Added: 2 months ago
From: Narutendo3
Views: 10,752
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (294)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The roster looks good but, I'd add:

    Raiden (MGS4 look)

    Liquid Snake

    Little Mac

    and Mr. Sandman

  • Shadow should be in ssbb

  • bomberman, knuckles and Pac man would be cool in ssb4

  • No Tails or Knuckles?

  • Comment removed

  • This should have Demise

  • what about waluigi?

  • do you like skull kid because he drops Giant Ruppees when you kill him in OoT?

  • It looks good but you should add Ninten

  • falta bomberman

  • Where is Sora? :(

  • I really like this roster. And you added Ridley, that makes you awesome.

  • I KNOW THIS MIGHT BE STUPID but i want Inuyasha in here..hes AWESOME!! and his Tetsiaga would be an awesome item.. :D and also.. WAT ABOUT GENO!? and in yourrs does Zelda transform into Sheik and the best of all.. WHAT ABOUT DARK LINK!? I MEAN SERIOUSLY!!!! DOES HE GET ANY RESPECT!?

  • Change Kirbys moves like nonstop fighter punch should be nonstop spear stab, final smash crash kirby, and cutter up upper cut which is fighter kirby. Last but not least add shadow, knukles, Dr. Eggman, SpongeBob, Jimmy Newtron, Timmy Tunner, and Danny Phantom. P.S make the NickToons Charicters

  • shadow??

  • i want geno...

  • "This is gonna be nice and short"

    17:40

    ...hm

  • DAMN you shoulda done cloud D:<

  • @Karasariiii oh wait you do have cloud o-o I didnt saw the buttom I FEEL DUMB NOW DX

  • @Karasariiii cloud is at the bottom, fourth one to the right...=.= geez..maybe you should double check ur answers..

  • @linkshero99 I know i replied that comment and say oh theres cloud LOL you shouldnt have commeted this waste of your time...

  • Knuckles would be a sick character to have in the next ssb.

  • Some of these would be cool to have, others not so much.

    I know it won't happen, but the charater that I'd want to see in the the next SSB is Amaterasu from Okami. She has plenty of different brush skills and weapons to make a good charater out of.

  • @GardeBlaze She was planed for SSBB from what I've heard. Hopefuly she makes this game as she did in MVC3. :)

  • Y U NO PUT TAILS, KNUCKLES, SHADOW AND SILVER

  • Waluigi?

  • this is a good character setup. too many pokemon, though. i believe that instead of zoroark, put in the black knight from FE9.

  • @MrDarthGogeta No kiddin

  • NARUTENDO3

    Y U NO PUT TOON LINK?

  • I think crash and a monkeyball character

  • young link

  • ZERO would be so fuckin awesome!

    

  • what about roy

  • DAISY

  • I think they should just add sheik in as another character

  • no crash bandicoot, no party!!

  • Awesome roster. I only have a few suggestions:

    1.Replace Toad with NES Mario to celebrate Ma rio's anniversary.

    2.Get rid of Lucario(because he is outdated) and Pokemon Trainer(because he takes up too much data space)

    3.Replace Cloud with Black Mage because Cloud is too associated with Sony.

  • and paper mario too

  • the only ones that should b added are ghirahim, knuckles, cactuar, ridley, megaman, baby bowser, NO MORE POKEMON, poo (from earthbound), whatever new cool character that comes from kid icarus, mayb a dual charcter of those two bots from portal2 (similar to ice climbers), and the rest of the brawl roster

  • Some how I really doubt Clowd or any Final Fantasy character will ever be in a Super SMash Brother game.

  • @MrMetroid1998 Actually, Final Fantasy characters including Black Mage,White Mage,and Cactuar have guest starred in some of the Mario sports games,so they can put those characters in. But probably not Cloud because he is too associated with Sony.

  • Very nice ideas dude but if it were up to me i would do the following:

    Geno instead of Toad. Sure Geno is only in one game but Toad. . just why. .?

    Fawful instead of Bowser Jr. He's crazyness in the Mario rpgs games is just awsome. And i dont like Bowser Jr that much.

    The Zelda ones are pretty god but i still would want Zant or Ghirahim in there.

