FUCKING STUPID first of all amy lee fired most of the original memebers the musicians get over it with this amy and carly shit evenanesce doesnt even sound like how they used to they have a different sound
@volcom3345 Uhh, where'd you get your info? Amy only fired one of her band members, and that was John. Thank you very much, and who wouldn't fire someone who was plotting against them?! I know I would. You should get your facts straight before you post something for the world to see. Loser.
I happen to like BOTH bands. Yes I did Like Evanescence way before I did We are the fallen but I mean really. You can't not like a band because they may sound like another. that's like me asking well who do you like better Get scared or Escape the fate (who by the way sound similar) So how can you say that We are the fallen are Copying off of Evanescence. I'm not saying you can't have your own opinion I'm just saying base your Choice on the music.
first of all, i would like to thank amy for her music. second if this new girl who happened to have amys band, didnt want to be compared to amy then she should make a new look. and sing different songs. its not hard come out with something different.. hate that amys band broke up but life goes on... and for carly good luck.
I do think its ridiculous that people make all this drama about the Amy vs. Carly thing. The fact is, things didn't work out between Amy and Ben and so Ben went to pursue a new Evanescence. And Ben found an amazing woman who can sing Evanescence like songs with the same range and style as Amy can. There is nothing wrong with that. Carly haters, think of it this way: there will now be more Evanescence to listen to. I'm fine with that!
HOW you COMPARE Amy and Carly...???????????????? GOD!!! 1) Amy is more beautifull than Carly. 2)Amy is better singer tha Carly. 3)Amy is more friendly and more cute than Carly. 4)Amy was before than Carly. 5)Carly is copying the Amy's style. 6)Carly is ugly xD 7) Carly NEVER is going to get the Amy's voice. AMY I love you always and forever!! :D I'm Spanish :)
this video was shit to begin with...............ok what if we are the fallen came first......and you heard carly first.........and ben left we are the fallen and formed evanescence after.....you would be saying shit about amy right......... so for the morons who hate this shit stop comparing the two cause they are both living the life that all of us want.....we are all jealous of them.....by the way we are the fallen rocks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!peace bitches
@buratmong69 I wouldn't have been listening to her from the start. Amy attracted people to begin with because of her opera voice, and her opera tendencies and her natural beauty... carly doesn't have any of that, hence why your pretend situation doesn't matter. Amy was something different and new. Carly is just being dragged into the scene by moody who is btw extremely talented and could have done better than a cheap copy of evanescence and using an american idol singer. Her can do better.
@ MasakoXer You are a cunt. Get over it that Carly is just another fucking clone of every God Damed 'gothic' singer out there. Evanescence is done. It's been done for 5 years. I must say; for someone that claims that this is just 'the internet' why are you getting so offended with what everyone else has to say? Fucked up, right cunt? As well; if you're defended Amy we all have the right to defend Carly.
what the fuck are you even talking about, dumbshit. I posted those comments a week ago, it takes you that long to reply back? That's pretty sad. Yeah, when I said "come back to me when you have something smart to say", it really seems you didn't take that into consideration.
I don't give a shit about your grandmother, dumbass. Why are you getting family members in here?
dude, you can't even cuss properly. Get some new insults, jackshit.
How wonderful of you to come to my channel and see a Jesus Christ picture as my profile image. That's just another channel view.
I'm a Christian, and I say whatever the FUCK I want. I can curse, who gives a fuck, it's the internet. Lmao, "Pathetic little oaf" thats the besu insult you could throw at me? That's pretty sad.
Amy Lee will always be number one compared to WATF cuz having stole 3 of amy's members AND copied their title "Fallen" off evanescence's album.
You seemed to be offened by what I am telling you. I can see that half of these comments are towards me. How pathetic. I'm not in the least bit offened or moved. Also, God is dead. If you believe in heaven; guess where you'll go in the end. Fucking hell bitch with all the butthurt cunts out there that waste their precious little hours of life on the internet fighting with someone like me who could give a rats ass! Since you're so 'gothic' why don't you kill yourself in most morbid way? Amirite?
@MasakoXer How could you judge Carly and yet love Jesus Christ? I saw your page. Hypocrite! Pathetic little oaf! Besides, Disturbed sucks so much and is for dirties! lulz
I would love to agree with all of you but We Are the Fallen's Album is just better than Evenesence's newest, and its not about about who can sing better iits about who sounds better and who's band decides to show up... and musician will tell you that. Besides, I would have left too if I had to put up with Amy's drama.
Amy Lee is the best and always will be. Carly and her stupid band will fail, because there are more Evanescence fans then whatever fans so they won't be supported. I love you Amy!!
Is that so?... Well if Carly is an Amy wannabe then Amy is a Sharon den Adel and Cristina Scabbia and whatsherface from Nightwish (the orginal singer) wannabe! So since I have dark hair, pale skin, high cheek bones and a whiney voice am I an Amy Lee wannabe? lulz fail. Here's one thing that Carly can do that Amy cannot do; hold onto band members and omg not disappear for like 3545 years and put out a mediocre album! (I used to be a diehard Amy fan) I woke up thank god!
Well, let's compare - Amy Lee hasn't done anything in 5 years, that I'm aware of and sucks at live performances. Carly won American Idol, sounds great live and is doing We Are The Fallen... So... not a complicated decision
@MasakoXer Amy is 'beast?' luuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuulz! Sharon has a background in opera, such a prestigious area of music that Amy Lee cannot touch even if her hick ass depended on it!
As well, by the looks of it; you're quite the little imp. You seem to be defending a woman that doesn't know your very existance nor cares. Find something else better than playing an Amy solider all day.
You just come out of nowhere saying random shit. Amy Lee's voice would be God'd voice if he were a girl.
