Muslims all over the world try to offer more in the month of Ramadhan, some are debating to cut short.
chintubihari 1 year ago
it is sad that we are fighting on so simple issues
erfanullahjan 1 year ago
what zakir said is based on evidence which is enough for the varification of 8 taraveeh.thats all zakir rocks with great knowledge
MsFatimaable 1 year ago
taraweeh is 20 not 8. i think zakir naik didnt get the meaning of the hadees.
the hadees is A PERSON ASKED AYESHA FATIMA(RA) THAT WHAT ARE THE PRAYERS DONE BY HUZUR(SA). SHE REPLIED THAT HE PRAYED 11 RAKATS. THE PERSON DOESN'T ask AYESHA FATIMA(RA) ABOUT TARAWEEH.
makki64 1 year ago
@makki64 hazrat Mohammad saw did taraweeh only 3 days by jamaat,23 ,25 and 27 and it was 11 rakaat.
4511394 1 year ago
AND ANOTHER THING- RESPECTED DR NAIK IS A STUDENT OF COMPARATIVE RELIGIONS! HE IS NOT A SCHOLAR! SO PLEASE PLEASE I REQUEST YOU DO RESEARCH LEARN FROM HIGHLY RESPECTED SCHOLARS NOT STUDENTS THEMSELVES
txr573 1 year ago
AND HOW DO YOU EVEN KNOW THAT THE PRAYER THAT WE DO OFFER IS ACCEPTED OR NOT? WHY RISK THE CHANCE BY OFFERING LESS PRAYER INCREASE THE CHANCE OF ACCEPTANCE
txr573 1 year ago
Salaam BROTHERS AND SISTERS! I find it annoying when people are arguing over silly things- Teach urself through a teacher NOT YOUTUBE! You want knowledge seek it do not sit at home debating on YOUTUBE! 1ST OF ALL 8 RAKAATS OR 20 RAKAATS? WHY ARGUE OBVIOUSLY DO 20 MORE REWARDS- WE ARE IN THIS DUNIYA TO BUY FOR OUR AKHIRAH! THE MORE THE BETTER! AND WHO CARES WHAT DR ZAKIR NAIK SAYS! WHY SHORTEN YOUR PRAYER? WHEN WE DIE WERE TAKING DEEDS WITH US THATS ALL! PRAY EVERY OPPORTUNITY YOU GET
txr573 1 year ago
@RASHEEDAK12... PLEASE GIVE ME THE ARABIC TEXT OF THAT HADITH AND SANADH. IF IT IS MORE POWERFUL THAN THE HADITH THAT BROTHER ZAKIR NAIK QUOTED. I WILL ACCEPT THAT. PLS DONT SAY UMAR R.A AND ALI R.A ACCEPTED 20 RAKA'TH........I HAV HADITH. UMAR R.A TOLD IMAMS TO DO NAMAZ 11 RAKATH
satholiful 1 year ago
@satholiful Muwatta Imam Malik :: Book 6 : Hadith 6.2.5
Yahya related to me from Malik that Yazid ibn Ruman said, "The people used to watch the night in prayer during Ramadan for twenty-three rakas in the time of Umar ibn al-Khattab."
hotmaleloveind 1 year ago
Comment removed
satholiful 1 year ago
book of thahajjud saying not about tharaveeh and not only for ramzan
Volume 2, Book 21, Number 223:
Narrated 'Aisha:
Allah's Apostle used to offer eleven Rakat and that was his prayer. He used to prolong the prostration to such an extent that one could recite fifty verses (of the Quran) before he would lift his head. He used to pray two Rakat (Sunna) before the Fajr prayer and then used to lie down on his right side till the call-maker came and informed him about the prayer.
