Liar - Silver Ash

[Vampiric59]

this song sounds really thrash metal-ish......nice xD

[whitfury]

Damn i've searched 4 this for ages! Thx to chaos to leading me to this video<3

[LittleAngelFan]

Could somebody tell me more Chinese visual bands? Too interesting sounding )

[antiTuiskuFani]

Still some years ago I couldn't imagine there's this kind of bands coming from China :S However, it's a big shame their action has been restricted! More songs of Silver Ash and resembling bands to here, please :)

[bloodXblade]

I don't really like the singing... everything else is great. ^^

[AsakoChu]

same c:

[lnzd1]

I agree, I don't really enjoy bands or songs with excessive cussing, but in this case I don't think they're doing it to be cool.

It's more to prove a point and convey their feelings to their audience.

Regardless, I really like this song & Silver Ash.

[Koizora101]

no it was actually to the chinese goverment

[crazysocksgirl13]

I dont know why bands think they have to swear to sound cool I honestly think I would like more bands if they didn't swear as much

[kyedhenfemale]

Oh I love Silver Ash sooo much. Their music is so hard to find though T^T

[020LTV]

...but the guy is saying "your such a liar, your a f*cking liar" because thats the english I'm hearing...am I right? @_@

[YourSilentWhisper]

I like this band. Sucks that they had to stop being visual but still theyre a good band.

[gotitlovemanga]

I like japanese vk better ., i'm not so crazy about this  band., though I think there should be more like them in china

[plaguebacillus]

i wish silver ash was visual again T_T

[MadPrinceKyouka]

Wow, how come you hate Denmark? At least Denmark is METAL!!! Here in the U.S. everything is rap or pop or what they call R+B (but what I call lame). And unfortunately most U.S. metal bands suck.

[KyoLover2011]

@MadPrinceKyouka I am not much of a metal fan but America isn't all about rap/pop/R&B... being that those are our mainstream music, you would get that impression. But there are many rock, heavy rock, metal bands out there from the USA that are actually pretty decent and are better than the shit mainstream you hear.

[XxredvanillaxX]

feel happy to be Chinese xD

[ISayWhatIMean]

Lucky you, I would give almost anything to be Asian ._.

[NoodleMoogle]

Why? Be proud of who you are : ^.^

If not to sound toooo corny : ^.^

[ISayWhatIMean]

Yeah, but I hate Denmark o.o

[gotitlovemanga]

yea me to ., o.O

[nekonnichiwa]

are there any other chinese VK bands?

[Dark4Lillith]

This music video is pretty damn hard for China...

They are really courageous~ x3

[NoodleMoogle]

Lol subs : "You are a Liar"

Ling obviously saying something else : ^.^

Love this song - I love the song "control" too : ^.^

[plaguebacillus]

this motion looks like part of dir en grey like obscure & cage

[Ghoro]

Oh and also do you guys know any other good Chinese rock bands? They dont have to be VK.

[irisek]

it's the only one better known chinese visual band

[MILKKILLER0]

queen sea big shark,p.k47,fuck n'droll ,....they are great!

[mcrsk8punk]

I've been waiting three months for this answer xD

[xkumagorobeamx]

try Glazed Rose.. they're really good too

[Ghoro]

Do they have any other hard or harder songs then this? Cant seem to find any.

[ryuukatamura]

dood does he sing "you are such a liar" or "you're a fucking liar???"

because...

or does he alternate?

[Iruth27]

He uses both thrases :D

[ryuukatamura]

ahhh~ lmao that's what i thought XD

[xxcutexkidxx]

alternates

[kosopaty]

not bad

[BlloodRayyven]

Well, their guitar solo is good as usual.

[mediateketsdeg]

yeeeeeeeeeeess!!

[panikku11]

Ugh what a shame for China

I'm 100% Chinese,and I'm rather disappointed at my own country.

I visited once when I was 7 and it was actually China,when I visited again, it seemed like America.

Silver Ash would've been something like X Japan to China.

