Audi S5 Vs BMW M5 Fortune Magazine

[JBScicom]

the M5 steering wheel looks way too thick for her hands haha

[playman9111]

worst review ever...anyways you should compare the m5 to the rs5 not the s5, unfair review

[envyv07]

This is why women shouldn't review cars!!! They should stick with reviewing lipstick and handbags. Am I wrong?

[hypercarbon]

why she is not in the kitchen? i need a sandwich

[VoidInvader]

there must be a mistake i think a woman is driving

[atami210]

So the suspension setting controls the transmission?

Knows nothing about cars, this woman.

The M5 has settings for transmission, differential, engine, suspension and pretty much everything else....

[hondablade1000rr]

what the f**k is shit?! lol this was the worst 5 mins of my life, staring at some idiot that babbles on about stuff she does not know anything about, I am an idiot also for watching this crap :/

[hondablade1000rr]

@hondablade1000rr oh and another thing, the third gen MMI on the Audi S5 also allows you to set the suspension and the steering wheel stiffness, throttle response, light dimming etc. so when you compare, please do it fucking properly!!! but also with a car in its own class! the 335i would be more appropriate.

[Astonmartinv12]

worst. comparison. ever.

Good lord

[jvlazzar]

someone give her a mop, women cant review cars

[Anthonyhercules]

what is she doing out of the kitchen?

[shawnfbgm]

but why make the m5 4 door ? ? ? ? ?

[xXJDiaz914Xx]

this bitch dont know what shes talking bout

[Ikilledyou123]

lol fly by cops who are waiting to give you tickets? this thing would be a magnet for speed tickets ! :P

[AliGhanizad]

bull shit, comparing a coupe to a sedan and then talkin shit that its the only v10 in the market. she needs some anal work.

[carguy978]

There are plenty of women and men that know what they're talking about when it comes to cars... This woman just doesn't happen to be one of those people... M5 has 383 lb-ft of torque btw

[onabreeze]

e39 was the best beamer .

[Colinfichman]

obviously all that power will never touch the ground. Shitty columnist. looks like these were the only cars they could get their hands on. Only production car with a v10?! this lady is retarded. She should give up on car reporting completely.

[Colinfichman]

obviously all that power will never touch the ground. Shitty columnist. 

[TurboRSV]

Cars are not for you women.....

Forget about sports cars.

What the hell this test is about? She can't even hold that steering.

About the cars, the M5 is the boss of all.

[mcclarinscott]

if you can't compare X-Drive with Quattro = clueless about why people are increasingly buying AUDI!

[Basketballer43]

women canrt drive, why the fvck this biatch does this mag ?!?

[redmond12400]

M5 is THE BEST. AUDI is SHIT.

[jhhibbs]

so dumb...

[bart12121314]

looking at this video you know why US is such a mess... they're all incompetent starting from the Presidents (Bush or Obama doesn't matter) all the way down to car testers. They're all sooooooooooo dumb and have no clue what they're talking about. Well, this is maybe why they vote how they vote. Incompetent morons vote for incompetent morons as they don't know any better, right?

[iloveyoubmw]

m5 the best

[910127]

Lol, nice try silly girl

[jjyooo11]

She has no idea what she's talking about.

[2005CR125R]

ok first off i wanna say, these cars have no similarities and should never be compared, and also, the fuckin steering wheel on the m5 is fat as fuck lmao

[LFC0610]

The video is stretched.. No shit.

[pe3ty]

Hat ez szanalmas volt de nagyon!

[Bajko5]

why you yankees, let women drive so beatiful cars !?

do you realy want to see them damaged ? ;)

look at tim schrick, he is a awesome testdriver!

[PIMPKENNY666CARFREAK]

wtf, the M5 has 383 lbs torque, n m5 only prodauction car wit v-10? Lambo Gallardo, Dodge Viper, BMW M6, Audi R8, Audi S8, DUMB SKANK!!!!

[Monger4142]

im getting really sick of all of these people trying to act professional in videos and not know what their talking about. just read off the fact sheet useless bitch

[MustangGT2142]

u should compare M5 vs RS6

[lekocaj23]

dumb ass bitch

[emantabrizi]

Sue, find another line of work. "The M5 is the only production car with a V10?" Seriously? If you're going to do an automotive segment, perhaps you should do a little automotive research.