Amy Lee's voice is beautiful. She barely uses autotune which means she's nothing but talent.
Yes, Carly sucks. She just came out of nowhere stealing her music, doing covers though she even admitted she never heard her music. Go ask beetoven that, how was he able to "hear" and make music though he was deaf, eh?
lmao, no she's not. Pop singers don't have head banging guitarists and loud drummers on stage. Have you even heard of any of her songs before? That's not pop. "pop" sounds COMPLETELY different.
@MasakoXer 'You little shit' what are you a fucking 60 year old woman? My grandmother uses that at her cat! lulz. Hey don't get me wrong I love Amy Lee! I just get a rise out of setting you off. And HOW could I ask Beetoven? he was deaf asshole!!!!!!!! fuckingomgyoufuckingfailedcunt
amy will always be my favourite . She is much more preety than carly and more talented (she can play the piano very well and she has the most amazing voice ever ) ..... carly has that ,.... idk ..... somehow a long face ..... and her ayes are to close one too each other ............ amy is the best and she will always be :D
maybe my comment some people will be mad but Amy is not good live and i heard carly and she sound much better I m more into metal with bands like Nightwish ( old nightwish) and Epica they are very good singer btw they are not comercial bands.
maybe my comment some people will be mad but Amy is not good live and i heard carly and she sound much better I m more into metal with bands like Nightwish ( old nightwish) and Epica they are very good singer btw they are not comercial bands
@MasakoXer what ever you said I don't care about this pop crappy singers im gonna show you a very talnted and real metal singers (womens) so go and chek Tarja Turunen ex nightwish ,Epica and Nightwish
did you just say Amy Lee sings pop? I don't think that's what you said, cuz if you did, it's like admitting to the world you have downs syndrome or some shit. Seriously, tell me you did not say that. Cuz that's hilarious.
AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY AMY LEE!
AMY LEE IS SO AMAZING I LOVE YOU AMYLEEE!!!!<3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333
Amy Lee is the best singer, better personality, better career, and more common sense. I am not a "hater" of Carly, but I am a huge fan of Evanescence and Amy lee. And I always will be. Amy is Amy. Carly is not a good singer in my opinion.. But Amy, there is no one who doesnt think she can sing. Amy's voice is soothing, and always great to listen to. Amy has true talent. :)
There is no better than Amy's anyone in the world! This mymra Carly builds itself does not know who Amy forever! "How can they compare? Of course Amy! Carly ... you are not the subject!
There is no better than Amy's anyone in the world! This mymra Carly builds itself does not know who Amy forever! "How can they compare? Of course Amy! Carly ... you are not the subject!
There is no better than Amy's anyone in the world! This mymra Carly builds itself does not know who Amy forever! "How can they compare? Of course Amy! Carly ... you are not the subject!
i think every 1 just needs to get over it... its not like ur going to bring we r the fallen down. let them b. the best will come out @ record sales. let them have there 15 minutes.
Oh I'm the f'n idiot?! Srsly? Your screen name is grammatically incorrect...you missed the apostrophe "e".....dumb ass. What are you like 12?! Cuz that's exactly how you act, pre-pubescent.
TAKE THIS VIDEO DOWN! its blasphemy!!! Amy lee is the most hottest, beautiful woman ever. she has the voice of an angel, writes the BEST lyrics and oh yeah HAS THE VOICE OF AN ANGEL seriously how can ANYONE compare than ugly tattooed hooker to amy lee?
O.O OMFG! Great! I'm gonna have nightmares with this pic! D: 1:14
Darn it! Carly will never gonna be anything like Amy! She's original; carly's just coping her in almost everything!!! D: doesn't she have a bit of self-esteem and be herself!!?
wow everyone who is talkin bad about Carly is crazy.... Carly is actually a fantastic vocalist.... and she deserves credit for it.... she is one of the best singers out there right now.... for me Carly is a better singer then Amy but Amy rings ore emotion whenshe sings.... you guys just need to quit being jealous about Carly now being with Amy Lee's people... they just didn't get along.... and they've moved on .... so why an't you??????
I don't hate Carly and I also think she has a very great voice and is very pretty, but what I don't appreciate, like some of the fans are angry about, well, er I don't want to say copy, but took a whole of Amylee's style.
@smartsailorscout4 what's wrong with Carly having a similar style to Amy??? They have similar voices nd styles but are uniqe in there own ways as wll.
I didn't know this until today, but Amy wrote a song for the happenings in Haiti this year called "Together Again" Very pretty , look it up on here and give it a listen <3
That bitch can never compare to Amy Lee. They edit her voice to make it sound like Amy Lee, she'll never be a tenth as amazing as Amy. Amy's voice is different and unique, that ufly mo fo can suck it.
I think the video information is a little exagerated, I mean Ben didn't left to Amy to make a new band, god this was a lot of years later, I love Amy lee, and I can see the new band it's not like evanescence was, but Carly hasn't fhe fault :( and she's not anorexic.. maybe bulimic jaja
and sure AMY LEE is waaaaay better and hotter and her voice like an angle
but carly`s voice like a donkey . so carly don`t even think abt taking EVA place
coz this will happen in ur fucky dreams sucker so go to ur fucky house and live with littile but of dignity . what u monkey trying to make out like people.
GO EVANESCENCE!!!! Carly can go die in a ditch! She's a pice of CRAP!!! She is an attention whore and an Amy Lee wannabe! What a fucking poser! It makes me physically SICK!!!! Amy Lee has been through to fucking much to be treated like this by her band "mates". She is exetremely talented and beautiful! And she could sing circles around the fucking poser Carly! GO AMY!!!