    I acually want Jigglypuff to be replaced in SSBU

    And i also think including some characters from newer games like

    XenobladeC, No More Heroes &Madworld

  • @Mannetasi 1.Zant only appeared in one game.

    2.Jigglypuff is part of the original 12 characters and they've established that they will never get rid of any of them.

    3.No More Heroes?! MADWORLD?!

  • @olekidsf 1. Yeah i know so what? Pit was only in one NES game and he was included in SSBB.

    2. I know they are never gonna do it but still it sucks.

    3. You havent heard of them? Well thats a shame dude since its 3 awsome hack&slash games for the wii. Check them out:

    No More Heroes 1&2?v=DgrVSpF3-Hg

    Madworld?v=bY4txiWSuto

    And including some characters from those games might make people intrested in them.

    Remember Marth&Roy in Melee and Pit in Brawl?

  • @Mannetasi Pit was in one NES game and Kid Icarus Up rising

  • @wendysremix I think that Kid Icarus IS Pit. IDK Someone told me.

  • @Mannetasi 1.Pit also had a Game Boy game and they're gonna make a sequel for 3DS

    2.I know it sucks.

    3.I've heard of them I just don't think that Nintendo would put them in. I do think they're awesome though.

  • I agree. Impa with Shiek's moveset is a really good idea!

  • FINALLY ONE WITH MEGAMAN

    

  • Gray Fox, or Raiden? D:

  • bomberman? :*(

  • Well "Perfect" is entirely your opinion, as I must agree on MOST of the characters here, some, I am not to sure about such as Megaman but who knows, if the Japanese sheet was legit, it did say they were going to introduce non-Nintendo franchises so who knows :3 Also, I am SOOO glad you didn't put something ridiculous in here like Naruto or Dragon Ball Z >.> I am SICK and tired of people thinking that anime will be possible when there are PLENTY of other games out there that should come first.

  • Good and bad.

  • there are too many pokemon and it sounded like you didnt even know enough info on the characters to prove why they should be put in the game...

  • cloud??

    

  • ...Shadow the hedgehog isn't in it..Shit just got lame

  • roy shouldve been right in the middle, being the oldest american fire emblems main chars son >.>

  • but toon link has a different FEEL to him. dr mario didnt, he felt the same, just a new costume.

  • what the hell is a sukapon?

  • This roster is missing a Tales of symphonia character (Lloyd Irving)

  • Where the heck is Ghirahim? o.o

  • not bad

  • I hope they will replace Olimar and ROB with something better in the real Smash 4.

  • @Flash11I19 probably bowser jr and maybe another sonic character or quite possibly krystal from star fox

  • skull kids final smash should be to summon the creepy moon from mm that would rock haha

  • to much pokemons sorry

  • @fouserd Pokemon is equally important to rep as Mario and Zelda.

  • @Narutendo3 Not on my opinion since im a pokemon hater

  • @Narutendo3 But as OPed as....hell, they are the most OPed characters, not to critisize your roster. But really, you could make your roster more complex, like adding Little Max or Pacman, Yarn Kirby or Paper Mario, AND Krystal. But love the new characters, you could add more. (forgot to mention Waluigi ^^)

  • @Narutendo3  no....

  • @fouserd no pokemon are famous there should be alot but there are too many mario characters and definetly not enough sonic characters

  • Mega Man X

  • put simon belmonte bro

  • Pur Megaman, Ninten, Paula, Pacman, and Frank as an assist trophy and I'll be happy with you nintendo.

  • i think waligi would be nice, might as well shove packman in there :P

  • I don't think 3rd Party Characters will be in the next installment, because I think it was a gimmick.

  • for the pkmn trainer changing his color can possibly change his generation?

  • Y U NO PUT SORA O-o (kingdom hearts)

  • YAY SOMEONE FINALLY PUT IMPA IN!!!

  • weres oshawott and tails? FAKE!

  • @SuperBryantR How can something be fake if it's his opinion as to what he thinks would be a good roster?

  • Where is geno!? I demand awnsers!!

  • wouldn't toon ganon have a different fighting style than normal ganon because he has 2 swords.

  • I would of loved to try toon zelda and toon ganon

  • I think everyone wants bowser jr

  • what would be cool is for the color pattlettes for pokemon trainer would be for the generations 1st the pokemon from brawl 2d and so on

  • uh... why put toad he is already on peaches move set idiot

  • @ikeforever34 Duh really? Gee, I didn't know about this. It's too bad being a princess' move isn't quite a big enough role for one of the most iconic video game characters in existence.