rasheedak12 1 year ago 2
pls brother naik this is the refe of sahih buhari vol1 book no9 472 there is not saying about tharaveeh
Volume 1, Book 9, hadeeth Number 472:
Narrated Ibn 'Abbas:
Once I came riding a she-ass when I had just attained the age of puberty. Allah's Apostle was offering the prayer at Mina with no wall in front of him and I passed in front of some of the row. There I dismounted and let my she-ass loose to graze and entered the row and nobody objected to me about it
rasheedak12 1 year ago
jazak allah
chadsreal 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Islam is name of obeying Allah and His Messenger (May Peace be Upon Him).
irfanchmba 1 year ago
This is where you can see the difference between the knowledge of Dr Tahir ul Qadri and Dr Zakir and this is the exact reason why everyone should not pass Fatwas. Please refer to:
/watch?v=JtHSuFiC2WQ&feature=email
shahzad05 1 year ago
Dear All,do go by numbers,but also go by the quality of the prayers you offer to Allah....
Is having one sweet apple better,or having 1 dozen rotten apples!!!
As Huzoor(s.a.w.) has asked,do that,and if one can,go a little extra mile.
sajsidd123 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
THE TERM THRAWEEH CAME LATER........... ITS KIYAMULLAIL. SO KEEP THE STRONGER AND SAHEEH HADITH IS BETTER. THAT IS 8+3, AND MAKE IT LONGER .......I THOUGHT THAT IS THE RIGHT WAY
satholiful 1 year ago
THE TERM THRAWEEH CAME LATER........... ITS KIYAMULLAIL. SO KEEP THE STRONGER AND SAHEEH HADITH IS BETTER. THAT IS 8+3, AND MAKE IT LONGER .......I THOUGHT THAT IS THE RIGHT WAY
satholiful 1 year ago
@satholiful u r correct
NASIR9695 1 year ago
@satholiful u r correct
NASIR9695 1 year ago
@satholiful its not right way i hve ref of that
1. Imam Tirmidhi (rh) [passed away 279 AH] states that ‘Umar (ra), ‘Ali (ra), Sufyan Thawri (rh) and Imam Shafi’i (rh) all accept the taraweeh salah as being twenty Rakaahs. He quoted Imam Shafi’i (ra) as saying that he saw the people of Makkah performing twenty Rakaahs. (Tirmidhi, v.1 p.99)
rasheedak12 1 year ago
Jazakallah ho Khair
aamirking1 1 year ago
Comment removed
aamirking1 1 year ago
Why Mr Zakir Naik forgot this hadith IT is related from Sayyidina Ibn Abbas : ‘The Prophet :pbuh: would pray 20 Rakats and then witr inthe month of Ramadhan.’ (Musnad ibn Abi Shaybah vol 2, p294/ Sunan Baihaqi vol 2, p496/ Tibraani Kabir vol 11, p393/ Musnad ibn Hameed p218)
THIS HADITH CLEARLY INDICATES THAT 20 RAKATH IS A SUNNATH OF OUR BELOWED PROPHET sallahu alai hi wasallam
8 Rakat is a sunnat in tahajjud namaz and 20 rakat is a sunnath in taraweeh namaz in ramzan it is the clear
thowfiq2000 1 year ago 7
I go at a Masjid where there are two Imams. one leads for first 8 rakas, then other leads the remaining 12. Can we leave after 8 since the imam changed?
SAMS96max 1 year ago
PART 1
from watching this i have come to my own conclusion the longer the "duration the better" meaning time not rakats .Therefore 20 rakats is better then 8...if 20 rakats takes longer which it does, but you shouldn't read 8 rakats in a mosque where they are doing 20 and then walk out i reckon its discouraged if you do because you won't get the reward of qiyaam al-layl.
boxingfan786 1 year ago
PART 2
Ive read that different people read different amounts even 39. To get over the dispute of rakats is simple. Do what the prophet (peace be upon him) did because he was the perfect muslim wasn't he not??? So 8 rakats followed by 3 witr...but if a mosque does 20 i will do 20...but if there is a mosque that does 8 rakats i will go there.
