Added: 5 years ago
From: azswirlgirl
Views: 293,488
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (258)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The eerie part is that Tori wrote this before 9/11...

  • "and you said you would find me here......"

    :'(

  • That's very sad. R.I.P. to all adults that passed away on that sad day, September 11, 2001. Let us never forget what had happened on that day. Let us all pray together.

  • Ten years later, and it's still hard to see the video footage of that day.

  • @K1MB3R1Y123 It's still hard to think that it happened :(. I feel like I might cry.

  • Ten years later, and it's still hard to see the video footage of that day.

  • The only thing sadder than this video is the event it depicts.

  • Beautiful.

  • Thanks for making me cry :'(

  • Now having said that...I love Tori Amos, but I find her lyrics so muddled and unclear it boggles my mind. It's almost as if she sings in a daydream full of emotion with no clear focus! The lyrics and approach to this song fustrate me so much. It's so ambiguous, like most of Tori's lyrics, but really should be clear considering the theme! But for some reason or another I relate this song to that day, this war, and especially when they finally killed the Boogey Man!

  • @DRUNKENRAMBLE It wouldn't be authentic Tori if we understood each and every aspect of her lyrics. That's what keeps them precious to her. She doesn't always want to show the exact meaning of the songs like she did way back when with Little Earthquakes. Plus, pulling this song out is just a snippet of the entire concept album of the on-going story of Scarlet's Walk.

  • I love America, I was raised in NY, and I love Tori Amos. AMERICA...we didn't have to sacrifice another drop of our blood to avenge this unjust attack thanx to our military might...FACT!!!! NY...I used to love lower Manhattan, the mall under WTC, dreaming about Wall Street and all it's Possibilities and Most of all the museum at the top of the WTC and lookn at the craters on the moon thru the quarter binoculars. I've been on that roof so many times, I lost count!

  • wow how could you dislike this video

  • This video is incredibly sad.

  • New York is so naked without those twin towers please re build them I don't like naked thing's :/ 

  • what is that at 4:07 ? a women but what

  • Comment removed

  • Thumbs up if you didn't even realize its been 10 Years

  • try play this slow again and again many times from 4:47 and to building start collapse you see stick flames and explosin betwen all dutch in right time they have do it and other video you see flash.

    If any think building go down just becuse plain hit it then analyse steal and fakta..where is this gigantic cores?;-)

    building can collapse but concret can not get to dust by self.

    Of 3000 peopel they only have found pices of them what can have don that.?only c4 and heavy explosive..Right

  • @MultiAirbrusher NO A PLANE WOULD BE ABLE 2 TAKE OUT A BILDING SO DONT SAY STUF LIKE THIS OK N? IT KIILD ALOT :''( NEW YORK'S ♡ IS BEING KILLD ♡♡♡♡♡

  • @KIZDEV09 YES IT WOULD YOU FOOL! IT MELTED THE STEEL BEAMS!!! jet fuel is kinda like a torch, IT CAN MELT CRAP!!!!

  • @KIZDEV09 nvm the fool part but yes a plane can do that

  • @MultiAirbrusher Maybe you should learn how to speak before you try and say stupid things like this. Take it for what it is and leave it alone. Stop trying to make the tragedy worse than what it was. Nobody appreciates it. K, thanks. Awesome video, by the way. I cried watching it. That happened on my birthday </3 Such a sad and depressing time. And it still makes me sad to see the pictures, knowing all of those people were killed, and knowing they were about to die...Ugh..I can't even imagine.

  • I remember that i saw this on the news..

    I just started crying ..

    Even if its over the ocean .. It stll made me cry..

  • made me cry...

  • inside job. 

  • faked videos and photos.

    Aluminum planes can't just punch through steel girders and concrete floors and walls.

    No way never.

    All of the videos that pretend to show the plane just disappearing into the building are faked. Anyone with a working brain should know that.

    It's like saying an empty beer can could punch through a brick wall.

  • @txsray1 You should try and read some science books before you say something like this...

  • INSIDE JOB 

  • "Can't find my way out of your hunting grounds" as the camera man is getting cornered by the dust clouds from the collapse - excellent work man!

  • R.I.P Jennifer....... ;(

  • inside job

  • OMG This is awesome, thank you, Michael's Mom, FF Michael Edward Roberts, Engine 214, WTC, 9/11

  • Very, VERY good video! To everyone, Why the hell are those towers not built back yet and why the fuck are they not taller and bigger than before? This is America! God's shining light on the world.

