This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Those were some terrible lines that Muppet just stole from ReTarD. That "speech" is so similar to the one at the end of Bad Wolf. Sylvester McCoy is awesome though. What's with all the scathing comments about Sylvester McCoy and his tenure? The weakest story of his is like an ingenious masterpiece when compared to the incompetence of ReTarD & Muppet as well as Eccleston's & Tennant's OTT acting. Matt would be ok if he weren't made to behave so immaturely.
@bdragond Unfortunately I have seen that appalling episode, only made worse by the outcomes in the Big Bang. He just gets out using his wand again. I made a parody/reviews of most of series 5.
@Ghastly98 What makes you think that I'm not calm? Ghastly98? Talk about stupid, you're just another Youtuber who couldn't come up with an original name so stuck some random numbers on the end (or probably your birth-year). there, I at least justified calling you stupid, but there was nothing I did or said that was stupid & I was calm, so your comment was irrelevant & irreverent.
I agree completely... if McCoy had lines like this. his doctor would have gone on. he was fabulous in my opinion of the old series him, pertwee and tom baker were the best of the originals
Great! Not quite as he would've played it for real, but that end bit has some of the 7th Drs familiar menace. A great Doc and I hope he comes back for the anniversary!
Lovely bloke and he has been an exellent ambassador for the show since he left the role.
But he never had the acting talent to pull the part off. This just reminds of the nigthmare that Dr Who was during his reign. I am just grateful Sophie Aldred isn't in it aswell.
And its not a patch on Matt Smiths version of this speach.
@ffmarkm That he never had the acting talent is your opinion. He and Sophie always rose above whatever they were given in my opinion. A lot of modern Doctor Who has not been any better. It has just had better special effects technology.
@Markel1970A I'm assuming you haven't heard the majority of his speeches if you think that was the best. It was severely unimpressive, out-of-character & unoriginal. Check out Bad Wolf - it's the same dumb speech.
@ffmarkm I read somewhere that McCoy was hired because the BBC wanted to cancel the show. They aired it at the same time as Corrie on ITV, so it wouldn't pull in the viewers. He grew into the role, and I think if he was allowed another series it would have been the best one yet (with McCoy I mean).
@ffmarkm His acting talent exceeds that of Tennant's, as well as Tennant-impersonators'. If you want to be reminded of what a nightmare DW was then check out 2005-present.
Doctor Who is like a box of chocolates that reads: BEST BEFORE 2005
@redfinale - not in character for his Doctor - that wasn't McCoy up there... it was Seven :) and Seven wouldn't have shouted that... he'd have whispered it, make 'em GUESS who it is ^_^
Amazing to see how he just 'sank' back into his role as the Doctor throughout that speech... totally brilliant ^_^
The 7th Doctor really knew how to give a speech...that's why I loved his incarnation. Now if only he didnt roll his "R's" , But still he was my favorate.
@tjhornikel He had at least three great ones that I can remember. Threatening the guards to kill him on Iceworld. The dressing down of Davros in the 1963 Dalek story. Then, the scene with the cafe owner about the nature of time in the same Dalek story was one of the Doctor's best of all-time. And his farewell to Mel was one of the best scenes in the history of the show as well. He was not to blame for the gap, the blinkered philistines in the BBC were.
@tjhornikel Am I the only one who noticed that this "soliloquy" is almost identical to Eccleston's shouty lines at the end of Bad Wolf? (Normally the Daleks are the ones shouting the threats, not the Dr).
Anyway, that's a misconception of fans. There was no actual good reason why the BBC cancelled DW. Being put up against Coronation Street would kill any show.
His speech at the end of Survival is superior to this one. If he had had this speech they would've attest had a good reason to cancel it.
@LegoDaleks Opinions and criticism are not the same thing. From a story-writing angle, R.T. Davies does have childish tendency, but his understanding of SF motifs go well beyond the majority of commonday television. Moffat may not have as strong understandings of SF motifs, but his ability to develop complex narratives is amazing, as evidenced through his entire carreer in Doctor Who as well as other works. The original show was entertaining scifi, even with some legitimate SF.