  • well if an opinion bothers you so much why not run for president and ban it and no first off it would be okward if toad saw toad theres not two toads theres a toadett

  • @Narutendo3

    Please define ''iconic'' as it definitely isn't a synonym for ''filler character''.

    Toad is useless, nothing else needs to be said about him. Plus Mario doesn't need more reps, obscure characters must be given a chance to shine!

  • @dumbwakeup Toad is one of the first characters that come to people's minds when they think Mario, or even Nintendo. That's called being an icon. *facepalm

  • @Narutendo3

    If freaking Toad is really one of the first character someone thinks about when he/she thinks of Nintendo, that person probably only ever played Mario Kart. Even when a normal gamer thinks of Mario, he's likely only the 6th or 7th character,at best, which really isn't deserving of the ''Icon'' status. His purpose as a character always was to fill a spot in party and sport games, that or being annoying NPCs. Almost anyone would deserve to be in Smash Bros more than him.

  • @dumbwakeup Most people just tend to think "Mario, Luigi, Peach, Bowser, Yoshi, Wario, DK, Toad". That makes him more of an icon than Bowser Jr, Waluigi, etc. Some of that is due to Mario Kart and Party games always having him playable even from the beginning. And Toad has much more moveset potential than you give him credit for. And don't you think Nintendo acknowledges his ability to do things if two out of the four playable characters in New Super Mario Bros Wii were Toads.

  • cloud and ike should not be on a game together.

  • could always do a three gen trainer with 2nd, 3rd and 4th games...like Swampert, Typhlosion and Torterra. That'd be neat.

    At the end of the day there won't be enough slots and even though I don't like her in SSB, they'll probably keep Jigglypuff. What we need is a Pokemon only fighter. That would be amazing.

  • @TopherTramonte Yeah it's a shame jigglypuff is pretty much guaranteed to stay forever at this point. It's a totally pointless character to have. I've considered a trainer with starters from gens 2-4 like you said. It would be cool. I kind of think that would take too much development time though to have so many pokemon. I don't like the idea of Victini though. In my newer roster I have Pika, Jiggz, Pkmn Trainer, Zoroark, Mewtwo, and Deoxys. And yeah, a pokemon only fighter would be cool.

  • -cause they're not higher in significance than each other. I would have to lean more towards representing the newer games, and so I would replace Lucario with Victini, and add Zoroark. Final Pokemon selection would be: Pikachu, Mewtwo, 1st Gen Trainer, 5th Gen trainer, Zoroark, Mewtwo, and Victini. That's fair and balances the first generation which everyone loves most with the new, currently gaining popularity fifth generation. The only problem is the absence of the other generations, but they

  • Personally, as I only really care about/play Pokemon out of these games, I'm only going to comment on it;

    I don't understand why Jigglypuff is still in SSB. He/she might have been relevant back in SSB1 when he was in the anime, but he's not anymore. I'd say two variations of Pokemon Trainer (one with 1st gen Pokemon and the other with 6th) should take the first two Pokemon slots. Zoroark and definitely Pikachu, but I'm iffy about Mewtwo and Lucario. It's difficult to pick Pokemon characters be

  • Don't replace Gannon with Girahim replace him with demise because he is awesome.

  • @ccm2540 What moron would want to replace Ganondorf?

  • @Narutendo3 REPLACE TOAD AND INSTEAD PUT SAMURAI GOROH IN THERE AND DON'T MAKE THE VIDEO

  • @MrMegacrazzy I MEANT JIGGLYPUFF MAN MY TYPING IS GOING DOWN

  • @MrMegacrazzy plus put zero in there

  • @MrMegacrazzy AND ROY

  • @Narutendo3 IMO needs more Fire Emblem characters. Only Hardin is new? Needs at least Micaiah. For like another magic oriented user. Or Ephraim or Eirika. Ephraim would be a cool addition with a lance, and Eirika would be another cool sword fighter. Lyn and the Black Knight would be epic as well. But other than that, great list man.

