Added: 9 months ago
From: pesaodejameya
Views: 139,333
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (201)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i luv this soooo much

  • Stephanie does not need the "GaGa" persona. she is a good singer and a great paino player and song writer.

  • 8 personas son beliebers

  • So touching ;')

  • '' they told me not to do this, but, i dont give a shit'' Best line ever.

  • REAL MUSICIAN RIGHT HURR!

  • This just proves that she is a true artist.....ie; she can sing, write, and play a mean piano!

  • Inever realy liked her, but my jaws dropped when I listened to this!

  • i wear my grandmas ring everyday.... :)

  • another shot before we kiss the other side <3

  • She make me cry... I love her so much.

  • I'm in love with a woman called LADYYY FUCKING GAGAAAAA! <3

  • Real fingers, not for babies...

  • BEAUTIFUL!! 

  • 2 all the gaga haters....like Gaga said...i dont give a shit

  • "I was told not to do this but... I don't give a shit..."

  • you saved my life gaga. thanks mother monster , LOVE YOUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU

  • OMG this is breathtaken, AMAZING, the best live version of this song

  • i luv her voice and her and her songs

  • you are so fucking amazing, love youu mother monster!

  • I fuckin love y ou gaga

  • Well, i was told not to do this...but i don't give a sheisse

  • I -3 u lady gaga!!!!!!!

  • her voice sends chills down my spine,such a beautiful song!

  • altro che cantante costruita!!! grande!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • she's strange...she's acting strange..like a robot..

  • Ya know it's hard to stay completely perfectly on tune live... There are lots of distractions going on and sometimes you just can't hear yourself perfectly... I think she does amazing live, way better than other pop singers.... I can't stand when people with too much classical training judge pop music....

  • love the way she sang it,,, how i wish all her song would go acoustic!!!

  • Love this song. Especially on piano

  • This was the first time she sang this song live and she'd just taken off a pregnancy suit. I'd rather hear a few bum notes in a live acoustic version by GaGa instead of no live notes from Britney or a pumped up backing track from Rihanna or Katy Perry.

  • When Rihanna see this, She shit in her pants.

  • @Lola4404 hahahahahahahah yup

    

  • @Lola4404 lol! i couldn't have said it better myself :)

  • Anyone who is coming on this video just to say hateful things: do you really have nothing better to do with your time? You are actively dedicating your time to something you claim to hate...that makes absolutely no fucking sense. (You're also getting this video more views, so lol). Personally, I stay away from things I don't like and let other people enjoy what they want to enjoy. Jfc get a life.

  • @theburiedgirl815 she sucks and so do you! hahahaha

  • @EdwardRichtofenDr oh well I'm sooooo hurt by your mean comment wahhh! and what a clever person you are, coming onto a video purely to hate!! How revolutionary of you!!! Grow up. What are you, 5? Get a life.

  • I know that he's down in Hell is probably what she was gonna say. She thinks that place is Heaven. Satanic bitch!

  • Whoever told her not to sing this deserves a kick up the Ar*e!

  • like the hair!

  • out of tune. she misses the leaps.

  • @periola People believe when they listen to her she is this all mighty performer/singer.Compared to Sia,Jill Scott she can't sing for toffee.

  • @periola Definitely not, I have a frequency-meter (don't know how it's called in English lol), hits the notes perfectly. There's only a very little miss on the second "it's time to feel the rush", but that's it. Gaga's an incredible vocalist and singer, and here she proves it yet again. ^_^

  • @sjmaco I'm a musician since I was 5, and that's over 20 years. I think the ear is better than a device.

  • @periola Unfortunately, I can't simply trust you on that, I'm with people who have been quite a longer time than that, all saying that though she changes some tones, she near-always hits the mark perfectly. There's no problem at all on the "the edge"-s.

    I'm quite obsessed with gaga, so I always am bringing her round to my lessons. Been 10 years (16) :) The ear can deceive you, depending on what you want to hear, hence why no matter how much music-trained you are, it's good to have a 2nd opinion

  • @sjmaco Listening to it again, I'm noticing that a lot of her passing tones, the little notes, are the ones that are out of tune. It is very hard for a tuning device to pick up passing tones. You say you bring her to your lessons. What do you play? I'm a violin teacher myself. It's good to have a 2nd opinion, I agree.

  • @periola Oh, you may be right about that, I'll look into it, I thought you said on the chorus! Sorry, and yeah I play piano :)

  • @sjmaco Yeah I did say "the leaps." THe chorus is the best part actually. I notice that the first ascending perfect 4th was what I was talking about, in the verse. Also the notes that move in scalar motion, the "2nds", they are not perfectly in tune. There are a lot of these. I want her to do well because she has a lot of fans, so it disappoints me that she is not as good as her videos in live performance.

