@fastasthewind3 thats why he performed with elton john. he would only perform if elton john it with him. there was alot of controversy about him being a homo fobe. it was basically to show he wasn't a homofobe.
@fastasthewind3 no, I don't think he is... I think theres a differance between not liking, or not agreeing with homosexuality (I don't) and Being afraid of one. if he was a real homofobe, he wouldn't have hugged elton infront of millions of people. he did it to show everyone that he's not afraid of them, just doesn't like them. big differance.
@LyricBoy12 i agree he did tht to, like u said "show everyone that he's not afraid of them", even so- he is a homofobe, he only did tht to make ppl think it
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger niggnigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo hahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
who cares if elton john is gay... He makes great music.. Theres no reason to judge him just for his sexual orientation. Judge him on his work. And I have to say his work is pretty damn good.
gay you call this gay what the !@#$ is wrong with you man i hate rap man but this song is amazing screw you man you dont know what music really is man
does it matter if u are gay or not? really? elton john and eminem what better match? people get off the gay crap... we got bigger worries... and the song told a story thats so true....
no you factless maggots elton jhon only did this cuz the gay community got angry over this song *which rock btw* and criied out and asked eminem not to sing like that.
this is awsome, anyone including producers and music artists have mad appreciation for Elton john, mad talent this is pure music right here, Elton john and Eminem are legends in different ways.
@youtobe731 you realize thats right realize is spelled realiZe with a Z not S you realize that its assholes like you that rain on parades people all know the facts it just makes it feel alot more better to say R.I.P maybe they feel it is more respectful to do so whatever makes them comfortable
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This song is based off what really happened. Eminem had a huge fan who commited suicide who had a girlfriend and everything. Stan is the fan. = D hope this helps.
ofc this didn't really happen... are ya'll people crazy? why do you think the character's name is STAN u moron?it's the name that rhymes best with FAN.
And yes ofc he had a girlfriend and everything...u know, the girl in the vid is actually his real girlfriend.Yep xD
Ahhahahahaha I can't believe someone would think this happened 4 real.
dude your obviously as "racist" as i am because your using a derogatory term for someone who is mentally disabled. picking on mentally or physically disabled people is the lowest you can get...
@bywaterrr Stan is a fictional charector Eminem made up in his music to talk about how "insane" it is about how many people adore him. The name stan comes from the two words, "stalker" and "fan" which together he made stan. I hope that helps.
you realize thats right realize i spelled realiZe with a Z not S you realize that its assholes like you that rain on parades people all know the facts it just makes it feel alot more better to say R.I.P maybe they feel it is more respectful to do that whatever makes them comfortable
This was one of the greatest things ever!!!!That performance was amazing!Elton did a great job with the piano.He helped Em a lot with the drugs, that's why Em appreciates him so much...and @ the idiots below who were arguing about who's the greatest rapper blah, blah...I'm sorry but Eminem's the best rapper ALIVE and ya'll know it.He could lyrically murder anybody, like he did w/ Jay.
@nospace44 u obv dont no wtf your talkin bout, eminem is good but tupac shakur was and always will be the king of rap ask anyone who nows anything bout rap..................., nuff said
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Lol. This is silly. Dido makes it sound cold and eery and dark. Elton makes it sound silly. haha his voice makes me laugh. And the way he sings the words. And the piano makes it funny upbeat piano with sad lyrics. this is just soo sillllyy
No, I don't agree. In my opinion, the piano in ht ebackground doesn't fit into the song, furthermore the sotry was the important thing that lead me t this song, but when Elton sings it's no more authentic.
In comparison with the other songs I'd say that Dido's better in this song, but Elton together with 2Pac in "Ghetto Gospel" is fantastic.
i like this version too, but the tempo is up beat and elton's voice is a little too up beat, this song fits better with dido's voice, it just sounds cold and distant, plus it sounds odd without the rain in the background, i have a feeling if this was the original it wouldnt have been as big
if eminem was homophobic im sure he wouldn't do a song with gay artist elton jhon if you take some of eminems songs seriously you should not listen to him he does comedy rap/hip hop
I hate rap but this one Video I like ;)
1Darkshow 1 year ago
elton jhon says picture like a beast
wezzy535 1 year ago
First 20 seconds are awesome.
9906197439 1 year ago
i rly dnt understnd this he's da biggest homo-phob
fastasthewind3 1 year ago
@fastasthewind3 thats why he performed with elton john. he would only perform if elton john it with him. there was alot of controversy about him being a homo fobe. it was basically to show he wasn't a homofobe.