Ben did not betray the Evanescence, he did what he thought was right at the moment, you'll never understand why you will always see one side of the story, imagine that? Of course, Evanescence! Before anything I am a fan of Evanescence, but I'm not the common census, before then say something, shut up and listen to both sides of the story. If Ben had not made that decision Evanescence maybe it was just this past and not what everyone worship with as much pride as if Amy was the victim
Ben não traiu o Evanescence, ele fez o que achava certo no momento, vocês nunca vão entender por que vocês sempre vão ver um lado da historia, imagina qual? Claro, Evanescence! Antes de qualquer coisa sou fã do Evanescence, porém, não sou do censo comum, então antes de falar alguma coisa, cala a boca e escuta os dois lados da historia. Se Ben não tivesse tomado essa decisão talvez Evanescence fosse apenas passado e não isso o que todos idolatram com tanto orgulho como se a Amy fosse a vitima
i feel the band changed who Carly was as a singer. i liked the songs "WE ARE the fallen" put out, but they cant lie to themselves and say they r unique. Amy lee is a wonderful idol and Carly is just straying from what shes known as a singer.
wen they covered som EV stuff i was pissed. You say that your, your own band, not trying to copy them, then y did u cover 1-2 of there songs.
i like both bands but i am disaopointed in WATF choices, they need to clean up their act.
Amy sucks i realy can't stand her i tried so before people have a go at me i realy tried to get into evanescence but i just couldnt i say amy live at download 07 and she just sounded fucking awful, just terrible im sorry to the fans of amy lee but like i said i did try to....BUT i love we are the fallen :P
@Warcry667 YOU ARE A CUNT AND YOU HAVE TO DIE. amy lee is BEST. amy has the voice of an angel. she's beautiful. carly smithson is a dog. a mutt that needs to be put down.
@Warcry667 you realize.. there are literally MORE than.. oh, i don't know, 500, at least. OVER 500. yeah, you wouldn't exactly be your best, would you.
dude, do you not see everyone saying that we are the fallen is a fucking lie.
carly has never heard any of evanescence's songs. Yet, she does covers. That's pathetic. Carly is a little whore who came out of absolutely nowhere just to be a fake singer. what else do you need to know?
@MasakoXer That makes no absolute sense bro, how on earth could she have sung 'Bring Me To Life' without having heard how it was done? She sang it pretty well and close to the real thing. As with her own touch. Are you saying that every wannabe out there that puts a song on Youtube is a 'little whore'?
Yes, Amy is more talented ONLY because she uses her piano skills to write. If she couldn't play piano, her talent would be equal to Carly’s. Besides, look at everything that Evanescence has gone thru. At some point you have to admit that all the rumors about Amy being a beotch is true, I hate to say it but when ur a beotch like that, talent can only take you so far.
Wow srsly?! I have always loved Amy. But if you view interviews and such, Carly IS NOT trying to be like Amy Lee. Geez guys, know what ur talking about before you blab. Carly is def. her own person. Her voice is similar to Amy's. It takes years to develop a voice like that. She didn't copy Amy, chances are her and Amy were developing it at the same time, just Amy got famous before Carly did, geez use ur heads ppl.
Wow srsly?! I have always loved Amy. But if you view interviews and such, Carly IS NOT trying to be like Amy Lee. Geez guys, know what ur talking about before you blab. Carly is def. her own person. Her voice is similar to Amy's. It takes years to develop a voice like that. She didn't copy Amy, chances are her and Amy were developing it at the same time, just Amy got famous before Carly did, geez use ur heads ppl.
Yes, Amy is more talented ONLY because she uses her piano skills to write. If she couldn't play piano, her talent would be equal to Carly’s. Besides, look at everything that Evanescence has gone thru. At some point you have to admit that all the rumors about Amy being a beotch is true, I hate to say it but when ur a beotch like that, talent can only take you so far.
amy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! she is just so amazing and beautiful and talented
TheBettyandBooShow 2 months ago 2
@TheBettyandBooShow Agreed
JordanMcCoyFan94 1 month ago
FUCKING STUPID first of all amy lee fired most of the original memebers the musicians get over it with this amy and carly shit evenanesce doesnt even sound like how they used to they have a different sound
volcom3345 5 months ago
@volcom3345 Uhh, where'd you get your info? Amy only fired one of her band members, and that was John. Thank you very much, and who wouldn't fire someone who was plotting against them?! I know I would. You should get your facts straight before you post something for the world to see. Loser.
cjmsja 3 months ago
no one can look like amy ..... i think amy is the best
Evanescencelover927 5 months ago
amy is a true rock goddess :)
suhayb888 6 months ago 6
a new amy ahahahahah amy is one ....only one
funfangtasia90 6 months ago
Comment removed
funfangtasia90 6 months ago
AMY LEE IS THE BEST!!!
AARON75FLY 6 months ago 6
@AARON75FLY Agreed!
JordanMcCoyFan94 1 month ago
pelo amor de Deus amy lee e unica ela e diva amoooo de maisssss!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
emillydevil 6 months ago
obviusly Amy lee =) !!!!
sushiloop 7 months ago
ieeuw. carly is so ugly
misssouly 7 months ago 2
Amy Lee is THE best <3
Amy Lee est la meilleure
Evanescence forever ! <3
bakakawazi 7 months ago
amy leeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee forvereeeeeeeeeeeeeerrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
Elzkazooki1 7 months ago
Evanescence and Amy Lee FOREVER! ♥
jFohr 7 months ago
AMY LEEEEEEEEEEE YOU ARE A SERIOUS ROCKER CARLY I DONT CARE WHO YOU ARE YOU STOLE SOMEONE IMPORTANT FROM AMY SO BACK OFF
eltazz1 7 months ago 2
amy lee
amy lee
amy lee
FUCK YOU carly
amy lee!!! :D
XxAshleyAcidicxX 8 months ago 2
carly you suck make your own damn songs amy lee your the best
96dib 8 months ago 3
I like carly smithson and we are the fallen but amy better than her .