  • @badmagik6 I agree..built better and bigger and taller buildings before the Muslims build.

  • @badmagik6 Bigger and Better won't bring these lives back. Bigger and Better won't make anything better. I'm not sure if anything is appropriate...not just yet any way.

  • @badmagik6 i just visited ground zero. they're currently in the process of building the freedom tower. it will be taller than the twin towers were and it will be a symbol to show that you cant knock us down. at least not for good.

  • @badmagik6 it's because it's Ground Zero and they don't feel right to build over the landmark in which the victims died.

  • @badmagik6 the new one will be done next year and the meuseum will be done on 9/11/2011

  • Very Good Video.

    Tori Amos and this song go perfect for a tribute video.

    May all those whom lost their lives on 9/11 Rest In Peace.

    And to all the family members who lost loved ones that day, our prayers go out to you.

  • The camera man runing in 2:59 should try out for the olympics.

  • the pic at 1.39 is just totally awesome .my town would fit into that green park area ..but it shows how ,they can kkep a city like this sustained but they cant do anything with north africa ,,,,,makes you think huh

  • this is too real

    i can't get over it

  • You are so very welcome, azswirlgirl.

    I love this song and love this clip.

    I used to play it on my iPod when living in Tokyo and on the trains.

    I am one of those who just keeps coming back and back to watch it here.

    Arigatou!

  • these people were not killed, they were murdered. and this is why we shall fight as ONE british and americans!!!! with all others that will stand up to their country!!!!!

  • @llifs123 yeah im with you .i love my country and im not against the system but i hate every single corrupt offical and their corrupt ways for the harm they cos to their fellow humans and other animals ,,,,nazi's lost the war but fascism won it

  • beautiful

  • And Thank you for posting this video.........Very well Done.....

  • R.I.P Jenn, Kenny ,Mr.Correa and ALL who were Murdered that Morning....You are all Missed soooo much...The heartbreak that happened that morning will NEVER heal....NEVER FORGIVE, NEVER FORGET...........Rest Easy Guys.. :'(

  • this song is really about being a plane on 9/11, I read somewhere that Tori said that

  • AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!

    My heart truly goes out to the victims, families, men in uniform that lost their lives on that day, and the ones to continue to fight for our freedom TODAY!!! may GOD BE WITH YOU ALWAYS!!!

  • haunting.......and so sad

  • The perfect song and video to commemorate the victims. Thanks very much for making it

  • @pushithead YOU ARE VERY WELCOME!!

  • Even thoe it was 9 years ago, Sept. 11, 2001, No mattter where you where, what you belive in or belive what happened that day, Many lives where lost. My heart still aches for thoes Who Lost there lives, faimlys and friends. :(

  • We will never forget.....

    Thank you for this truly touching tribute.

  • This makes me cry everytime I watch it.

  • :'(

  • AMAZINGLY DONE! 

  • @choclatesaltyballz

    Wrong Person... my bad... I honestly can't remember why I posted this

  • @Iceman5164 ......................I feel for all who lost their lives in 911, for all of them, including all the war boys, who also took innocent lives while fighting.but you are far to dumb to even know you're stupid, yet again, another government report blames the lone gunman

  • I thank you so much for posting this! It is by far the best self made video ever on youtube.We will never forget!!!

  • I want to thank everyone who has watched this video and those that have shared this video with others or keep coming back to watch it again.

  • How evil. How could you do this. "Though shall not bear false witness". You know you took part in this. And you will pay for it. Now or in the afterlife. Beautiful song.

  • Awesome job. What a powerful video and the song is so fitting

  • Beautiful video. As I watched horrified, with the world, on TV, the sanctuary of my teens collapsed, and my old haunts went up in fireballs, and in the midst of all my shock, I had one question:

    ~ How many brown people are going to die for George Bush's vengeance?

    I am a New Yorker. Until that day, most people in the USA did not consider NYC to be part of 'America'. It was our tragedy, not the Heartland's.

    Our tragedy is still an international, endless death-march. Peace, please?

  • mafaldacrumbwitty my heart felt sorrow to you and your family. We will never forget... ever

  • All those innocent people died because of those mindless terrorists

  • that was amazing

  • Never Forget

  • WOW1 ...WOW! I was just surfing Tori tunes when I came across this. this is the best self-made vid on Youtube. Ive got the actual pstcard that the final scene depicts. Amazing. great tru=ibute begining with historical NY and etc. FANTASTIC job heatherfeather, Incrediby effective!

