城裡的月光 - Tank

[okok8709]

他男的還女的

[TheWAoF]

講的好像你都沒對Tank做人身攻擊的樣子

你可以發表個人對這首歌的詳細看法

有需要直接一針見血?

不喜歡可以別看,可以別去這樣留言糟蹋人嗎?

說別人修養前先看看你多麼的自以為是

[Meizry]

Tank毀了這首歌

[TheWAoF]

@Meizry 你毀了你那張嘴

[Meizry]

@TheWAoF

本來想寫一下對Tank翻唱這首歌的詳細看法，不過既然這裡是一­言堂那就算了。

倒是閣下在網路上發表這種人身攻擊，你的個人修養與父母家教都有­待加強!



[jordan19851010]

真希望TANK趕快把身體養好~~超期待妳的專輯耶!!

[chyekc]

有任何高手可以告诉我4.04那个高音是什么音吗？

[lydiachang1]

tank唱出守候的感動 我喜歡這個版本

[dino681921]

的確，樓上說的沒錯，這首歌還是要帶點憂傷的情感，比較有fu

[tim61192005]

"'改編'"改的超棒



[o1oq25i0o2]

他唱得比較正面感情

[a0937689315]

好好聽^^TANK的聲音很吸引人

怎麼唱都好聽

[doen84725]

好難過....他現在唱歌不能這麼氣足了....

[qazask520]

原唱聽起來很悲傷，但是TANK版本的卻很溫馨，

兩個版本我都喜歡ＸＤ

[hamadicr]

原唱太感傷了 改了編曲後比較溫馨

[tarata88]

歌手唱得很好，可是還是比較喜歡原唱的arrange

[aqasdswedfcccvgfd]

這首歌的歌詞沒那麼悲情吧...再說好聽就好,沒什麼好比的

[qoo314090]

只有永遠好聽的歌 不是誰唱的好誰唱的不好 TANK唱的也很好聽 不同的心情聽不同版本啊  為什麼有這麼多爭議?

[khoocheepeng]

a good song by a naive nut

[a22660606]

好不好聽

我覺得都好聽阿

只是風格的不同罷了

青菜蘿蔔各有所好

爭什麼爭

[ksfann]

是ㄚ

[Mrbayleef10]

9s

[Mrbayleef10]

9s

[winter530530]

好聽啦~



[TsaxzSrew123]

好聽!!!!!



[bleujade]

听了许美静的版本感觉很悲伤。

听了Tank的感觉很轻松。

不同场合听不同版本，哈哈！

[roy5347]

讓這首歌有新生命~

[owrock]

风格有点像陶吉吉。。。好听！

[feelfreeonthesea]

Different people, different taste; different version,different meaning....

[jmejmejjme386]

改編成這樣的唱法，我好喜歡，感覺整個宇宙舞動起來，幸福充滿人­間。

[elaine991990]

He sing this song in such fun way....made ppl feel relax and happy after listen to it.....Gambatteh!!!

[ss558ss]

獨特的詮釋方式

也是很好聽

[gihjklll]

其實大家都有不同的 "好聽" 的角度  大家只要喜歡自己愛聽的方式 那便行了 不對嗎?

[l3al3yben]

tank唱得好正>_<!!!

[momokoxmas]

Guy version he is the best :-) hehe

[hou617]

改成這樣不好聽

[rhythmtmac1]

Tank 獻給已逝姊姊的歌~

感覺比許美靜唱的多了一種溫情.. 當然原唱也很好聽啦~

[Arverse]

好棒，　听了还要呢！

[MGlEml]

我覺得許美靜唱的感覺就是 已經沒有轉圜餘地的傷心。但是Tank唱的就是還有希望的那種感­覺

[loitecksan]

haohao ting^^

[spadypoonpeepee]

我觉得这个版本也不错啊。。。

[hln1201tw]

有特色 喜歡

[matengmeng]

呵呵，这首歌我觉得比原唱的好听啊，呵呵，我还是通过翻墙才进y­outube的，我操，国家太不厚道了

[tso1158687]

@matengmeng 廢話，共產國家，你還算好，北韓根本沒有機會

[matengmeng]

@tso1158687 你说哪里不能翻墙？？？

[tso1158687]

@matengmeng 北韓阿，他們雖然叫網路，事實上是一個超大的區域網路，只在北韓­內，你有看過北韓的網站了嗎?共產國家通常都有言論自由的管制

[9VARZ]

TERRIBLE! Absolutely disgusting!

The original is so much better!

[smart0339]

不同的感覺。也不錯聽啊！

[cuteflygon]

disappointing, total misinterpretation

[kermitloo]

omg he sounds like david tao!

[ivone129]

nice...