[zomgitsjason]

i dont give a flying fuck who you are sue, i want to see a audi vs bmw

[c3806md]

this old woman is a little stup. go home to clean. Do you have a car?

[xxxk]

I WANT THE M5!

[albokidnj]

the s5 should go against the 335i but i think that the s5 can hold up against the m3 e92

[minidude524]

its not the only production car with a v10 in it....

[dirtbiker4522]

no actually, dodge viper audi r8, audi s8, the list goes on... she needs to do her research

[themiker15]

wow she is dumb m5 isn't the only v10 car in production. s6 and viper and im sure there is more

[varnamosodra]

eemh s5 and m5 ? :s s5 is more like a bmw m3. Audi can beat any BMW. M5 gets beated by RS6 easy.... m7 by s8 z4 by tt rs.. m3 by rs4 and x3 by q5 and x5 by q7. there u got all the "best" of the BMW's but audi beats it ..... and no opponent to the 2009 audi r8 v10 ;)

[kingb212212]

your a fuckin moron u have no idea what ur talking about, people will laugh at u if u talk like that, the new 760 is a 550hp v12 bi turbo 8 speed manual engine, and dont get me started with the b7, go jump off a building.

[somon92]

no audi s5 vs bmw 335i!!

[siLentks]

what facts do u rely on?

[dirtbiker4522]

car wesites and driving them... you can see 5 and 5 pistons opposing eachother,,, duh

[MikeHuntIsItchy]

Ehh, Audi needs to get with the program and make some nice SMG tranny like the M3 has. I don't like the new M's I prefer the Gen before this.

2006 BMW M3 SMG coupe hardtop< BEST CAR EVER.... inline 6, smg tranny, dohc.... wonderful.

[proudcroatian95]

hard... i love both

[hermitette]

Ford do a van with a 6.8l v10, Lambo have a 5l v10 that is also used in the Audi RS6. Audi also use a V10 in the S8 and S6. BMW's own M6 also has a V10. I just Wiki'd it and it turns out theres LOADS of cars i didnt know about that also used V10s and WERE IN PRODUCTION in 2007.

[Pidkin]

talk about women drivers

who compares an s5 and an m5

[ChiliPepper92]

they both have a 5 in their model names NO DUH! ;-)

[SixSicxSicks]

hahahah the 5 is the only like feature

[nickolaus11]

BMW ist the best!

[Streetracingpunk72]

"The M5 is the only production car on the market with a V10?" WTF is she talking about?

[VeEvey]

Women lol :D

[pretsler]

This is two years old, might that have something to do with it?

[Streetracingpunk72]

Yeah, that might be why, although, even those the RS6 was not being produced in 2006, I'm pretty sure the Dodge Viper still had it's V10 layout. I don't know. I could be wrong. Good thinking though, I didn't even notice that.

[Streetracingpunk72]

Nope I was wrong. The Viper was not produced in 2007. 92-95, 96-02, 03-06, 08-. Bastards.

[ruscutuflufus]

@Streetracingpunk72

The BMW M6 uses the same engine that the M5

[Streetracingpunk72]

@ruscutuflufus Never said it didn't. Not quite sure why you responded?

[FukYurAss]

@Streetracingpunk72 She probably ment to say "production sedan." but idk

[frendlytemjin]

@Streetracingpunk72 u know it was made in 2007

[99klauszb]

2 beautiful cars - but - ...AUDI IS THE BEST...

[HLOsunshine]

I don't know if the reason is that you don't have these in the states, but wouldn't it be fairer to compare the audi coupe s5 with the bms equivalent M6, and the same for the RS6 with the M5 (both sporty executive saloons)?

[zaqgt5]

but it is in the states...

[peanuthandler1]

You are completely correct. These two cars are in a totally different class. Typical though, that a women is doing the news piece...she has no clue...just watch how slow she shifts. Ha, ha. I think the M6 has a way higher price disadvantage, however. The CLS or E550 might be closer but then Mercedes won't pull their head out of their ass and offer a manual. My '06 CLS is a POS, not only for its lack of a manual but that it is so unreliable. I will never purchase another merc...ever!!!!!