  • qué horror, cuánta locura!

  • 0:16 that huge hole in the sky where the twin towers should be standing makes me so sad..

  • Rest in Peace ...

  • Very dreadful day :(

  • thank you for using Tori for this rememberance video...tears still flowing from me...touching video..

  • Today has been a day of sad remembrance.

    In honor of every innocent life lost on September 11, 2001. Rest in peace.

  • Very moving ................so many years later but so present in all our thoughts! God bless!!

  • the pictures of people jumping/falling and the planes crashing in to the W.T.C make me brake up in side i feel so sorry for the losses of all fire men and cvilians and police men who lost there lives i feel sorry for american famlies who list dads, husbands, brothers, mums, aunties, sisters, daughters and wifes and im not american im british and proud!

  • thank you. i just want to say that in light on anti-american backlash it's nice to hear from someone who can realize no matter where we are from...we're all human beings. that in itself shoul unite us.

  • @demon658 Amen.

  • Excellent job

  • God bless America and god bless the famlies of the people who died again. I saw a rainbow in the sky there that means god is puting down his bow and arrow for the last time let's hope nothing like this ever happens again I just rly wish I could have Ben there and pulled a firealarm like 30 mind befor it happened. Rip to all those who died.

  • The combination of these images, and this song...just killed me.

  • -.- R.I.P

  • RIP the 9 lives lost in mid air collision over the hudson today, incuding a child , I immediately thought of this song...

  • i know alot of people are not gonna agree with me but now all the stuff that is on some videos and info saying that they blow up the bottom of the towers if that is not a lie i am glad because if they fell side ways there could be a lot more kids with out a mum or a dad , or a husbad without a wife , or a mum and dad without a son/daugther

    but R.I.P everyone who lost there lives we will never forget

    And i hope the familys who lost the people heal aswel

  • We will NEVER forget.

  • I hope so!

  • You do honor to the song, to New Yorkers and to her. Thank you.

  • the guy in 3:14 brhind the ambulance didnt kno the smoke was coming smart tho the other guy opened the back door and both of em were safe form it

  • Its still so hard to look at....so unbelievable.... so horrible....my heart goes out to all the people that lost their lives in such a tragic way.

  • Very moving. Well done on an awesome tribute. RasputnaViolist, the artist is Tori Amos of the Scarlets Walk CD.

  • nice song. whoever it is..... : D

  • Tori Amos- I Can't See New York

  • thank you america for helping us through the tuff times canada is with you

  • The best video I've seen on youtube. I was also the 198,888 viewers.

    God bless all the people involved in this attack to come.

  • you are absolutely right

  • god bless america r.i.p everyone

  • i love it, ok ? love your song, very tasteful

  • very very nicely done

  • HELPING THE HOMELESS and im promothing human kindness as i walk across AMERICA for every life lost in 911 2001 and our soldiers lost, lets change some ones life im calling all millionaires/billionaires/all celebs/HUMAN BEINGS to walk a mile with me and in that mile help some one so for every life lost is a life gained ARMAND YOUNG(BAMBOOTHEWALK)UTUBE OR MAN WALKS AGROSS AMERICA GOD BLESS R TROOPS IM CALLING ALL ANGELS

  • yes. you are right. and i am crying again right now :( this song. the video. it's just impossible not to get emotional.

    my heart goes out to everyone that lost their lives on that day. RIP

  • i was in like 4th or 5th and we all thought the world was ending...

    god bless the families of 9-11

    and did u know that the letters 911 cant be used in aircraft/ boat/ and exct recording names and as addresses now

  • i was in 1st grade wen this happened..it was like 2 hrs atter school started...nd it was like my 2nd day of school =[

  • I wish I was there

  • @TheGreyDaisy I am curious, a year later, as to why?

  • @azswirlgirl I can imagine what a huge emotion explosion it would be, actually experiencing THE 9/11-attacks. Seeing those towers get hit by planes and just exploding. People running around, not knowing what is going on. This is a historically very important event. Sure, it's horrible, but being there sure would be exciting as hell.

  • i dont want remeber that day :(:(:(:(:(

  • These terrorist comited a suicidal attack on America. I live in NYC. I don't think that I was here at the time. I was in my dad's country. I guess that 9/11 happened when I was not here in New York City! I hope that they finish the Freedom Tower and that the FT stands strong for us all and will give us all freedom from terrorism. I also hope that our soilders come back here to the United States of America safe! I wonder if they will ever find Osama bin Laden. Would they?!? R.I.P to all!!