BenMoodyFan 8 months ago
AMYLEE FOREVER<3!!!
shayynn09 8 months ago
How could you EVER compare her too amy lee like seriously lol.
Maybebluechels 8 months ago 2
Essa Carly smithson não passa de uma cópia da Amy.Mil vezes Amy Lee!!!
TheGabrielaIsis 8 months ago
AMY AMY AMY AMY AMY AMY!!!!!!!!!!!!
15jallred 8 months ago
oh my gosh, who is that little boy with amy??? can someone please tell me!!!
chelsea11194 8 months ago
is it amy's son on 2.03 ?? :o
encamile 8 months ago
amy !!!!!!!! :)
encamile 8 months ago
I happen to like BOTH bands. Yes I did Like Evanescence way before I did We are the fallen but I mean really. You can't not like a band because they may sound like another. that's like me asking well who do you like better Get scared or Escape the fate (who by the way sound similar) So how can you say that We are the fallen are Copying off of Evanescence. I'm not saying you can't have your own opinion I'm just saying base your Choice on the music.
Vampbabe 8 months ago
Amy Lee is better much
TheLexi0005 8 months ago
LOL LOL LOL Carly looks like one of those whores in Evanescence's Everybody's Fool music vid. XD
KakashiHatake2121 9 months ago
@KakashiHatake2121 She really does.
rainxinxblack21 8 months ago
FUCK U BITCH Carly Smithson EVANESCENCE THE BEST AND SHE STILL THE BEST
AZIZVOTEHCK 9 months ago
ok...search buzznet : Amy Hartzler....(Amy Lee's Wedding Statment)
amy doesn't fire anyone
sophiant18 9 months ago
fuck you he don't betrayed amy, amy fired a member without reasons and he left because that was stupid that's why he formed we are the fallen
yoshiskato 9 months ago
@yoshiskato That isn't even how it happened...
CHICKdrummer 9 months ago
@yoshiskato not what happened bud...
KakashiHatake2121 9 months ago
what is the first song?
yoshiskato 9 months ago
first of all, i would like to thank amy for her music. second if this new girl who happened to have amys band, didnt want to be compared to amy then she should make a new look. and sing different songs. its not hard come out with something different.. hate that amys band broke up but life goes on... and for carly good luck.
217ray 9 months ago
I do think its ridiculous that people make all this drama about the Amy vs. Carly thing. The fact is, things didn't work out between Amy and Ben and so Ben went to pursue a new Evanescence. And Ben found an amazing woman who can sing Evanescence like songs with the same range and style as Amy can. There is nothing wrong with that. Carly haters, think of it this way: there will now be more Evanescence to listen to. I'm fine with that!
enochthedunadine 9 months ago
So far I still like Amy Lee better since I have been listening to her amazing singing for 10 years since Origin.
enochthedunadine 9 months ago
Amy Lee
HappyChik001 9 months ago
Never heard anything from Carly, so how you can copare???. Who is hotter? Well i dunno? But who cares, we are talking music, right???
Milton2k 9 months ago
Sarha1997 10 months ago
AMY LEE FOREVER!!! :3
gohanfan98 10 months ago
this video was shit to begin with...............ok what if we are the fallen came first......and you heard carly first.........and ben left we are the fallen and formed evanescence after.....you would be saying shit about amy right......... so for the morons who hate this shit stop comparing the two cause they are both living the life that all of us want.....we are all jealous of them.....by the way we are the fallen rocks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!peace bitches
buratmong69 10 months ago
@buratmong69 Maybe, but didn't happen that way. Amy is the Goddess of imaginary light.
KakashiHatake2121 9 months ago
@buratmong69 Carly sounds like a pop singer.
KakashiHatake2121 9 months ago
@buratmong69 I wouldn't have been listening to her from the start. Amy attracted people to begin with because of her opera voice, and her opera tendencies and her natural beauty... carly doesn't have any of that, hence why your pretend situation doesn't matter. Amy was something different and new. Carly is just being dragged into the scene by moody who is btw extremely talented and could have done better than a cheap copy of evanescence and using an american idol singer. Her can do better.
KakashiHatake2121 9 months ago
AMY LEE SUCKS!
SHARON, Simone!! AND THE BEST: TARJA ARE THE FCKING BETTER THAN HER!
JkLabMetal 10 months ago
ok i have now officialy seen both amy lee and carly live i am now happily saying THERE BOTH SHIT!
Warcry667 11 months ago
No contest. Amy rules over Carly ANY DAY.
iloveevanescence1795 11 months ago
Carly looks too preppy ._. Amy is more amazing
MissSlipknotJordison 11 months ago
Amy was the first!!!! Carly is her copy!!
Carly is ugly, Amy is PRETTY!!!
NEVER COMPARE!! AMY IS BETTER!!
Sarha1997 11 months ago
amy all the way her voice is soooo great and she is prettier
anx1106 11 months ago
@ MasakoXer You are a cunt. Get over it that Carly is just another fucking clone of every God Damed 'gothic' singer out there. Evanescence is done. It's been done for 5 years. I must say; for someone that claims that this is just 'the internet' why are you getting so offended with what everyone else has to say? Fucked up, right cunt? As well; if you're defended Amy we all have the right to defend Carly.
