Hilary Duff - Who's that Girl [Lyrics on screen]

[TheShar24]

This is a sad [P.s. MAIN CHARACTER: GIRL]..Everyday, a girl and boy would fall in love with eachother. Both of them feel like they've been together and will always be together FOREVER! Just when things were bright and sunny, one day the girl sees her bf cheating on her... Her heart felt icy The next day he breaks up with the girl. Her heart breaks and it seems like FOREVER for it to heal. :( Now, in this present-day, more boys are breaking girls' hearts like it's normal. Thumbs up if you agree!

[Faryen5068]

i love that song it maks me so sad

[loladrienne]

This is a different version than the one on her original album. it was much more upbeat. this almost sounds like the acustic version. Still nice though.

[princessloverofemo]

this song sucks

[DemonLover930]

OMG!Her voice changed!I haven't listened to her sing in years & I could barely know that she sang it!

[missbrookiecookie87]

EEP TOP COMMENT <3 <3 <3

[bubblepopper202]

i remember when i was little i thought it was "its not day, its not night" haha

Love u hilary!!<3

[StarDance87]

@bubblepopper202 Yeah me too, isn't it? I've seen lyric videos where it says so, I thought this one was wrong...

[lawandordersvurocks2]

I remember going to every one of her concerts since I was six. Hilary Duff will always have a place in my heart. She was my first idol. <3

[o0xst]

I LIEK 2 GO 2 THA MALL N C IF KEWL SONGS R PLAYING LOTS OF TIMES THIS 1 IS AND I SHOP SHOP SHOP TILL I DROP LOL LOL LOL

[sabrinaparadise]

I was sooo in love with Hilary Duff when I was younger. I was in like second or third grade when she became my idol and I listened to her all the way up to about...6th grade? lol anyways I am in 11th grade now haha. This makes me think of the past sooo much. I had my walls COVERED in Hilary Duff posters.

[dogloverr67]

@sabrinaparadise SAME HERE!!! I STILL LOVE HER!! <33 AHHH

[StarDance87]

@sabrinaparadise My wall still has a Hilary Duff poster up and I'm 24!

[konathepusspuss]

I don't have a ex, im in a relationship i love him so much, This is what im gonna sing to him if he finds someone else

<3

[grandmasprayer]

this song reminds me about my life changing from moving from the country to the city, half the time I don't even know who I am anymore. I changed too fast. I wanna go back

[Awe50meRand0mCh1ck]

thumbs up if dis song reminds u of urr ex and the bitch he is dating!!!he doent deserve me anyways!!!

[animadicct123]

This song is so sad but it's so good I can't stop listening to it

[zennachua]

i love it

[Pokemaniac4Ash]

I hav a crush on someone at my school.he is funny

[MrCHARLESFH]

this song is my favorite

[kirthicsk]

i love this song!!!!!!!!

<3........u hilary!

[aussiealex12]

hey can you please tell me what font that is you used? :)

[slayer99ize]

I love how people are giving advice to a person who commented ove a year ago lol

[crazygirlmaddy]

i love this song

[maqierodriquez]

luv thisz sonq

reminds me of mehhh n'd himmm!!!

but itsz sad memories:((

wenn i see himm i think of tht sonq fo' likinq thisz other qurl !:'(

ahhhhh

[ILOVEWICKED97]

@maqierodriquez i think you spelt love wrong. and this. and song. and me. and him. and it's. and when. and him again. and that. and song. and for. and liking. and this. and girl.

nice typing. :p

[lizzybombom]

awwh a beautiful song x

[martaaa027]

She singing about my life! Also I would like to start living the way he wants! BE yourself! And by the way-I love the voice of Hilary ...

[0rca0cean]

lovet 5/5

[Roxy41678]

my fave song!!!!! HElped me go through alot.... There was a stage in my life tht i was in a group tht had a bad influence on me nd my oda friends got worried so they played me this song nd i started wonderin maybe this song has more thn 1 meanin.........It could be about sum1 who u r not nd tryin 2 be sum1 else or about sum1 else interferin in ur life

[Roxy41678]

This song helped me get through all my breakups nd whn i liked my bff's brother nd he liked me but we were to scared to go out cause of my bff nd thn the one nite we wen 2 a restaurant nd i heard him tell the oda girl tht was there 2 tht he loved her.............

[BiblioLuichai]

Hilary's songs have a meaning to it...thats the best thing about them!