This is what i think from what i gathered from sources...what do you guys think?
boxingfan786 1 year ago
Brother, I agree with you....Prophet (PBUH) had expressly allowed one to pray as many rakats as per his wish. Yet at the same time, he had always prayed 8+3. So Muslims instead of fighting with each other on this topic & telling that 20+3 rakats is bidath (unwanted innovation in the religion), they should quitely choose whichever they want & abide by it.
I will go to my nearby mosque & irrespective of the number of rakats they pray, I will start and finish with the Imam.
Allah knows better.
iqqy2007 1 year ago 2
@boxingfan786 SALAAM I THINK YOU HAVE MISUNDERSTOOD- TARWEE IS 20 RAKAATS! IT IS THE SUNNAH OF THE PROPHET SO WHY ARGUE AGAINST IT- DR ZAKIR NAIK IS QUOTING HADITHS FROM TAHJUT PRAYER WHICH HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH TARAWEE- YOU CAN NOT PRAY ODD NUMBERS OF TARAWEE BUT TAHJUT YOU CAN,
txr573 1 year ago
Respond to this video... Oh and do not come to conclusions watching videos and links on you tube- to understand something you need reliable sources i.e. books or lectures that are well in depth and are longer then 10mints! im not insulting just givin advice. learn through teachers not you tube. forgive me if i have in any way insulted you JZK
txr573 1 year ago
@boxingfan786 , Dear brother, why '786' in your id? I hope you are very much aware that it has nothing to do with Islam.
iqqy2007 1 year ago
Dear brothers and sisters,this point has been dealt with by ALLAMA YOUSUF LUDIANAVI in his book APKE MASAIL AUR UNKA HULL in great detail,please read it there and any one will be convinced that TARAVIH are 20 for sure.It is my humble opinion that Dr sahib should not discuss IKHTILAFI masail and lose his standing.
aamirmp1 1 year ago
is the 3 for witr?
Ishayu085 1 year ago
@Ishayu085 total rakats are 11 and 3 are witar
and u can offer witar 1 3 5 7 9 etc
nokia5095007 1 year ago
SUBHANALLAH this man does not appear to be a scholar of islam> he should really stick to the basics>
anna5471 1 year ago
i think dr zakir naik should stick to his field which is comparative and leave the fiqh (jurisprudence) issues for qualified scholars .
MrHamidmehr 1 year ago 4
@MrHamidmehr why?
boxingfan786 1 year ago
@boxingfan786 why ??? ....because he is not qualified alim in the science of fiqh its not allowed for anyone to go out and start giving fatwas when ur not authorised to do so despite being knowledge in issues like comparative religion like dr naik is .. its like a brain surgeon starts giving lectures and advice about the heart when thats not their field... u see my point bro ?? ...do u know how many years u have to study to become a alim in science of fiqh ??? it take years and years ...d
MrHamidmehr 1 year ago
@MrHamidmehr AGREE WITH YOU BROTHER PLUS YOU NEED IJAZAATH!
txr573 1 year ago
For those who keep emphasizing about the terminologies and their late appearance in jurisprudence, should know that the scholars of hadith have chapters on Tahajud as well as Tarawih, yet this hadith is not included in the chapters of tarawih.
Khaatab716 1 year ago 18
This has been flagged as spam show
3) In addition if this hadith was concerning tarawih, then why did Aisha (RA) the narrator of the hadith not reject the consensus reached by Umar (RA)? she could have informed him in some way or the other that the correct number of rakats for tarawih was eight.
Khaatab716 1 year ago
Besides this hadith which clearly is referring to Tahajjud, and is found only in the chapter of Tahajjud in every book of hadith and not in the chapter of Tarawih, the other hadith supporting 8 have strong weaknesses in it. Therefore the muslims as an Ummah are to follow the Ijma, the consensus of the Sahabas which was reached during the time of Umar (RA). And this Ijma has been followed for the last 1300 years.
Khaatab716 1 year ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
3) In addition if this hadith was concerning tarawih, then why did Aisha (RA) the narrator of the hadith not reject the consensus reached by Umar (RA)? she could have informed him in some way or the other that the correct number of rakats for tarawih was eight.
