Added: 4 years ago
From: rockfan7777
Views: 292,421
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (424)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • bon scott s headbanging to this song in hell

  • Way BETTER than original. I Love amazing Axl's voice!!!

  • Love it!!

  • Every blues based rnr band has been trying to recreate whole lotta love, heartbreaker, and so on. Its the sound, angus wanted to be like Jimmy Page, and Bon like Robert Plant.

  • @mikeyj122 angus didn't want to be like jimmy page. he wanted to be like chuck berry

  • @mikeyj122 your 100% wrong

  • @mikeyj122 Dude, Angus never gave a FUCK about Jimmy Page! Angus was influenced by good ol' black Rock N' Roll!

  • If you go and listen to live zeppelin from say 71 or 72 then listen to acdc live in paris from 79, you cant deny they were trying to be like them I dont care if they admit it or not. The proofvis in the pudding.

  • AXL SCOTT and SLASHUS YOUNG!

  • .... never best than the original

    AC/DC

  • Crowd should be yelling "Slash"

  • @Phaellos

    no they shouldn't since it's a tribute

  • @itamar4256 that was a joke

  • @Phaellos

    it doesn't sounds good either, lol, s-lash !

  • I accidentially posted under my wife's name, JennJ

  • I'm not trying to diminish ac/dc's accomplishments but if you listen to early ac/dc they were completly influenced by Zeppelin. And Zeppelin srarted the whole sex, drugs, and rnr mentality. Yes some of their songs were "spacey" but they wrote the book on fast, hard hitting, rock songs. Every band that followed Zeppelin was influenced by them; aerosmith, acdc, van halen, gnr, and whoever else. I'm sure Angus would admit it himself if he was asked

  • @mikeyj122 Silly boy Mikey! AC/DC are a fun rock band not influenced by the likes of Led Zepp who wouldn't know a good rock'n'roll boogie song if they fell over it! I love both bands but they are totally different in style, outlook, sound and attitude!

    Drugs, booze, and all the other stuff don't come into it!

  • Ac/dc is zeppelin minus the epic songs like stairway, kashmir, etc. So I personally think gnr is better than ac/dc because they are a more versitile band. But ac/dc does rock out!!

  • @JennJ5181 To suggest ACDC are a Led Zep copy is ridiculous, they were just inspired (like the majority of bands who were big in the late 60's, early 70's) by blues music, you hear the same blues riffs all the time from countless bands. But where they differ, is Led Zep sing about The Lord of the Rings, and can be spaced out and trippy, ACDC just make fast, fun rockin' music about Booze, loose women and rock n roll!

  • I love both ac/dc and gnr but for people to be bashing gnr need to remeber that ac/dc didnt break any new ground in rock history. All ac/dc did was copy Led Zeppelin. Angus Young was completly inspired by and wishes he was Jimmy Page. Whole lotra love, heartbreaker, rock n roll, how many more times, basically any blues inspired riff. If you listen to ac/dc's live in paris cd and listen to zeppelins how the west was one you woild know what I mean.

  • ACDC > Guns N' Roses

  • the ac dc version is better

  • @TheBacco93 That's not really the point. Guns are only playing it as it's obviously a song they loved and wanted to pay tribute to Bon and AC/DC.

  • This version is good...but no one gets the AC/DC sound.

    AC/DC are simply the best.

  • @manolete1165 Krokus man krokus

    Krokus is the ACDC no one has ever heard of

  • There's something bout Slash's playing that is so fucking peculiar. AND SO FUCKING AWESOME.

  • AC/DC>Guns N' Roses .no contest.

  • Putain, qu'est-ce que ça gueule !!! J'aime le metal mais plus calme que ça !!!

  • you are the best SLASH hahahahaahhaa

  • This is Slash Vs Angus! A great cover

  • that was cool

  • That was just fkn awesome............

  • I'm a masive AC/DC fan but i'll give it to them.. They did cover it well =)

  • ANGUs

  • Everybody wants to cover the best band in the world...

    

  • original with Bon is the best, but this is a great cover though!

  • Did they yelled "SLASH" at the beggining?