[shainababy2000]

I love listening to this song cause it totally speaks to my aunt. My aunt has be married for 8 years and realized that for 3 years her husband has been cheating on her and now he wants a divorce so he can marry his new girlfriend. I love you aunt Nina... Be strong! <3

[Lucy2001ful1]

@beatlesfan8171763 just move on even though ur mad. same thing happened 2 me so i moved on and now im a straight ''a '' student, have a good bf, better BFFs, and im star singer in the school. so move on as i always say, things happen for a reason!

i <3 u guys

-zoey

[Lucy2001ful1]

@beatlesfan8171763 just move on even though ur mad. same thing happened 2 me so i moved on and now im a straight ''a '' student, have a good bf, better BFFs, and in m star singer in the school. so move on as i always say, things happen for a reason!

i <3 u guys

-zoey

[NunuInvincible829]

First time hearing this and I like it but my all time favorite Hilary duff song is "fly"

[TheNiGaHIgAFan121]

best song ever!

[LEILAELWI]

i love her songs, i listen to her all the time since i was 6.

[Riiko143]

This is my story. I went out w this guy that ive known since 2nd grade. We never really liked each other. But thn bout 4 months ago, we called a truce. That truce led 2 friendship, witch led 2 a crush then a relationship. Now im not one 2 believe in love, but is that really how ppl feel whn they r in love? like u have this thing... u like it, yet at the same time you want 2 throw it, & scream? Well he made me "love him" now hes gone. & i see him talking bout this chick. She has his heart now..

[sweetchicks211]

@beatlesfan8171763 I feel sorry for you....boys.....boys.....they can't stop dating girls even though they left a girl but they don't care.....you should do something to get back to him and your friend....I don't date......I focus to my education until after college I will date.....but whatever just date a nice guy and that cares about u sometimes that'll work to frget about him

[missbrookiecookie87]

wow! i barely knew who she was(im 11) SHES AN AMAZING SINGER! so much better than miley demi selena

[lazzyfendi]

@missbrookiecookie87 I'm 19 and you just made my feel old. LOL

[missbrookiecookie87]

@lazzyfendi sorry bout that! lol 

[xTwilightWolvesx]

@lazzyfendi my cousin is gonna be 19 and he already feels old without that comment.

[Lollypopster09]

@missbrookiecookie87 shes better than selena & miley but not demi..theyre about the same in my opinion D:

[missbrookiecookie87]

@Lollypopster09 i totally agree NOW. but i posted that like a year ago so her new album wasnt out yet :P im a total demi fan now! <3

[Lollypopster09]

@missbrookiecookie87 haha i didnt even notice the date on that comment :L♥

[missbrookiecookie87]

@Lollypopster09 it's kinda really random that people are JUST NOW commenting on it XD

[Jazzmineanime]

@missbrookiecookie87 So you're 12 now, right? My age, then. XD

[missbrookiecookie87]

@Jazzmineanime just turned 13 :D like a month ago...

[Jazzmineanime]

@missbrookiecookie87 Awesome. =D

[Nicol19687]

@missbrookiecookie87 ok that sooooooooooooo true about miley and selena but demi is amazing

[loveanime74]

@missbrookiecookie87 I'm 11 too but I think that anybody is better then them!

[vgirl98]

@missbrookiecookie87 i cant belive u hardly no her i grew up with hilary and ill be 14 in april. Hilary is amazing and always has been. she was in so many movies was lizzie mcquire she was mily cyrus' idol and insperation and is now pregnant

[gogosfreak]

this is my life my ex &i broke up a month ago and now my bestie is dating him every time i want to hang out with her ill call her and she would say "srry im busy with my new bf" my other besties think i should be happy but instead i act like it but im not i cried after i found out my bestie and ex were going out cuz i didnt want to break up but he said we have to go our own ways my friends and enimies think im being abit selfish tho im not like MY BABE XO XD but i hate her now =(

[missjenny3lla1]

@gogosfreak awwww not 2 b mean or anything i think ur bestie is rubbing her bf in ur face what a bitch but he might hurt her 2 n she might come bck like saying im srry n shit !!!

[gogosfreak]

this is my life since no one knew me much but one day i saw my bf with another girl! that dam flirt stole my whole world! now we broke up and that flirt is dating him now! DX i wanna freakin kill her btw great job with the lyrics so i faved it XD

[EmmieAndDemi]

beatlesfan8171763:

if your best friend was an actual best friend he/she wouldnt have even ever thought of dating ur ex so i dont think your selfish at all

[keziamarinachan]

i love this song so much ~

hillary as cadet kelly. LOL xD

[9jroose]

i love this song but my mom said i shuld turn it off

[sparkgem94]

@9jroose ya. my friend came over to my house and i played this song. she told me to turn it off too cos she says its depressing but i love it. i love all her songs

[Sasori1chan]

This song is awesome. awwwz, you all have such sad lives. i mean, i'm an outcast and all, but i've never lost a crush to anyone. tho i have been rejected one too many times ^^'''' Just hang in there guys! there is always someone like me, not tooo much of an outcast, that will befriend you and won't every do anything to hurt you.