[Streetracingpunk72]

I don't think so. The M6 is faster than the M5 and let's face it the S5 is no where near as fast as the M5 or M6. It's kind of a weird comparison. Also like Peanuthandler1 said, the M6 has a much bigger price disadvantage, even more so than the huge one already here between the M5 and S5. Just because cars share a number doesn't mean they are always comparable.

[mitrahloca]

2 very good cars

[Skito89]

she is talking so much shit... damn.... maybe some people will hate me for this comment but, in a auto magazin a man should drive and explain the features of the car... sorry...

[ItsBergey]

Uhh 'the BMW M5 is the ONLY production car with a V10 (2:35)' umm there's the Dodge Viper SRT-10, the Porsche Carrera GT (5.7ltr V10), Lamborghini Gallardo the list goes on, come on if your reviewing a car on TV get your facts right at least

[Gstarking]

she ment a sedan not a coupe

[BenBieb]

Audi S6 and RS6 also have V10..

[phantomflt]

And the S8

[maazali66]

and also the s8

[bustlee]

i would lick her butthole anyday for those cars!

[yashamilton1]

i rather take the audi better looking and more reliable

[badyoute]

um ok ....uuuuuuuuuuuhhhhhhhhh i still love my audi s5....

[wasimkhan321]

some would argue that the Mercedes e63 amg is the grand daddy of saloons/sedans

[wasimkhan321]

the back is not roomy, unless you're a midget

[miloscaki]

audi is better then bmw!!!

[regisfun]

no ther not lol bmw rule

[wurschd11]

tzzzz, you cant compare the audi with the m5.

ohh yess you should compare the s6 withe m5!!

[younggotribe]

Silly comparison. Better comparison would be M3 at around $60k or even loaded 335i at about $50k. Other videos show the 335i beating the S5 on a closed track.

[Xevisberi]

Exactly!

Audi-A 4/6/8= BMW-Series 3/5/7

Audi-S = BMW-M

Audi-RS = BMW-CSL

A5/S5 is a very beautiful car though, perhaps the most beautiful! But I won't consider buying one unless Audi makes it RWD and lighter...

[8MunchenBayern8]

CSL doesnt compete with RS...CSL is a one off

[overdocistri188]

bmw m is way more performance based than audi's s, you could maybe compare the m to the rs models. audis are built as luxury cars, they are more comparable to lexuses than bimmers or benzes

[guy247]

1. its spelled "beamer"

2. a beamer is a BMW... what are you saying!

[keerboy69]

man, I don't know what is more stupid, this review, or your ignorance. A BEEMER is a BMW motorcyle, and BIMMER is what BMW cars are. Get your shit straight

[guy247]

well shit on my dick, i spelled it wrong. go squat on a cock and enjoy it, assface.

[thelittleflowerpower]

Who cares...

[one6s4]

AUDI S5 is so beautiful. BMW looks so dumb

[BMWdieselFahrer]

tzzzz, you cant compare the audi with the m5.

[eighthgap]

Did she just say this car is the only V-10 currently in production on the market? What, we no longer are counting the Dodge Viper?

[zacafreakingriah]

ok.... WHO THE FUCK LIKES PADDLE SHIFTERS!?

[Rathinko]

Ok, before watching it I was looking forward for a comparison, but she killed it. Makes no sense in comparing the two cars: $50k S5 vs $90k M5. 345hp vs 500hp. Why not throw in a Ferrari in as well into the comparo, cos evidently "price is not a concern".

[NUTRIOR]

wtf m5 only production model whith a v10 she doesnt know shit about cars how could work at a car magizen?????????????

[jamesjr934]

Hey they both have a 5 in their names, they must be a good comparison. :)

[yarghen]

what a terrible review, comparing 2 completely different cars.

[funnycore]

you are right that the review is horrible, but they compete with eachother so how are they totaly different?

[golf1262]

they shouldnt. it should be like s5 and m6. eh?

[GymKnightSucks]

WTF? fortune mag???

this bitch don't know squat about cars...

lol, two steering wheel stalks she can't get right on the m5!

agreed, worst review ever.