  • Comment removed

  • @periola It doesn't matter. As long as it sounds good. It does. So there we go she does well, problem solved, fans happy, yay.

  • @periola The only thing I can see that's technically insufficient is the pronounciation.

  • @sjmaco Check "Amy Winehouse - You Know I'm No Good (Live Acoustic)" for comparison.

  • Comment removed

  • @theburiedgirl815 There is such a huge contrast between the two.I can't imagine how you can listen to Sia and then listen to that cheap hussy tramp gaga.You are either very deaf or have something missing in your life.

  • @morman29 Exactly. There's a huge contrast between the two, they aren't even the same genre of music! It's useless to compare them. I love both, and both have touched my life. You, my friend, are the deaf one if you think Gaga isn't talented. Music touches people differently. It's not up to you to judge. Gaga isn't worthless, you are the worthless one if you think so.

  • @morman29 And once again, as I said, your opinion and your hateful trashing is serving absolutely no purpose because we will never stop loving Gaga no matter how much you beg to differ. Also, lol at the fact that every time you comment on this video you're getting it another view. Spending so much of your time on Gaga when you supposedly hate her. Lol. Just LOL.

  • @theburiedgirl815 get a life people.she is not christ, she is just a woman.

  • @EdwardRichtofenDr No one's claiming she was. But she has helped a lot of people, myself included. So kindly fuck off.

  • kocham Cie <3 <3 <3

  • @EdwardRichtofenDr have sum respect for her grandfather, shes allowed to mourn her grandfather!

  • @EdwardRichtofenDr yep you are loving :/ dont be a jerk you hater

  • she can sing . probably she has not such a beautiful voice but she can sing . And it´s neither her voice or her piano skills why she is famous , its here life style.

  • wow im starting to LOVE her... not being obsessive though but i love her :3

  • I actually cried watching HER pull away from the mike to cry a little

  • lady gaga=guttersnipe compared to Sia lol i'm reading comparisons of Lg to Sia all the time.No comparison..may i retort..1)Sia is not a back alley abortion of the music industry.2)She does not need to parade around in underpants and bra to make a decent film clip 3)Sia can sing with the voice of an angel i rest my case.

  • @morman29 As a huge fan of both Gaga and Sia (the music of both of them has gotten me through some very tough times and always helps break me from a bout of writer's block) I really don't see your point in coming on here to trash Gaga. Gaga fans are always going to love her whether or not you have a bad opinion of her. You're wasting your time. Stop invalidating what Gaga has done for people and move on with your life.

  • she´s so... ♥

  • @aznbank just like lady gaga you and her are both a waste of sperm

  • Compared to the artist Sia she is zero

  • @morman29 are u saying lady gaga is zero? i dont understand this? this judgment you're making is narrowminded and makes u look arrogant. i have never put down an artist like that regardless of who i think is better. i love lady gaga but i would never say that katy perry is zero compared lady gaga or whoever people compare her to. Lady Gaga is not zero and she is great, in dancing in singing and in inspirational healing to the youth. but in the end, compared to lady gaga, u are zero.

  • @morman29 But Sia isnt the one who's touched people across the world, has she?

  • NWO will fail!

  • The 5 people who disliked this are probably the people who told her not to do that (:

  • "I was told not to do this... But I don't give a shit."

    You go Mother Monster!

  • PFOTEN HOCH!!!!!!!!!

  • bloody AMAZING!

  • Comment removed

  • Beautiful.

  • the best performers are lady gaga and Beyonce!!! Lady Gaga is the first lady of pop and Beyonce is diva of RnB! They are Queens!!!

  • True live talent no auto tune!!

  • hammer geiles Lied ich liebe es aber ich denke dass sie playback singt!

  • @TheSupertalentGirl Is nich dein ernst oder?!...

  • no matter what people says

    she can sing and i love her geniality <3

  • HER VOICE...leave me speechless everytime <3

  • she is amazing. she is the best artist out there today.

  • Simply amazing.

  • I love these "first time" reveals, its always so fun

  • I Love Gaga!!!!

  • Amazing :)

  • Mindblowing!!!!

    

  • I like how her voice sounds

  • "I was told not to do this...but I don't give a s***". Lady Gaga-you rock.

  • I love 3:11.

    (And I love the rest).

  • She says he s watching over me down haha mmm boss song tho hehe

  • I like her hair

  • i don't like this song

  • I wish she would do an acoustic album

  • Just beautiful

  • She is just perfect in every fuckin way. I don't give a fuck what anyone says

  • It's incredible, I grew up with Bob Dylan and Neil Young, and now I'm loosing control for a popstar like Lady Gaga. That's pure talent, pure art, pure emotion.

  • people who say she can't sing just haven't seen her sing like this, with just her and the piano.