  • @catalyst4081 No ANGUS ofcourse

  • Liking this

  • Good shit!

  • If you wanna see a really great cover, search Gnr doing Rosie at L'arc this past year.

  • Nah, epic fail for gnr on this one, you need to be as good or better than the original on a "cover"!

  • Nah, epic fail for gnr on this one, you need to be as good or better than the original on a "cover"!

  • this is how I know I would totally waste a time machine. I'd go back and see Zeppelin, Van Halen, and GnR when they were young and hungry and immortal. and maybe put some money in microsoft.

  • Axl does a pretty good job on this but the drummer should be shot for this

  • i love ac dc..but gnr did some kick ass covers. knockin on heavens door, aint it fun, rosie, even hair of the dog was alright

  • @livewirevirginia who originally does aint it fun

  • @rockfan7777 the dead boys

  • @livewirevirginia wow i had no idea

  • @rockfan7777 yeah haha everything on the spaghetti incident is covers as well..some of them are spectacular, and others arent nearly as good as the original (see sympathy for the devil)

  • @rockfan7777 both wrong. it was Rocket From The Tombs.

  • @josh90123 nope you are wrong it is by the dead boys maybe you should go see if they did it before you comment

  • @kai1100 maybe you should check your rock n' roll history. "Ain't It Fun" is a song written by Peter Laughner and Gene O'Connor (known as Cheetah Chrome) and performed by their protopunk band Rocket from the Tombs. Later it was released by the Dead Boys in 1978. Rocket From The Tombs disbanded where members left to for Peru Ubu and Dead Boys.

  • @rockfan7777 Every song of of "The Spaghetti Incident?" is a cover.

  • @JasonL77 Makes sense considering I knew that most were

  • @livewirevirginia Knockin on heavens door is a real gnr song not a cover

  • @acdcfreak1994 nahhh its originally by bob dylan later covered by clapton later covered by gnr

  • @livewirevirginia i thought bob dylan covered it from gnr :x if it is like you tell me than i'm bad informed

  • @acdcfreak1994 the bob dylan version is from 1973, when the majority of gnr was stil little kids haha

  • @acdcfreak1994 no it's by bob dylan he wrote it in 1963, gn'r later covered it in 1987 and then put it on the use your illusion 2 album in 1991, so wherever you heard that, i'm sorry but you're very wrong

  • @livewirevirginia Mama kin?

  • @iwantsmoney fuck yeah. only problem is, aerosmith is rock n roll gold

  • Great version!!!!!

    really good

  • of course theyre gonna say "angus" its ac/dc's song

  • The first time they did this song was when Axel didn't show up at a show. Duff had to sing and it was a disaster. But Alice Cooper saw the show and for some reason hired them to open for him for a tour. Go figure.

  • This is the first time I have seen this GNR cover ever though I knew they did play it.This was a song they covered way back when just getting known.They also have recorded Rose Tattoo's Nice Boys song and when in OZ they also covered The Angels' Marseilles.So almost apart from Paul McCartney's Live and let die ,and Dylans Knockin on Heavens door(,their covers) they had a great respect and some influence from brilliant OZ rock.They wrote terrific songs of their own ,and did great cover versions.

  • @yellayute.... I also notice that any ACDC song covered by any other band always seems to be from the Bon Scott era. Says a lot.

  • I like AC DC to much to give a positive review

  • nooooo........they aren't as good as AC/DC xD

  • @fashion1nako well of course

  • @fashion1nako true that

  • Man..I gotta admit that young Axl was only the guy as hot as Bon.

  • damn the energy :O If I were on that concert:

    1. Grab a girl

    2. Dance like a motherfucking maniac

  • FAIL

  • angus and slash are rock gods!

  • i like GnR.. but i dont like Bands who cover other Big Bands.. especially GnR covering AC/DC.. thats like Sivester Staloone would cover Terminator 2. well. its not bad thing.. im still bigger fan of AC/DC. hehe

  • ^^. FAIL solo. GnR are cool, but i guess the real solo is just to fast for Slash.

