Melanie Amaro Being Brought Back To X Factor, Simon Admits He Messed Up

[maxescate]

Todo fue un show, Simon desde q la escucho en su primera audicion sabia q ella era la ganadora

[miritavirgo]

puro show simon did always know, melanie was the best singer in the competition.

[777777932]

what i know about Simon is a good decision maker also he has a very very good taste, good hearing. i'm very sure he is not gonna messed up on Melanie Amaro.tx u Simon .

[rosarino2012]

LO MEJOR QUE PUDO HABER HECHO SIMON EN SU VIDA! ADMITIR QUE COMETIO UN ERROR!!!!!!!!!!!!

[resonatorMUZ]

Melanie, find YOUR heart and you will be successful.

[TheValkyron]

why did she get kicked out? as i heard it wasnt cuz of low votes

[TheTheLydiakwano]

Can I give you a hug Simmon?

[963ok]

@TheTheLydiakwano a u girl?or shemale??

[TheTheLydiakwano]

@963ok a girl? why?

[mememk1]

Simon you Plonker!!! What were you thinking?

[redlipstickxx]

so who droped that she came back ?

it made my cry. what a great family she has :) <3

[signizy93]

What song in the background?

[redlipstickxx]

@signizy93

against all odds by mariah carey :)

[iKawaiiCake101]

why she elimiated?

[agabriel003able]

She definitely deserved to win the first season of The X Factor.

[kevinleejj1]

1:32 the way he said " how are u baby' sounds wrong

[accesskb]

its all part of the plot ... Simon can't be so stupid to make such a mistake... other judges, maybe xD

[Yoelkiller]

@accesskb you are totally right!, we know everyone loves her, she has no social possition, her family loves her and we feel it, the staff knew that was going to be a BIG BANG for everyone to see her come back! she never had to be oout by the way!

[RandomCoked]

he should be a raybans model!

[tecnocato]

Now how's that for a comeback?

[vegas63robert]

I knew Melanie gonna be the winner. She's amazing singer.

[tefi1789]

so many girls with her voice

[xlr8r2010]

If Melanie doesn't win this competition I will be shocked...she has an INCREDIBLE voice.

[abno88]

and now she is in the finals...

[Xiofang]

If you look at the computer screen at 1:19 she was watching the x-factor LOL

[DramaQueen9324]

(gasps) Simon made a mistake? But I thought he was the expert on music?? smh tisk tisk -__-

[SecretGG911]

"APOLOGY ACCEPTED"

that made my day :D

[TheAwasa]

they're tryin to get high rate by doing this. ofcourse he wouldnt eliminate her with her beautiful voice. just one big drama.

[XarcZai]

Melanie's family is so supportive of her! I love that!

[fluidko]

the guy who opened the door, seems to be a very lovely and happy person :-)

[Faithbeliever123]

@fluidko HE IS! OMG! HES MY 3RD DADDY! I LOVE HIM.

[rosedoug]

i could not freaking believe when she was booted out....she was and is my first pick to take it all....i wish Melanie the best of luck in the competition...you go girl

[TheAjvizcarra]

she HAD to come back, cause she has what it takes

[charmanderblitz]

she knew he was coming somebody had to know in the family just to make sure she was home when he arrived and all those cars parked in front of the house yeah they knew.

[krya505]

@charmanderblitz someone at home knew but i really don't think she did

[SAPCmafi]

Yea Melanie wins the x factor... that's all...

[12NatRox]

ahahahahaha. her sister cries so much more than herr, ahahaha

[godblamesme]

Notice she was watching her performance on the computer, in the background?

[InvictusAmare]

YES!! Melanie all the way beautiful girl, beautiful family  may the lord bless them Melanie to the top!!

[iheartmtd93]

if melanie didnt come back i wasnt going to watch the show anymore. instead of keeping talent he kept girls who could not sing as well. he picked girls who he thinks would be a hit dependant on their appearance. melanie amaro is beautiful inside and out.

[BGM111474]

Yes, you made a stupid mistake Simon!! Should of never happened!!

[movinmommy]

Well done Simon! I've always loved your honesty and generosity and you have proven yourself once again

[strivehumbly]

simons smart bringing her back

[unhealthycarrot]

all planned, her tears didn't even come out lol

[MjloverofALLtime]

@unhealthycarrot Tears didn't come out because she was so happy

[rene4eva]

1:19 she's watching xfactor on her computer!? seriously...this is a setup :P She knew he was coming..

[MjloverofALLtime]

@rene4eva She was probally watching her performances

[1207doc]

i think simon has planned to do this all. this all for the rating!!!

[rosedoug]

@1207doc i have to agree with you on this one...hmmm...looks like a setup

[l3daX]

Too much drama



[jasonme2u]

@l3daX so true! and melanie was casually watching the x factor on her pc when simon came in

[caramelina]

shes gonna win the show!

[p6subhrap]

who went home instead of her then?

[gizarangi]

seems like a bit of a set up i think . made for tv drama.

[Prboi92]

@gizarangi Well maybe it was but it that was an authentic and real reaction from Melanie because she had no idea. You saw hysterical crying she was when he said she wasn't going through to the live shows.

[chillchi]

@gizarangi  damn all that, well someone please tell why Simon is always scratching his face with the F.U finger. and what the hell is going on with his left arm, he keeps hugging people with the right and barely moves the left. what is it, was he injured in the Iraq war...i mean what the hell!