  • @Narutendo3 Actually, imo, the absence of Ganondorf will be pretty strong due to his absence in the latest Zelda game SS. The one who I think will replace him would most likely be Ghiriham (However you spell his name) considering he was the main protagonist in the last game. Who knows though, Ganon may be considered a vetran by now, though personally, I wouldn't count on it :/

  • @Narutendo3 does that make me a moron?

  • *Gasp!* No Toon Link!

  • zoroark:D

  • i would put roy insted of ike roy was so much better

  • You forgot Tails, Shadow, and Knuckles!

  • why is there no new earthbound characters?

  • what about the random selection

  • @ikeforever34 wow, I can't believe multiple people have commented about this. It is an unnecessary option just added or taken out for the sake of symmetry.

  • @Narutendo3 just stfu and add random i dont mean to be an asshole but come on if people are annoying you for it then do it itsnot hard just ctrl c and ctrl v the random pic

  • i think it would be more relistic if it had a random seletion

  • why the hell evrybody leaving out shadow

  • @xXBLACKXLABXx

    Because Shadow is a dick?

  • But Toon Link shouldn't be a clone of link! They could have so many different moves

  • @MrJayJayYay It's not the moves that always make a clone. In that case it's the character.

  • errr... you forgot random

  • Bring Roy back,add Goku,Ryu,mega-man,pac-man,and Espio.

  • @798Supremegreen Goku would be 4th party which is not very possible plus he's anime.

  • @UltimateGamerLPS Lol,what the fuck is pokemon?

  • @798Supremegreen Pokemon had games with Nintendo.

  • @UltimateGamerLPS That's like saying pokemon can't have an anime,cuz it's a game.Correct?

  • @798Supremegreen

    ...idiot

  • @Spudtron98 gtfo,faggot.

  • you need spyro and crash

    

  • an i the only one who thinks Pac-Man should make a return?

  • @GoldInforcer I think that a bit

  • weres waluigi. he will represent mario spin off games perfectly

  • Sheik got a new model because she was somewhat planned to appear in twilight princess.

  • wait where is tails, Krystal??

  • @Racrblpg Star Fox doesn't really need a new rep, but I do recommend it. Also Tails would be from the Sonic series, which is a 3rd party series, and it wouldn't be good to have 2 characters from the same series that's 3Pty.

  • @UltimateGamerLPS naa that dosent matter Tails apperas in brawl as a trophy, they had to pay to put it like that. And think also about mario and sonic at the olimpic game sthey have bought the right to use them and as I understand they had to keep using those caracters to continue using them for the future so I strongly belive they can put another sonic character. And star Fox does need Krystal! more womens to play

  • Why do lots of people want Ridley as a character? Ridleys way to big to fit on the screen plus he has an unfail adavantage of flying as long as he wants :(

  • @bigbangblader15 Not much of a Metroid fan, huh? Ridley is actually no bigger than Bowser and often walks. Plus he's just a cool character who is very iconic for Metroid and Nintendo altogether.

  • @Narutendo3 Oh, cuz he looked WAY big when he was a boss O_O

  • @Narutendo3 it depends which game you're talking about. in metroid fusion, ridley-x is the size of samus' ship. and just because he's "iconic" doesn't mean he would make a good character.

  • @bigbangblader15 If they could resize Olimar, than they can do same as Ridley.

  • I stop watching when i saw cloud &, no more starfox character???? when nintendo is making one for wii u lol.

  • @icepuka That's only a rumor and starfox only needs 3 anyway.

  • I have to say this is one of the best fake ssb4 rosters I've seen but a few things bug me such as skull kid without Majora's Mask, Zoruark is just an updated Lucario and it's not likely for both to be in there same as Mewtwo, a lot of clones, and I personally don't know who or what Sukapon is but  it doesn't look like a character I would like being in the game. Other than that I really like it... and Impa?

  • you should add Bomberman, Rayman and Ghirahim + Random, PERFECT. :)

  • still really can't get why you have no krystal and no lyn,we need more bitches up in here

    and your statement for no little mac is a little pathetic,the concept here is a fighter in a fighting game for god's sake

  • Wow,that is a really good roster in my opinion,I like that you included Impa,I don't know why so many people don't consider her as a potential character and I also think that hardin is a good idea,but the fire emblem series is always hard to judge as of which character will be in the game.