LyricBoy12 1 year ago
@LyricBoy12 but he is
fastasthewind3 1 year ago
@fastasthewind3 no, I don't think he is... I think theres a differance between not liking, or not agreeing with homosexuality (I don't) and Being afraid of one. if he was a real homofobe, he wouldn't have hugged elton infront of millions of people. he did it to show everyone that he's not afraid of them, just doesn't like them. big differance.
LyricBoy12 1 year ago
@LyricBoy12 i agree he did tht to, like u said "show everyone that he's not afraid of them", even so- he is a homofobe, he only did tht to make ppl think it
fastasthewind3 1 year ago
Comment removed
fastasthewind3 1 year ago
@fastasthewind3 naa hes not some west coast gang said that and he did this to show he aint a homophobic thats why he did this with elton john
mattitudev1hardy 1 year ago
yeah. ive been stun. with this one....
soulreav21 1 year ago
EEEEEEEEE
EEE
EEE
EEE
EEEEEEEEE
EE
EE
EEEEEEEEE
MEXICO CITY
udiazcapo 1 year ago
Elton John owns this track now he's on it. It's probably why they conspired and got Dido in the spotlight.
ForgeOfIntelligence 1 year ago
This version is much better than the one whit Dido, love it! Eminem is the best.
xnathalajjx 1 year ago 2
best remix
kingjoseph99 1 year ago
this is horrible
elton john's shit
309502854 1 year ago
elton john made dis song
JJMK369 1 year ago
what alburm is this song on with elton jon not dildo
mikewhite7361 1 year ago
@mikewhite7361 lol dildo
dfury666 1 year ago
i asked myself if the story is true ..
does anybody know ?
TEDDiLii 1 year ago
@TEDDiLii Its not true. :)
KungenBaz 1 year ago
2:43
TheEric102 1 year ago
Die melodie ist Besser wie die alte. Doch Dido sollte den Refrain singen aber Trotzdem 5 * oder besser gesagt den Daumen hoch =)
BlackAngel18888 1 year ago
EMINEM IS THE BEST!!! THE KING OF RAP!!!
EminemChannelVideo 1 year ago 3
I like it more with dido....
Lorenaschatj 1 year ago
Just Amazing ... Nothing Else to Say...
AlexDeDevil 1 year ago
thats good
Marcel651997 1 year ago
the instrumental is to repitive, but its a good song
loverboi161 1 year ago
Piano Makes It A Tad More Epic
BlackStarZ7 1 year ago 3
@BlackStarZ7 Almost as much as your every word Capping makes your comment ;)
guylfe 1 year ago
Way to take a good song and turn it to complete and utter faggotry, thanks em
networkoperationscen 1 year ago
:'( i know all the words to 16 of eminems song this is one of dem
dalekpat 1 year ago
@dalekpat omg, let me worship u like a god.
do u think anyone care about u knowing the lyrics dumbass?
hermansen5 1 year ago 2
I love the first 20 seconds of this video. The piano take me to another world!
9906197439 1 year ago
best song ever Em and Elton the best ever
vinniedawg 1 year ago
how can't u like any eminem songs
mricksgers 1 year ago
with elton john. this song is the best.
R636603C 1 year ago
Must be fucked up to know that someone killed himself/his girlfriend/unborn child because you didn't get his messages in time...
CharlieJulietEcho 1 year ago
I LOVE THIS SONG <3
BielEntertainment 1 year ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger niggnigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger nigger homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo homo hahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
youcrackers 1 year ago
friggin song is gonna make me cryy :'(
iluvhimmx3 1 year ago
omg i like this song but elton john just makes this song the best !!!! love this song
nib8law 1 year ago
awesome song..... forever
Superkingbong 1 year ago
I loved the original, but this is immense.
The piano, and elton's chorus bring out the best of it.
Eminem's lyrics are amazing, it tells a story, but not like any other.
Love eminem, and i gained a lot of respect for Elton aswell through this song, however his music is not my type, but this definitely is.
510Kirky 1 year ago 2
this is so good
unleashyourfooki 1 year ago
who cares if elton john is gay... He makes great music.. Theres no reason to judge him just for his sexual orientation. Judge him on his work. And I have to say his work is pretty damn good.
pimpnaastyband 1 year ago 3
thi song is so sad,beautiful and cool at the same time<3
Joanna2Jo 1 year ago 3
this song is so sad
anisaDarkAngel 1 year ago
TALK ABOUT G.A.Y.
poundsthepinkalot 1 year ago
gay you call this gay what the !@#$ is wrong with you man i hate rap man but this song is amazing screw you man you dont know what music really is man
slash6121 1 year ago
does it matter if u are gay or not? really? elton john and eminem what better match? people get off the gay crap... we got bigger worries... and the song told a story thats so true....
malachite141 1 year ago
no you factless maggots elton jhon only did this cuz the gay community got angry over this song *which rock btw* and criied out and asked eminem not to sing like that.