[qfuzi]

where to download this song?

[colorsoflife100]

I'm sorry to be honest, but this version has miss the interpretation of the song...this cannot beat the original. Total misinterpretation....very disappointed.

[happifruit]

The original has a sentimentality that Tank misses in his reinterpretation.

[fairex88]

very nice....i so love to hear....tank is better!

[b361780f]

還不錯聽~

[shjong08]

好聽不錯

[PYCHAN0]

佢同原唱都唱得好好聽耶,,

雖然係2種唱法,,

但都好正!!!

[qxTHIEFxp]

但是原唱是许美静啊，我觉得两个都好听啦。不同的唱法嘛

[mosiang619]

我就觉得比原唱的好听

没那么沉闷

[RobinCher]

@mosiang619 lol. i can't believe you just said that. Well to each's taste.

To me, this is terrible.

[edwardpong]

你能唱得有他一半那么好就说你厉害，否则你就只是粉肠里面的屎

[D0516S]

tank's version better,R&B version...nice

[xiaobaobei92]

he is taiwan ...!

mavis hee is mostly sing the song slow but tank sing is rnb both of nice....

realli love it!

[yeelin1]

很棒啊

[rawr018]

i actually like both versions.

[Cutejack12345]

很好听啦。还是Tank唱得较好听

[teoyk1989]

Mavis Hee...

[mapgi]

没想到这首歌可以唱出不同的心情

[IMusicFanatic]

He not as good as Mavis Hee lol

[wimg17]

nice

[tabbieurshawty]

nope,not a singaporean~

[ivickii]

is he from taiwan or singapore ?

I<3THISSONG. :D

[nameless954]

我還是覺得許美靜唱的比較好聽。因為這首歌是悲傷的，但換成很像­嘻哈的那種。這樣的話就沒feel了。

[cmajorful]

100% 同意~~~

[sad74]

@nameless954

现代的歌手已经没有从前歌手的那种好听的feel了。现代所谓的­好听只是表面上的好听，已经没有深度了。

找好歌真的好难啊。

[SuperLee1963]

@sad74

雖然我覺得好聽

但這倒是沒錯

沒甚麼深度



[Boss10jqka]

@nameless954 不是嘻哈喔 這種叫R&B 不過這兩種的節奏都很像

[lanceyang0315]

老歌新唱8错啊~

[andrew567567]

if ur reading this and bored Y

[dgftytxc]

好聽!節奏很不錯!

[ramdomvideoreo]

i like this version of the song!! :DD

tank rocks man :DDDDDDDDDDDDDDD

[ltfung]

唱得比較輕挑, 歌技雖然不錯, 但不能理解.許美靜是最好的版本. : )

[ltfung]

對不起, 收返對上的評句, 聽真的還是不錯的!

[idiotku]

good job by tank..

[tabbieurshawty]

its funny how this small little singapore work is being used around the world,in many different versions,yet,people used to say ,that singpore can't make music,this proved them wrong!

[antigone21]

everyone always favors the original... i've never heard the original but i still like this song.

[styluster]

the original by xu mei zhen is still the best...this is bs..

[lennoxchan]

this is a beautiful song. Somehow I like Mavis version only. Tank's did not really had the song's mood.

This is a happy + Sad song.

城裡的月光把夢照亮 請溫暖他心房

看透了人間聚散 " 能不能多點快樂片段 " !!

若有一天能重逢 讓幸福撒滿整個夜晚 <=== so sad

[singuann]

So do you mean 若有一天能重逢 讓幸福撒滿整個夜晚

means singapore needs more happiness at nighttime?

[yutyeesarm]

taiwan

[kenji4560]

i prefer the original

[micuty213]

can any one pls tell me tank is from which country?thank u.

[slyiscool]

A very nice song

but it is better in the classic versoin

[justwatchitnowok]

i think if he combines elements of the original and the remixed version, it would be better..this version seems like he is trying so hard to make a difference

[DavidTaoTellMe333]

Love it both! Mavis and Tank de.

[j222742305]

.... David Tao did not invent R&B

[brownbatman]

its true...but thats cause david tao is his idol

[anyouqirocks]

both this and the original version are awesome!

[Redtide]

I try to be open to different way of intepreting the song but I feel that Tank's version kind of lost that nostalgia and old time feel of the song..I think Mavis interpret the song better... Mavis really make you feel the mood of the song

[damaeimi]

I like both. They all sing well with their own characteristics.

[krabby90]

yikes

i prefer the original version

[zian9]

LOVE IT!

[cibaipukinaruto]

like it!!

[a49ner]

韓劇-真的真的喜歡你片頭曲

[wickaflame05]

TANK is such a talented singer!

[sawguan]

nice song