[12sae62]

this is the stupidest review ever , the cars aren't comparable and the reveiwer knows nothing about cars, she can't even drive a manual

[funnycore]

the cars arent different theyre competitors

[yarghen]

what are you talking about, the bmw 335i competes with the audi s5. the bmw m5 competes with the audi rs6...

[hovy82]

HAHAHAHA, I like the "let me show you".

S5 vs M5 ?! WTF ?!

Since when Fortune mag. reviews cars???

It's like C&D or MotorTrend reviewing money stuff?

simply: WTF !

[DrivebyDude]

S5 vs M5?!?!?!?!

Are they dumb of something?

An S5 is compareble with a BMW 335i.

RS4-M3

RS6/S6-M5

S8-M6

[StreeTRacR008]

How is the S8 comparable with a M6? WTF? An S8 would be comparable with a M7 if they had one, but they don't so its 760i/Albina B7.

[LiquidRetro]

The only production V10 on the Market COME ONE.

Audi S8 = V10

Audi S6 = V10

Dodge Viper = V10

Not to mention the more rare offerings from Europe.

[StreeTRacR008]

M5

M6

Gallardo

[formula1nyc]

Hahaha this has to be the worst review ever.

She considers the cruise control placement a "glitch". What a tard.

Fortune's car reviews are just as bad as Consumer Reports' reviews.

[Mazda6B6]

Sorry but the M6 is v10 also.

[heidi4srki]

americans...

[AudiEnthu]

This is the worst review I have ever seen...Fortune should never review cars!

[italy430]

why the hell are they comparing the S5 to an M5??? not even in each others class. an RS4 competes with an M3, and the S5 wouldn't touch the RS4. the best car to compare the S5 to is the 335i where the BMW beats it in handling and the S5 beats in 0-60 as it is more powerful.

[amerikanzero]

this was rather dumb. we went from talking about the s5 to saying something as dumb as "if you want the ultimate sport car and are willing to spend 40g more..." well with that logic why not spend 200g's more and buy a gallardo, or just drop 1.4 mill and get a veyron...sick cars anyway.

[ricmclife]

How do a cars magazine take a coupe V8 to compare with one "berlina" V10??? Without notion...

[TimmyTime1989]

my god, n i thot americans could get any dumber!!! this woman doesn like an m5 for wer the cruise control stalk is.....enough said!!!

[ThePegasus1979]

But she isn't that wrong. I love my european 335i coupe (more power than the american versions), but i REALLY hate and get mad about the direction and cruise control stalk, being only 2 inches away from each other.

[tomie867]

u gotta shittin me bitch?

[shanerorama]

obviously you drive some piece of shit mid nineties trans am

[7614686]

Car and driver

[teme8]

Hahahahahhaa only production car with v10? What about s6? s8? Let alone Lamborghinis etc.

[zacster007]

Sue You dont know your cars  . The S5 is as you stated a slot between the 4 and 6 Sedans. Dont you think you should be comparing RS4 VS M5. What a review it sucks!!!!

[tonya786]

" the sheet metal is muscular " what is a yank woman doing commenting on european cars stay with your tractors that you call cars...BMW should not sell the M5 in america as they dont deserve or appreciate it..joke review by this bint

[ytwoktt]

dumb comparison these cars have nothing in common you moron.

[AudiFreak1988]

V8 vs. V10??

[jc55]

Shouldn't it be Audi S5 vs BMW M3?

[7614686]

why put a performance coupe vs performance sedan, throw the rs4 in there, by far better than m5 hence the award it recieved for being the best performance car

[Cerim87]

The Audi s5 is a beauty, the M5 is just a monster no comparrison... compare that ///M Power with the new Z06 and lets see what?? Corvette will not be that much faster, but its a shitty GM........

[mclarenv12]

I am now dumber, and more angry for viewing this garbage. I agree this lady is indeed automotively ignorant. Hmm v10 cars: Audi RS6, Audi S8, Lambo Gallardo, Viper, Dodge Ram truck,Ford Trucks, Porsche Carrera Gt, Volkswagon Toureg and Phaeton, just to name a few. lady quit your job! or be fired...

[8MunchenBayern8]

i love the chunky steering wheel!