  • i just dont know while people would do this, what is the point in the terroists, cant they jsut get on with there own lifes. I hate them. Nice tribute

  • <3 I can remember this horrible day, i was a lot sad. Those terrorist were too bad, sorry.

  • The title "I can't see New York" says it all. New York will never look the way it should. Unless the towers are rebuilt, Osama will have won. Thank you for this moving trubute.

  • My thoughts are with the people who needlessly died and the families who lost them.

    There are no words.

  • god i can't listen to this song or watch the vid i start crying everytime yet i always keep coming back

    R.I.P to all those who lost their lives

  • it makes me sick to watch this, so much horror and yet I'm sick. I'm sick of realizing the desperation in people of all nations, Conspiracy theory aside it is becoming more noticeable the condition of the world economic situation and the US role in the mess of money they've (we've) made. Still it takes your breath away to see the repercussions.

  • <3

    Amen

  • i always wanted to visit the World Trade Center in New York but i never get to :'( why does the disaster have to happen!?!?! WHY?!

  • My Heart goes out to those that suffered such a horrific death. The panic must of been unbearable. Your brain can't possibly comprehend whats happening. Lets hope Obama finds Peace for the World. We All have to share it!

  • i feel SOOO SORRY FOR THE PEOPLE WHO LOST THEIR LOVED ONES!!! ='( My friends father was in one of the buildings and hes always crying on this day and i feel sooo bad!!! R.I.P<3

  • ='(

  • this is so moving.

    We are America.

  • amazing video i miss those towers and i dont live in new york

  • Baaaaaaam.....amazing video!....so emotional!...and sad...poor New York

  • It's just so powerful picture. I mean I don't even live in Usa. I have nothing more to do with those people there. But I'm crying. It's more that 7 years ago now.

  • Very moving

  • Imagine yourself trapped on those towers. You're cut off and the flame is stinging your eyes. Everything is happening and you have no control whatsoever. But jumping outside, away from the flames, into the clear blue sky, may have been the only choice that those people had. Would you die in a burning hell hole? Or would you give it all for the last 10 seconds of your life flying?

  • It is nice to put it that way. I think that they chose to jump, because burning was more painful and took much longer. They kind of knew they will die anyway.:(

  • That was the question I and many others faced that day. I still to this day have the News cast and footage saved on my TV, just so I never forget those heros and inocsent people who died on that tragic day. God Bless all those who where killed, injured or lost a one love on that tracgic day.

  • fuck war :(

  • Amen

  • I'm whit you proudcroatian95

  • rest in peace everyone who went throo this and passed away, the people who done this and ruind thousands of peoples lives and took them away from there familys i hope you suffer, rest in peace everyone else, xxxx

  • What a nice, respectful video. I liked it and the music goes well with it. Very upsetting though, the ammount of people killed on that day just makes me want to kill the b*****ds who did it and not care that I might just get thrown in prison. . . .btw I like MixJauert's little poem its cute :)

  • I wish this video would be showen on tv.I think people are forgeting what happed that day,and business is going as usual.

  • Give me your tired, your poor

    your huddled masses yeaming to breathe free

    The wretched refuse of your teeming shore

    Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me

    I lift my lamp beside the golden door!

    (Statue of Liberty)

  • #1 imperio yankee no forget ever.

  • it makes no sense how we get a day off to celebrate the great and late Martin Luther King Jr, or the presidents, yet we have no day to commemorate 9/11.

    we do nothing to remember it, we say nothing about it. and 9/11 is a day that we should never EVER forget.

  • Well we do something. Just nothing big like making it a holiday. But yes we should. Maybe Obama will! Maybe there is a reason Bush didn't. But you are so right it should be a holiday.

  • we as in america shall never forget this sad day

  • so sad. such dispair.

  • To think that all those people who jumped from the windows were just ordinary office workers... I would never have the courage to do that. Everyone who died has a different story. Imagine if your mother or father went to work one day in a simple office job and never came back because they had seen a plane fly into the side of their workplace and been forced to decide whether or not to leap or burn to death. So tragic... excellent song

  • hey i must cry when i read your text and in background this song played.....my uncle is died there. It was the most shit day in my life:(

    When you are home and your uncle is working thousands miles away and you thing in 6 months he comes to germany visiting me..and then there are in all channels ov TV news about it. What do you thing? How you are feeling?