LittleSerboLamb 11 months ago
@LittleSerboLamb
what the fuck are you even talking about, dumbshit. I posted those comments a week ago, it takes you that long to reply back? That's pretty sad. Yeah, when I said "come back to me when you have something smart to say", it really seems you didn't take that into consideration.
I don't give a shit about your grandmother, dumbass. Why are you getting family members in here?
dude, you can't even cuss properly. Get some new insults, jackshit.
MasakoXer 11 months ago
haha rocky gray with long hair. thank god he left evanescence, his face disturbed me
Sansiara 11 months ago
Listen to "My Immortal" the band version. That's not pop, dumbass.
MasakoXer 1 year ago
Come back to me when you have something smart to say.
and yes Sharon can't be compared to Amy Lee because they are completely different.
Amy Lee hs her own genre of music.
lmao, and about Disturbed. That just tells me you don't have any taste in music, or just listen to shit that has no meaning in it.
MasakoXer 1 year ago
How wonderful of you to come to my channel and see a Jesus Christ picture as my profile image. That's just another channel view.
I'm a Christian, and I say whatever the FUCK I want. I can curse, who gives a fuck, it's the internet. Lmao, "Pathetic little oaf" thats the besu insult you could throw at me? That's pretty sad.
Amy Lee will always be number one compared to WATF cuz having stole 3 of amy's members AND copied their title "Fallen" off evanescence's album.
MasakoXer 1 year ago
You seemed to be offened by what I am telling you. I can see that half of these comments are towards me. How pathetic. I'm not in the least bit offened or moved. Also, God is dead. If you believe in heaven; guess where you'll go in the end. Fucking hell bitch with all the butthurt cunts out there that waste their precious little hours of life on the internet fighting with someone like me who could give a rats ass! Since you're so 'gothic' why don't you kill yourself in most morbid way? Amirite?
LittleSerboLamb 11 months ago
@MasakoXer How could you judge Carly and yet love Jesus Christ? I saw your page. Hypocrite! Pathetic little oaf! Besides, Disturbed sucks so much and is for dirties! lulz
LittleSerboLamb 1 year ago
whats the song?
AmericanGirl4ever91 1 year ago
I would love to agree with all of you but We Are the Fallen's Album is just better than Evenesence's newest, and its not about about who can sing better iits about who sounds better and who's band decides to show up... and musician will tell you that. Besides, I would have left too if I had to put up with Amy's drama.
dwoolensnider 1 year ago
Amy of course.... carly is just a wannabe idol!... and she always be!
AnnyMusiC91 1 year ago
@LittleSerbolLamb I like Amy but Obviously Sharon is million times better
vocaltears 1 year ago
Amy Lee is the best and always will be. Carly and her stupid band will fail, because there are more Evanescence fans then whatever fans so they won't be supported. I love you Amy!!
lovebug980612 1 year ago
Is that so?... Well if Carly is an Amy wannabe then Amy is a Sharon den Adel and Cristina Scabbia and whatsherface from Nightwish (the orginal singer) wannabe! So since I have dark hair, pale skin, high cheek bones and a whiney voice am I an Amy Lee wannabe? lulz fail. Here's one thing that Carly can do that Amy cannot do; hold onto band members and omg not disappear for like 3545 years and put out a mediocre album! (I used to be a diehard Amy fan) I woke up thank god!
LittleSerboLamb 1 year ago
Oopsy, she didn't win American Idol xD!! My bad!! Lmao!!
GothicNightmare66 1 year ago
Well, let's compare - Amy Lee hasn't done anything in 5 years, that I'm aware of and sucks at live performances. Carly won American Idol, sounds great live and is doing We Are The Fallen... So... not a complicated decision
GothicNightmare66 1 year ago
@GothicNightmare66 Amen brotha! lol
LittleSerboLamb 1 year ago
Amy Lee 4 life. Carly sux as a rock singer
hippotrot123 1 year ago
This girl is such a wannabe! she does nor even have her own voice... just a filthy copy o amy..
vocaltears 1 year ago
@vocaltears then Amy is just a dirtbag copy of Sharon den Adel!
LittleSerboLamb 1 year ago
@LittleSerboLamb
amy lee is beast.
she can't even compare to Sharon.
MasakoXer 1 year ago
@MasakoXer Amy is 'beast?' luuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuulz! Sharon has a background in opera, such a prestigious area of music that Amy Lee cannot touch even if her hick ass depended on it!
As well, by the looks of it; you're quite the little imp. You seem to be defending a woman that doesn't know your very existance nor cares. Find something else better than playing an Amy solider all day.
LittleSerboLamb 1 year ago
@LittleSerboLamb
lmao, you fucking little shit.
You just come out of nowhere saying random shit. Amy Lee's voice would be God'd voice if he were a girl.
Amy Lee's voice is beautiful. She barely uses autotune which means she's nothing but talent.
Yes, Carly sucks. She just came out of nowhere stealing her music, doing covers though she even admitted she never heard her music. Go ask beetoven that, how was he able to "hear" and make music though he was deaf, eh?
MasakoXer 1 year ago
@MasakoXer yes is said amy is a pop singer! and idn't care Tarja is better!!
MarsTerrible 1 year ago
@MarsTerrible
lmao, no she's not. Pop singers don't have head banging guitarists and loud drummers on stage. Have you even heard of any of her songs before? That's not pop. "pop" sounds COMPLETELY different.
Lady Gaga = pop.
Evanescence = gothic metal.