[wronguy0]

how is she a car columnist? she puts the car in automatic mode when in 'M' mode? the M5 is the only production car with a V10 in it? how about the S6, S8, Viper, etc..

Worst car review in history

[eurorap]

First of all, comparing a 354hp car to a 507hp car is just stupid. The S5 is a competitor to the 335, and the M5 competes with the RS6. This is as it is for all you that fight with eachother: RS6 - M5 S6 - 550i S5 - 335i Coupé S4 - 335i Sedan RS4 - M3 S3 - 130i TT - Z4 A8 6.0W12 - 760 S8 - no competitor from BMW since there is no M7 And so on...

[andy55055]

eurorap, u forget the most obvious comparison, and that is BMW Z3 vs supermarket shopping trolley. Most BMW's are made in south africa and basically suck. Audi rules!

[roman740il]

ehm...Dingolfing isn't in south africa. My 7series is made there, like all other 1,3,5, and 7series

[sliver2003]

This lady is horrible, these cars are nice but she is so boring she puts you to sleep.

[bill75077]

Does this lady know what the hell she's talking about? I bet she'll compare a C350 with an RS4 on her next episode. She's nuts!

[job112006]

girl u have no idea what u talking about how can u compare s6 w/ m5. u better stop fooling people bitch because this generation is not like your but anyway wait untill the RS6 comes out... also for your information

audi s3 vs. bmw m1

audi s4(rs4) vs. bmw m3(csl)

audi S5(rs5) vs. bmw m6

audi s6(RS6) VS. bmw m5

audi S8 vs. bmw m7

Got it thank you

[bimmer540iT]

I'd say A8 -vs- 750i ... no m7

S8 -vs - Alpina B7

also, the M3 CSL is more hard core than the S4.

[zapopaul]

okay, i would like to tell the columnist to do her homework to. and i would also like to add the Porsche Carrera GT to the list of v10 production cars

[MyWorld108]

The Carrera GT is not in production anymore.

[328iPower]

the S5 doesn't even compete against an 'M' though. it competes against a 335i

[MyWorld108]

Production cars besides the M5 with V10 engines:

BMW M6

Dodge Viper SRT10

Audi S6

Audi S8

Lamborghini Gallardo

Do your homework Sue!!! You moron bitch. "Hi, Im Sue Callaway, the dumbest and worst car columnist ever".

[MyWorld108]

She doenst know what the fuck she is talking about. First of all, the M5 is not the only production car with a 10 cylinder engine and secondly the M5 has more than 352 ft/lbs of torque. They need to leave the M5 to more qualified auto columnist test drivers. She also needs to learn how to speak on camera. Where the hell did fortune magazine find this cunt? Either they hire anyone, or its just another example how connections are everything (because they are everything).

[pulse007001]

I love it how these magazines test the Audi with something in a totally different bracket against the BMW. Like everyone's been saying...test the BMW with the RS cars and I think it would be a little different reaction. Was it just me noticing this, or did she have some difficulty shifting in the S5? And did she suggest maybe evading cops somewhere in there then say the levers wern't allowing her to signal properly in the M5?

[richey713]

You're absolutely right!! Test that M5 with an RS6. The latter is definitely at the same level as the M5. Now just wait until they compare the M to the new RS6. That should be an M killer - no doubt!

[neo171171]

SHE IS A BLOND with a wig...testing a v8 against a v10. The m5 should be tested gainst an s6. For crying out loud, she's getting mixed up with indicator stalk and the cruise control.

[es492420]

No, the RS6 competes against the M5

[neo171171]

You are right, I actually did mean the RS6. It was a typing error. Honest. Just looked at your reply and realised.

[onoitsaWRX]

If she was able to get the job, I should go ahead and send them my resume! :P

"And... I'm... here...doing my... Stop moving the teleprompter, please!!"

[Methanoladdict]

How the hell did she get the job of Auto tester ??

She dont know shit.

Ruins the credibility of the review.

[a4qt]

WRONG! The M5 isn't the only car on the market with a V10. I can think of a few, Dodge Viper, Audi S6, Audi S8...

[es492420]

lol. i was just about to leave a comment about that. what, is this lady stupid?? when i heard her say that i wanted to reach through the screan and smack her. btw, don't forget the Gallardo.