@likenlk err.... dude... "first it's from 'end of an era'"? You actually do know, that Tarja NEVER performed with Nightwish afterwards again, right? Besides... If you read the video title, it was in 2004, Lowands was releases in 2005 and EoaE in 2006. This one is called half-playback. In TV, you usually don't have time to make a soundcheck, so you play some parts playback and some, especially the vocals, live at some times
@likenlk Umm, it's impossible for this to be End of An Era. After EOAE, they kicked her out and never spoke to her again. I also enjoy how you said there's a part from Lowlands 2005...this performance was 2004.
I'm not disagreeing that it's playback, it probably is. It's some kind of live version, because of Tarja's accent. Also, there's NO way any television company in Germany will let you perform live. German television always uses playback. Only NW used live playback to protect their rep.
i would say that this was playback in original. i think author ripped live sound from some live performance and paste it here.but really. its cool. looks real(maybe it is=))
I think it was a playback... or author ripped... cause tuomas NEVER plays live with only one keyboard... In the ECHO AWARDS, Helsinki Olympics & Such they sued playback and whenever its playback he only uses one keyboard
E.g. Marco does not like this playback performance at all. He seems to get bored. Compare his mimicry and moves in classical live performance and this one - it is something completely different.
And have a look at 3:29 - Tarja is claping her mouth completely different than the lyrics is.
All I know, is her vocals are live! If you pay any amount of attention to how she sings in studio and live you can tell the difference! She says "ern" instead of "one without A name". Are you seriously trying to tell me she's using playback for vocals?!
the guitarist does not do a slide at the begining, and the drums does not fit at all, in the 1st chorus, there's alot of crash and he does'nt hit one.... But the vocal seems to be live
It's not playback. You can clearly hear that at least Tarja's singing is live because her accent shines through here a bit. She's just singing the song very well this time and she usually fucks up at the song :P
i think it is not playback because tarja on the album says "forever" and live she says "foreever" like here, agree?...i love her accent..maybe the instruments are playback..but her voice isn;t.
learn how and anette there it is!
bbb228 2 months ago
Tarja,I LOVE YOU
Ivan32870 8 months ago
"This is me, for 'foreaver'..." She always messes up that one word and pronounces it like shit. She got it right in the studio version though.
rokiroful 10 months ago 2
@rokiroful She speaks English far better than I speak Finnish.
Marshallsatten 2 months ago
@likenlk How is it possible the first one to be from End of an Era when it's their last concert together?
xNightSwaNx 11 months ago
@xNightSwaNx good point! :D
aquillaSrb 9 months ago
Really!!
Oomka 8 months ago
Круто))
254404l 1 year ago
Ach Du Scheiße ist das schlecht geschnitten. Und: Ich hasse Playbacks.
Sephaer 1 year ago
@likenlk err.... dude... "first it's from 'end of an era'"? You actually do know, that Tarja NEVER performed with Nightwish afterwards again, right? Besides... If you read the video title, it was in 2004, Lowands was releases in 2005 and EoaE in 2006. This one is called half-playback. In TV, you usually don't have time to make a soundcheck, so you play some parts playback and some, especially the vocals, live at some times
Yviman 1 year ago 7
I love TARJA!!!! <3
potterclubtv 1 year ago 2
@likenlk Umm, it's impossible for this to be End of An Era. After EOAE, they kicked her out and never spoke to her again. I also enjoy how you said there's a part from Lowlands 2005...this performance was 2004.
I'm not disagreeing that it's playback, it probably is. It's some kind of live version, because of Tarja's accent. Also, there's NO way any television company in Germany will let you perform live. German television always uses playback. Only NW used live playback to protect their rep.
LovingLife411 1 year ago
alguien que me diga de donde puedo descargar el video??
patytogoth 1 year ago
Clearly the playbacks chnaged at 2:10.
Obelix5150 1 year ago 2
@Obelix5150 your right
MrsSchlamm 1 year ago
Tuomas is so cute!!!<3
Poppaea6 1 year ago 2
thats live tarjas voice sound different to live the album version an of course trhey can yoouse one keyboard
1880Chris 1 year ago
It's clearly live
theshow2k8 2 years ago
@theshow2k8 ya it is. normally on the tracks tarja doesn't have such a thick accent.
42lacey 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Of course this version isn't playback! You can note the accent of Tarja "fooor foryvour the one withouthor a name". ^^
RonaldoDavid 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
RonaldoDavid 2 years ago
i would say that this was playback in original. i think author ripped live sound from some live performance and paste it here.but really. its cool. looks real(maybe it is=))
nightwishfan15 2 years ago 3
I think it was a playback... or author ripped... cause tuomas NEVER plays live with only one keyboard... In the ECHO AWARDS, Helsinki Olympics & Such they sued playback and whenever its playback he only uses one keyboard
shadowparkour 2 years ago
You guys are so stupid.