MasakoXer 1 year ago
@MasakoXer 'You little shit' what are you a fucking 60 year old woman? My grandmother uses that at her cat! lulz. Hey don't get me wrong I love Amy Lee! I just get a rise out of setting you off. And HOW could I ask Beetoven? he was deaf asshole!!!!!!!! fuckingomgyoufuckingfailedcunt
LittleSerboLamb 11 months ago
This girl is such a wannabe! she does nor even have her own voice... just a filthy copy o amy
vocaltears 1 year ago
amy will always be my favourite . She is much more preety than carly and more talented (she can play the piano very well and she has the most amazing voice ever ) ..... carly has that ,.... idk ..... somehow a long face ..... and her ayes are to close one too each other ............ amy is the best and she will always be :D
VeronikEVfan 1 year ago
amy of course is way better carly is just an ameteur beyotch
sexygamerchick69ify 1 year ago
AMY ES LA MEJOR !!! ESA NO LLEGA A LOS TALONES
dafnehochfaerber 1 year ago
Amy
paramore5able1 1 year ago
AMY LEE (Evanescence)
MushroomValleyGal 1 year ago
AMY LEE ALL THE WAY.. i dont like dat chicks voice.. peyuck .. i will always be a Amy Lee fan.. GO AMY LEE:0)
kellyfan57 1 year ago
Amy all the way!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
chloeluvzjonet 1 year ago
maybe my comment some people will be mad but Amy is not good live and i heard carly and she sound much better I m more into metal with bands like Nightwish ( old nightwish) and Epica they are very good singer btw they are not comercial bands.
MarsTerrible 1 year ago
maybe my comment some people will be mad but Amy is not good live and i heard carly and she sound much better I m more into metal with bands like Nightwish ( old nightwish) and Epica they are very good singer btw they are not comercial bands
MarsTerrible 1 year ago
@MarsTerrible
fuck off to hell dumbshit.
Amy Lee is better than Carly, that's a fact. She just stole her members. That's also a fact.
MasakoXer 1 year ago
@MasakoXer what ever you said I don't care about this pop crappy singers im gonna show you a very talnted and real metal singers (womens) so go and chek Tarja Turunen ex nightwish ,Epica and Nightwish
MarsTerrible 1 year ago
@MarsTerrible
did you just say Amy Lee sings pop? I don't think that's what you said, cuz if you did, it's like admitting to the world you have downs syndrome or some shit. Seriously, tell me you did not say that. Cuz that's hilarious.
MasakoXer 1 year ago
AMY LEE of course dah
thogg101 1 year ago
OMG, amy lee is the best of the best, carly is ok but definitly no were near close to amy:DDDD
MsJessyca13 1 year ago
AMY LEE IS A TRUE GODDESS AND ANGEL! IT IS A DISGRACE THAT PEOPLE HAVE THE NEVER TO EVEN THINK THERE IS SUCH COMPARISON AMONG THEM!!!!!!!!
imaginaryboii 1 year ago
OF COURSE AMY LEE !!!!!!!!
andrezakristina 1 year ago
AMY LEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
but carly in a good singer u.u
BuffaPuffa 1 year ago
AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY LEE AMY AMY LEE!
Sakuma8Ryuichi 1 year ago 15
CARLY IS AN IDIOT!
AMY LEE IS SO AMAZING I LOVE YOU AMYLEEE!!!!<3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333
Freeyyaaa 1 year ago 9
amy lee is the best and always will rock!!!!!!!!! carly is a fake!!! thumbs up if u agree!
Evanescence will liveon forever!!!!!!!!
littlegurl747 1 year ago 2
amy lee is the best and always will rock!!!!!!!!! carly is a fake!!! thumbs up if u agree!
littlegurl747 1 year ago
Amy Lee is the best singer, better personality, better career, and more common sense. I am not a "hater" of Carly, but I am a huge fan of Evanescence and Amy lee. And I always will be. Amy is Amy. Carly is not a good singer in my opinion.. But Amy, there is no one who doesnt think she can sing. Amy's voice is soothing, and always great to listen to. Amy has true talent. :)
Bblynnking 1 year ago 2
Here are the facts....1 Carly is a liar, she stated on radio that she had never listened to Ev yet she sings covers of Bring Me To Life ect.
2 We are the.... Fallen, Like the name of that last album he made before he left.
And 3rd...Amy Lee is real...Carly Shitson is a fake....cuz real people don't copy like she does...
CARLY IS SHIT.....all of you who agree...plz let me know, I'd like to talk
AmyLeeRox4EvaAndEva 1 year ago 2
@AmyLeeRox4EvaAndEva I didn't know she said that on Radio... What a lying fake cunt!!!!!!!!!!!
imaginaryboii 1 year ago
@imaginaryboii Yes she did, there is a video on youtube where she said this
AmyLeeRox4EvaAndEva 1 year ago
@AmyLeeRox4EvaAndEva hell yeah!!!!!!
Smickyla 1 year ago
AMY LEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE MY BITCH!!!!!!!!!!!!! xd
trecoolblood 1 year ago
AMY LEE IS THE BEST NO QUESTIONS ASKED.
screw that other douche bag carly
shelbs7740 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
There is no better than Amy's anyone in the world! This mymra Carly builds itself does not know who Amy forever! "How can they compare? Of course Amy! Carly ... you are not the subject!
Ruslan010203 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
There is no better than Amy's anyone in the world! This mymra Carly builds itself does not know who Amy forever! "How can they compare? Of course Amy! Carly ... you are not the subject!
Ruslan010203 1 year ago
There is no better than Amy's anyone in the world! This mymra Carly builds itself does not know who Amy forever! "How can they compare? Of course Amy! Carly ... you are not the subject!
Ruslan010203 1 year ago 37
jajajajaja ovbiiooo gana amy lee she is the best
billy12344able 1 year ago
ugh... common guyz..... Ben is good.... but that carly whatever from american idol is a big shit!!!