  • I am sorry for your loss. Your Uncle's Death will never be forgotten. Find peace in the rage. Do not add to the chaos. Pray for those whom did this for when they pass they will have to meet their maker and face final judgement.

  • yeah my mom and her friend were supposed to be their tht day but my mom said 2 her friend can u take the kids to school today? meanin me and my brother..that took 20 minutes and when she got off the train she only saw smoke imagine what thos 20 minutes would have done? i was only 3 and i remember it so well such a sad day

  • Thank you Sunshine.

    :)

    You have just (without knowing) defended my sister who died.

  • man, that was amazing.

    i haven't any family-members lost that day. but all these pictures and videos ant mostly texts like yours - the touch me so deep.

    we'll never forget 9/11.

    we'll never forget all those people, who lost their lifes that day.

    i wasn't very old - only 10 - bit i'll never forget that day.

    nobody will forget.

  • Courage to leap to an easy death in the face of burning alive in flaming jet fuel? I suspect you'd find it.

  • I totally agree. Say a prare... :(

  • I wonder what happened to the woman in the bright pink blouse casually walking holding a cup of coffee as the videographer is running for his life past her.

  • Beautiful video tribute and song. we will never forget

  • Execelent.

  • A day no New Yorker will ever forget. RIP all the victims of 9/11 and terrorism.

  • This was a great tribute and a great video for one of Tori's most heart-felt songs. Great job and my heart still goes out to the families of those who passed on that tragic day.

  • i remember the day this happend i was in 4th grade and during class everyone was getting called to the office to go home and we all had no idea what was going on until we actually got home. i remember i had to go pick up my sister from school and her school was a few blocks away from the twin towers. my bus drivers daughter died on the 100 floor of the first building. r.i.p everyone

  • wow xD

    great

  • This isn't and shouldn't be a laughing matter. Regardless of our opinions on what may or may not have happened, we should just acknowledge this video as an amazing tribute to a horrific day. Some people really just need to show a little more respect.

  • bella, people don't have respect anymore.

    This is a term that people cannot even comprehend. It's gone.

    I just try to ignore them as best I can.

  • Those pictures are really terrifying indeed,especially the ones from people jumping from the towers,really sad.But you also have to see pictures of people after american bombingS in vietnam serbia iraq ...REALLY HORRIBLE!!

  • I wasn't referring to you. You weren't making ridiculous comments.

  • My husband was one of the jumpers. I'm glad his last few seconds were spent flying free.

  • im really sorry,may God be with him.

  • My heart is with you and I know he is surrounded by pure love and knows no fear.  You will see him when again "on the other side"

    This song is for you.

  • Bless you for your kindness

  • @mafaldacrumbwitty  When the time came to choose, to accept the death they were brought the flame, the cracking steel, the air consumed, There were some who refused they would not stay, caught to burn, be crushed, asphyxiate entombed. They made their own deaths into on final act of freedom. They made their deaths into one last gasp of liberty. They made their own deaths. They flew down, as their souls flew up above the smoke. - 14 Sept 2001 by a New Yorker (then in Denver)
  • @mafaldacrumbwitty

    God Bless You and your husband....

  • @mafaldacrumbwitty if you dont mind me asking but how do you know he was one of the "jumpers"

  • I cannot believe it has been 7 years...what a terrifying day that was...

  • thats an amazin song for a touching video xxx love Pardoe xxx :-) xxx

  • my brother was in mew york he was talking to my unce he lokked at the win towers (he was 4 at the time) he said "uncle were are the bildings?" my uncle told us to run as fast as we could we went to the hotel the second plane came. we cried.

  • I was at the bottom level when the first plane hit I ran outside to morone street and watched..... I took my eye off the building for five seconds and a loud bang rang right next to me the back of my shirt was covered in blood I looked at the body next to me and it was my friend Tom Baskovich RIP tom.

  • vaildranger11, I cannot imagine what you have went through, and what you go through everyday ! I myself did not lose anyone on that day. However, I have not been the same since 9/11. My heart goes out to the victims, but the survivors and their families are the ones I pray for and hope for !

  • Thank you, everyone, whom have watched this video and commented; especially more than once.  Thank you for sharing this video with others. This date will remain in our hearts and blood as Americans and We Will Never Forget. ~Heather~ aka AzSwirlGirl