THIS IS NOT PLAYBACK.
Tarja has an accent- no offense- and
when she sings this of all songs,
you can really here it.
There is no way in hell this is playback.
And it could not have been from End of an Era,
because that hadn't even happened yet!!!
LovingLife411 2 years ago
Are you blind and deaf ?
Everything starting from guitar to vocal is playback.
cheyen123 2 years ago
Okay, I don't know what the hell being
blind has to do with anything, but whatever.
Play them both idiot, and try
to tell me again this is playback.
LovingLife411 2 years ago
You really do not see the difference ?
E.g. Marco does not like this playback performance at all. He seems to get bored. Compare his mimicry and moves in classical live performance and this one - it is something completely different.
And have a look at 3:29 - Tarja is claping her mouth completely different than the lyrics is.
cheyen123 2 years ago
This is not playback! I don't know what
you're taking about at 3:29,
but at 3:34, she says for-eee-ver, not for-ever.
That is live and she isn't holding her notes
at the same pitch at the end she changes it.
LovingLife411 2 years ago
I will say up to 2:12 this was live, but those
instrumentals don't seem live- I'll agree to that.
But her vocals are definitely live.
LovingLife411 2 years ago
So acording to you a half is playback and a half is live ? Cany you imagine how it could be organised in TV ? And why to do that so complicated ?
You are joking aren´t you ?
cheyen123 2 years ago
All I know, is her vocals are live! If you pay any amount of attention to how she sings in studio and live you can tell the difference! She says "ern" instead of "one without A name". Are you seriously trying to tell me she's using playback for vocals?!
LovingLife411 2 years ago
the guitarist does not do a slide at the begining, and the drums does not fit at all, in the 1st chorus, there's alot of crash and he does'nt hit one.... But the vocal seems to be live
JiJiLaGo 2 years ago 3
Colour of her microphohe does not match to colour of her dress. What happened ?
cheyen123 2 years ago
It's not playback. You can clearly hear that at least Tarja's singing is live because her accent shines through here a bit. She's just singing the song very well this time and she usually fucks up at the song :P
onewiththewaves 2 years ago
the sound is the "end of an era"
mywinterstorm07 2 years ago 2
good old times
diana17rock 2 years ago 39
it is not playback!
diana17rock 2 years ago 5
of course its playback, can you see any microphones at the drumset or can you see any cable at the key board.
the drummer doesnt play the things you can hear
rockdrummer1893 2 years ago
i think it is not playback because tarja on the album says "forever" and live she says "foreever" like here, agree?...i love her accent..maybe the instruments are playback..but her voice isn;t.
diana17rock 2 years ago 3
could be like that .. :D didnt thought of that
rockdrummer1893 2 years ago
and btw at the beggining jukka isnt hitting drums
JovidzaCar 2 years ago
it's live, can't you hear Tarja's vocals? they're nothing like the studio version
deutschesmaedchen 2 years ago
I actually meant the drums... but what ever .. :O
rockdrummer1893 2 years ago
then make yourself clear from now on. you tried to persuade somebody into thinking the song wasn't played live, THE SONG not the drums.
deutschesmaedchen 2 years ago
i dont think this is lip syncing. i think that is just a transmission problem. great job though nightwish!
Kilicka123 2 years ago 4
at 2:00 she "sings" the word nemo ....but her mouth...
ChapChippetz 2 years ago
Her dress is so perfect!
1NightwishManiac1 2 years ago 4
Play back or not Tarja ls so dam beautiful
and not only the german shows make the artists do that
AlegraBlueberry 2 years ago 2
I don't think that's playback and that's not from end of an era's dvd at all !
that's not lipsync but that happens very often due to a transmission problem.
guys that's an old nightwish video ! and that's just fucking magic!!
xxtarjavaloxx 2 years ago 3
yeah, fucking german´s shows... oops! hahaha
ValosDemon 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fake, the sound is from the end of an era concert.
ChapChippetz 2 years ago
HOw can it be from end of an era...after end of an era tarja was kicked out you dickhead!
1NightwishManiac1 2 years ago
the video was manipulated ! the sound was added later !
Lostcobra 2 years ago
Tarja is very very beautiful! I love Tarja!Tarja foreveeer!!:)
DarkVadCica 2 years ago 3
yeah fucking german tv shows!!
She could sing it live and it would sound like this - because she CAN sing
not like all the other "singers" in these tv shows
she's the best
TarjaSenpai 2 years ago
It's funny..
Because this is lipsync, but she did record her vocals in one take before this performance to make it not too obvious
I don't like these tv shows that make artists do this.
Allard88 2 years ago
I hate it too =(
She has an amazing voice and she don't need to make this =(
StrawberryMartaChoco 2 years ago
It's always the german tv shows that do that :P
Allard88 2 years ago