TheFramer38 1 year ago
I like it better with dido :}}
lilnip67 1 year ago
genial
Mutekiable 1 year ago 4
this is awsome, anyone including producers and music artists have mad appreciation for Elton john, mad talent this is pure music right here, Elton john and Eminem are legends in different ways.
SocalGT02 1 year ago 46
@SocalGT02 Amen to that. :]
NEGAtivism2 1 year ago
Just goes to show... anyone can mix with anyone when they get past themselves.
RSVJosephV 1 year ago 2
Eminem + Elton John?!
I thought Eminem was a homophobe o.O
HisPrincessKittykat 2 years ago 3
Elton is helping him out with his addictions, they hit it off after the '01 grammies. Rare duo though, I agree.
zuperxtreme 2 years ago 30
he was criticized by the Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation
so he responded by performing with elton john...who is openly gay
JtotheP123 1 year ago
O_o Elton John is openly gay?!
Banjogoose 1 year ago
@Banjogoose yea, for awhile
JtotheP123 1 year ago
he was
CelebratePrideLatino 1 year ago
he is. a bit confusing....
gellerstudent 1 year ago
He second biggest thing about the songs is that he's "only clownin" with a lot of the stuff he sings.
If you actually thought he was even half series with basically anything he says... haha oh wow.
DeathlyCrunch 1 year ago 2
best grammy moment
jcurt7324 2 years ago
just to clarify english spell realise with an s
americans spell it with a z, i'd personally go with the english cause its our language;);) but you know whatever...
JokerGenocide 2 years ago 4
Hey, its like American "Theater" is "Theatre" in the UK
dangerdantheone 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
no it's with a z
skatmanbb 2 years ago
@vodkachuckles no it's with a z
skatmanbb 2 years ago
@youtobe731 you realize thats right realize is spelled realiZe with a Z not S you realize that its assholes like you that rain on parades people all know the facts it just makes it feel alot more better to say R.I.P maybe they feel it is more respectful to do so whatever makes them comfortable
skatmanbb 2 years ago
realise is spelt with a "s"...
salvational 2 years ago
who is Stan? Someone can tell me? plz ;)
Bywaterrr 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This song is based off what really happened. Eminem had a huge fan who commited suicide who had a girlfriend and everything. Stan is the fan. = D hope this helps.
Emmercedes 2 years ago
@Emmercedes big up for you ;) thanx!
Bywaterrr 2 years ago
hahahha...are u serious???
LMAO
omg...hahahahaha
u gotta be kidding me??
ofc this didn't really happen... are ya'll people crazy? why do you think the character's name is STAN u moron?it's the name that rhymes best with FAN.
And yes ofc he had a girlfriend and everything...u know, the girl in the vid is actually his real girlfriend.Yep xD
Ahhahahahaha I can't believe someone would think this happened 4 real.
You people truly amaze me...xD
MaliceInDisneyland 2 years ago
Well; you made us all look like fools didn't you "MaliceinDisneyland".
Dimera09 2 years ago
No, you actually did that yourselves.
MaliceInDisneyland 2 years ago
the girl in the video is a British singer songwriter called Dido, idiot americans
benj8706 2 years ago
wahaha...it was a FCKN SARCASM you retard...I'm not american.People who have these stereotypes about america like you are racist retards.
and ofc I know who dido is.God, you're so stupid.Go kill yourself.
MaliceInDisneyland 2 years ago
dude your obviously as "racist" as i am because your using a derogatory term for someone who is mentally disabled. picking on mentally or physically disabled people is the lowest you can get...
benj8706 2 years ago
Get off me moron, you're annoying.
I didn't use the word retard in that context and I'm not a ''dude''.
Get a LIFE and a sense of humor.
MaliceInDisneyland 2 years ago
lol mentally disabled = a race?
gellerstudent 1 year ago
Stan is also what a obbsessed super is called. It's a collaboration of "stalker" and "fan"
Jasonisevil784 2 years ago
*super fan
Jasonisevil784 2 years ago
yep, exactly... ;)
MaliceInDisneyland 2 years ago
@bywaterrr Stan is a fictional charector Eminem made up in his music to talk about how "insane" it is about how many people adore him. The name stan comes from the two words, "stalker" and "fan" which together he made stan. I hope that helps.
sniper947 2 years ago 2
They can say what they want about Elton John, I love his voice . You can't take away his talent.
cupid4040 2 years ago
such a sad story... R.I.P. Stan
FreakinKoolMedia 2 years ago 4
you realise its fictional right?
youtobe731 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you realize thats right realize i spelled realiZe with a Z not S you realize that its assholes like you that rain on parades people all know the facts it just makes it feel alot more better to say R.I.P maybe they feel it is more respectful to do that whatever makes them comfortable
skatmanbb 2 years ago
i agree it is sad even though it's fake i agree
skatmanbb 2 years ago
was das ned dido mit der er das gesungen hat :D?