  • @TheThunderstruck200 Since it's a cover and the idea of the covers are to make it how the artist wants it to be and not exactly the same, i think slash might have just interpreted it differently and slower? But you could be right but that's just what i think lol

  • @TheThunderstruck200 not too fast for slash.. just too much booze for slash :)

  • Great! Check out Alter Bridge's version too.

  • Guns n Roses = The only band that can cover AC/DC and do them justice

  • @RockAndRollEruption Good, this is bad ! look up Airbournes cover for acdc, they rock the shit out of gnr!

  • @MrTheVoiceless I've seen it. Going to see them in 2 weeks in fact. They are basically AC/DC rip off's but very good ones at it :L

    I just like how Guns N Roses put their own style into it but don't stray too far from the original, and in my opinion, that is what a cover should be, not just a straight copy.

  • @MrTheVoiceless i did they SUCK ,AND YOU SUCK FOR LIKING THEM

  • still bon scott sounds better

  • this one is pretty good THIS IS REAL MUSIC

  • conshetumare

  • what a voice Axl Rose has in here!!!!!

  • @stradlin62 I thought the same thing!

  • Yeeaah.

    real music <3

  • Love it!

  • This sucks! Axel(Overrated) Rose can't carry Bon Scott's jeans.

  • @HinesXL obviously that covers doesnt beat ur first impression of a song that u love so much, but covers arent for a band to say we r better but to make a tribute, if ac/dc made a tribute of november rain i would prefer the original, but i wont say that axl sucks but neither that he is better than bon, none is better than the other one, both singers fit perfect in what they do and both or gods of rock to me

  • @HinesXL It's a tribute, the point isn't to be better than Bon.

    And FYI, he spells it "Axl", not Axel. :x

  • @pevpevpevpev that`s cos his name is an anagram of `Oral Sex`!! only one 'E' in there!

  • Brian does a better job with this than Axle. this is the best cover I've heard though. No one beats Bon though!

  • @Waycooljr294 AXL not AXLE :)

  • @Waycooljr294 BON LIVES ON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • when did Bon Scott join GNR?

  • @Riff28Raff Dead on man.

  • Good cover but acdc do it better!

    

  • damn good, so *80

  • OH YEAH AC/DC AND GUNS ARE FANTASTIC

  • @reaper2230 and then again it was chuck berry that inspired angus young :)

  • you could say shes got it awowahhh!!!!!!!!

  • I love AC/DC, but this sounds really great...but what do you expect? It's the orginal G'n'R line-up! ;)

  • AC DC created the foundations for hard rock. Without AC DC GnR would never of existed.

  • Cuando eran una banda ...

  • Axl should have his mouth sewn shut permanently :)

  • me encanta este cover

    yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhh

    ^_^

    5/5

  • Pretty nice. Both bands are fucking awesome, dude!

  • Coma757 ACDC is not that you racist peice of shit! GnR isnt even that good. they cant even play their stuff live. what good is that. without ACDC you would not have your precious gnr bitch!

  • yaa finally an ACDC fan thats bad to the bone :) backin you upp on this one 100%

  • It's a whole lotta rosie on steroids

  • AC/DC was, is and will be the best band in the world... GNR was good at the begginig but when they splited up Axl fucked up

  • What!? Guns N' Roses were known for being one of the best bands live and you are saying that they suck live? I guess your age says everything!

  • Love how they still say "Angus" at the start.

  • @hockey6408

    thank god it wasnt "axl" they were yellin, LOL

  • @hockey6408 me too :DDD

  • Comment removed

  • @hockey6408 ikr

  • @hockey6408 shouting Angus become part of the s

  • Not as good as AC/DC, but its the best cover of rosie ive ever heard! GNR deserve a pat on the back for this one!

  • @AngusInDaHouse1983

    the best one ive heard cover this song is Alter Bridge....that band in general is fucking awesome,but yeah either alter bridge or W.A.S.P. does it WAY better than GNR

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • WTF

  • @zephranna01

    This isn't brian, it's Axel

  • its axl by the way...you wouldnt be talking about axl without saying his name right...Axl Rose is a mixed up way to say Oral Sex saying axEl will just kill the meaning...thats e truth behind axls name according to him and slash

  • Haha, that's funny, that's not how he came up with the name though

  • @jeffmay1 hmm how was it then??? i thought that was the reason i remember reading

  • He got the name from a band in high school that was called Axl, after the wheel-axle on a skateboard, which everyone was doing at the time.