    Cloud is rather unlikely,because he never appeared in a final fantasy game on a nintendo console and it was his game that drove the ff series away from nintendo so I doubt they would include him.

  • @altermann1991 Thanks! Based on your criticisms (which several other people have had as well), I'd guess you'll be more pleased with my updated roster that I'm uploading in a minute here.

  • shadow? where ist shadow!?

    thats not the perfect roaster!

  • @medsestraification I am indeed a Shadow fan as well, but it won't happen in a million years.

  • Nice to see that others agree with me on Impa being in the game... She's the perfect Zelda character for the game. Like the other Zelda characters, she's been reincarnated throughout the series, but more importantly, she'd have a badass move set.

  • @lazorzez Yep, I'm surprised most people still give more consideration to Ghirahim even though he is just a side antagonist of the one game. If Skyward Sword is going to give reason to add a character to smash, it's Impa by far for her prior reoccurance.

  • Lets say that they put all these characters in ssb4.What new characters would you want after that?

    The more the better,right?

  • @ginga2122 Haha, that's a good question. If this was the roster for SSB4, I guess SSB5 would be the time to start giving actual consideration to characters like Waluigi, Geno, Funky Kong, another Pokemon Trainer of some sort, Dark Matter, Sylux, Balloon Fighter, Tingle, etc.

  • @Narutendo3 Yeah,but i think they should concentrate mosly on the fighting mechanics and enhancing movesets,if you know what i mean.Every character should have two fighting stances,as a result low tier characters will still have hope and wont be be left out to collect dust.I dont know about you,but i enjoyed ssbn64 the most in terms of gameplay.Btw are you going to make a new video.If you are i will give you ideas about what needs to changed and replace.I dont have the time to make a vid.

  • @ginga2122 Well uh, you did ask... Of course gameplay should always be improved. And I actually am planning on posting a new roster based on the main criticisms I've already gotten and some things I've realized myself. (btw I wasn't the one who flagged your comment as spam in case you thought it was me)

  • @Narutendo3 Good luck in making a new vid,remember if you need any idea tell me,(how weird does that sound lol).As for the flagged comment ,well...water under the bridge.

  • @ginga2122 It's actually already up if you want to see it.

  • @Narutendo3 wow..that was a fast reply.Yeah i will see it now,

  • @ginga2122 lol

  • @Narutendo3I think we are both online at the same time.

  • What about the EB/Mother series? Or Star Fox?

  • @valzilla2000 What about them?

  • @Narutendo3

    Well, you coulda put some new ones in... I'm not very knowing of SF, but you shoulda put Krystal (or whatever it's spelled) and Kumatora.

  • @valzilla2000 Riiiight, because Starfox obviously is much bigger and more popular than Metroid or Kirby... Not to mention this "Kumatora" who I have never even heard of in all my years of gaming. And Mother has had only three games which are barely played outside of Japan. In fact, I plan on taking out Lucas from my roster. (granted I'll be removing Black Shadow as well)

  • Geno, Your Missing Geno.

    

  • @NiqqaWhoYouKillin Not even close to being as important or iconic as Toad or Bowser Jr. And while I think they could certainly get it, they would have to go to the trouble of getting copyright permission from Square, which I doubt they would do just for some random old Mario RPG character.

  • Geno, Your Missing Geno.

    

  • Very good list. My only issue is that the Black Knight was and wasn't an antagonist. The reasoning is that without him Micaiah wouldn't have lived to stop the main antagonists Sephraim and Ashera. Then you have differences between Japan Fire Emblem and North America, but they have no major differences. Other than those things it was a awesome list.

  • @Pachico760 I really don't know the story of Fire Emblem games too well. But I do know that a Black Knight is some sort of antagonist in many of the games. That is why I will be replacing Hardin with him in my updated roster later.

  • One thing bad with organization: Adding Sukapon is like adding the Ice Climbers or pit more than it is like adding Mr.Game or R.O.B.

    I like the idea of keeping the major antagonist for the major series only. Bowser, Ganon, Mewtwo (can be treated as one), King K Rule, King Dedede (granted he's a joke), and Ridley. Let's stop there.

    I think you are too left handed in balancing Major series : Misc.

  • @smashkote I don't see how. Ice Climbers and Pit were main characters from their individual popular NES games. Ev