TheCeroxGaming 2 years ago
du bist zu stylerisch um das zu wissen :D DE hat meistens echt kp was in america ab geht
embimaru 2 years ago
fantastic
cotenbalive 2 years ago
if yall like this shit and are feelin sir elton.. check ghetto gospal with elton and pac. fire.
criscio41 2 years ago 3
@criscio41 Elton John is a true G in the hip-hop community.
FlamingDZCorp 2 years ago
Comment removed
Dennislool 2 years ago
man du weisst nichtmal wie die "frau" heisst...
beschwer dich nich wenn du keine ahnung hast...
Gottwerk666 2 years ago
Comment removed
Dennislool 2 years ago
was war des für n schlechter konter xD
des war dido und zwar der refrain von dem lied "thank you" ;)
Gottwerk666 2 years ago
loads better than didos version (y)
iXxHuNtSyxXi 2 years ago
elton john version is alot better
GangsterRon 2 years ago 2
elton john have a sick voice, whoa
tr4ckz 2 years ago
Elton John helped him through his alcohol addiction and what not, they're friends.
Xishin 2 years ago 3
cool song
MJ10490 2 years ago
@Crexeer
Genau.
HerrFrelser 2 years ago
This was one of the greatest things ever!!!!That performance was amazing!Elton did a great job with the piano.He helped Em a lot with the drugs, that's why Em appreciates him so much...and @ the idiots below who were arguing about who's the greatest rapper blah, blah...I'm sorry but Eminem's the best rapper ALIVE and ya'll know it.He could lyrically murder anybody, like he did w/ Jay.
I do love pac but come on, get real.
MaliceInDisneyland 2 years ago 5
ya first name isnt stan is it?
grownman1991 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Tupac is horrible............that's why they killed him
xxjohnnyxx89 2 years ago
I laughed.
ThatAlastairGuy 2 years ago
Fuck You Skum Bag I hope YOU ARE SODIMIZED YOU FUCKING ASSHOLE
Tupac Was the best ever SO Eat a fucking dick
MrCameronAdams 2 years ago 2
gudd song(-__-)
gossip1993 2 years ago
this actually happened to eminem so he decided to write about it
johnnywilko2003 2 years ago
not true johnnywilko2003. he specifically sed it aint real
BASSASP 2 years ago
@BASSASP
Wasn't there something about this song inspiring someone to whacking themselves or some-m? Dunno. I think it's a rumor, but ya never know.
HerrFrelser 2 years ago
Kick ass song. All you haters go back to listening to barney mofos.
wd0 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sounds like shit, dont even try to make his music sound like that, he aint elton john, he's a rapper.
misio66661 2 years ago
Pretty darn good job piecing them together, man.
I liked the song ever since I first heard it in 99. I found this version pretty cool too.
MoonshadowRogue 2 years ago 4
Thank you! :)
Halvard1992 2 years ago
wht is he talking about
BluePolcadots 2 years ago
its pretty obvious...
wd0 2 years ago
good song :-))
TechnoTerorist23 2 years ago
i think it would be funny if elton john took the girls place haha great song though
wendiburd420 2 years ago
i like this version so much more elton johns sick
good job puttin this shit together
mrcheesetaco 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
IMO I do not like this version, Dido is way much better =D
leondmcdantere4 2 years ago
this song is soo deep, tunee tho loving it :)
comdoms07 2 years ago 4
This song has plenty of meaning.
Yes Tupac is amazing.
But this song has alot of freaking meaning.
Its about how addicted people are to stars.
And will do anything just to be like them. Just to see them.
Like girls trying to be skinny like the supermodels. And they go aneroxic. So open up your mouth before you speak Mr Jammyman. The End.
MicPeePants 2 years ago
like this song has no meaning. racist douche. learn how to spell
OmgAaeva 2 years ago
i hate to admit it but mrjammyman is rite in the respekt that tupac shakur is the greatest rapper of all time
davpilkie 2 years ago 3
how is he racist??????
davpilkie 2 years ago
wtf king of rap wt are u talking about most of eminems raps are meaningles !!!!! tupac shakur ii the king least his raps have meaning
MrJammyman 2 years ago
dunno nothin bout shady.....go get some tunes and ull see his tunes are full of meanings...
