Added: 4 years ago
From: quickaccent2006
Views: 27,401
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (18)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Every version has a different year and date at the start of it:)

  • The best version of this song I have heard even better than the famous one with Judy Collins and Ted Bickel which was excellent.

    I think a common fault of many of the great American folk singers of the 50's 60's and 70's is that their versions often lacked sufficient instrumentation-there is a hell of a banjo player on this song.

  • @RPenta - a matter of taste, certainly. But simply as a matter of information, those earlier folkies were trying to replicate the sound of the songs as they would have been sung originally. Versions like this and the Pogues and so on are the Hollywood version - very glitzy and professional. But no whaler singing this tune on a New Bedford whaler in the North Atlantic in 1840 would recognize this version as their song. And if you want to hear a great banjo part - try the Chad Mitchell Trio.

  • @CompVid101They would have recognized it as a professional version of the song.

  • I'm 5 years old and I first got into this music when I wrote it onboard a schooner that fished out of Gloucester back in the 1840's.

    I'm American born but my father was an Irish fisherman and my mother was a codfish from the harsh deeps of the North Atlantic.

  • Heh, when I heard it it was in 1853.

  • Excellent, Fergus on lead. One of my favorites of Ryans Fancy.

  • Wonderful rendition to a classic sea chantey song!

  • Nice song. I love by Judy Collins or Peter,Paul & Mary

  • R.I.P DERMOTT O'REILLY

  • from cagliari,sardinia: i love this music.i love the dubliners,the pogues,the ireland.great great great

  • I am 18 years old and i wish i grew up in the era when this music was popular. It really does it for me as opposed to the stupid dance music in the nightclubs these days

  • I'm 19 and have found clubs with this kinda music. Pretty much how I got into it :-p

  • I'll be 19 next month. Thanks for proving me wrong :P I'll hav to start going to different clubs then.

  • I'm 24, and this music is STILL popular :D

  • @gfl1984 I'm 19, and I usually go to Irish pubs (or irish-themed as I don't live in ireland :P) where the people are very friendly, and the music great! :)

  • The Pogues one is canny aswell.

  • Great song! I also like the version sung by The Dubliners.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more