Je déteste comparer les chanteuses. Elles ont des vois tellement différentes.
Varnay fut magnifique, Nilsson aussi, mais Behrens aussi chacune dans son style.. Comparer n'est que paroles oiseuses.. Ecoutons.. Et savourons.. Laissons nous aller à la musique.
Il faut des fois débrancher le cerveau pour laisser parler le couer.
I consider Astrid Varnay the PERFECT Brunhilde; eventhough I do love Birgit Nilsson whose success overshadowed Varnay; Nilsson's voice was like a laser and she had rock solid technique; but Varnay puts emotion and depth into her singing & gets into character. Varnay's blessed with a great technique as well; it's sad she was so underrated. She is brilliant, absolutely brilliant and she moves you to tears
C'est LA Brunnhilde. Il faut savoir que en 56, non seulement elle a fait le rôle écrasant de Brunnhilde dans le Crépuscule, mais elle y a fait aussi une norne (qui aurait dû être chantée par Mödl mais elle était "malade").
Nobody quite gets into the psychology of this scene as do Varnay and Knappertrsbusch, who understood Wagner as few others did. Listen to the way Varnay sings "Kein andrer!" as one of many such examples, and Kna's superb tempi and grasp of the long line.
There are a tiny elite number of Bruennhildes and/or conductors in this scene who may possibly surpass individually what we hear in this upload. But I've often felt that, as a whole, this entire Ring cycle from '56, with Kna and Varnay in their element and Windgassen, Neidlinger and some others at their best, may be the most uniformly satisfying one available. So thanks for letting us hear these closing moments from a special perf. May we look forward to the scene's second half being up soon?
I met her in Munich around 1971 when she was singing Herodias....lovely lady and superb Wagner soprano.
rumpwrestler 1 year ago
Beautiful!
Benjaminwolf 1 year ago
La Brunhilde, for sure. I love her almost mezzo-like dark voice and wonderful, wonderful character interpretation.
Arashi110 1 year ago
Flagstad, Varnay and Nilsson are my all time favorite Brünnhilde's.
Johnny1206 1 year ago
Je déteste comparer les chanteuses. Elles ont des vois tellement différentes.
Varnay fut magnifique, Nilsson aussi, mais Behrens aussi chacune dans son style.. Comparer n'est que paroles oiseuses.. Ecoutons.. Et savourons.. Laissons nous aller à la musique.
Il faut des fois débrancher le cerveau pour laisser parler le couer.
isabelle070209 1 year ago
I can almost smell the diesel from the T-34`s...They must not take Pankow from me!!
Kharkovkid 1 year ago
I consider Astrid Varnay the PERFECT Brunhilde; eventhough I do love Birgit Nilsson whose success overshadowed Varnay; Nilsson's voice was like a laser and she had rock solid technique; but Varnay puts emotion and depth into her singing & gets into character. Varnay's blessed with a great technique as well; it's sad she was so underrated. She is brilliant, absolutely brilliant and she moves you to tears
MastersoftheOpera 1 year ago 5
Comment removed
branko1b 2 years ago
This actually IS the immolation scene.
SDCmorg 2 years ago
Comment removed
branko1b 2 years ago
lol...yes it is...lol
jmahlon 1 year ago
To my opinion Varnay is more "human" than Nilsson ! She is more involved in her Brünhilde than Nilsson
motardbear15 2 years ago
How right you are! The Brunnhilde to end all Brunnhildes! That lucious ever so expressive sound. But where's the end?!
sorobji 2 years ago 2
Ya' gotta buy the recording to get the rest of it, bro. ;o) It's worth it.
SDCmorg 2 years ago
@sorobji
fastborzoi 9 months ago
This sounds so right, easy and beautifull. And the voice - Flagstad and Nilsson melted together.
dermotafan 2 years ago 4
C'est LA Brunnhilde. Il faut savoir que en 56, non seulement elle a fait le rôle écrasant de Brunnhilde dans le Crépuscule, mais elle y a fait aussi une norne (qui aurait dû être chantée par Mödl mais elle était "malade").
isabelle070209 2 years ago 3
Nobody quite gets into the psychology of this scene as do Varnay and Knappertrsbusch, who understood Wagner as few others did. Listen to the way Varnay sings "Kein andrer!" as one of many such examples, and Kna's superb tempi and grasp of the long line.
billyguns2 2 years ago 2
what a performance, Knappertsbusch and Varnay you are right the tempii are what I was searching
egymagyar1111111 2 years ago
excelente!!
58wotan 2 years ago
A magical moment in music history. There are no more artists as Varnay, old Kna, Wagner... alas
HHenzen 2 years ago 3
Great!
LeonoraPasiniani 2 years ago 2
AWESOME!!!!
great singer, marvelous technique, a breath taking interpretation!!!
LaBartoli 2 years ago 4
There are a tiny elite number of Bruennhildes and/or conductors in this scene who may possibly surpass individually what we hear in this upload. But I've often felt that, as a whole, this entire Ring cycle from '56, with Kna and Varnay in their element and Windgassen, Neidlinger and some others at their best, may be the most uniformly satisfying one available. So thanks for letting us hear these closing moments from a special perf. May we look forward to the scene's second half being up soon?
grig035 2 years ago
So wonderful, so great and dateless !
Astrid Varney is the incarnation of Brühnhilde and
"KNA" was simply one of best Wagner conductors
ever, in the same line with Furtwängler.
Thank you for the video
-Michael
mickiandalusia 3 years ago 2
AWESOME!
lilleeWAfot 3 years ago 2
Astrid is la creme the la creme!!!
Federicopera 3 years ago 7
La crème de la crème.
isabelle070209 2 years ago 2
Astrid Varnay IS BRUNHILDE...THERE IS A PERFECTION TO THIS AND SHE SINGS THE HECK OUT OF IT..
AmericanEvita 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
F A N T A S T I C !!!!
ERIKEPAIOS 3 years ago 4
When it comes to the word "Heil," Gotterdammerung is the best.
Johnabraytis 3 years ago 2
Not the complete ease and extraordinary power found in Kirsten Flagstad's voice, but nevertheless one of the very best Brünnhildes on record.
operamagnus 3 years ago
Th is one of the two most interesting wagnerian singers of modern times. The other one is Birgit Nilsson.
birgitnilsson 3 years ago 8
pure magic
Markko122L 3 years ago 4