VK would be great in China because there's so many people and there'd be a lot more bands that might open up new concepts to music and such.

[TheBloodRedNinja]

I'm also a 100% Chinese and I agree!

[ryuukatamura]

I also agree! I think we all do.

[Amyna]

@panikku11 You're chinese and you've visited China twice? Geesh, I must be a Swede since I travel there every summer...

[KyoLover2011]

@Amyna I don't think you are comprehending what they are saying...

[Ravensteina]

There's a lot of videos of Silver Ash on a fansite but none works =[.

[h8r4me]

so they were banned in china for this?the people there are chinese?

[pichu4850]

kind of irrelevent, but I guess it's like how in many states, gay marriage is against the law, but for different reasons. "Bad influence," huh, yeah right. -shrug-

[h8r4me]

That's just weird. It's a style, but I can only somewhat get the bad influence thing. Well, it still sucks that they got banned.

[pichu4850]

yeah :/

[2100549]

uhh...they didnt get banned

[h8r4me]

They got banned from Beijing I think. I don't know if it's really true. I'm just thinking they are.

[2100549]

i think its a rumor, ppl told me they went to a music store in china and got their Cd

[h8r4me]

In Beijing?

[2100549]

idk

[mugenjouproject]

they where banned but they could return if they changed the whole style and drop the visual stuff, also several subjects like these where banned

[cindyzxr]

imao,this song (especially PV) would be obviously banned in china. what a shame...

its pretty good regardless of the so called similarity thing.

[Gameking102]

Bleh, I find they're way too similar to Dir en grey's visual kei scene. In one of their photo's they basically looked like a bad cosplay version of Dir en grey.

[xXChocoKellyXx]

They're inspired by DeG I believe...

[Hizakirose]

I really need their song "who" x(

This song is awesome but I think this was one of the songs the government didnt like.. they are awesome and i love them.

[mukku4ever]

wolę c.rock od j.rocka

[Saiura]

T-T I CANT UNDERSTAND HIS MANDERINNN...well some..

<_< I can't read that much chinese words...

[IyatehLolita]

don't worry, C-VK fans, there are other underground C-VK bands out there... I heard there are a lot actually... it's just hard to find them.

[xChiakix]

haha i love the beginning "You are such a liar!! You're a fucking liar!"

[synstanzer]

Lack of originality definitely.......feel so much like copying, in Rock even Visual Kei required own definition of art and hence output to the image and also musics......they're so much similar to Dir En Grey I would say

[Aya585]

ive herd more chinese Visual bands but can someone up this on sendspace or just the mp3 please

[AreinaChan]

You know, I would totally send this to you had I not lost all my Silver Ash mp3s =A=;

try livejournal comms?

[Aya585]

tyy!~

[ghemelza]

....

[MadderJIN]

The MV is cool~~~~

[dreadful66]

The beginning was really cool.

I hope they keep this up.

[VkFan1]

Anyone know of anymore chinese visual kei (ive heard all the japanese stuff)

[dreadful66]

This is the only Chinese Visual Kei band I've heard of(and they're really good).

By the way, are you sure you heard "all" the Japanese stuff? Dir en grey, Gazette, and Kagrra isn't the only J-rock band. There's a lot more.

[VkFan1]

yeah ive heard more than that. i like the more darker stuff than gazette and kagrra usually, phantasmagoria, moi dix mois, nightmare, hizaki ect, but those bands dont have as cool video clips as dir en grey, kagrra and gazette

[dreadful66]

I have a lot of those stuff saved to my favorites.

Gazette can go pretty hard too by the way. Some of Gazette's song: "No. 666", "Mad Marble Hell Vision".

[VkFan1]

yeah ruder is pretty cool too =D

[AreinaChan]

well unless you delve into the underground indies bands, all the older disbanded bands, all the new upcoming bands, AND all of the bands still together (in which case you wouldn't maintain a very consistant musical taste, but that's cool because I don't really either)--

Then I'd pretty much say, yeah, it's impossible to hear -EVERYTHING-.