[22Kissgirl]

I LOVE the song

[TheSelenagomez4lyf]

this song reminds me of the time i lik this guy but then he found another girl,n that another girl was my kindergarten BEST friend,she always lik 2 tease me around now,of course,that was wen i was in grade school but now,it's torture

[secretgirllisout]

Makes me think of this girl I hate

[3Mili33]

luv this song

[Wolfadon]

beatlesfan8171763- your friends are wrong,your bestfriend is such a bitch and your ex probably did it to make you gelous.I wouldn't let the guy get away with it

[beatlesfan8171763]

@Wolfadon but he doesnt even talk to me anymore.... :*(

[beatlesfan8171763]

@Wolfadon thx but if i was only older than i am now i could go on to a dating site instead of the STUPID school place ( my ex... leaving this year, yay! and she is all like ohhh booo hooo and im like wow.....)

[1LuvAlli00]

good videio she sings good

[Gluecksbaerchiiex3]

das video ist echt gut geworden. (: ich liebes dieses Lied.♥

[samroks3]

I used to have a shirt that said hilarys best friend lol

[pukser]

I remember I was hilarys biggest fan ever, She has amazing songs. I remeber putting her CDs in my cd player and dancing around my room and singing to this song, I didnt get it than though.

[1LuvAlli00]

@pukser i yost to do that to hehe =)

[clibob112]

beatlesfan8171763 <--- i feel lousy for you i dont think a guy you dated or your best friend should hook up, thats really lousy to be honest i dont blame you for hating him, but i would really not let him get away with that:)

[beatlesfan8171763]

clibob112- thanks, the sad thing is that they (even him!) want me to "approve" of them dating. Its a stupid world at times...

[beatlesfan8171763]

@clibob112 believe me i've tried to make him mad and sad and well all that got me was no friends

[beatlesfan8171763]

this is my life.... my ex and i broke up like a few weeks ago and now my BEST friend started dating him...... i hate her now. but all my other friends think im being selfish and should be happy for them

[DiaryOfSceneQueens]

thats sad.......

[beatlesfan8171763]

thanks :*)

[mexicanprincess13x]

@beatlesfan8171763 hellz no u shouldnt be HAPPY for ur friend and who do ur friends think they are to choose wat u should do or think?!go by wat u think its right and get new friends cuz if ur friend is dating ur ex and ur not ok with that then shes not a true friend just pretend that u dont care and start laughing or smile when they are around& shes ur BEST FRIEND?more like fake ass bf lol just get over it i know is hard and kick those ppl out of ur life.u deserve better than that everyone does

[beatlesfan8171763]

@mexicanprincess13x Well see, he doesnt even talk to me anymore like i tried and he doesnt even answer... :/ i dont talk to the girl anymore but stil i dont like her anymre. it happened to her and she was like " but but but...." and im like welcome to my world and walked off.

[pichigirl]

@beatlesfan8171763

let me guess, you don't want to hate her but you can't help it?

no one can control the way they feel, feelings aren't rational, if there's one thing i learned in this world, than it's that.

[beatlesfan8171763]

@pichigirl well yea... however, now they sorta broke up cuz he's moving and yea... but i'm just counting down the days until i can go onto a dating site. 3 more years to go.

[pichigirl]

@beatlesfan8171763

i guess i'm gonna try that to when i'm allowed to. never you til you try, right?

[beatlesfan8171763]

@pichigirl Yea but at least this one (without my parents knowing) is allowing 16 year olds and im like YAY. So i'm getting an account there the DAY i turn 16. Plus there are some HOTTT gothic guys

[pichigirl]

@beatlesfan8171763

i have to wait til i'm 18 *sigh*

[beatlesfan8171763]

@pichigirl Well..... im totally not waiting THAT long, 16 is like... ugh..... im the goth in an all cheerleader school....

[pichigirl]

@beatlesfan8171763

yea, and i'm the overweight girl in barbie-school -.-

[beatlesfan8171763]

@pichigirl Hey us outcasts have to stick together, and dont worry, someday you'll find that good guy ;)

[beatlesfan8171763]

@pichigirl Yea... i mean i'm totally doing it. Hey if i can date the popular in my school then a dating site should work :) Maybe you'll get your guy soon :)

[pichigirl]

@beatlesfan8171763

right!!

yea, h just took the wrong turn and got lost, right?