EVANESCENCE FOREVER!!!!!
haleyrockerz 1 year ago
Amy Lee is the best!!! And that's for sure :D
sonyr3d 1 year ago 32
@sonyr3d fuck no lol
eeffoooo 1 year ago
Amy Lee wins!
punkchick743 1 year ago
i think every 1 just needs to get over it... its not like ur going to bring we r the fallen down. let them b. the best will come out @ record sales. let them have there 15 minutes.
karly72 1 year ago
Oh, I just looked at your profile. You're not 12....you're 16. That explains it. And you got banned for two weeks? Surprise, surprise.
niccubus 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Grow up you moron.
niccubus 1 year ago
Oh I'm the f'n idiot?! Srsly? Your screen name is grammatically incorrect...you missed the apostrophe "e".....dumb ass. What are you like 12?! Cuz that's exactly how you act, pre-pubescent.
niccubus 1 year ago
TAKE THIS VIDEO DOWN! its blasphemy!!! Amy lee is the most hottest, beautiful woman ever. she has the voice of an angel, writes the BEST lyrics and oh yeah HAS THE VOICE OF AN ANGEL seriously how can ANYONE compare than ugly tattooed hooker to amy lee?
HeyImHotAndYourNot 1 year ago
@HeyImHotAndYourNot haha, a tattoed hooker? agreed!!!
Smickyla 1 year ago
O.O OMFG! Great! I'm gonna have nightmares with this pic! D: 1:14
Darn it! Carly will never gonna be anything like Amy! She's original; carly's just coping her in almost everything!!! D: doesn't she have a bit of self-esteem and be herself!!?
KHFanClub13 1 year ago
wow everyone who is talkin bad about Carly is crazy.... Carly is actually a fantastic vocalist.... and she deserves credit for it.... she is one of the best singers out there right now.... for me Carly is a better singer then Amy but Amy rings ore emotion whenshe sings.... you guys just need to quit being jealous about Carly now being with Amy Lee's people... they just didn't get along.... and they've moved on .... so why an't you??????
kbaker2011 1 year ago
@kbaker2011
I don't hate Carly and I also think she has a very great voice and is very pretty, but what I don't appreciate, like some of the fans are angry about, well, er I don't want to say copy, but took a whole of Amylee's style.
smartsailorscout4 1 year ago
@smartsailorscout4 what's wrong with Carly having a similar style to Amy??? They have similar voices nd styles but are uniqe in there own ways as wll.
kbaker2011 1 year ago
I didn't know this until today, but Amy wrote a song for the happenings in Haiti this year called "Together Again" Very pretty , look it up on here and give it a listen <3
Kitehnz 1 year ago
@Kitehnz
Didn't write it for Haiti. Was written well before that.
LeFemmeCrystal 1 year ago
Amy Lee is WAY more Beautiful and Prettier. than fucking Carly Smithson, and Carlys voice sucks ass. Carly is nothing but Another Wanna Be.
neko305 1 year ago
That bitch can never compare to Amy Lee. They edit her voice to make it sound like Amy Lee, she'll never be a tenth as amazing as Amy. Amy's voice is different and unique, that ufly mo fo can suck it.
RainbowzItUp 1 year ago
DIOOS AMYY ES UNICAAA Y SOBRETOODOO HERMOZAA NU LA QOPAREN CON LA MORRA EZA DE CARLYY JUMM JA LA CARLY ES UNA COPIA BARATA DE DE AMYY LEEE YEAAAHHH
33nan 1 year ago
amy lee will be the #1 hit for 2010 and 2011 and carly smithbitch u suck and amy lee rulez 1:12 what the heel who is that and 1:49 shes so ugly carly
TheAgonistRox 1 year ago
I think the video information is a little exagerated, I mean Ben didn't left to Amy to make a new band, god this was a lot of years later, I love Amy lee, and I can see the new band it's not like evanescence was, but Carly hasn't fhe fault :( and she's not anorexic.. maybe bulimic jaja
50605954 1 year ago
Amy-Lee all the way lovee!!
iloveyou amy lee! <<333
Freeyyaaa 1 year ago
@Freeyyaaa am with u
TheAgonistRox 1 year ago
Amy Lee the 1 and only original rock goddess!
REALSTRENGTH78 1 year ago 2
@REALSTRENGTH78 totally
TheAgonistRox 1 year ago
I don't mean to hate on Carly but I've noticed something. Pre We Are The Fallen, Carly's hair was brown. Now it's black...
LPchick503 1 year ago
@LPchick503 i noe shes a fuckin copier
TheAgonistRox 1 year ago
Amy lee for sure,
Carly is a fucking cock I hate her so much
Amy lee is beautiful
Carlys a fucking minger!
Amy has an amazing voice
CARLY SOUNDS LIKE A RAT!
Freeyyaaa 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Freeyyaaa totally
TheAgonistRox 1 year ago
¡¡¡Amy Lee!!!
margarita200993 1 year ago
AMY LEE!!!
jocelynnvampire 1 year ago
OHHHHH HORRIBLE PIC OF CARLY 1:17...HATE HER...shes a wanna be...
eshghemanito 1 year ago
FUCK the clone
musiicmuch 1 year ago
fuck carly i hate her so much she`s bitch
and sure AMY LEE is waaaaay better and hotter and her voice like an angle
but carly`s voice like a donkey . so carly don`t even think abt taking EVA place
coz this will happen in ur fucky dreams sucker so go to ur fucky house and live with littile but of dignity . what u monkey trying to make out like people.
in ur face fucker
xXblackflowerXx1 1 year ago
1:45 vs. 1:14
...enough said. 0.o
XsweetxsacraficeX 1 year ago
Amy Lee:X>:D<Is the number 1 xDWe are the fallen suckX(
prozoroschia 1 year ago
GO EVANESCENCE!!!! Carly can go die in a ditch! She's a pice of CRAP!!! She is an attention whore and an Amy Lee wannabe! What a fucking poser! It makes me physically SICK!!!! Amy Lee has been through to fucking much to be treated like this by her band "mates". She is exetremely talented and beautiful! And she could sing circles around the fucking poser Carly! GO AMY!!!