[WolfDragon94]

This is the only Chinese Visual kei band so far....I'm Chinese but half chinese

[xChiakix]

...you haven't heard all of the japanese stuff because there are so many Japanese visual kei/oshare kei/angura kei bands that are indie and not very well known, yet still totally awesome. maybe you should look into it before you say "i heard all the japanese stuff" and of course there's jpop and other stuff but whatever you like

[GhostsINtheSnoW]

They're like a chinese Due le Quartz but the singer isn't as bad as sakito

me likey

[GRIMRACHAEL]

WOT U MEAN AS BAD SAKITO NO BAD AT ALL

[xChiakix]

how dare you! IT'S BLASPHEMY!! XD seriously, sakito was awesome.. oh well opinions are opinions

[BlackSama]

haha they're pretty good another band to add to my vk collection

[Aphrodite85]

Visual Black Metalis the style of this song is really cool.

[DemonSinxX]

umm CHINESE VISUAL KEI????

[rekniP]

Damn. I wanted to start the first Chinese VK band. =*(

[Ranma064]

I like them enough; but I'm not a fan of Diru's older stuff so this definately isn't my favorite. I like it enough to buy and listen to Silver Ash though. It's cool to see a Chinese VK band who have a lot of potential.

[beccaninos]

were did you find this pv? I've been searching the net for a while, but not with any luck

[AreinaChan]

Hell if I remember, lol.

I really don't know...I've had it for quite a while.

I think a friend sent it to me ):

[Kaorusmine]

I thought that CRock whould be weird, but they're all right, I like them.

[ubella]

YOU would be weird.

[paperxplanes]

Wth is he singing?

All I hear is mumbling.

[Keiseki]

liar liar liar your a fucking liar" is all Ling sings in the begining...

This band has a very demo sound so... it's kind of hard to understand them.

[Derlanger]

They needed courage to do a song like this one in China ._. But it rocks ! I understand better why they've been forbidden ;__; (did you notice that this video has been shot in the same place as Lunar Eclipse has been ? lol)

[OSPG]

yeah, very low budget indie style. XD

[PallorSomnium]

hmm...it reminded me of what I've read and seen about WWII...anyways, it's the first time for me to hear Silver Ash. I was so surprised that there's a Chinese VK band ^-^ they sound pretty good though. this song's nice

[iluvgackt413]

Haunting, yet good song.

[Kaishiou]

the pv reminds me of old Diru pvs .__.

[AreinaChan]

kind of, huh? Just a bit, I think, in the way it's filmed moreso than the PV itself...*ponders*

[inuhanyou777]

not to me i have a permanent diru fetish >>

[inuhanyou777]

yea and its purple >>

[link]http://brokencliff.deep-­ice.com/ling04.jpg[link] <-- i see kaoru resemblence <<

[inuhanyou777]

lol the hair and i dont know something about him just reminds me of kaoru... coulda kinda be the style too not sure its just..something...

[AreinaChan]

probably his hair...how it was kind of lazily spiked?

[SpicyMarmelade]

Kaoru? where? oO"

do you mean his hair?

[inuhanyou777]

Kaoru* X_X I hate this keyboard

[inuhanyou777]

awsome song but IMO lead singer look like Kaoruu and guitarist looks like die ( From Dir en grey) ^^ very kawaii <3

[innasama]

maybe because they're influenced by Diru

[xChiakix]

they ARE influenced by Diru... not just diru, but radiohead, X Japan and Malice Mizer

[neongreentea]

Ling is hotter then Kaoru

[SpicyMarmelade]

perhaps its a protest in general?

[Hozi]

yeah, I love this band also...not sure who the statement is stated to though.

[Delise]

mmm a political statement but against who? I love Silver Ash they are the first Chinese VK band I hear

[paracite]

I believe this video was about some western powers attacking an asian country. I'm not sure which Western country attack what Asian country. But if you can figure out what country that salute the kid made was from, then you can figure out from there.

[xkumagorobeamx]

im pretty sure... the country was China

[SpicyMarmelade]

Silver Ash sind so doll *__*