@lorvincent What sci-fi motifs? The DW is actually about a guy who travels in a time & space, but instead of traveling in time & space ReTarD just has him hang out with a 19 year old low-life & go on family visits in contemporary Cardiff. That sci-fi motif you mean?
Muppet's stories are no better than the ones you find in the common soap opera. Oo, two people turn out to be related, wow, it's shocking! Writing for shocks isn't good writing & it's especially bad for repeated viewing, like soaps.
I DO!!!
2Scribble 1 week ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Those were some terrible lines that Muppet just stole from ReTarD. That "speech" is so similar to the one at the end of Bad Wolf. Sylvester McCoy is awesome though. What's with all the scathing comments about Sylvester McCoy and his tenure? The weakest story of his is like an ingenious masterpiece when compared to the incompetence of ReTarD & Muppet as well as Eccleston's & Tennant's OTT acting. Matt would be ok if he weren't made to behave so immaturely.
LegoDaleks 2 weeks ago
@LegoDaleks that was the speech 11 made in the Pandorica episode...did you not see it?
bdragond 2 weeks ago
@bdragond Unfortunately I have seen that appalling episode, only made worse by the outcomes in the Big Bang. He just gets out using his wand again. I made a parody/reviews of most of series 5.
LegoDaleks 2 weeks ago
@LegoDaleks Calm down and take your anti-stupid pills...
Ghastly98 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Ghastly98 What makes you think that I'm not calm? Ghastly98? Talk about stupid, you're just another Youtuber who couldn't come up with an original name so stuck some random numbers on the end (or probably your birth-year). there, I at least justified calling you stupid, but there was nothing I did or said that was stupid & I was calm, so your comment was irrelevant & irreverent.
LegoDaleks 1 week ago
best. doctor. ever.
DickVanDeath 2 weeks ago
My mind is blown.
MrTerra5005 2 weeks ago
That was awesome! :D
jediewok16 3 weeks ago
Love how he says the end "that'll keep them squabbling for a bit" with a great expression of "hope it works." Man, I miss him.
Anynom 3 weeks ago
Sylvester IS the Doctor!
WC3POchannel10A 3 weeks ago
I agree completely... if McCoy had lines like this. his doctor would have gone on. he was fabulous in my opinion of the old series him, pertwee and tom baker were the best of the originals
dustbiter445 1 month ago
Great! Not quite as he would've played it for real, but that end bit has some of the 7th Drs familiar menace. A great Doc and I hope he comes back for the anniversary!
outland101 1 month ago 2
@outland101 Yeah, you could take him seriously. And his one minute lighthearted, the next dead serious, made it that much more menacing.
WC3POchannel10A 3 weeks ago
Lovely bloke and he has been an exellent ambassador for the show since he left the role.
But he never had the acting talent to pull the part off. This just reminds of the nigthmare that Dr Who was during his reign. I am just grateful Sophie Aldred isn't in it aswell.
And its not a patch on Matt Smiths version of this speach.
ffmarkm 1 month ago
@ffmarkm that's your opinion but I know loads of people who LOVED Sylvester's tenure as The Doctor.
bdragond 1 month ago 12
@ffmarkm That he never had the acting talent is your opinion. He and Sophie always rose above whatever they were given in my opinion. A lot of modern Doctor Who has not been any better. It has just had better special effects technology.
WC3POchannel10A 3 weeks ago
@ffmarkm I liked Sylvester's Doctor, and this is the best speech by any Doctor.
Markel1970A 3 weeks ago
@Markel1970A I'm assuming you haven't heard the majority of his speeches if you think that was the best. It was severely unimpressive, out-of-character & unoriginal. Check out Bad Wolf - it's the same dumb speech.
LegoDaleks 2 weeks ago
@ffmarkm I read somewhere that McCoy was hired because the BBC wanted to cancel the show. They aired it at the same time as Corrie on ITV, so it wouldn't pull in the viewers. He grew into the role, and I think if he was allowed another series it would have been the best one yet (with McCoy I mean).
dragonash1993 3 weeks ago
@ffmarkm His acting talent exceeds that of Tennant's, as well as Tennant-impersonators'. If you want to be reminded of what a nightmare DW was then check out 2005-present.