RabuneHino2 1 year ago
Ben did not betray the Evanescence, he did what he thought was right at the moment, you'll never understand why you will always see one side of the story, imagine that? Of course, Evanescence! Before anything I am a fan of Evanescence, but I'm not the common census, before then say something, shut up and listen to both sides of the story. If Ben had not made that decision Evanescence maybe it was just this past and not what everyone worship with as much pride as if Amy was the victim
angelblackjess 1 year ago
Ben não traiu o Evanescence, ele fez o que achava certo no momento, vocês nunca vão entender por que vocês sempre vão ver um lado da historia, imagina qual? Claro, Evanescence! Antes de qualquer coisa sou fã do Evanescence, porém, não sou do censo comum, então antes de falar alguma coisa, cala a boca e escuta os dois lados da historia. Se Ben não tivesse tomado essa decisão talvez Evanescence fosse apenas passado e não isso o que todos idolatram com tanto orgulho como se a Amy fosse a vitima
angelblackjess 1 year ago
Comment removed
angelblackjess 1 year ago
Team AMY! :D
omgxosteph 1 year ago
i feel the band changed who Carly was as a singer. i liked the songs "WE ARE the fallen" put out, but they cant lie to themselves and say they r unique. Amy lee is a wonderful idol and Carly is just straying from what shes known as a singer.
wen they covered som EV stuff i was pissed. You say that your, your own band, not trying to copy them, then y did u cover 1-2 of there songs.
i like both bands but i am disaopointed in WATF choices, they need to clean up their act.
watchit2341 1 year ago
they're both talented women, but we all heard amy first and there for carly became a replica of amy...I personally like them both, but like amy more
MrFrank1968 1 year ago
amy lee hands down.
MacenMadness 1 year ago
Amy sucks i realy can't stand her i tried so before people have a go at me i realy tried to get into evanescence but i just couldnt i say amy live at download 07 and she just sounded fucking awful, just terrible im sorry to the fans of amy lee but like i said i did try to....BUT i love we are the fallen :P
Warcry667 1 year ago
@Warcry667 So you dont like evanescence but you like the bootleg version of them? LOL that makes no sense.
Iwrestledahippoonce 1 year ago
@Warcry667 YOU ARE A CUNT AND YOU HAVE TO DIE. amy lee is BEST. amy has the voice of an angel. she's beautiful. carly smithson is a dog. a mutt that needs to be put down.
HeyImHotAndYourNot 1 year ago
@Warcry667 you realize.. there are literally MORE than.. oh, i don't know, 500, at least. OVER 500. yeah, you wouldn't exactly be your best, would you.
Smickyla 1 year ago
@Warcry667
dude, do you not see everyone saying that we are the fallen is a fucking lie.
carly has never heard any of evanescence's songs. Yet, she does covers. That's pathetic. Carly is a little whore who came out of absolutely nowhere just to be a fake singer. what else do you need to know?
MasakoXer 1 year ago
@MasakoXer That makes no absolute sense bro, how on earth could she have sung 'Bring Me To Life' without having heard how it was done? She sang it pretty well and close to the real thing. As with her own touch. Are you saying that every wannabe out there that puts a song on Youtube is a 'little whore'?
LittleSerboLamb 1 year ago
amy lee is powerfull but i had to admit carly smithson had a great voice but evanescence is the best band ever i waiting for the new album
tanin04 1 year ago
amy was under treated by the band cause she was so small and innocent in fallen and you can feel it from her songs
when she stood up for herself and wanted to be strong the guys didn't like it
she just want to change her life to the opposite and that's what happend
maybe it sound selfish but this is the truth so wake up
kivancis 1 year ago
PART 2 to my post:
Yes, Amy is more talented ONLY because she uses her piano skills to write. If she couldn't play piano, her talent would be equal to Carly’s. Besides, look at everything that Evanescence has gone thru. At some point you have to admit that all the rumors about Amy being a beotch is true, I hate to say it but when ur a beotch like that, talent can only take you so far.
niccubus 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wow srsly?! I have always loved Amy. But if you view interviews and such, Carly IS NOT trying to be like Amy Lee. Geez guys, know what ur talking about before you blab. Carly is def. her own person. Her voice is similar to Amy's. It takes years to develop a voice like that. She didn't copy Amy, chances are her and Amy were developing it at the same time, just Amy got famous before Carly did, geez use ur heads ppl.
niccubus 1 year ago
Wow srsly?! I have always loved Amy. But if you view interviews and such, Carly IS NOT trying to be like Amy Lee. Geez guys, know what ur talking about before you blab. Carly is def. her own person. Her voice is similar to Amy's. It takes years to develop a voice like that. She didn't copy Amy, chances are her and Amy were developing it at the same time, just Amy got famous before Carly did, geez use ur heads ppl.
niccubus 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
PART 2 to my post:
Yes, Amy is more talented ONLY because she uses her piano skills to write. If she couldn't play piano, her talent would be equal to Carly’s. Besides, look at everything that Evanescence has gone thru. At some point you have to admit that all the rumors about Amy being a beotch is true, I hate to say it but when ur a beotch like that, talent can only take you so far.
niccubus 1 year ago
@niccubus you are a fucking idiot. amy lee is 300 times more talented than that cunt carly HANDS DOWN
HeyImHotAndYourNot 1 year ago