ChrisBackster 2 years ago
The ultimate M classic, and even better with Elton.
ryannstockman 2 years ago
This Song Is Simply One Of Em's Best Work Some Good Shyt. Better With Elton John.
StatusLalo 2 years ago
i love old eminem
gorfy13 2 years ago 5
Em - IS and WILL ALWAYS BE King of Rap..
GameXGod 2 years ago 3
@GameXGod tupac amaru shakur was and always will be the king of rap ems not in his legue the only 1 close was biggie smalls................
davpilkie 2 years ago
Excellent :o
TRKLoLaD 2 years ago 6
eminem is the king of rap. nuff said...
nospace44 2 years ago 6
@nospace44 u obv dont no wtf your talkin bout, eminem is good but tupac shakur was and always will be the king of rap ask anyone who nows anything bout rap..................., nuff said
davpilkie 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
omg elton john sounds so fucking terrible
Damnshid 2 years ago
are u fukin stupid
jisung2009 2 years ago 2
geile version
stleodererste 2 years ago 2
the piano ♥
skatejoskate 2 years ago 4
Eminem has severeley fucked up now but he truely belongs in the Hall of FAme!
esmaili818 2 years ago 6
bold fool
NilouLuvsJD 2 years ago
it is soo beautiful i love this song !!
Freakylove94 2 years ago
got this on ipod and i got curtain call just to get this song, em come to austraila
talldylan 2 years ago
the piano is alittle loud, other then that its pretty good
Hitsulikeapunch 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Lol. This is silly. Dido makes it sound cold and eery and dark. Elton makes it sound silly. haha his voice makes me laugh. And the way he sings the words. And the piano makes it funny upbeat piano with sad lyrics. this is just soo sillllyy
MagicCowWtf 2 years ago
quiet fool !!
MrBuckman1990 2 years ago 3
i think this version is much better
tourneagauche 2 years ago 10
ya Elton John makes it waaaaaaaaay better
Residentevil2nut 2 years ago 5
No, I don't agree. In my opinion, the piano in ht ebackground doesn't fit into the song, furthermore the sotry was the important thing that lead me t this song, but when Elton sings it's no more authentic.
In comparison with the other songs I'd say that Dido's better in this song, but Elton together with 2Pac in "Ghetto Gospel" is fantastic.
IGardenSpellsI 2 years ago
This is so much better with Elton John.He's the secret member of D12:)
handsomeguy30 2 years ago 3
this is live version from where EM brought Elton john !!
Singh778 2 years ago
i like this version too, but the tempo is up beat and elton's voice is a little too up beat, this song fits better with dido's voice, it just sounds cold and distant, plus it sounds odd without the rain in the background, i have a feeling if this was the original it wouldnt have been as big
sloppdizzle 2 years ago
anyone know where I can get the instrumental to this with Elton John singing in the background?
linkoninja 2 years ago
if eminem was homophobic im sure he wouldn't do a song with gay artist elton jhon if you take some of eminems songs seriously you should not listen to him he does comedy rap/hip hop
Zukoblast36 2 years ago 4
so your saying this is comedy? or hailies song or lose yourself?
ngame1994 2 years ago
this is better then da old 1 XD
j2dapbloop 2 years ago
the version with elton john is much better
o0PlayboyBastard0o 2 years ago 2
i like the elton john version 2
Jared31AKABigpopie 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
the version with dido is better
YouJustGotOwned123 2 years ago
Much better than the original.
v3nuzbeats 2 years ago 3
Beautiful!:)♥
Aggrofanatikahhh 2 years ago 4
segayno..
zohebnick001 2 years ago 3
yea elton john made this song better i didnt like the girl singing as much
Ihateopp 2 years ago 3
When did Elton become a member of eminem´s posse?
reynzi 2 years ago 2
ages, he's part of D12 :L
007jack700 2 years ago 3
he's the secret member of D12 ;)
1993gandy 2 years ago 3
wow!!!!
RIA310 2 years ago 2
Perfect song...i like it...
brko90 2 years ago 4
absolutely better with Elton. Love this song.
muthrukdarl 2 years ago 4
Yes!
muthrukdarl 2 years ago 3
paddy des is des beste lied was es gibt^^
uuuund herz natürlich...
000franki000 2 years ago
Eminem and Elton together ...= This is ..
THE BEST !!!
Langbeinkater 2 years ago
not best but really nice ;]
Sarrgil28 2 years ago
piano is so fkn deep sounds sick i wish i could find this versions instrumental
PANESAR101494 2 years ago