Doctor Who is like a box of chocolates that reads: BEST BEFORE 2005
LegoDaleks 2 weeks ago
@ffmarkm
He is in my top three favorite Doctors. It's fine if you don't like him but you don't have to insult him.
Kuronus 2 days ago
Huge smile on my face now :D
swordseye2 1 month ago
Every Doctor will always be the one and only Doctor. So shut up, because HE... IS.... TALKING!!!!
thatwhichisgiven 1 month ago 11
I love him just a bit more♥
Ljeac 1 month ago
would've liked it if he did the shout of:
I
AM
TALIKING
redfinale 1 month ago
@redfinale - not in character for his Doctor - that wasn't McCoy up there... it was Seven :) and Seven wouldn't have shouted that... he'd have whispered it, make 'em GUESS who it is ^_^
Amazing to see how he just 'sank' back into his role as the Doctor throughout that speech... totally brilliant ^_^
2Scribble 1 week ago
sylvester should appear in the 50th anniversary like if u agree
cvrmaniac 1 month ago 10
RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
benlroberts2 1 month ago
Man, Sylvester McCoy is a riot!!!
psxwarrior 2 months ago
I really need to watch the old shows.
SirhcAdrbohc 2 months ago
Love it but still dying to see David Tennent do it.
Anynom 3 months ago 8
RRRemember every black day I ever stopped you!
Whitechapelfiend 3 months ago 37
@Whitechapelfiend I love his rolling r's =)
bdragond 3 months ago 15
Oh McCoy, you need to come back for an episode or two.
EmmersEmily 3 months ago 9
Wow this was made for the 7th doctor.
penninefilms 4 months ago 6
The 7th Doctor really knew how to give a speech...that's why I loved his incarnation. Now if only he didnt roll his "R's" , But still he was my favorate.
maxcardun 4 months ago 5
@maxcardun I love the rolled Rs!!
psxwarrior 2 months ago
He still look good!
AceTrax2007 4 months ago 7
If Sylvester McCoy were allowed a soliloquy like this one, we might not have had a 15+ year gap in the series.
tjhornikel 4 months ago 62
@tjhornikel He had at least three great ones that I can remember. Threatening the guards to kill him on Iceworld. The dressing down of Davros in the 1963 Dalek story. Then, the scene with the cafe owner about the nature of time in the same Dalek story was one of the Doctor's best of all-time. And his farewell to Mel was one of the best scenes in the history of the show as well. He was not to blame for the gap, the blinkered philistines in the BBC were.
WC3POchannel10A 3 weeks ago
@WC3POchannel10A One word - Ghostlight.
DickVanDeath 2 weeks ago
@tjhornikel Am I the only one who noticed that this "soliloquy" is almost identical to Eccleston's shouty lines at the end of Bad Wolf? (Normally the Daleks are the ones shouting the threats, not the Dr).
Anyway, that's a misconception of fans. There was no actual good reason why the BBC cancelled DW. Being put up against Coronation Street would kill any show.
His speech at the end of Survival is superior to this one. If he had had this speech they would've attest had a good reason to cancel it.
LegoDaleks 2 weeks ago
@LegoDaleks Chill out. There's no need to go all crazy about some TV show.
midgetwars1 1 week ago
@midgetwars1 I'm not "going all crazy" I'm merely giving criticism where criticism is over-due.
LegoDaleks 1 week ago
@LegoDaleks Opinions and criticism are not the same thing. From a story-writing angle, R.T. Davies does have childish tendency, but his understanding of SF motifs go well beyond the majority of commonday television. Moffat may not have as strong understandings of SF motifs, but his ability to develop complex narratives is amazing, as evidenced through his entire carreer in Doctor Who as well as other works. The original show was entertaining scifi, even with some legitimate SF.
lorvincent 1 week ago
@lorvincent What sci-fi motifs? The DW is actually about a guy who travels in a time & space, but instead of traveling in time & space ReTarD just has him hang out with a 19 year old low-life & go on family visits in contemporary Cardiff. That sci-fi motif you mean?
Muppet's stories are no better than the ones you find in the common soap opera. Oo, two people turn out to be related, wow, it's shocking! Writing for shocks isn't good writing & it's especially bad for repeated viewing, like soaps.
LegoDaleks 1 week ago