There is NO way that I would have liked this song if I were to hear it first on the album!
The live version is a MILLION TIMES BETTER than the studio version (I almost wish I would have never listened to the studio version, but I searched for it eagerly ever since I've seen this performance and others..!), it's unbelievable!
Same song, two versions- two absolutely different effects on me.
I'll keep listening to the live version on repeat.
There's something so sticky on this chorus, especially when she goes to these verses, "(All my dreams and all the lights mean) Nothin' without you"! <3
@wiixel the drum on Without You is just a bit bigger and with a syncopated loop and the piano is so muted it's almost non existent, think it's a bit disappointed compared to the live versions which are much more simple and haunting. I have sent you a message.
heard dark paradise, carmen, Lolita, lucky ones and without you. bit disappointed with the production on Lolita. lucky ones is a nice surprise v good carmen is quite dark and dramatic, lota of strings. Dark Paradise is a little heavy handed on the production again but it grew on me, am a big lana fan so think the whole album will be pleasing .
@goblinab can i ask you to send me a mail? it's not to annoy you i promis i just wanna ask you some stuff but it's not simple here on youtube! i send you a message on your youtube! thanks a lot!!!
Heard the album version of this yesterday cos I work for a digital music site so had a sneaky pre-listen of a few tracks, it's not as pretty as it is live got quite a bit of treatment on it... :( gorgeous song...
Wow! this song never fails to get me right in the gut. She really knocks it out of the park when she performs this song. This song is a beautifully sad and I love it.
Gosh, this live version almost ruined this song and killed the love I have for it...
lymnSOUL 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
lymnSOUL 2 weeks ago
This is so so beautiful
1990ccoleman 3 weeks ago
Pity, I waited for the album version so much and end up not liking it at all. It's not bad, it's just that the live version is so flawless.
Koriperse 1 month ago 2
We are nothing without you Lana ♥
IamPeter87 1 month ago
There is NO way that I would have liked this song if I were to hear it first on the album!
The live version is a MILLION TIMES BETTER than the studio version (I almost wish I would have never listened to the studio version, but I searched for it eagerly ever since I've seen this performance and others..!), it's unbelievable!
Same song, two versions- two absolutely different effects on me.
I'll keep listening to the live version on repeat.
TitanNV28Coral 1 month ago 6
get a grip dude seriously
panthelic 3 weeks ago
I really like this live version better than the studio version, it would have been one of my favourites if it had remained this way :(
mrmcmad 1 month ago 2
There's something so sticky on this chorus, especially when she goes to these verses, "(All my dreams and all the lights mean) Nothin' without you"! <3
hernandobsneto 1 month ago
But where the hell have u been able to hear this damn album? :D
JC28414 1 month ago
@wiixel *disappointing rather...woops for the typo!
goblinab 1 month ago
@wiixel the drum on Without You is just a bit bigger and with a syncopated loop and the piano is so muted it's almost non existent, think it's a bit disappointed compared to the live versions which are much more simple and haunting. I have sent you a message.
goblinab 1 month ago
heard dark paradise, carmen, Lolita, lucky ones and without you. bit disappointed with the production on Lolita. lucky ones is a nice surprise v good carmen is quite dark and dramatic, lota of strings. Dark Paradise is a little heavy handed on the production again but it grew on me, am a big lana fan so think the whole album will be pleasing .
goblinab 1 month ago
@goblinab can i ask you to send me a mail? it's not to annoy you i promis i just wanna ask you some stuff but it's not simple here on youtube! i send you a message on your youtube! thanks a lot!!!
wiixel 1 month ago
@goblinab why exactly do you say without you is not as good? are there still the same instrumental with the piano and the drum?
wiixel 1 month ago
Heard the album version of this yesterday cos I work for a digital music site so had a sneaky pre-listen of a few tracks, it's not as pretty as it is live got quite a bit of treatment on it... :( gorgeous song...
goblinab 1 month ago
@goblinab What songs have you heard? How they sound like?
bbr222 1 month ago
This song gonna be included in her new album? ='(((((((((( I love it
eduardofm87 1 month ago
BestHQ live audio version. thanks!
xOEHLALA 1 month ago
Love it <3
AngelosStratis 2 months ago
Comment removed
AngelosStratis 2 months ago
Ahhhh this is too fucking good.
1whitehorse1 3 months ago
Wow! this song never fails to get me right in the gut. She really knocks it out of the park when she performs this song. This song is a beautifully sad and I love it.
moofushu 3 months ago
Yes, you are deadly glamourous!
Funnykaplanaa 3 months ago
I love this and you are the first that uploaded this with HD! Thanks mate!
DanndyGarbage 3 months ago 2
I'm raping the replay bottom.
maturinmeridaboy 3 months ago
Officially it's "WIthout You". That's what was written on her setlist. "China Doll" was just the name given by a guy who post the first video of it.
JC28414 3 months ago 13
This is not Without You, this is called China Doll.
tnargtnarud 3 months ago