  • omg she looks seminormal

  • wow.... a women like other else just that .... she sings

    U 'r the best of the best , and the edge of glory never will end!

    Ionut - Romania

  • I've never liked Lady Gaga, but when she's realesing a aoustic album i'll be first in line! She's got an amazing voice, it's just so sad that she is hiding it in all her originals! :-(

  • mrsjessy you are totally right ^^

    She sings great anyway, but with a piano that whole complete sextape image of gaga isnt there its just real feel music ^^ i saw her here in the netherlands doing pokerface live on piano and hell did i love it ^^

  • Lady Gaga sounds much better when she´s singing her songs with the piano!

  • I love her acoustic versions <3

    It is different in a way and it shows that she is a really good singer with an incredible voice!

  • i have to say i always love these acoustic versions!!! why doesnt she ever put them on the radio like this? stripped down, inspiring, emotional?

  • everytime i hear this i am speechless..amazing..she's a genius!!

  • She's so amazing. In my opinion the acoustic versions are much better than the normal versions. I love her voice *-*

  • Je l'aime cette beauté.♥

  • Outstanding..... You rock GaGa.

  • Perfect! She should do more like this, just her voice and a piano.

  • TAN BELLA LA AMO LA AMO LA AMOOOOOO <3333333

  • she's perfect

  • this is what we call music!! not autotuned!! :D love you lady gaga <3

  • The version from Howard Stern is fantastic. Check it..

  • @buddyduke100 I know i feel the same way

  • wow ! she can sing

  • I m gonna cry now:(

  • Lady Gaga has crazy talent!

  • -3

    And they said that she can't sing...

    Some people must be deaf...

  • exactly, she's one of the few artists in the world who sounds better live than on a video

  • @96frantic great musicians generally tend to sound better live because they like playing with their songs and can capture the feelings better that way. it's only the trashy pop acts that need autotune and boobjobs to sell music who are unable to give proper live performances. music was live before it was recorded.

  • note her perfect posture.

    bam.

    thats my girl.

  • this made my day much better!

  • so sexy :) i love you !!!!!!!!!!

  • I. Got. Goosebumps.

  • @LaLLipOp21 Yep, so did I. :D

  • Love. Her!

    Why do people say she can't sing?! She's incredible! And so inspiring!

  • If and when someone tells me that Lady Gaga can't sing I will send them to this video. holy crap!

  • this is so beautiful! :) gaga, you're amazing.

  • she really has the most fantastic voice :) i just love her and that she isn't afraid to be herself and tell the bigots and bullies in this world where to stick it! You go Gaga!

  • I just covered this song! GaGas the best!

  • Anyone notice or am I being skits when she talks of her pop she says I know he's down he's watching over us I mean mmmm too much pot maybe I duno lol

  • She's my idol she's pretty great singer I wish I was all that

  • im not lady gaga's biggest fan, but DAM that girl can SING!

  • She is so badass! Monster 4 life!!!

  • people who say she can't sing are either RETARDED of effing DEAF

  • she is AMAZING

  • OMG she can sing !!

  • heey guys please see this channel SMASHTUBE18 shes an amazing singer u wont regret it im telling shes amazing

  • جامد

    

  • So beautiful :-))

  • Wow she looks kinda..... normal here. Too normal, that it's weird. ^^

  • Wow fighting but honestly @arthurdeodat your being mean she did only ask a question

  • Ah yes, the lovely Carlisle R1BW. Where Radio 1's pathetically inadequate method of handling ticket entries completely screwed over a lot of local people.. including me ¬_¬. Anyway, love seeing lady gaga like this, really see her talent.

  • Just the songs meaning mixed with the beauty of a piano is amazing makes me cry

  • Amazing version <333

  • i always get goosebumps when she goes " IAM ON THE EDGE " with full power

  • I was there, right in the front!

    AMAZING! <3

  • 3 people fell of the edge of glory.

  • This song is so beautiful .

  • I cried, singing and watching this video...

  • Lady gaga es realmente maravillosa, genial :D

  • There is a lot wrong with the music of today

    But its deffo not her

    This was bangin. Respect.

  • lol all you people who say she has fat fingers, her grandpas baby ring fits on her finger, and shes an adult! so ha you haters!

  • @ arthurdeodat - it was never said it was acapella - this wonderful melodic piece of music is lyrically genius and sang ACOUSTICALLY - which it is !!!

  • and this, ladies and gentlemen, was completely clean of autotune!!!!

  • she's God's gift of empowerment.

  • This is fucking amazing... clearly the best vocal talent and no one else can even compare.. props to lady gage seriously... so well done...

  • her voice. is just incredible. sounds just the the recording.

  • Wow. Never seen anything like her. What a gift. I'm 49 years old, mostly a rock fan, but love all good music. She is the best performer I have ever been privileged to watch. Can't wait to see her live.