*sigh*

you too though :D

[beatlesfan8171763]

@pichigirl idk maybe... but oh well.... other fish in the sea... hope none of them eat me though....

[pichigirl]

@beatlesfan8171763 don't hold your breath though... people can't accent what's different.

[beatlesfan8171763]

@pichigirl true... but oh well... maybe one day ( near future hopefully) but yea.... holding my breathe would help with the whole depression thing though

[sparkgem94]

@beatlesfan8171763 omg im so sorry if i were you ill prolly hate her too

[makayla12ful1]

@beatlesfan8171763 wow then there not ur true friends if they tell u tht u should be happy for them SCREW THEM if ya want to add me i would be even happer

[fuckmyfeelings]

@beatlesfan8171763 i feel so sorry for you. that happened to me to. but i threatened my life for him and that still didnt go threw his mind of how much i loved him. :(

[missjenny3lla1]

@beatlesfan8171763 its normal for yu 2 be mad if ur best friend was a true friend she shouldnt go after him ur best friend seems like a backstaber srry its my opion im just tryin 2 be reasonable her

[xojustinsloverxo]

@beatlesfan8171763 my friend had the same thing happen to her everyone felt bad but if they like eachother most ppl just hadd to get over it, its better than veing cheated on. it sucks

[NeoLoverPet]

@beatlesfan8171763

Maybe you should... :/

[steeffie888]

@beatlesfan8171763 they think you're selfish? don't listen to them...it's really cruel that your ex-best friend starting dating your ex just after a few weeks you two broke up! I'll root for you, you'll find a new best friend who won't do something like that and you'll find a better boyfriend too :)

[me2lover9969]

@beatlesfan8171763 your NOT being selfish it's how you are never regrett it but if he crawls back give him a chance ok I'M NOT BEING MEAN EITHER!!!!

[candyfanatic24]

@beatlesfan8171763 you are not being sefish. maybe u could be ok with it, but its not waht ur other freinds say:)

[CrookedFruitloop]

@beatlesfan8171763 You can tell your "freinds" (no offense) that it's not selfish to be angry with someone who should have been there for you, not turned around and dated your ex. You have a right to be mad about it. She obviously isn't that loyal if she is throwing you out the window to date someone you've been with.

[MsPucksss]

@beatlesfan8171763 what a s l u t :)

[livelovecheer1997]

@beatlesfan8171763 i think your completly right you dont need to listen to them

[moxie4ever]

@beatlesfan8171763 selfish?! how are you being selfish?!?! She started dating your ex boyfriend!!! how the hell is that selfish?! no offense but that so called "best friend" of yours is a little bitch im sorry but thats what i think

[dreamwishergirl]

@beatlesfan8171763 OMG that is not right! I know that was a year ago (that you commented) but really, that is not right. I would be mad at my best friend too if she started to date my crush, ex, or anything like that.

[eamstore3]

@beatlesfan8171763 sing dont hold ur breath to him by nicole schersinger, that will teach him lolz

[Agkarina]

@beatlesfan8171763 i have the same life my best friend started to date my ex the guy i rlly loved and now im pissed off at her nd then my other friends say just forget about himm

[AmbrosioLover]

@beatlesfan8171763 OH MY GOSH THE SAME EXACT THING IS HAPPENING TO ME imma inbox you whats happening to me

[Catherinaaisonhit]

@beatlesfan8171763 Samee thing happened to me and now shes starting to talk my other bestfriends boyfriend behind her back. Shes just a scandalous hoee.

[iloveyou5554321]

@beatlesfan8171763

The same as me 

[Awe50meRand0mCh1ck]

@beatlesfan8171763 that happened 2 me yesterday!!! ii hope she dies in hellllll!!! :( she didnt steal my world she stole my universe!!!

[Sharing4you2]

@beatlesfan8171763

YOur not being selfish

Believe me if my bestfriends dated m ex i would be really mad

Its kinda mean of her for dating the guy you dated because thats just selling out your best friend so if there calling you selfish there not your real friends

[meburpzilla]

@beatlesfan8171763 there not ur real friends then

[gymasticsgirl88]

man i love this song its mii life at this point

[UzumakiMizukiChan]

My life described in a song.

Great.

[dabanz]

love this song

[1EternalHope]

such a beautiful sonq xx

[528213]

@1EternalHope i love this song to :-)

[cutieselenagomez21]

this song is awsome

[aryan952000]

My favourite song as it belongs to ma life tooooooo..............

[jboocuttie1]

i love this song