Khaatab716 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
3) In addition if this hadith was concerning tarawih, then why did Aisha (RA) the narrator of the hadith not reject the consensus reached by Umar (RA)? she could have informed him in some way or the other that the correct number of rakats for tarawih was eight.
Khaatab716 1 year ago
Therefore she could not have been speaking about tarawih since you only perform tarawih in Ramadan, so the question of Abu Salmah was about tahajjud.
2) Many compilers of hadith, such as Imam Muslim, Nasa'i, Abu Dawud, Tirmidhi, Ibn Maja, Ibn Khuzayma, and Imam Malik, have also not included this hadith in their chapters on tarawih, despite it being such a rigorously authenticated hadith. Instead, they mention it in their chapters on tahajjud or witr.
Khaatab716 1 year ago 8
1) The prayer mentioned in the hadith is clearly not tarawih but rather tahajjud prayer. Abu Salama's inquiry was regarding whether or not the Messenger SAWS performed any extra rakats of tahajjud during Ramadan. Aisha (RA) answered by stating that the messenger SAWS would perform no more than 8 rakats of tahajjued throughout the year, regardless of what month it was. Hence she was speaking of prayer performed both in and out of Ramadan. As she states "neither in Ramadan nor out of it."
Khaatab716 1 year ago 3
@Khaatab716 Lol this sounds familar whos your SHAYKH?
txr573 1 year ago
@txr573 Salam, much of the info are from a specific book brother
Khaatab716 1 year ago
@Khaatab716 wasalaam. I am not a brother- see how you jumped to that conclusion? and what book are you refering to? i wasnt debating with anyone- just saying why can people not read 20? why debate whether its ok to read 8? why would anyone shorten their prayer? all i was trying to say was that we shouldnt even talk about this topic and read maximum as we need the deeds for our sakes!
txr573 1 year ago
@txr573 Salam, apologies, for assuming your a brother, its just that your username really doesnt give me much to work with. Secondly if you read what I wrote I am not against 20 I am for it, lol, so it seems that you are assuming. Nor was I trying to debate with you, frankly I only responded to you when you asked me. Sister please read what I wrote. I wasnt even attacking you lol. And its a book by Abdur Rahman Ibn Yusuf, fiqh al imam
Khaatab716 1 year ago
@Khaatab716 lol i didnt realise i asked you something.. I thought you was picking on me lol! yes no problems. I see where i commented now.. sorry about this :)
txr573 1 year ago
@txr573 Its ok lol no harm done
Khaatab716 1 year ago
@Khaatab716 rather about that***
txr573 1 year ago
this ans leads to confusion. Brothers refer to sahih Hadith .
Prophet Muhammad SAW has never prayed more than 15 raka'h.
then y he s confusing. we have clear proof for 11(8+3).
Almumin11 1 year ago
The word TARAWIH it self is a innovated name. He never mentioned about that. He himself used that word. The correct word is KHIYAAM UL LAIL. We should Follow the sunnah. It s 8+3 rakah. when we have clear proof for 11(8+3). then y confusion
Almumin11 1 year ago
@Almumin11 "KHIYAAM UL LAIL" as you put it brother means standing at night, and refers to Tahajjud the night prayer. Dr. Zakir knows this and there referes to it in the traditional wording.
baig102 1 year ago
11 rakaats are only for tahajjud not for tarawih as he said also praying in other months too this clearly means that this is not tarawih it is specially for tarawih as it is written in book of tahajjud in bukhari as he gave the reference...
gooddeee123 1 year ago
At 0:48, he is giving an incorrect reference. There is no hadith number 472 in Book of Salaah under Volume 1. I have searched and searched all over the place for the hadith that is quoting. There is none. Can someone please point me to this Hadith in Sahih Al Bukhari so I can correct my misconceptions about this, if I have any that is?????
rafaybinali 1 year ago
@rafaybinali Yeh i Have been searching to brother- i found it in Bukhari :: Book 2 :: Volume 21 :: Hadith 248
txr573 1 year ago