Happily Never After: Backstreet Boys/Pussycat Dolls

[bieberhater2010]

What was the first clip of the Backstreet Boys from?

[LeticiaBSB100]

I JUST SAY ONE THING:

BACKSTREET BOYS ARE THE BEST!

[DeniseIlles1]

na minha opnião BSB é MUUUUUITOO melhor do q PCD , eles cantam mt melhor e a versão deles é mais contagiante ! BSB forever s2'

[bsbghef4ever]

BSB should own this song. I don't hate nicole but its the boys who gave a true justice to the song...

[barbybsb]

bsb 4ever

[unshackled101]

BSB forever!

[icc2010]

BSB ALL THE WAY! KTBPA

[marie21w]

 Hate PCD's version, BSB's is so much more enjoyable. <3

[no1nicolefan]

pcd!!

[teamgreatwaat]

bsb..... most def!!!

[neegzoonkauj]

Bsb is so much better than pcd

[buzzcath76]

I STILL LIKE THE BSB VERSION....SO TOUCHING AND REALLY COOL....LOVE IT

[nykall]

BSB!

[squiddysushi]

Definitely BSB's. PCD's version has no emotion at all. Nicole just sings, no emotion involved. This is a sad song, one can't deliver it emotionlessly and even happily like Nicole does. PCD sing and dance like a bunch of stupid girls.

[CasidyDS19965]

Backstreet Boys!

[mmron2012]

@CasidyDS19965 you're right

[tvaddict456]

definitely the bsb. you can hear their emotions in the song.

[AskJohnReed]

The Girls' voices have a better timbre for my ear and a lot more depth, so I have to give them my vote - but hey - I'm an OAP so my heyday was the Tommy Steele, Lonnie Donegan, Elvis and Beatles era - with Bob Dylan and Bruce the Boss to follow......... I like depth in a tune!

John O'York

[merdjanii]

@AskJohnReed THE GIRLS ? ... It's only one girl :) Nicole Scherzinger :P

[MissBeatrizMaia]

Backstreet Boys!! = D

[nancybsb81]

Esta canción la escuché por primera vez de los BSB y me enamoré!! Hace un mes que descubrí la versión de las PKD pero sinceramente los BSB tienen una versión muchos más melódica, sin duda me quedo con Backstreet boys!!!

[Sazness]

BSB all the way!!

Nicole just butchered it DX

[VildeAndersen]

PCD, because, and don't get me wrong; i really like BSB, but when they sing the refrain in the song, they just sound gay... But they are bloody good with their other songs. It's just this one. So PCD ftw in this song :)

[merdjanii]

@VildeAndersen You are gay fuckin musical invalid

[VildeAndersen]

@merdjanii Oh, crikey! I'm sorry! I didn't realize I called them gay! I'm so so sorry! I only meant that they sound slightly femenine. I really like BSB. Really. It's just that I like PCD better. But I really didn't mean to say they sounded gay. I'm sorry...

[Rafys100]

PCD

[ibelieveintomorrow]

Nicole's version is not bad, its nice version but nothing like BSB's version. They put so much power, warm, emotions, power but too warm in this song. It can touch my heart when this song sang by BSB. That why in my opinion BSB is win in this song 100%

[lotrfreakkk]

i love both versions!!! lol i cant choose.

[TROYNDEX]

BSB I think don't express more than PCD. I also like BSB, I like literally grew up with them. . .but my heart is settled on PCD. What they have in common however is that they both lost one member. BSB lost Kevin, PCD lost Carmit. But they both sound great. PCD sound greater than ever.

And they both have new albums. BSB I think has 2 new albums.

[backstreetgal07]

backstreet boys for sure! theres no contest!!!!

[BlueJasmineRose]

BSB!

[bsboyjoseph]

Is obvious that the BackStreet Boys are Great.! and No Competition!!!

[Timesz1984]

BSB...that's obvious!!!!!!! They own the essence of the song....everybody can sing it good, but with BSB there's that little extra which makes a song real, coming from within :)

[uncchristine99]

I like the beat on PCD better (it IS Neyo after all!) but of course, the voices on BSB are superior.

[iTHINKSiLOVEyou]

BSB. there's just something about it....

they completely own the song

[madoll92]

I Love Both Version

ps. there both are fav band

[BackStreetBoy90]

i Like PCD, but there's No Comparison, BSB are the Best

[missnewbooty206]

PCD BABY!!!

[millie12345679]

i like pcd's version.

the bsb version souds like whining.

and come on, if you think about, the only artificial sounding difference is that pcd added a beat, like louder drums.

with nicole, you actually hear her voice, but bsb, it sounds like god knows how many whining guys.

to sum it up, bsb is whiny and thin, no beat

pcd is crisp and real

[MelZSquash]

I think the pussycat dolls version isn't bad at all, but c'mon, bsb's version is so much more touching. It's not as bland, it has awesome harmony, and u can HEAR the emotions put into the song when the bsb sang it.

[SugeeMcLeLe]

BSB!!! No competition!!!!!

[noura5i]

backstreet boys sure DUH !!!

i luv them <3

[rokna]

BSB！！so obvious

[rabbitx14]

Backstreet Boys hands down. No duet - it would ruin it.

[Gorgis90]

i like both BSB and PCD's version!!! i would love it if they can make this a duet!!! but i prefer Nicoles version more!! because she has more emotion in her performance!!

[elesansoso]

BSB win,it said and done!

[uptowngirls90]

definitely BSB ;))

[crystal530way87]

BTW, PCD sound too artificial.

Actually, female can feel the emotion of this song better, but with male sings, the song can be brought to another level..interesting

[crystal530way87]

I would vote for BSB.

BSB is like telling the story with their soft voice. My heart feels like touched by BSB's voice. I can feel the way that woman feels.

PCD sing well but I think they didn't put the emotion in a right way. It's the same plain tone throughout the song. Even when they're sing "No", I can't feel the determination.

[SugeeMcLeLe]

Good description!

[BSB2JG]

BSB. No need for a duet.

[rebeckarocks]

They are both really good, but I think that the PCD version is much much better, because it is more modernized and it sounds better. But the song is really good. the PCD got this one in the bag. BTW this song doesnt sound in male voice. <3

PEACE&LOVE

[4ourbeck]

the songs owner is BSB...so Forever BSB>...

[songoku17]

Backstreet takes te win here, I think BSB won over all lol

[nicksbabygirl]

bsb! wayyyy bettterr

[swishabiz]

Both are great. But Im going to give it to the Dolls. Its because Nicole sing it with emotion. BsB sing was very good but it took all of them to make it emotion. Only 1 Nicole took it all the way.

[rbdcutie21]

they're bot so goooood!!! but BSB is the winner!!

[BackStreetBoy90]

BSB of Course, they all sing

where is the other dolls, it's just nicole who sings

KTBSPA

[jecicabsb]

backstreet boys, el sentiemiento que le ponen es impresionate

nicolle, esta todo bien, pero no me gusta

[rositapowa]

BACKSTREET BOYS!!!!!

[Fabien4ever]

BSB <3

Briannnn

[brianlover93]

love them both but I think BSB has this one in the bag!!!!

[PHNSvideos]

PCD is much³³ better !!

[Marshallma]

Backstreet Boys is better

[ruleroftherose]

BSB version is waaaay better, I think....

[michellecourt84]

ha ha like your video! i have both versions and i have to say that BSB sing it so much better, they put more passion into it than Nicole does.

[Colemanleesitrev]

Backstreet Boys

No Duet

[LeahMarie624]

Backstreet boys version is defiantly better. Nicole's voice just doesn't go well with the song.