  • @jeffmay1 name of a band he was in is it not?

  • yes it is

  • @slashsappetite1965 Yes what is?

  • I like both AC/DC and Guns and Roses but I like AC/DC better!

  • GNR is good, AC/DC is better

  • AC/DC is in a higher rank than GnR. Fuck GnR, copy cat blow hards. Angus and the boys are still making music while GnR is all broken up and disbanded. Brian's still got his vocals while Axel is shot.

  • fuck the ranks,

    Eric

  • you are probably 12 year old punk with no knowledge off music. (asshole)

    they are both very good bands but acdc is nigger and more famous than GNR but for me there will be always one and only GNR

  • well angus young, dont play so much, he only use A E ang G notes on most of their songs, and his solos are the same. Axl sing shit in this day but Brian its only falsetto .-.

  • first it's Axl, secondly Guns is touring and has sold out River Plate stadium in Argentina next month, 70.000 people who still care obviously.

  • @jdlewis60 By the way Axl now can sing very well compared to the 2002-2006 shows 2010 he really rocks and fuck the ranks okay if want that then GnR has already been the biggest band of the world in the late 80s and still is considered huge even if seperated

  • zo da klinkt egt niet

  • you can barley say that Gn'r are better than AC/DC because they the most popular band who was inspired by AC/DC well you can say that Gn'r are better but without AC/DC Gn'r maybe would've never existed

  • they sang this song again in the 2009/2010 tour

  • I think AC/DC is better .. :)

  • It's always been "angus" ! Our American brothers just get a bit over-excited

  • well respectively enough, i've seen them more than i can count on both hands, and at every show i've ever been at they were shouting rosie... so not to be a douche or anything, i just found that at the concerts i have attended, they have all shouted rosie.... hate to burst your bubble... but then again, mine has probably been busted since i've never seen them outside of the usa, but here, its always been rosie...

  • respectively enough mate...its Angus du du du du du du du Angus du du...well u get the picture.

  • GUNS N ROSES y nada massssssssssss

  • Axl Rose go go go !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • One of the best covers I've heard

  • Comment removed

  • Axl is the Best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!

  • id like to see a video of them doing this live

  • Ok, I might be one of Axl's biggest fuckin' fan, but you have to agree that everything he sings on, becomes unique, and even better when he sings such great songs!!!

  • nah man they shout angus at the start of this song, mabye when u went and seen them 6 times the idiot next to you thought it was rosie leaving you too beleive it was rosie :)

  • Do I hear the crowd shout Angus! Angus! at the beginning? I know it's a tradition and all, but shouldn't they shout Slashus or something in this case? :P

    Anywho, I think this is a good cover.

  • ... don't you mean Rosie? i mean c'mon... i've seen AC/DC 6 times, and each time i've seen them, its been Rosie... not Angus...

  • You might be deaf or somethin, the crowd usually shouts ANGUS, not Rosie LOL

  • Im not their biggest fan, but Guns and Roses kicks ass when they want to

  • yeah, Malcolm formed AC/DC, its definitely his band.

  • angus formed it

  • is that delay in the intro suppose to be like that? or is just steven real high on coke when this was recorded? :P It sounds kinda cool anyways!

  • Yes it is

    Normally when AC/DC plays it the crowd yells "Angus!" in that delay

  • Oh you got me wrong i think because I am talk about the drums in the very begining hehe :P

  • saw acdc live, now i hope gnr is also going to tour in europe ;)

    bye

    theyre both real real real good btw

  • c'è qualche figa metallara (o no) che vuole scopare nelle prossime 48 ore?

  • why are people slating GNR? people should be slating the so called 'rock bands of today' its pathectic.

    oh by the the way GNR+AC/DC = rock heaven

  • Ya, it's funny how if they are so into a group that anything anyone else does is crap.....I love alot of types of music.....but hard rocking good ole rock n roll is my fav..... like AC/DC, KISS, GNR and a host of others.... I like when other groups do covers!!!